Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

150k in undisclosed savings

266 replies

NCsecret · 17/08/2021 19:35

First off, I know IABU but not sure how to tel my DP this.

We’ve been together for 3 years and are now engaged (living together in my house). I’ve always been a saver and I have a well paid job. Now things are getting serious, as we’re just engaged and I’m wondering about how to disclose this topic.

DP knows I’m comfortable as obviously I have a good job and a house which I own 50% of. I’ve always been transparent on that.

However, I haven’t mentioned previously that I have also a good amount of cash savings (Excl shares and pensions)

How do I start this convo?

OP posts:
TheRealHousewife · 17/08/2021 21:25

We had some friends and this sort of dilemma split them up! Wedding on a yacht planned for abroad. Men’s suits measured up for and ordered, women’s outfits chosen and paid for. 1 week before we flew out the groom discovered his bride to be had a house on the back burner. She maintained it was hers to keep to herself as ‘insurance’. He called it all off as he felt he didn’t know her and could no longer trust her.

I’d disclose in a matter of fact way and protect yourself going forward and be honest and open about that too. Good Luck 👍

userxx · 17/08/2021 21:24

@Reallyreallyborednow

pre-nup all the way

Are they enforceable in england/uk though? I didn’t think they were?

Nope, pretty sure they don't stand up in the uk.

CeeceeBloomingdale · 17/08/2021 21:23

I’d pay it most of it into my pension, then it’s not really a topic for debate any more.

Reallyreallyborednow · 17/08/2021 21:23

pre-nup all the way

Are they enforceable in england/uk though? I didn’t think they were?

fallfallfall · 17/08/2021 21:22

pre-nup all the way.

sassbott · 17/08/2021 21:22

Personally I'd advise anyone with disproportionate wealth to the other to not get married.

👆🏽

VladmirsPoutine · 17/08/2021 21:21

If I were rich I'd avoid marriage but if poor then it would be in my best interest to marry someone financially better off.
I suppose I perhaps shouldn't be answering this as I don't believe in 'ever-lasting' love but at some point you're going to have to have some very frank discussions about where you both stand financially and so forth and indeed your expectations for the future, i.e. will one of you become a SAHP and all that good stuff.

acolderwar · 17/08/2021 21:19

Personally I'd advise anyone with disproportionate wealth to the other to not get married.

Yeah, basically this.

sadlynotme · 17/08/2021 21:19

How can you marry a person and not expect to reveal your financial status? I couldn't marry someone who kept such secrets and I would feel weird not talking to my spouse about my own finances.

If you are legally married that person becomes your next of kin and they will be the ones deciding on such things as your medical treatment should you be unable to do so yourself, including donating your organs should you die. Furthermore, if you have children they will be the co-parent of your children and most likely your children will have half their DNA.

Such a close relationship and yet some people think finances can/should be kept secret?? The mind boggles!

acolderwar · 17/08/2021 21:18

I know I may come across as jaded and cynical but I am contributing from the POV of someone who has been stung financially more than once. I wouldn't get married. However I appreciate that marriage is really important to lots of people (and was to me at one point in my life). Marriages can end, and partners who you would never expect would ever be malicious or downright unreasonable can surprise you. Although I'm not suggesting that this will happen to you, it could, and you would stand to lose whilst your partner would stand to gain.

I also wouldn't disclose the amount of savings. Although you would of course be free to do what you wanted with it, there would always be the underlying expectation that it should be used to benefit your partner too. And maybe that would be the right thing to do, but having enhanced two ex partner's lives financially and knowing that their gain is my DC's loss in terms of inheritance (as well as my loss) is a bitter pill to swallow.

Noteshook · 17/08/2021 21:16

@ChipButties

This thread is mad. So one affluent person can’t marry someone else who is potentially not as well off? Are all of you saying ‘what does she bring to the table?’ Or ‘don’t do it’ that if you met a partner richer than you you’d be happy if they didn’t marry you and kept all their savings to themselves and never told you?

This thread is batshit. If someone had posted on here ‘My DH has loads of money but won’t marry me because of it’ the responses would be VERY different.

Also, maybe OPs partner bring love and kindness to the relationship - does she have to just bring cash?

Personally I'd advise anyone with disproportionate wealth to the other to not get married.
mynameisbrian · 17/08/2021 21:16

Are you planning to raise just so she is aware or are you going to discuss a prenup or protecting your assets before marriage?

userxx · 17/08/2021 21:12

@TootTootTootToot

I wouldn’t get married if I had the money. ( If I were the poorer half then of course I’d want to get married.) Three years is not long.

Would you though ? Would you get married because of the money?

Mindymomo · 17/08/2021 21:11

I wouldn’t be surprised if your partner also has quite a bit of savings if she lives with you and pays some of the bills, but not the mortgage. Especially if she has a good job. I don’t believe that if you are serious in a relationship and are wanting to get married and have children, that you both shouldn’t discuss your money situations. I would start with, I know we’ve not ever spoken about how much money we both have, but do you think we should know what we each have.

TractorAndHeadphones · 17/08/2021 21:10

@SarahAndQuack

It isn't just a double standard to have different views on men and women, though.

On average, lesbian couples are substantially worse off than straight couples. Most lesbian couples who have children do so with financial and/or legal interventions of one kind or another. And lesbian couples with children face a double 'mummy penalty' at work. If the OP and her partner hope they'll both TTC, they may end up with biological and financial complications that simply do not apply to straight couples.

It is worth thinking about these things.

Why would they face a double ‘mummy penalty’ if only one of them gets pregnant like straight couples do? I know a fair few lesbian couples (I’m not straight) and none of them have both partners TTC. It doesn’t make sense to have two people take the hit. Of course this is just anecdotal observation. I could it happening if one partner could never give birth again after the first.

If anything lesbians are better off than the average couple because of no unplanned pregnancies ruining their life plans…

fuzzymoomin · 17/08/2021 21:07

@gunnersgold

Are you both female? Or are you a man?
I'm baffled that some people's answer will be different depending on the answer to this question. Does it matter?
Hekatestorch · 17/08/2021 21:06

Plenty of people might have personal savings within marriages, but if they split up, that matters not one iota. Once you’re married all finances as equal and will be split that way.

Saying don’t tell her is fair enough enough, if they don’t get married but you would assume that they will at some point.

But as I said, I was speaking about her and her dp. If they do get married, then obviously that changes. But she still doesn't have to tell her if she doesn't want to, in my opinion.

No I would assume they would get married. Plenty of people get engaged multiple times. Have multiple relationships that don't end in marriage.

Besides which, a couple of posts later I told op I would get married at all. I would keep separate finances and if they have kids, I would want us both to reduce our work, rather than one giving up work. Or both work full time.

Obviously, if they decide one is going to be a sahp, as a joint decision that changes things again.

But right now, recently engaged with no shared assets, I stand by what I said. I wouldn't tell her.

fuzzymoomin · 17/08/2021 21:06

@MojoMoon

"now we are engaged, I want to discuss finances and our future plans."

Topics for discussion

  1. current debts and savings
  2. future life plans eg having kids/caring for parents/travelling the world/studying for another qualification/moving house. How would you pay for these?
  3. retirement planning - what are both of you doing currently for pensions? When do you expect to retire? How will you fund retirment? How much will you need to have saved to fund it realistically?
  4. life insurance/critical illness coverage - how would you manage if one of you died or was very ill? Do you have any coverage?
  5. making wills - have you done it? What would you want to be in them - leaving everything to each other or would you want something to go to siblings/parents/friends etc

I'd say savings were one element of a much bigger conversation or series of conversations that you need to have before you get married. Don't make a massive deal of that part.

This! You should be having this conversation before you get married, along with discussing whether money will be kept separate or shared. I'm confused by the replies here telling you not to disclose it/to protect yourself. You are planning to spend your life with this woman, why would you not tell her you have some savings. In my home we share everything, we each brought different finances, possessions, life skills to the partnership and share it all openly and willingly, I can't imagine living any other way.
UmbilicusProfundus · 17/08/2021 21:05

Not answering the question, but you should pay off more of your mortgage than keep all that cash in whatever it is invested in and is not reaping sufficient interest to offset your cumulative mortgage interest costs.

Second maybe you need to keep back some cash (quite a lot really) to pay for IVF or similar.

Thirdly if you are doing a DIY insemination, your partner will have zero parental rights unless you are married. It’s different if you are going via a licensed fertility clinic.

You need to have lots more conversations!

QueenBee52 · 17/08/2021 21:04

[quote NCsecret]@SwanShaped I don’t want to keep it as a secret, I’m just not sure how to broach the topic but good advice here on how to![/quote]

in that case.. if you want to tell her just tell her..

its no big deal if you lose half in divorce right ☺️

QueenBee52 · 17/08/2021 21:01

@Bopahula

Honestly. Don't get married. Or find a way to protect your savings.

yip..

or protect your savings in a Pre-nup...

say Nothing to your partner yet

TableFlowerss · 17/08/2021 20:59

@Hekatestorch

I’m talking about the fact you compared the situations, but once they’re married, the situations will be vastly different.

OP states they are engaged so assuming they are planning on marrying. You’ve made no reference to wanting to get married etc…

Marriage is a whole different level of bell game regarding finances so it’s not as simple as ‘not telling him….’ That only works when your co-habit, like you!

No actually, plenty of people have personal savings in marriages.

As of yet, they aren't married. They are just engaged. They could get married in a year or 5 or never.

What difference to the marriage is op savings going to make? Non. It not a negative impact. So if op wants to tell them further down the line or when they are actually married fair enough.

But right now, they aren't married. So I wouldn't say a thing to my dp which is my opinion on what the op should do, in regards to their own dp.

Plenty of people might have personal savings within marriages, but if they split up, that matters not one iota. Once you’re married all finances as equal and will be split that way.

Saying don’t tell her is fair enough enough, if they don’t get married but you would assume that they will at some point.

Dongdingdong · 17/08/2021 20:58

On a peripheral note, unless you are mega rich with variable cash needs £150,000 in cash is far too much. You should look at global equity funds to get some real growth. That is the real issue to me.

Quite. Does anyone really believe this OP is real? Come on.

SarahAndQuack · 17/08/2021 20:57

@Hekatestorch

Assuming you will both have parental responsibility, bear in mind that even if you arenotmarried, if you live together in a house owned by you, your DP is likely to acquire some rights, and at the very least (obviously, one would hope!) you couldn't kick her out with the children if you suddenly found things went sour.

Where do you live? Because this isn't true for all countries of the UK.

I apologise - thanks for clarifying. OP, it might apply and worth checking out!
vivariumvivariumsvivaria · 17/08/2021 20:57

TBH, if you CAN'T have the conversation Sarah just laid out, you shouldn't get married.

I didn't. Got married, had kids, one got sick and so I didn't work for years. He did, so we were fine financially but he resents that I didn't contribute to the mortgage and conveniently forgets the amount of work he was able to do because I was at the hospital/juggling everything with the other two/managing a very stressful situation alone so he could pay the bills. I landed up being a support human for about 10 years.

Happily, DS is a hulking, healthy teenager now, but I will never recover the pension contributions and career pathway. I have to work hard at not being resentful about that, and DH's attitude. I did contribute, just not financially because there was constant crisis management, which has been forgotten by DH because he didn't have to do it. So much for "in sickness and in health".

I wish we'd had a hard conversation before we'd married because if I knew then what I know now I'd have thought twice.

Swipe left for the next trending thread