Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a doctor telling you that you need to lose weight isn't "fat shaming?"

185 replies

FrankieDoyle · 17/08/2021 19:00

Genuinely interested in opinions.
I follow a plus size Instagram blogger/influencer who normally posts about fashion, inspirational quotes etc.

Today she posted about a trip to hospital that she had. The doctors there were apparently unhelpful and told her that they couldn't operate on her because, amongst other reasons, her weight. They told her she would need to lose weight before they could consider it.
I think she's about a size 26-28, from her posts about her wardrobe where she's mentioned the size she wears.

So she posted a video stating that she was sick of being fat shamed, something needs to change, and the doctors don't take her seriously etc.

It got me thinking that actually I disagree with her viewpoint that it's "fat shaming" to inform a patient that they need to lose weight? The doctors have to check that it's safe to perform an operation on someone don't they?

I say this as an overweight person myself (currently a size 20 but following a diet plan and trying to lose weight. )

Maybe I'm wrong I don't know, but it seems unfair to criticise doctors on a public platform with thousands of followers, simply for doing their job.

I understand some doctors can be patronising or seem to focus on a person's weight, and that can't be a nice experience. But I really disagree that it's "fat shaming" actually I quite dislike the phrase being used to criticise these medical professionals.

OP posts:
Staffy1 · 18/08/2021 11:41

It would be a start to acknowledge and treat hypothyroidism appropriately if they really do want to help. This is not always the GPs fault as they have guidelines to follow, although enough of them are reluctant to even follow those regarding thyroid. It’s the national health organisation that sets these guidelines that is failing thousands of people who are not getting the treatment that they should be and would be getting in other countries.

Duetorain · 18/08/2021 11:36

Not fat shaming. Required and should include sources of help such as dietitian.

Medical professionals and MNetters that are obese will often explain medical reasons for the obesity- physical and mental.

Just as for those threads it is fat shaming to assume that advice from a professional about weight loss is invalid just due to the weight (high or low) of that person.

Spondooliesforholibobs · 18/08/2021 11:10

@Flatdisco

It's not actually proven weight has a negative impact on health but doctors have been taught this is true and have no reason to learn off their own backs so keep spouting this as truth.
This is why they do have to keep mentioning it @Flatdisco is not the only person thinking this, some people realise the risk but don’t equate it with themselves and much more commonly people don’t realise all the risks.

Flatdisco being obese is absolutely proven to affect health in multiple ways including increasing the risk of some cancers.

Eg overweight risks anaesthetic increase, but also increases surgical risks, increases risks of wound problems etc. So sometimes the risk outweighs the benefit unless someone looses weight.

For some health conditions it only increases risk, so not every overweight person will become type 2 diabetic and some “healthy” BMI will become type 2 diabetic. This is not because the overweight person is eating lots of sugar, it is because the large amount of (particularly abdominal) fat causes insulin resistance. So the very fact they have higher BMI contributes to the increased risk, irrespective of exercise/ healthy diet etc

Ibelieveinghosts · 18/08/2021 10:59

@SchrodingersImmigrant

Obesity isn't always a symptom of MN struggles. Sometime it can be the cause. It needs very individual approach. Some of us are just fat and if someone tried to tell me I must have MH issues, I would not react well. But someone else has them and it would be needed for them.

I am also of the opinion that anyone presenting mh issues should have blood tests done. I had anxiety attacks which gave me incredible chest pains. I still get anxcious about things when my vit D is low. I am pretty sure from description of my symptoms that if I had a different GP I would get antidepressants or anxiety medication, rather than treatment for deficiency. Hollistic approach is needefld with everything medical.

Yes it is an extraordinarily complex area. Many GPs try and treat all mental health issues with medication which in the long term very rarely solves the problem unless the cause of the mental health problem is only a chemical imbalance.

Physical issues can also replicate symptoms of mental health issues as well as causing them.

The medical profession are extremely incompetent at dealing with mental health issues or anything presenting as such. Usually, like you say antidepressants (many of which themselves cause weight gain) are just prescribed.

I think what we agree on is that the medical profession repeatedly fail to look beyond what is immediately presented and spends a lot of time and money trying to sort the symptoms rather than underlying causes.

Keke94LND · 18/08/2021 10:51

It's not fat shaming lol, be fat and be happy but don't be surprised when it comes with health issues or a literal medical professional brings up your weight in relation to a surgery/medical issue you have .. it's like, as an example, if a very thin woman with a six pack was struggling to conceive, they would possibly tell her she needs to gain more body fat, that's not shaming it's just facts

ThatSunnyCorner · 18/08/2021 10:50

@Flatdisco

It's not actually proven weight has a negative impact on health but doctors have been taught this is true and have no reason to learn off their own backs so keep spouting this as truth.
It's been proven many times and for numerous different aspects of health.
SchrodingersImmigrant · 18/08/2021 10:48

@bebanjo

It may not be fat shaming, but it is not helpful. Addicts af all kinds are offered help from the nhs to beat there additions, smokers can get gum and patches. If your overweight you just get told to eat less, why don’t we tell heroin addicts to just stop injecting? Unless you are over a massive BMI the nhs will do nothing. Untel there is some real help, the obesity crisis will just get worse.
I would be careful. People always say "treat it like addiction" bit how are addictions treated generally? You don't see a drug addict showing injection scars proudly while telling people to fuck off and stop drug shaming them, you don't see local heroin dealer collaborating with them on insta... Now I know that's illegal drugs, but the same goes foe alcohol. You don't have an obvious alcoholic promoted and hailed as a role model and getting money from promoting stuff.

Either people want to treat it as an addiction, or not. But pussyfooting in the middle and picking just handy bits, is not right.

Also, smokers can get patches, obese can get gym for a pound, at least i did. And dietitian. And I wasn't even morbifly obese then

Spondooliesforholibobs · 18/08/2021 10:44

@bebanjo

It may not be fat shaming, but it is not helpful. Addicts af all kinds are offered help from the nhs to beat there additions, smokers can get gum and patches. If your overweight you just get told to eat less, why don’t we tell heroin addicts to just stop injecting? Unless you are over a massive BMI the nhs will do nothing. Untel there is some real help, the obesity crisis will just get worse.
What do you suggest? Genuinely trying to work out if you mean food addiction counselling?
SchrodingersImmigrant · 18/08/2021 10:44

Obesity isn't always a symptom of MN struggles. Sometime it can be the cause.
It needs very individual approach. Some of us are just fat and if someone tried to tell me I must have MH issues, I would not react well. But someone else has them and it would be needed for them.

I am also of the opinion that anyone presenting mh issues should have blood tests done. I had anxiety attacks which gave me incredible chest pains. I still get anxcious about things when my vit D is low. I am pretty sure from description of my symptoms that if I had a different GP I would get antidepressants or anxiety medication, rather than treatment for deficiency. Hollistic approach is needefld with everything medical.

bebanjo · 18/08/2021 10:39

It may not be fat shaming, but it is not helpful.
Addicts af all kinds are offered help from the nhs to beat there additions, smokers can get gum and patches.
If your overweight you just get told to eat less, why don’t we tell heroin addicts to just stop injecting?
Unless you are over a massive BMI the nhs will do nothing.
Untel there is some real help, the obesity crisis will just get worse.

Ibelieveinghosts · 18/08/2021 10:38

@SchrodingersImmigrant

"Got a pain in your stomach? Have you tried losing weight". "Feeling depressed Have you tried losing weight".

These two can actually be weight tied. Being obese afects digestive system so does not exercising. Also obese are more likely to be vit d deficient which can lead to depression and even suicidal thoughts. Interesting research on it. People, including often doctors, sometimes don't realise how physical and mental sides are tied

Absolutely agree that this tie in with physical and mental health is often totally ignored by the medical profession. It’s not a coincidence that we have both an obeisity and mental health crisis in this country.

Drs need to really start seeing obesity as a symptom of mental health struggles, as I mentioned up thread there are numerous studies that show poor mental health leads to obesity, they are even well understood reasons why.
it’s increasingly recognised in the mental health word but the general medical profession are appallingly misinformed about the realities of mental health.

The government really needs to be focusing on mental health, drs (and society) need to move beyond the whole obese =lazy +greedy, = stupid often this is so far from the truth.

They need to move away from if you just lost weight you might feel better/less depressed etc to if you felt better/less depressed you would probably loose weight. It’s impossible to go for a run if you’re talking every ounce of energy to put one foot in front of the other.

Eating might quiet that stomach churning with anxiety, facial movements might pull you briefly out of fight or flight. It’s about (as one rape victim respondent said) after losing more than half her body weight and regaining more, feeling safer as men don’t look at fat women. It’s impossible to look after a body you can’t feel through dissociation or hate so much because you still associate it with being abused as a child. We like to think these situations are rare, unfortunately they are not.

Obesity wont be solved by removing snickers from advertising boards, it will be solved by investing in mental health services and people starting to see obesity as largely a symptom of a very serious and complicated disease rather than something to laugh at and blame the person suffering.

SunShinesBrightly · 18/08/2021 10:37

@Popetthetreehugger

A good friend is a dispenser in a pharmacy, they have been told , backed up with training , that if someone is overweight they must initiate a conversation about it . She just told the manager to jog on !
If a chemist dispenser started talking to me about my weight I would think it was highly inappropriate! The same would apply if they asked why I was taking certain medication. These conversations are for me and the doctor.
AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 18/08/2021 10:36

I’m often deeply concerned about the number of very obese children I see when I’m out and about with my children.
The poor kids are just being set up for a life time of struggling with their weight and suffering terrible health issues.
I wonder what will have to happen before it will start being taken seriously instead of labelled as “fat shaming” to discuss the issue.

Binnaggy · 18/08/2021 10:32

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

itsgettingwierd · 18/08/2021 10:26

“It's not actually proven weight has a negative impact on health but doctors have been taught this is true and have no reason to learn off their own backs so keep spouting this as truth.”

So not link between belly fat and type 2 diabetes?

Extra weight on joints?

Heart disease cause by excess fat?

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 18/08/2021 10:25

It’s not fat shaming to not want someone to die on an operating table.

Popetthetreehugger · 18/08/2021 10:24

A good friend is a dispenser in a pharmacy, they have been told , backed up with training , that if someone is overweight they must initiate a conversation about it . She just told the manager to jog on !

Binnaggy · 18/08/2021 10:08

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

Qwerty789 · 18/08/2021 09:57

I was at a museum yesterday and people were negatively commenting on the size of Henry VIII's arse and waist. It made me feel uncomfortable as l thought these are people that probably don't understand the concept of fat shaming. I mean it was just a model so it doesn't matter in that context but ...it wouldn't enter my head to say 'look at that enormous bottom!!' about a model

That's not fat shaming either. You can't fat shame a dummy and you can't fat shame someone who has been dead for centuries. There's nothing at all wrong with discussing how massive Henry VIII was when he died.
People are still allowed to have opinions on things, it's not illegal (yet). The "body positivity" movement goes on and on and on about "fat is beautiful" and so on. Well, I'm happy for women who feel beautiful if they are morbidly obese and I'm happy that other people find them so and I hope no-one treats them badly about their size...BUT I don't personally have to find it beautiful and I don't have to think its great. Because I don't.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 18/08/2021 09:55

"Got a pain in your stomach? Have you tried losing weight". "Feeling depressed Have you tried losing weight".

These two can actually be weight tied. Being obese afects digestive system so does not exercising. Also obese are more likely to be vit d deficient which can lead to depression and even suicidal thoughts. Interesting research on it. People, including often doctors, sometimes don't realise how physical and mental sides are tied

Disneycharacter · 18/08/2021 09:52

She's too busy believing g her own propaganda to listen to common sense

Qwerty789 · 18/08/2021 09:48

@Flatdisco

It's not actually proven weight has a negative impact on health but doctors have been taught this is true and have no reason to learn off their own backs so keep spouting this as truth.
What a load of bullshit. There are a million ways weight affects health and they are very much proven. Where do people get this bollocks?
joystir59 · 18/08/2021 09:44

It people will not take care of themselves how can the Dr?

joystir59 · 18/08/2021 09:43

Telling someone in your care they need to lose weight is the right thing to do. Telling someone you love that need need to lose weight is the right thing to do. Asking someone who is complaining about a health problem that you know can be caused or worsened by being overweight if they've considered trying to lose weight is the right thing to do.

itsgettingwierd · 18/08/2021 09:41

Of course it's not fat shaming.

It's another piece of evidence of the increases entitlement some people seem to be getting.

I'm pretty sure if she had surgery and had complications due to her morbid obesity she'd try and sue the consultant for that.