Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

150k in undisclosed savings

266 replies

NCsecret · 17/08/2021 19:35

First off, I know IABU but not sure how to tel my DP this.

We’ve been together for 3 years and are now engaged (living together in my house). I’ve always been a saver and I have a well paid job. Now things are getting serious, as we’re just engaged and I’m wondering about how to disclose this topic.

DP knows I’m comfortable as obviously I have a good job and a house which I own 50% of. I’ve always been transparent on that.

However, I haven’t mentioned previously that I have also a good amount of cash savings (Excl shares and pensions)

How do I start this convo?

OP posts:
idontlikealdi · 17/08/2021 23:55

Make, female or anything else I'd be protecting my 150 before marriage. Keeping it secret is just wrong for everyone and a massive headache for wills, any future kids and divorce if it happens.

Hekatestorch · 17/08/2021 23:41

@5329871e

Best of luck to you bitter cynical bitches. I hope you’re happy living your lonely, suspicious lives. I’m glad my DH didn’t feel like that when he married me!!
Who is the bitter one?

Why would other women's financial choices upset you so much?

Or is that some women don't like marriage, that's upset you?

I am glad your dh made a different choice. You both made a choice that suits you both.

Why is it so upsetting that other people make choices that suit them?

TableFlowerss · 17/08/2021 23:34

@SchrodingersImmigrant

It's not always 50/50 after divorce. People need to stop saying that. If one comes in with nothing, the other with a million and they divorce after few year being in the same earning position as before there is just no way court would order 50/50. Even with kids it still isn't guaranteed 50/50.

However, I would protect the savings if I could. Afaik if you can prove you had the savings before the marriage, they could be left alone anyway

That’s what happens in Scotland. You could say it’s a more fair way of dividing up the finances, if one has millions and the other nothing, before they marry.

It really isn’t like that in England though. It will be much nearer to 50:50 than not.

I’ve known one guy who was burnt twice by marrying someone then after a year or so they divorced and she took him for half his house and got it.

He got back on his feet and bought another house, married then next GF and same think happened. He had to sell his house to pay her out.

RandomLondoner · 17/08/2021 23:29

Why are people saying dont get married? If you're committed to a person enough to have kids with them wouldnt you want to marry them so if anything happened to you they'd be okay with the house and savings for the children?

Would you rather give someone what your regard as fair, or some greater amount you have no say in determining?

(In the event the legal process gives less than you think is fair, you're free to top it up, so if a divorce settlement is unfair, it will always be unfair in the other persons favour, never yours.)

RandomLondoner · 17/08/2021 23:22

I see on here all the time that women are advised not to move in with someone and have kids with them unless they're married or own their own property. Why is this situation different

Because the advice is to the person with more money.

Anything gained by the women following that advice is lost by the people they marry. What's good for one is necessarily bad for the other.

Hankunamatata · 17/08/2021 23:20

I would use a big chunk to pay off mortgage if you can then keep house solely in your name before marriage and have it financially ring fenced.

SwanShaped · 17/08/2021 23:15

@NCsecret yes, I thought that. I was more responding to posters who put that you should keep the money a secret! I’m sure you’ll figure out a way.

userxx · 17/08/2021 23:13

[quote fallfallfall]**@Reallyreallyborednow* and @userxx*
pre nups and post nups are taken into consideration if both were signed in good faith.[/quote]
Really? My friend was advised by her solicitor that they don't stand up. The solicitor also advised my friend not to marry.

HollowTalk · 17/08/2021 23:09

Because she can earn more if she invests in stocks and shares. Mortgage rates are very low at the moment.

Pootle40 · 17/08/2021 23:02

Not your question but why have a mortgage if you could pay it off?

SchrodingersImmigrant · 17/08/2021 22:54

It's not always 50/50 after divorce. People need to stop saying that. If one comes in with nothing, the other with a million and they divorce after few year being in the same earning position as before there is just no way court would order 50/50. Even with kids it still isn't guaranteed 50/50.

However, I would protect the savings if I could. Afaik if you can prove you had the savings before the marriage, they could be left alone anyway

SilverOnToast · 17/08/2021 22:50

I’m a woman who married another woman who initially had a lot more money than me (though I was younger with a slightly higher income at the time). I believe my partner thought that the potential of losing money wasn’t as important as her feelings for me at the time, which was good for me, obviously. We both spent a long time campaigning for equal marriage in Westminster. I carried our children and gave birth, but then she took several years out of the workforce to be a SAHP, which was both our wish. Our marriage enabled us to become citizens of each other’s country. It allowed us to both be on the birth certificate of our DC without question. It actually gave us a lot of rights in our current country which wouldn’t have been possible without marriage, and in the eyes of many in my family, it (rightly or wrongly) legitimised our relationship in a way that I wouldn’t have needed if I’d been heterosexual.

I know that this post isn’t about marriage per se, but it’s absolutely true that female same-sex couples have twice the mummy whammy, due to literal time out of work, or the prejudice that one of us might. I am grateful that my DW did not shun me for my lack of finances in the early days, as it turns out I have earned more than her since.

Anything can happen once you’re married. People get ill, money can disappear suddenly due to situations beyond our control (thanks, economic downturn!). And I’d like to think that our DC are protected now, no matter what happens in our marriage and what our earning potential is.

I think, if you love her, tell her, OP, providing you generally see eye to eye on finances. 3 years is long enough to know whether you see a future or not.

SarahAndQuack · 17/08/2021 22:46

@RosesAndHellebores

Crikey that kicked off.

Hope all's well @SarahAndQuack

Yes, very well thanks! I've just been out for lunch with some MNers of old, and took DD to buy school uniform ... I don't know where the time has gone. How are you?!
nokidshere · 17/08/2021 22:46

If the OP hasn't discussed finances with her partner it's possible that the partner has significantly more than the OP - why is everyone assuming she's poorer? She may also have undisclosed financial security especially if she's been saving the rent money!

SarahAndQuack · 17/08/2021 22:45

(And sorry I can't be more helpful!)

SarahAndQuack · 17/08/2021 22:44

Which data?

As I say, my understanding of patterns in lesbian couples choosing who gets pregnant (or who tries) is anecdotal based on a conversation I had with someone who was researching it a few years ago. The info on lesbian parents and income is more a case of joining dots. There's some good info to suggest that lesbians tend to be paid more than straight women (this is linked to higher levels of education/qualification). But, since straight women pair up with straight men, household incomes for straight couples are liable to be higher. Add to that the fact that most lesbians with children who are higher-income will spend money having their children, you end up with lower income or a more dramatically 'dipped' income around the time when couples have children (which is relevant for the OP).

This has some stats, but it takes a lot of interpreting: assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/539682/160719_REPORT_LGBT_evidence_review_NIESR_FINALPDF.pdf

Phobiaphobic · 17/08/2021 22:41

Be honest. If you feel you need to hide stuff, you shouldn't be getting married in the first place.

fuzzymoomin · 17/08/2021 22:40

@5329871e

Best of luck to you bitter cynical bitches. I hope you’re happy living your lonely, suspicious lives. I’m glad my DH didn’t feel like that when he married me!!
Ditto! My god, it must be so depressing to go through life as cynical and suspicious as most of the people on this thread.
RosesAndHellebores · 17/08/2021 22:39

Crikey that kicked off.

Hope all's well @SarahAndQuack

TractorAndHeadphones · 17/08/2021 22:30

@SarahAndQuack

Why would they face a double ‘mummy penalty’ if only one of them gets pregnant like straight couples do?

Because they might both get pregnant (or both try and not, and that takes a toll too), but also because part of the mummy penalty is discrimination - the expectation that a woman of reproductive age isn't a good bet to employ or promote because of the unspoken assumption she may 'go off and have children'.

I know a fair few lesbian couples (I’m not straight) and none of them have both partners TTC. It doesn’t make sense to have two people take the hit. Of course this is just anecdotal observation.

Interesting! I believe statistically it that it is slightly more common for both women to TTC than only one if the couple has or tries for more than one child, but that's based on a conversation I had with someone who was writing a book on the subject a few years ago - it may have changed, and even then, she said it was very hard to get stats or to see patterns to them.

If anything lesbians are better off than the average couple because of no unplanned pregnancies ruining their life plans…

But not financially better off. This is just factual: lesbian couples are not a well-off demographic.

Have you got a link to the data - I'd be interested to have a look.
SarahAndQuack · 17/08/2021 22:30

@5329871e

Best of luck to you bitter cynical bitches. I hope you’re happy living your lonely, suspicious lives. I’m glad my DH didn’t feel like that when he married me!!
I bet he does now though. Grin
TractorAndHeadphones · 17/08/2021 22:27

@5329871e

Best of luck to you bitter cynical bitches. I hope you’re happy living your lonely, suspicious lives. I’m glad my DH didn’t feel like that when he married me!!
I'm sure your DH is glad that you haven't divorced him and walked away with half his assets. Or maybe the other way round if you're now the higher earner.

Don't worry... there's still time :)

Noteshook · 17/08/2021 22:26

@5329871e

Best of luck to you bitter cynical bitches. I hope you’re happy living your lonely, suspicious lives. I’m glad my DH didn’t feel like that when he married me!!
Thanks hun :)
5329871e · 17/08/2021 22:24

Best of luck to you bitter cynical bitches. I hope you’re happy living your lonely, suspicious lives. I’m glad my DH didn’t feel like that when he married me!!

coodawoodashooda · 17/08/2021 22:21

@Bopahula

Honestly. Don't get married. Or find a way to protect your savings.
This. Can't emphasise this enough.
Swipe left for the next trending thread