Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

150k in undisclosed savings

266 replies

NCsecret · 17/08/2021 19:35

First off, I know IABU but not sure how to tel my DP this.

We’ve been together for 3 years and are now engaged (living together in my house). I’ve always been a saver and I have a well paid job. Now things are getting serious, as we’re just engaged and I’m wondering about how to disclose this topic.

DP knows I’m comfortable as obviously I have a good job and a house which I own 50% of. I’ve always been transparent on that.

However, I haven’t mentioned previously that I have also a good amount of cash savings (Excl shares and pensions)

How do I start this convo?

OP posts:
mm8989 · 19/08/2021 07:53

Pay off the mortgage, don't get married. Suggest she invests in a property of her own.

Even if you have a deed of trust and are tenants in common, it can be overturned after a few years.

Ddot · 19/08/2021 07:43

You have told her you have savings so what's the problem, if she asks tell her if she dont dont. I would Pay off the mortgage and put a prenuptial on the house.

Topazmumma · 19/08/2021 07:40

I am honestly shocked at some of these comments... why would you not tell her? If you are serious enough that you are engaged, then you are planning to share your life with her. In my mind, that means sharing major details of both of your situations.

Obviously you wouldn't necessarily discuss financial at the beginning of a relationship, but surely now would be the time to sit down and have a frank and open talk. If you are not happy with how it goes, better to find out now than after you are married.

Mamanyt · 19/08/2021 00:54

@MojoMoon

"now we are engaged, I want to discuss finances and our future plans."

Topics for discussion

  1. current debts and savings
  2. future life plans eg having kids/caring for parents/travelling the world/studying for another qualification/moving house. How would you pay for these?
  3. retirement planning - what are both of you doing currently for pensions? When do you expect to retire? How will you fund retirment? How much will you need to have saved to fund it realistically?
  4. life insurance/critical illness coverage - how would you manage if one of you died or was very ill? Do you have any coverage?
  5. making wills - have you done it? What would you want to be in them - leaving everything to each other or would you want something to go to siblings/parents/friends etc

I'd say savings were one element of a much bigger conversation or series of conversations that you need to have before you get married. Don't make a massive deal of that part.

ABSOLUTELY THIS! The discussion about savings becomes a small part of a larger discussion, and quite normal and natural. And it will save a LOT of problems later, not just about the savings.

I would add "handling bank accounts" to that list. I've found that the best way to avoid issues is to have a household account, into which each person deposits funds for all basic living expenses (plus a contingency fund), and separate accounts which are used at the discretion of the holder..."Mad money," if you will.

I wish the people would spend one tenth of the time and energy planning their marriage that they do on planning their wedding. There would be far fewer divorces.

hopeso · 19/08/2021 00:05

The OP and partner have been together for 3 years already. I don't understand why some people think that's not long enough to get married. Would you think differently if the OP didn't have any savings? I truly believe that financial matters should be out in the open. Money is one of the biggest reasons for relationship breakdown. OP, are you expecting that when you get married you will add your partner to your house deeds and also have a joint account with her? When I met my husband, we both had our own flats. I had almost paid off my mortgage, he'd been in his flat for two years so had a big mortgage. He sold his, moved into mine and I put his name on the deeds so it was joint ownership. The huge amount of equity I had in my flat (I still think of it as mine by accident even though we both lived there for nearly ten years!), allowed us to buy a house together. I know exactly how much he has in his accounts and he knows how much I have in mine. We don't have joint accounts - just lazily never got round to it. My career and earnings over the past few years have been erratic, sometimes no work as a freelancer (especially during the pandemic), while he has been working consistently.

I guess you could have a pre-nup of sorts to protect what you have built up yourself - a friend of mine did that, the relationship is still going strong. What is your partner bringing to the financial table? Is that an issue? Will your reveal of your savings cause her to feel an inadequacies or change the relationship in any way?

Whatever you do, try not to keep things in the dark. I was upfront with my husband because my father had had huge debts which he hid from the family and not only can it be devastating, it can also impact hugely on mental health.

TroublesomeTrucks · 18/08/2021 23:46

@gunnersgold

Are you both female? Or are you a man?
Does it matter?
sassbott · 18/08/2021 23:27

@TractorAndHeadphones FWIW I agree with you. Especially on this part

It staggers me how entitled some people are to someone else’s products of their labour. Especially when earnt before the marriage

But brace yerself re the Q5 convo and ‘telling’ your wife no. Apparently in the world of Mnet that’s tantamount to financial abuse.
You should work until you die, but you cannot possibly say to someone ‘no you cannot spend 80k on a car.’

That’s financially controlling (apparently). I mean I call it financial planning. Tomatoes, tomatoes.

Bertiebiscuit · 18/08/2021 22:33

Not telling him might turn out to be the best thing - why does he need to know - ALL women should have their own money and answer to nobody about it imo

TractorAndHeadphones · 18/08/2021 21:44

[quote 31flavours]@Mermaid67

Pretty sexist statement. I came across this site as I am worried about my toddlers development. Dads care too.

Also I bring some red pill truth to certain discussions.

It staggers me how entitled some people are to someone else’s products of their labour. Especially when earnt before the marriage.

I had arguments with my wife about money before we got married as she wanted me to have my salary paid in to our joint account. I didn’t want to.
Anyway I relented somewhat. I pay between 70-90% of my take home in to our joint account . Depending what expenses I incur. You can’t really have a marriage and hide the money but you also need to critically assess the character of the person you’re marrying to protect yourself. I knew the character of my wife and she got with me when I was broke and married me when I was only just on £43k. So if she was gold digging she was digging in the wrong spot. I knew we would have to build together as I inherited nothing and had no wealth.

Your circumstance OP is different as you have more to lose. Hiding it isn’t an option but putting your foot down on the use of the funds is going to be a necessary discussion if you think she will become a bridezilla or start buying fendi everything.

Now I am earning more Ive had to do the same with my wife. Saying no, we’re not buying an Audi Q5. Because frankly My job is long hours and and at 35 I can’t imaging working another 35 years in it. So I need to be smart to retire early. This is the first potential argument you will have about money. It won’t be the last.[/quote]
You say your wife isn’t a ‘gold digger’ but you’ve had arguments about money. She wants an Audi but you want to retire early.
Doesn’t sound consistent at all to me.
Also sounds like you’re telling her what to do.
Looks like you’re arguing because you’re not on the same page about money. Not sure how long you’ll last without the same goals

Yorkshiretolondon · 18/08/2021 21:40

Why not pay off your mortgage if you have so much in savings

Brondie319 · 18/08/2021 21:36

If you're ever single.. Hit me up 🤣🤣
Seriously though, just bring it up casually if you feel like you should. You don't have to disclose a figure, just that you have savings. You're adults, discuss it as such x

Mermaid67 · 18/08/2021 21:33

[quote 31flavours]@Mermaid67

Pretty sexist statement. I came across this site as I am worried about my toddlers development. Dads care too.

Also I bring some red pill truth to certain discussions.

It staggers me how entitled some people are to someone else’s products of their labour. Especially when earnt before the marriage.

I had arguments with my wife about money before we got married as she wanted me to have my salary paid in to our joint account. I didn’t want to.
Anyway I relented somewhat. I pay between 70-90% of my take home in to our joint account . Depending what expenses I incur. You can’t really have a marriage and hide the money but you also need to critically assess the character of the person you’re marrying to protect yourself. I knew the character of my wife and she got with me when I was broke and married me when I was only just on £43k. So if she was gold digging she was digging in the wrong spot. I knew we would have to build together as I inherited nothing and had no wealth.

Your circumstance OP is different as you have more to lose. Hiding it isn’t an option but putting your foot down on the use of the funds is going to be a necessary discussion if you think she will become a bridezilla or start buying fendi everything.

Now I am earning more Ive had to do the same with my wife. Saying no, we’re not buying an Audi Q5. Because frankly My job is long hours and and at 35 I can’t imaging working another 35 years in it. So I need to be smart to retire early. This is the first potential argument you will have about money. It won’t be the last.[/quote]
Sorry didn’t mean to offend, certainly not sexist! Just assumed mumsnet was just for mums!

31flavours · 18/08/2021 21:26

@Mermaid67

Pretty sexist statement. I came across this site as I am worried about my toddlers development. Dads care too.

Also I bring some red pill truth to certain discussions.

It staggers me how entitled some people are to someone else’s products of their labour. Especially when earnt before the marriage.

I had arguments with my wife about money before we got married as she wanted me to have my salary paid in to our joint account. I didn’t want to.
Anyway I relented somewhat. I pay between 70-90% of my take home in to our joint account . Depending what expenses I incur. You can’t really have a marriage and hide the money but you also need to critically assess the character of the person you’re marrying to protect yourself. I knew the character of my wife and she got with me when I was broke and married me when I was only just on £43k. So if she was gold digging she was digging in the wrong spot. I knew we would have to build together as I inherited nothing and had no wealth.

Your circumstance OP is different as you have more to lose. Hiding it isn’t an option but putting your foot down on the use of the funds is going to be a necessary discussion if you think she will become a bridezilla or start buying fendi everything.

Now I am earning more Ive had to do the same with my wife. Saying no, we’re not buying an Audi Q5. Because frankly My job is long hours and and at 35 I can’t imaging working another 35 years in it. So I need to be smart to retire early. This is the first potential argument you will have about money. It won’t be the last.

CloudPop · 18/08/2021 21:26

I think it comes down to your relative attitudes to money. If you can agree on a savings / investment approach then that's good. If your partner wil immediately start to think what to spend it on, then there is a problem.

entropynow · 18/08/2021 21:13

@BluebellsGreenbells

I will add to that as well, what are you both like with money? Are you both savers or is she a spender? That can cause problems.

DH is due a large inheritance we’ve been married 20 years however I would see that money as his to spend or save as he pleases. Rather than half mine. I think that makes a difference.

I think the opposite. Married 35 years and inherited 300K, thanks to DH's advice I have boosted my pension (towards family expenses), given DS cash toward a flat and increased the remaining capital via good investment, it's all family money to me. When we were struggling 20 years ago his inheritance saved our family bacon. It would be churlish to consider my inheritance all mine.
Chickychickydodah · 18/08/2021 21:06

I’d keep some in secret and put a bit into the pot .

NurseMumMe · 18/08/2021 20:59

I should add of course in a divorce solicitors hunt for hidden finances to divide up but solicitors cost an absolute fortune and by the time they’ve finished neither of you will have any money left to divide - my ex obviously had MH probs which set off the chain of events but I will always be grateful for my financial choices at the time and would never marry again. Financial suicide if the marriage goes wrong

NurseMumMe · 18/08/2021 20:55

Late to conversation but I’ve been in same position.
My ex wife moved into my home I had almost finished paying for, we got married (civil partnership) and had a family. After 2 years my wife had an affair and took off with our joint savings- totally unpredicted.
I was left with my one income, our children and two lots of car insurance / phones etc plus all bills as she moved her wages to another account !
Thanks to some forward planning I had never put the house in shared names and had substantial savings tucked away. Yes I lost a lot cleared out the joint account but I was able to move forwards without losing our home etc
Maybe we should have been up front but being slightly older I wanted a safety net - glad I did or I’d have lost everything.
Nobody expects trouble in paradise but sadly it happens to the best of marriages.
I’d exercise caution.
Stats also suggest same sex marriages have a high failure rate last I knew too.
Good luck though and all the best for your future married life and starting a family ☺️

buey · 18/08/2021 20:42

Get a pre nup. I’m a family lawyer if you need some advice.

Hopelesscase32 · 18/08/2021 20:26

I wouldn't tell at all

Roxy69 · 18/08/2021 19:46

@oakleaffy

Don’t get married unless you want to lose half. Speaking from the experience of too many people. Only marry someone of equal Financial standing. Sounds callous, but the person you marry isn’t the person you divorce.
Excellently put.
oakleaffy · 18/08/2021 19:30

@MobyDicksTinyCanoe
I agree!
Don’t ever get married unless you want to lose half of everything.

oakleaffy · 18/08/2021 19:28

Don’t get married unless you want to lose half.
Speaking from the experience of too many people.
Only marry someone of equal
Financial standing.
Sounds callous, but the person you marry isn’t the person you divorce.

MobyDicksTinyCanoe · 18/08/2021 19:23

Oh ffs. I've said it once I'll say it a thousand times.
Don't
Get
Bloody
Married.

Just don't.

mellicauli · 18/08/2021 19:02

My feeling is that marriage should be an equal partnership: you pool your wealth, time and skills to start a family. You make joint decisions about how you live your life together and what your priorities are.

If you are not prepared to put your savings in the pool or you can't agree priorities, marriage may not be for you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread