Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a doctor telling you that you need to lose weight isn't "fat shaming?"

185 replies

FrankieDoyle · 17/08/2021 19:00

Genuinely interested in opinions.
I follow a plus size Instagram blogger/influencer who normally posts about fashion, inspirational quotes etc.

Today she posted about a trip to hospital that she had. The doctors there were apparently unhelpful and told her that they couldn't operate on her because, amongst other reasons, her weight. They told her she would need to lose weight before they could consider it.
I think she's about a size 26-28, from her posts about her wardrobe where she's mentioned the size she wears.

So she posted a video stating that she was sick of being fat shamed, something needs to change, and the doctors don't take her seriously etc.

It got me thinking that actually I disagree with her viewpoint that it's "fat shaming" to inform a patient that they need to lose weight? The doctors have to check that it's safe to perform an operation on someone don't they?

I say this as an overweight person myself (currently a size 20 but following a diet plan and trying to lose weight. )

Maybe I'm wrong I don't know, but it seems unfair to criticise doctors on a public platform with thousands of followers, simply for doing their job.

I understand some doctors can be patronising or seem to focus on a person's weight, and that can't be a nice experience. But I really disagree that it's "fat shaming" actually I quite dislike the phrase being used to criticise these medical professionals.

OP posts:
Dentistlakes · 18/08/2021 09:40

@kittykarate

There are definitely some doctors that basically just see the fat and as the only possible cause for your illness. "Got a pain in your stomach? Have you tried losing weight". "Feeling depressed Have you tried losing weight". "think you might have autism? Have you tried losing weight".

And if they can't mop up their diagnosis via fat shaming, they'll go for "it's your age" and maybe with some added "it could be the menopause"

It may not be the only possible cause but in a lot of cases it’s a contributing factor. For example, exercise can greatly improve mental health, but if someone is very overweight they may feel unable to exercise. Losing weight can improve someone’s confidence which then translates into them being able to make other lifestyle changes.
Oogachuckachopsy · 18/08/2021 09:37

Fat shaming or……..sound medical advice in relation to postoperative complications, issues with anaesthetic and mid-operative cardiac arrest?

lljkk · 18/08/2021 09:37

I'm sorry for the metaphor sounding like a slur, it wasn't invented to have anything to do with obesity. GPs can't win, I suppose, and would rather risk giving offence than be negligent.

It's ignoring the elephant in the room not to tell someone that their hugely excess weight isn't a known or likely problem. Like saying "Sure! I'm a debt specialist & I'll loan you £5 to pay Paul & let's just ignore that your home is about to be re-possessed and you have to go bankrupt, you don't want to talk about any of that, do you?" Don't collude in denial.

Dentistlakes · 18/08/2021 09:35

Of course it’s not fat shaming for a doctor to give their medical opinion regarding a patient’s weight. I wish more would tbh. Being overweight contributes to so many health problems and imo should be the first port of call for patients as something they can address to make a real difference to their health.

I’m a good case in point having been overweight for many years after having children. The weight creeps on and you just get used to feeling crap and tired all the time. The problem is there’s no quick fix and it takes an enormous amount of effort on the patient’s part to change their lifestyle.

SleepingStandingUp · 18/08/2021 09:35

Also I was surprised that surgeons were just like on tv medical drama shows. Stuck up and thinking they are demi-god like i imagine the absolute power they have to give life plays into the ego, but I've had the same surgeon who's properly balled out a nurse in the middle of the ward because his word is law, then calmly sit there whilst I've screamed and shouted at them. There's rarely one side to anyone

kittykarate · 18/08/2021 09:34

There are definitely some doctors that basically just see the fat and as the only possible cause for your illness. "Got a pain in your stomach? Have you tried losing weight". "Feeling depressed Have you tried losing weight". "think you might have autism? Have you tried losing weight".

And if they can't mop up their diagnosis via fat shaming, they'll go for "it's your age" and maybe with some added "it could be the menopause"

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 18/08/2021 09:30

@Vates

Also I was surprised that surgeons were just like on tv medical drama shows. Stuck up and thinking they are demi-god like. The surgeons that saw my Mum whilst I was there were just plain rude.
I haven't dealt with any surgeons but I've run into a few GPs and specialists like this in the course of an over 2 decade chronic illness. I know people with my chronic illness who have been told to go away and lose weight first as if it's a panecea. When really what they needed was a way to reduce their suffering so they had the mental and physical capacity to cook and exercise and make healthier choices.

In the case of the OP not fat shaming, but there are doctor's that do see the weight, not the person, and in so doing fail to help them. I think society still falls to much on the side of thinking of weight, of fat as a value judgement.

Coogee · 18/08/2021 09:29

I was at a museum yesterday and people were negatively commenting on the size of Henry VIII's arse and waist.

Even if he could hear, he’s a man so unlikely to be so sensitive, or even bothered at all

My husband went to visit his doctor and he hadn’t even sat down before the doctor said “You could do with losing a stone or two”. He came home and laughed about it. Then lost nearly three stone.

SleepingStandingUp · 18/08/2021 09:28

@Longdistance

It’s not fat shaming per se, but would be more helpful if the GP gave some dietary advice or referred them to a dietitian.
It wasn't the GP, it was a hospital doctor. It isn't the consultants / anaesthesiologists job to provide dieting info
SchrodingersImmigrant · 18/08/2021 09:24

@lotsofdogshere

Not meaning to minimise a great OP. I’m on Facebook groups for specific dog breeds. There are so many posts that attack vets who dare suggest fluffy is overweight. Pics of fluffy confirm (IMO) the vet is right, the dog needs to loose some weight. What follows are numerous pics of other overweight dogs with the comment ‘see just like mine, perfect’. Some of us seem to be losing all understanding of what being significantly overweight does to us
Animal abuse. Pure and simple
lotsofdogshere · 18/08/2021 09:16

Not meaning to minimise a great OP. I’m on Facebook groups for specific dog breeds. There are so many posts that attack vets who dare suggest fluffy is overweight. Pics of fluffy confirm (IMO) the vet is right, the dog needs to loose some weight. What follows are numerous pics of other overweight dogs with the comment ‘see just like mine, perfect’.
Some of us seem to be losing all understanding of what being significantly overweight does to us

Cannes12 · 18/08/2021 08:56

Obesity is a health issue. There's no escaping that.
Being very overweight also counts against you if you're seeking to adopt as it suggests an unhealthy lifestyle you could pass onto your xhildren.

ShingleBeach · 18/08/2021 08:36

@Vates Your post demonstrates exactly why real fat shaming is so damaging, and traps people into not being able to do the very thing that non-fat-shaming doctors would like them to do… because most doctors do in fact care about the well being of patients.

I am very sorry that you have been subjected to such bullying and abuse.

Sadly HCPs can’t diagnose which of their patients are bullying and fat-shaming others, because curing them if that nasty habit could work wonders!

gurglebelly · 18/08/2021 08:26

I think there is a difference between making you aware of the impact of your weight, and that being the sole focus of every interaction.

I recently met with a consultant - first appointment got a weight lecture, when he came to see me after my op got the same weight lecture, first follow up appointment got the same weight lecture, I must admit that the first thing I said when I attended my second follow up was 'message about weight is heard and understood and I'm not prepared to listen to the lecture again, so can we please just talk about what is actually wrong with me?'.

He had gone way past making me aware that my weight had an impact on my health (which not being an idiot I am well aware of), but it was not relevant to the reason I was seeing him and it genuinely started to feel like he was just enjoying making me feel bad by this point

PieceOfString · 18/08/2021 08:18

@Ludo19

I had thyroid surgery and weighed just over 10st at the time. The aftercare nurse said "now you'll need to watch your weight???" Preceeded to give me exercise and dietary advice, even though I trained in a gym as well as horseriding and swimming. Not being rude but she was at least double my weight, so I smiled sweetly and asked if she followed her own advice. Practice what you preach
Wow, nurse tries to advise you that your surgery could affect your weight and you retaliate with a remark like that without knowing you anything about why she was overweight! Smiles sweetly = makes a shitty comeback. You must know the thyroid plays a big part in weight +/- surely, she wasn't commenting on your lifestyle!
Binnaggy · 18/08/2021 08:13

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

ThinWomansBrain · 18/08/2021 08:10

@MyCatEatsPrawnCrackers

Oh FFS it isn't 'fat shaming'. Having said that, when I was a size 20, I was advised to lose weight by a nurse who was even fatter than me Confused. My sister also had to see a dietician at the local hospital, as she had been referred due to a medical condition she had and said she struggled to take him seriously as he was very overweight.
no - not easy - but I once had a stick thin dietician who clearly had her own unhealthy issues with food. Over several appointments, the only food she ever expressed a liking for was purple sprouting broccoli (and harped on about the fact it was only in season for a very short season, which from the way she expressed it was part of the attraction for her). When she waffled on about having a daily treat, and cutting a marathon (snickers) bar into seven pieces & having one each day, there was clearly little empathy or understanding.
JulesCobb · 18/08/2021 08:04

It's not actually proven weight has a negative impact on health but doctors have been taught this is true and have no reason to learn off their own backs so keep spouting this as truth.
And you, of course, have a peer reviewed source for this grossly inaccurate statement…

IsItWorthTheHassle · 18/08/2021 08:01

@SilverGlitterBaubles

Sometimes overweight people go to the doctor for a completely unrelated reason and the doctor brings their weight into it. That's fat shaming. But not when it's relevant.

No it is not, in the same way as they might mention often do a quick check of blood pressure while you are there for something unrelated or if the doctor spotted another visible issue you would expect them to mention it.

It’s at the very least ticking boxes. ‘Oh ive to.d them they need to loose some weight’ with no support given for said person to actually do so.

That’s worse imo. Because you can be sure they've actually set the person to fail.
Training wouldn’t go amiss tbh.

IsItWorthTheHassle · 18/08/2021 07:58

Tbh, it depends

  • on the way it was said (Incl tine of voice, general attitude etc etc)
  • what sort of help has been given
  • what medication that person is on (see the effects of steroids for example)
  • what sort of tests have been done to understand the reasons of the weight gain.

Basically telling someone who has hypothyroidism that isn’t well controlled that they need to loose weight wo sorting the thyroid issue is crap (eg if you haven’t checked for autoimmune causes).
Same with hormonal issues, cortisol, MH etc etc

Because, surprise surprise, loosing weight isn’t just about ‘reducing calorie intake and exercising more you know’.

If that person is expecting them to do the surgery regardless, I would also hope that the risks have been laid out to her. Eg if we do the surgery, the risk of you dying in the process is (let’s say) 10%, the risk of you being disabled for life is 45%.
Because atm it sounds like they have no real understanding of the reason iyswim.

LittleRedPill · 18/08/2021 07:56

I don’t think this is fat shaming.

However, we do know that lots of HCPs are dismissive of overweight people and that they can take longer to get diagnosed with serious illnesses because many GPs tell them to just ‘lose weight’ instead of investigating symptoms. I read a good, peer reviewed study on this recently but for the life on me cannot find it now!

I am not obese now but have been in the past. I used to follow a lot of plus size bloggers for style advice/clothing tips. And many do look fabulous. But it did start to bother me. Being fat is just not an alternative body shape as is often suggested. It can have real, serious health risks. I remember reading a blog about an influencers trip to New York. All these shots of her looking amazing in beautiful dresses, shorts and dresses. A while later there was another blog saying how had that trip had been for her. How her knees had been agony after all that walking, how tough she had found the heat, how she was unable to do some of the things her slimmer companions enjoyed. She got very mixed comments for that one I think. It wasn’t what many of her followers wanted to hear.

NonagonInfinityOpensTheDoor · 18/08/2021 07:56

In this situation no, it’s not fat shaming it’s stating facts.

What does stick in my throat is how some HCP can’t see past the weight to diagnose medical issues properly. I suffered for years with various symptoms, every time was told to lose weight. After years and years of pushing back I finally find a doctor who referred me to a specialist who diagnosed me with a condition absolutely not related to my weight. Luckily it isn’t something life threatening but there are stories of missed brain tumours and terminal issues that are overlooked because “lose weight” is the first and only diagnosis some HCP will bother with.

MsTSwift · 18/08/2021 07:49

As a professional they need to cover their arses professionally. If they don’t mention it or take it into account in treatment and the obese person drops dead of an obesity related condition and there is nothing in the notes to say they mentioned it or considered it there may be liability.

SilverGlitterBaubles · 18/08/2021 07:41

Sometimes overweight people go to the doctor for a completely unrelated reason and the doctor brings their weight into it. That's fat shaming. But not when it's relevant.

No it is not, in the same way as they might mention often do a quick check of blood pressure while you are there for something unrelated or if the doctor spotted another visible issue you would expect them to mention it.

MsTSwift · 18/08/2021 07:39

Often it’s the push you need to lose weight. I had a routine medical and my bmi was firmly in the “overweight” category. In my mind I am slim but it had gradually crept on. The nurse was lovely about it but I was horrified. That was Oct 2019 I lost 2 stone by the following January and have kept it off. Totally changed my lifestyle. Very grateful for that wake up call as at 46 I would have got gradually larger if I had drifted on as I was.