Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a doctor telling you that you need to lose weight isn't "fat shaming?"

185 replies

FrankieDoyle · 17/08/2021 19:00

Genuinely interested in opinions.
I follow a plus size Instagram blogger/influencer who normally posts about fashion, inspirational quotes etc.

Today she posted about a trip to hospital that she had. The doctors there were apparently unhelpful and told her that they couldn't operate on her because, amongst other reasons, her weight. They told her she would need to lose weight before they could consider it.
I think she's about a size 26-28, from her posts about her wardrobe where she's mentioned the size she wears.

So she posted a video stating that she was sick of being fat shamed, something needs to change, and the doctors don't take her seriously etc.

It got me thinking that actually I disagree with her viewpoint that it's "fat shaming" to inform a patient that they need to lose weight? The doctors have to check that it's safe to perform an operation on someone don't they?

I say this as an overweight person myself (currently a size 20 but following a diet plan and trying to lose weight. )

Maybe I'm wrong I don't know, but it seems unfair to criticise doctors on a public platform with thousands of followers, simply for doing their job.

I understand some doctors can be patronising or seem to focus on a person's weight, and that can't be a nice experience. But I really disagree that it's "fat shaming" actually I quite dislike the phrase being used to criticise these medical professionals.

OP posts:
VladmirsPoutine · 18/08/2021 14:34

This might have already been said, but I think a lot of the issue stems from doctors or generally healthcare practitioners declaring that every single issue that a fat person may have is a result of their weight. Not even bother to run investigations or consider any other alternatives because they are just purely focused on weight.

BillywigSting · 18/08/2021 14:29

Coming from someone who is very overweight, it's definitely not fat shaming. Is it unpleasant to hear? Yes. Is it frustrating that whatever medical procedure is required is contra indicated by her excess weight? Undeniably. Is it even unfair? Yeah probably a bit.

It's many not very nice things, to be sure, but fat shaming it is not.

EBearhug · 18/08/2021 14:21

That's the approach my GP has, too.

ValidUser · 18/08/2021 14:19

@Lairymary

My husband is friends with someone who is a GP, she is rather large and I occasionally wonder how she delivers the "you need to lose weight" chat without getting embarrassed Hmm
I'm a doctor but not a GP. I'm a bit fat. In the past, I've had to have those conversations (not in my current job).

I always acknowledged that I could be healthier and it was easier said than done.

People received it quite well and often lost significant weight.

Geamhradh · 18/08/2021 14:00

@thestrawberrygirl

I'm in Italy, my Dr tells me on every visit that I'm overweight and must lose some. I'm 167cm and 72kg, I agree with him, I really need to, it's his job to tell me. I'm also told often my my DH, in laws and friends I need to and it's not offensive in the slightest to me, they simply care about my health and the impacts of being overweight on the rest of my health. It's a very accepted thing to say here and not labelled fat shaming, which I find ridiculous and might explain my shock at the size of some very young women on my last visit to UK. I don't recall young women being so large when I lived there 25 years ago. While we're on the subject, I'm two sizes smaller in UK clothes than I used to be despite being fatter, have they change the sizing?
I'm also in Italy and agree. And yes, for some reason companies selling us a size 16 and pretending it's a 12 makes us feel better about needing the 16. It's a dangerous precedent and they're all doing it.
pooonastick · 18/08/2021 13:34

Some good points on here regarding how to help people lose weight saying it in a helpful way . However as part of my job, I have to tell people that that can't have an anaesthetic because they are too big and their risk of dying is too high. This is always delivered in a kind way but its a black and white decision . Its not my opinion or judgement .

chaos76 · 18/08/2021 13:32

@Vates

I am a size 24-26 so true fattie here. I don't think it is shaming to be honest but approached with care. My GP who has treated me (severe mental health problems) since 19 only tried to tackle my weight problem once and she was incredibly sweet but honest about it. Unfortunately I don't want to live (and living a long life would be my personal hell!) and love food more than people (food is nicer than you're average person) so there's not a solution as far as I can tell. But Society in general definitely has a problem with fat shaming. My god, the incidents for me between the ages of 16-30 destroyed me, my confidence and my whole life. BTW, at size 20 people will definitely still look down on you! I think the shaming needs to stop.
Please get some proper help for your mental health so you can live life again, you sound like you are giving up, there are good things out there x
EBearhug · 18/08/2021 13:27

In this age of internet and information literally everywhere, do people really need someone else to tell them what food is low calorie and what food isn't? I mean, I reckon most reception kids know that carrots are healthy and Big Macs aren't! I think that weight loss groups can be helpful, but expecting a dietician to tell you what you should and shouldn't eat to lose weight is really quite shocking.

I don't know. When I was recently referred to the dietician, she was very focused on losing weight and just wanting to refer me to Weight Watchers, even after I said no. I wasn't asking about losing weight. I was asking about specific nutrients and managing comorbidities, because I want a more varied diet than leafy green vegetables (which I spread consume quite a lot of,) but it seems that some foods which are particularly good for e.g. Iron, aren't good for cholesterol and things like that. I still don't have the answers to the questions I asked, and she's still keen on referring me to WW. So for me, the dietician was a waste of time because I was specifically not asking about weight loss, and the appeared to be her only focus. And it's about the only appointment I've had which hasn't resulted in a customer satisfaction survey, either. (No, I wouldn't recommend this practice to most of my friends and family, because most of them don't live round here, so what would be the point?)

Dontwatchfootball · 18/08/2021 13:22

It is not fat shaming to be told they cannot operate on you safely. The NHS is crap at helping people lose weight and perhaps it is not their job, but its hard for people in this position. But no, I have had to lose weight to have an op before, that is just what it is.

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 18/08/2021 13:20

@itsgettingwierd

Great post I believe.

It still confuses me how they'll recognise anorexia as an ED caused by poor MH but will not recognise use that overeating is the same - just an opposite effect.

Then being overweight causes further MH difficulties.

But it’s not a direct parallel is it?

Obese people aren’t purposely eating in order to get fatter in the same way anorexic people restrict their eating in order to lose weight.

Also, where many anorexic people look at their emaciated bodies and often still feel they are too big, do obese people look in the mirror and see themselves as too thin and needing to get bigger?

I don’t think they have the same issues with control and body dysmorphia.

Therefore, I don’t think they’re comparative.

EmotionalSupportBear · 18/08/2021 13:13

its not fat shaming, its factual.. and speaking as a fatty (20st) she is being stupid.

There is however a HUGE issue in the medical world over diagnosing women as 'fat' rather than looking at the symptoms and diagnosing an issue.

I have back problems, had them since i was a teen (Who wasn't overweight) but recently they became chronic, i am in constant pain.. took years to get a referral for an MRI and they found spinal issues and hip arthritis. My specialist was nice about it, he told me my weight was NOT the CAUSE of my problems, but losing some would help with my mobility long term.. i'm currently 21lbs down on what i was in March.

Thats how it should be handled.. ignore the fat and investigate the symptoms.

There is a phrase in the medical world about looking for a horse, not a Zebra.. i think with fat people they need to be better about asking the Zebra for fucking directions.

EBearhug · 18/08/2021 13:08

It's complicated. Of course many people would be better off with a lower BMI. It does reduce risks from surgery and do on. Aching joints may be caused by, or exacerbated by excess weight, and if it's not, it's easier to diagnose without the weight clouding the picture. It is intimately mixed up with mental health. You mental health can stop you eating enough, and it can mean you self medicate with fatty, sugary foods. Food answers other needs besides mere nutrition. Sometimes it's the texture. Runner beans just don't feel the same in the mouth as a Curly Wurly or crisps. I have certainly eaten foods for how they feel as much as how they taste or smell or look. Even hearing is involved, sizzling and hissing and crunching and oozing and so on. Diets tend to focus on mainly nutrition and portions, and if that was all that was involved, probably loads more people would find losing weight easy.

I agree that if a patient is overweight, HCPs should mention it, particularly it's going to impact on pathways like surgery. It would be negligent not to, rather than fat-shaming. But there are ways and ways of doing it, and it can be particularly frustrating as a patient if you feel you're not being listened to. People who don't feel listened to are less likely to comply or ask further questions. Listening skills are an important part of healthcare, but not a skill all HCPs possess. (Fortunately, I think there are enough who do at my practice, with one or two notable exceptions.) I am sure that many HCPs would wish for better listening skills among their patients, too.

Not that I have any answers on how do we improve it.

MsTSwift · 18/08/2021 13:02

We were on holiday in the north east the majority of adults were visibly overweight they can’t all have MH issues. Something has gone wrong in how our society deals with food.

acatcalledjohn · 18/08/2021 13:00

Definitely not fat shaming.

This reminds of a few years ago when Cancer Research had a new ad which highlighted that obesity was now the #1 cause of cancer, which attracted some Twitter airheads to claim the ad was fat shaming.

The wilful ignorance is staggering.

FrankieDoyle · 18/08/2021 12:49

@LittleRedPill

I don’t think this is fat shaming.

However, we do know that lots of HCPs are dismissive of overweight people and that they can take longer to get diagnosed with serious illnesses because many GPs tell them to just ‘lose weight’ instead of investigating symptoms. I read a good, peer reviewed study on this recently but for the life on me cannot find it now!

I am not obese now but have been in the past. I used to follow a lot of plus size bloggers for style advice/clothing tips. And many do look fabulous. But it did start to bother me. Being fat is just not an alternative body shape as is often suggested. It can have real, serious health risks. I remember reading a blog about an influencers trip to New York. All these shots of her looking amazing in beautiful dresses, shorts and dresses. A while later there was another blog saying how had that trip had been for her. How her knees had been agony after all that walking, how tough she had found the heat, how she was unable to do some of the things her slimmer companions enjoyed. She got very mixed comments for that one I think. It wasn’t what many of her followers wanted to hear.

Good points. I also saw another Instagram plus size blogger who was shunned by the plus size community for having weight loss surgery and losing lots of weight. She apparently received online abuse for it too. Hmm I don't understand their mentality. Why not just be pleased for her?
OP posts:
SchrodingersImmigrant · 18/08/2021 12:42

@thestrawberrygirl UK has really different approach to it than other countries in Europe.

Bagamoyo1 · 18/08/2021 12:41

@Longdistance

It’s not fat shaming per se, but would be more helpful if the GP gave some dietary advice or referred them to a dietitian.
In this age of internet and information literally everywhere, do people really need someone else to tell them what food is low calorie and what food isn't? I mean, I reckon most reception kids know that carrots are healthy and Big Macs aren't! I think that weight loss groups can be helpful, but expecting a dietician to tell you what you should and shouldn't eat to lose weight is really quite shocking.
thestrawberrygirl · 18/08/2021 12:40

I'm in Italy, my Dr tells me on every visit that I'm overweight and must lose some. I'm 167cm and 72kg, I agree with him, I really need to, it's his job to tell me. I'm also told often my my DH, in laws and friends I need to and it's not offensive in the slightest to me, they simply care about my health and the impacts of being overweight on the rest of my health. It's a very accepted thing to say here and not labelled fat shaming, which I find ridiculous and might explain my shock at the size of some very young women on my last visit to UK. I don't recall young women being so large when I lived there 25 years ago. While we're on the subject, I'm two sizes smaller in UK clothes than I used to be despite being fatter, have they change the sizing?

itsgettingwierd · 18/08/2021 12:32

Great post I believe.

It still confuses me how they'll recognise anorexia as an ED caused by poor MH but will not recognise use that overeating is the same - just an opposite effect.

Then being overweight causes further MH difficulties.

pooonastick · 18/08/2021 12:29

At BMI of 40 and over, anaesthetic risks increase. Issues include intubation difficulties, increased risk of stroke, high blood pressure, angina, heart attack and DVT. So when we say no to a general anaesthetic its because we don't want to be responsible for your death whilst you are in our care . So unless your life depends on it, its too risky.

Gingernaut · 18/08/2021 12:26

@Longdistance

It’s not fat shaming per se, but would be more helpful if the GP gave some dietary advice or referred them to a dietitian.
She went to hospital.

I doubt she goes to a GP that regularly, otherwise she'd have been all over SM telling us about the GP (or family physician) fat shaming her as well.

TheGoogleMum · 18/08/2021 12:22

I think some doctors can be unhelpful, any complaints DH has (he has long term aches and pains) dr just says lose weight and isn't interested in helping. Surgery of course its riskier on the obese so it isnt fat shaming to refuse on those grounds!

Nonicknamesforcatapillars · 18/08/2021 12:17

It’s not fat shaming, it’s just medical advice. It would be negligent of any doctor to put a patient forward for a procedure where the risks outweigh the benefits.

That said if a doctor is telling someone to loose weight then that advice should come with some support and signposting.

emilylily · 18/08/2021 11:48

Also I agree that obesity is usually due to addiction or a state of eating disorder so just telling someone to lose weight is unhelpful and shows a level of ignorance about the complexities of Obesity as a state of disorder- it's a tricky one really!

emilylily · 18/08/2021 11:45

You're right- it's not fat shaming, just a medical fact that being obese puts you at risk of complications from surgery.

However I'm sure GPs can be very condescending to obese patients (I'm currently obese but haven't been to the GP since I was healthy weight!) and there are ways of saying things- maybe the GP was unpleasant and judgemental in their tone or choice of words.