Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

150k in undisclosed savings

266 replies

NCsecret · 17/08/2021 19:35

First off, I know IABU but not sure how to tel my DP this.

We’ve been together for 3 years and are now engaged (living together in my house). I’ve always been a saver and I have a well paid job. Now things are getting serious, as we’re just engaged and I’m wondering about how to disclose this topic.

DP knows I’m comfortable as obviously I have a good job and a house which I own 50% of. I’ve always been transparent on that.

However, I haven’t mentioned previously that I have also a good amount of cash savings (Excl shares and pensions)

How do I start this convo?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
skippy67 · 20/08/2021 11:18

I should clarify, we've been together 30 years, married for 18. Just in case the "it's different when your married" lot pipe up again.

skippy67 · 20/08/2021 11:05

I don't understand your use of "expect". For all I know my partner of 30 years has got savings I know nothing about. I've never asked.

Boombadoom · 20/08/2021 11:01

And yet the other side of the coin is that women should ‘just go and get a better job’ (another MN classic).

It’s absolutely nonsense. It is your choice to forego your career etc, and in the event you divorce, somehow you’re then entitled to whatever your husband had before you (here this mythical 150k) but not the other way around. This is part of the equality problem and I stand firm on that belief.

LastSummerHere · 20/08/2021 08:57

@Boombadoom

If a man came on here and said he had 150k in the bank and didn’t know how to tell his female fiancée, there is absolutely no way 50% of the responses would be to tell him not to marry his fiancée. NO WAY. There is disparity and it’s ludicrous.

Also, I’m sorry but 150k is fuck all really. If OP had millions I’d understand the concern a little more but you wouldn’t even buy a studio flat where I live for that. The histrionics (and complete ignorance of the requested advice) are unreasonable.

The power dynamics and disparity between men and women, and the future earning potential of each when children come along, means the two situations are simply not comparable.

Boombadoom · 20/08/2021 08:55

If a man came on here and said he had 150k in the bank and didn’t know how to tell his female fiancée, there is absolutely no way 50% of the responses would be to tell him not to marry his fiancée. NO WAY. There is disparity and it’s ludicrous.

Also, I’m sorry but 150k is fuck all really. If OP had millions I’d understand the concern a little more but you wouldn’t even buy a studio flat where I live for that. The histrionics (and complete ignorance of the requested advice) are unreasonable.

newnortherner111 · 20/08/2021 08:24

Not sure how to start the conversation, but I think you have to be open about this and not hide it.

Xenia · 20/08/2021 08:24

Yes, although even in marriage there was case called Imerman where the court said in terms of secrecy it depends on your relationshp - if you both keep things hidden, don't leave letters out, have secret accounts etc that is fine as it the opposite, during the marriage. If you are open (as we were - I did both our tax returns as he was happy I did, we both opened each other's post etc by consent) then you can each look during and at the divorce time. If you don't then you cannot snoop at the time of divorce either. Either set up is fine but it can h ave implications; although if there is a divorce then there is then a legal duty to disclose everything if it comes to a court hearing situation.

gunnersgold · 20/08/2021 08:07

Dp and dw is so different though isn't it because once you marry there is a legal entitlement .
Obviously you partner doesn't need to know what you have in savings .

Iamblossom · 19/08/2021 20:54

"So NCSecret's partner, what did you see in the considerably well off NCSecret?" Grin

Just say it in conversation, why should you feel embarrassed for being sensible with your money? They might be a bit taken aback and surprised, but should then be impressed and proud of you!

31flavours · 19/08/2021 20:38

@Ddot

The OP has all the advice they need. Protect themselves and know the character of the person they are marrying before revealing the true extent of their wealth. It’s simple. It’s 2021 marriages drop like flies with no real basis.

The nasty comments are warranted. Firstly because the other person is giving bad advice. Secondly because they are advocating materialism. Thirdly because they have inferred in to the state of another’s marriage based a single anecdote on a specific topic (money) when ironically they themselves are unmarried and not in a stable relationship (noting that they referred to their DH as a man they were dating… sounds super committed). Why shouldn’t that be called out. Especially when they hypocritically criticise others as being paragons of virtue when no such stance is taken.

Why take advice on how to navigate money matters with a spouse from someone so firmly camped in materialism and not even married. Needs to be called out.

Ddot · 19/08/2021 19:58

We are here to help op and give advice can we please stop the nasty comments to other posters, its tedious

Tal45 · 19/08/2021 18:36

I haven't read the whole thread so might be repeating. Are you earning more from the savings then you are paying in interest on the mortgage? If not I would pay a chunk/all of the mortgage off - then just say you've got some savings and you thought you'd use it on the mortgage.

31flavours · 19/08/2021 18:00

@TractorAndHeadphones

You happen to show internet comments to your other half so you can have a chuckle? Sounds like you’re capping’. Also sounds an incredibly dull marriage. If this poor soul exists, I’m also glad you go home to him than me. So I guess we’re both winning.

Hertsgirl10 · 19/08/2021 17:42

[quote Hekatestorch]@Hertsgirl10 I have no clue what you are on.

I didn't @ you. I quoted a small amount of what you posted and responded to that. The responded to other within the larger post.

You then replied and I replied back.

I am not offended you don't like my opinion. That's the point.

I am not complaining that people are advising the op she should tell her partner and marry them. Everyone has different advice.

Why would I be offended that you think a relationship is only 'real and true' if it involves joining finances? As I said, that sounds quite mercenary, but its not offensive.

Why would I be offended that you decided anyone who thinks op shouldn't get married is 'mumsnet' And deciding mumsnet opinion? Again, it's am odd thing to say, not offensive.[/quote]
Did I say the only real and true relationships share finances? Stop wrongly quoting what I have said 😂

I haven’t said anything odd at all, the way you’ve replied is though.

Walkingthroughwords · 19/08/2021 17:02

I'd be tempted to buy a house and rent it out. You can get a decent property here for that and rents here are very high. A 4 bed house costing 160 000 can be rented for 900 to 1000 a month. Plus you keep the house...just my take. My family all own properties.

Walkingthroughwords · 19/08/2021 17:00

I'm curious. I'm sure there's a reason connected to interest rates but why do you have the mortgage AND savings?
In Judaism there's a contract before marriage called a ketubah. It states what each person is bringing to the marriage. Topics like money and childrearing are covered on the first or second date. We all need to do this.
Draw up an agreement of some sort about what happens to money etc?
I was the one in my marriage who had money and I honestly rue the day I married him before I realised what he was like with money.

TractorAndHeadphones · 19/08/2021 16:59

[quote 31flavours]@TractorAndHeadphones

You sound kind of bitter. I said it is a 10 year old Audi. Bought when it was 5-6 years old. Other than that my daily driver is a 9 year old vw golf. Also we had more disposal income back then as we recently bought a new home at twice the price of our old home. So yeah you don’t know our circumstances. I never claimed to be a paragon of virtue. I like most am just finding my way through the trials and tribulations of marriage one issue at a time. Which is what the thread has evolved in to.

Why don’t you keep that bitter energy for whichever unfortunate sap comes home to it.[/quote]
Thanks for your comment - my DP and I had a good laugh. I’m glad I’m dating him and not a man like you, and he agrees
Please keep commenting and showing your emotion - it’s great entertainment :)

Hekatestorch · 19/08/2021 16:56

[quote JesusIsAnyNameFree]@Hekatestorch

Well, I'm gonna assume OP and her fiancée got engaged with the idea of getting married, like most people.[/quote]
But again, loads of people get engaged to get engaged. Or put the wedding off for ages. Or split.

So no, I don't consider newly engaged the same as definitely getting married. And the decisions I make would be very different. Depending on which camp I was in.

Hekatestorch · 19/08/2021 16:53

@Hertsgirl10 I have no clue what you are on.

I didn't @ you. I quoted a small amount of what you posted and responded to that. The responded to other within the larger post.

You then replied and I replied back.

I am not offended you don't like my opinion. That's the point.

I am not complaining that people are advising the op she should tell her partner and marry them. Everyone has different advice.

Why would I be offended that you think a relationship is only 'real and true' if it involves joining finances? As I said, that sounds quite mercenary, but its not offensive.

Why would I be offended that you decided anyone who thinks op shouldn't get married is 'mumsnet' And deciding mumsnet opinion? Again, it's am odd thing to say, not offensive.

purpletrains · 19/08/2021 16:45

My DP doesn't know what i have in my savings account

Doesnt need to know right now

31flavours · 19/08/2021 15:34

@TractorAndHeadphones

You sound kind of bitter. I said it is a 10 year old Audi. Bought when it was 5-6 years old. Other than that my daily driver is a 9 year old vw golf. Also we had more disposal income back then as we recently bought a new home at twice the price of our old home. So yeah you don’t know our circumstances. I never claimed to be a paragon of virtue. I like most am just finding my way through the trials and tribulations of marriage one issue at a time. Which is what the thread has evolved in to.

Why don’t you keep that bitter energy for whichever unfortunate sap comes home to it.

JesusIsAnyNameFree · 19/08/2021 15:08

@Hekatestorch

Well, I'm gonna assume OP and her fiancée got engaged with the idea of getting married, like most people.

Hertsgirl10 · 19/08/2021 14:54

@Hekatestorch

I didn’t say any of what you’re saying here so I don’t see what point you’re trying to make

Oddly, it wasn't ALL about you.

You haven’t seen ALL of the comments saying why tell her? That’s hiding. Not suggesting that the OP is a hiding things. I am answering her actually question, without making it personal to my situation or things I have been through... unlike a lot of you. So I don’t need to ‘crack on’.

Op hasn't told her so far. People are suggesting she continues to not tell her. So are both hiding it or both not hiding it?

Your view is one view. Other people have different views. But it appears you don't really like that. I just can't figure out why, some people believing op shouldn't financially tie herself to someone, has your back up.

You are saying you aren't making it perso Al to you, however you hs e fairly strong opinions on it and on posters. All that's coloured by your own personal life and experiences. Everyone's opinion, will always be impacted by that.

Do you believe people just pluck opinions from thin air?

To the people saying she should not get married... They are engaged. To come now and say she won't be marrying her partner is a breakup.

Not really. Plenty of people remain engaged for many many years.

@Hekatestorch I wasn’t making anything about me 😂 I was replying to you, because you literally @ me 😂😂

I can tell you’re offended by the way you’re making absolutely no sense at all and trying to make yourself make sense 😆

Again I was talking about what OP asked and not about her not actually getting married.

Hekatestorch · 19/08/2021 14:44

I didn’t say any of what you’re saying here so I don’t see what point you’re trying to make

Oddly, it wasn't ALL about you.

You haven’t seen ALL of the comments saying why tell her? That’s hiding. Not suggesting that the OP is a hiding things. I am answering her actually question, without making it personal to my situation or things I have been through... unlike a lot of you. So I don’t need to ‘crack on’.

Op hasn't told her so far. People are suggesting she continues to not tell her. So are both hiding it or both not hiding it?

Your view is one view. Other people have different views. But it appears you don't really like that. I just can't figure out why, some people believing op shouldn't financially tie herself to someone, has your back up.

You are saying you aren't making it perso Al to you, however you hs e fairly strong opinions on it and on posters. All that's coloured by your own personal life and experiences. Everyone's opinion, will always be impacted by that.

Do you believe people just pluck opinions from thin air?

To the people saying she should not get married... They are engaged. To come now and say she won't be marrying her partner is a breakup.

Not really. Plenty of people remain engaged for many many years.

Hertsgirl10 · 19/08/2021 14:27

@Hekatestorch

Ffs so according to mumsnet if you have got money behind you then don’t get married.

Not mumsnet. Some posters have this opinion. I am one of them, however, we are not 'mumsnet'

And its not about 'money or relationship', many people can have extremely fulfilling relationships without joining finances with people.

Tbh, suggesting that you can't have a fullfilling relationship, without joining finances, sounds quite mercenary in itself.

People who say money doesn't bring happiness are woefully naive. No one believes it brings happiness. But it does bring a certain amount of security and a hell of a lot of choices. That's what it brings. Relationships often fail due to money. More often than not, due to a lack of it.

Op asked about telling her dp. It's some people's opinions, that she doesn't need to. Just an opinion.

But so many are so outraged that anyone would dare venture that opinion.

If you got married and share finances, great. You and your spouse are on the same page and everything great. So crack on.

Neither opinion is more valid. They are peoples opinions. Different points if view based on different lives and experiences.

And I don't think anyone told op to hide it. Unless you think she is hiding it now. It appears that she just never brought it up. If you think op not disclosing this is 'hiding her money', surely you think she is already deceiving her partner, so probably should not be getting married to a partner she is actively deceiving already.

I didn’t say any of what you’re saying here so I don’t see what point you’re trying to make 😂

You haven’t seen ALL of the comments saying why tell her? That’s hiding. Not suggesting that the OP is a hiding things. I am answering her actually question, without making it personal to my situation or things I have been through... unlike a lot of you. So I don’t need to ‘crack on’.