Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a doctor telling you that you need to lose weight isn't "fat shaming?"

185 replies

FrankieDoyle · 17/08/2021 19:00

Genuinely interested in opinions.
I follow a plus size Instagram blogger/influencer who normally posts about fashion, inspirational quotes etc.

Today she posted about a trip to hospital that she had. The doctors there were apparently unhelpful and told her that they couldn't operate on her because, amongst other reasons, her weight. They told her she would need to lose weight before they could consider it.
I think she's about a size 26-28, from her posts about her wardrobe where she's mentioned the size she wears.

So she posted a video stating that she was sick of being fat shamed, something needs to change, and the doctors don't take her seriously etc.

It got me thinking that actually I disagree with her viewpoint that it's "fat shaming" to inform a patient that they need to lose weight? The doctors have to check that it's safe to perform an operation on someone don't they?

I say this as an overweight person myself (currently a size 20 but following a diet plan and trying to lose weight. )

Maybe I'm wrong I don't know, but it seems unfair to criticise doctors on a public platform with thousands of followers, simply for doing their job.

I understand some doctors can be patronising or seem to focus on a person's weight, and that can't be a nice experience. But I really disagree that it's "fat shaming" actually I quite dislike the phrase being used to criticise these medical professionals.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MrsSkylerWhite · 18/08/2021 20:07

ateluvscats

Flatdisco
It's not actually proven weight has a negative impact on health but doctors have been taught this is true and have no reason to learn off their own backs so keep spouting this as truth.“

Nonsense. My best friend lost 4 stone through sensible diet and regular exercise in her mid 50s. She is no longer a type 2 diabetic after years on metformin, her blood pressure is now ideal after being high for at least a decade, she no longer has to spend days lying flat with back pain and she feels looks years younger.
My own husband has been obese then morbidly obese for over 3 decades. He bought an exercise bike during the last lockdown, he is now cycling for an hour and a half every day and already his 3 monthly blood results (life threatening kidney condition) are showing impressive improvements, his nephrologist is delighted.

If you continue to believe what you said you are doing yourself a serious disservice.

Thedogscollar · 18/08/2021 18:51

Any operative procedure comes with risks no matter what size you are.
Being overweight comes with even higher risks of complications such as:
Infection
Haemorrhage
Deep venous thrombosis
Death
Being so morbidly obese is an anaesthetic risk in itself.
The medics are duty bound to point this out. It's giving the client informed consent so that she understands the risks she is taking due to her BMI.
No doubt if they said nothing to her and it resulted in any of the above complications she would be suing them.

Ibelieveinghosts · 18/08/2021 18:40

@SoreusBacchus

You might think it is “astounding silly” but professionals who have investigated this have overwhelmingly found a strong correlation between poor mental health and obesity

In some people, absolutely. In everyone who is fat, absolutely not, and your comparisons have moved on from astoundingly silly to borderline offensive. Hmm

How so? Why are they boarderline offensive? And I quite clearly say this isn’t everyone and that there are many reasons why people are overweight, I really don’t know why you are taking such offence over something clearly backed up by well respected research.
SoreusBacchus · 18/08/2021 18:28

You might think it is “astounding silly” but professionals who have investigated this have overwhelmingly found a strong correlation between poor mental health and obesity

In some people, absolutely. In everyone who is fat, absolutely not, and your comparisons have moved on from astoundingly silly to borderline offensive. Hmm

Ibelieveinghosts · 18/08/2021 18:03

@SoreusBacchus

It still confuses me how they'll recognise anorexia as an ED caused by poor MH but will not recognise use that overeating is the same - just an opposite effect

You must be very confused indeed because fat does not equal the opposite of anorexic. Most people who are overweight do not have any kind of eating disorder and its not usually caused by poor mental health.
Most people are fat because they eat and drink a bit too much and don't take enough exercise. It really is as simple as that for the majority.

I wish people would stop pathologising everything, its so unhelpful. To pretend that 65% of UK adults have an eating disorder caused by mental health issues is astoundingly silly.

You might think it is “astounding silly” but professionals who have investigated this have overwhelmingly found a strong correlation between poor mental health and obesity.

I’ll concentrate on the link between trauma esp those that have caused c-ptsd and ptsd. As that’s the area I know best. As I mentioned upthread research into the background of the patients at a Californian obesity clinic found a large portion of the patients had suffered child abuse, a survey of nearly 20,000 people who had suffered trauma found a very much above average incidence of obesity (as well as various addictions)

Stephen Porges in his polyvagal theory talks a lot about the act of eating being used to stimulate certain facial muscles to bring people out of fight or flight. It’s a calming, self soothing action.

Other reports indicate that some people use weight as a way to protect themselves from perceived threats.

Dissociation is extremely common amongst people with ptsd/c-ptsd which obviously feeds into how the body is treated.

Unfortunately ptsd and c-ptsd are extremely common.

I suffered from anorexia 25 years ago and using food as a means to control my world when everything seemed out of control seems very similar to the situations described above.

Obviously not every obese person has mental health issues, just like everyone who is underweight is not annorexic. In both cases it can be caused by genetics, medical conditions, hormones, etc as well as chronic under and overeating. Poverty plays a major part in both.

It’s not giving an excuse to not be a healthy weight to point out the multifaceted reasons behind unhealthy body weight but to solve the problem the true causes of these things need to be addressed rather than sticking a sliming world endorsed plaster over it.

To think obesity it caused by a persons greed, laziness and stupidity is both stupid and lazy.

SoreusBacchus · 18/08/2021 17:12

The doctor should complain about FACT SHAMING from the silly bint.

Maverick66 · 18/08/2021 17:09

I am fat ..size 22/24 and I would not consider a dr telling me I'm fat to be fat shaming. But hey ho it's getting her followers talking.

Dontwatchfootball · 18/08/2021 17:06

For the people who think losing weight is as simple as understanding that you need to eat less and move more, there are some excellent documentaries on how weight is treated in healthcare situations, and particularly 'Obesity: How prejudiced is the NHS' from 2017. Again, I dont think the situation in the OP was fat shaming but there is a lot of fat shaming going on in the world (and on this thread - people who are overweight are not stupid, they know they are eating more than they need to - it is the reasons and reactions to this which make losing weight so hard and fund the multimillion pound diet industry even though evidence shows people who diet end up heavier on average. So reducing the issue to that statement is really insulting).

Ilovewheelychairs · 18/08/2021 17:03

@SoreusBacchus I get that, I really do. I have friends in the profession who are open and honest with me, and I have seen the effect on their mental health when they have suffered difficult losses. But the same people who refused me the surgery I need to be out of pain, would apparently happily refer me to have bariatric surgery, which would require me to be under anaesthetic for far longer and would be a much more complex and involved operation.

At the end of the day, I am a person. My pain is no less valid or worthy of being treated because of my weight. If they treated my pain, they would also be treating my mental health and I would probably lose weight because I was happier and pain free, and I would be able to go out and exercise! I used to dance 5 nights a week! Some days now, I struggle to spend more than 10 minutes standing at a time. If I had bariatric surgery, I still have the risks of the operation, and it's a much bigger operation with a much bigger wound site to heal, and my pain wouldn't be treated or changed at all. So I would then require a second operation, with all those associated risks, to treat that, along with all the medication and intervention required for my mental health as well.

As I said, I see both sides. I'm obviously biased against it because chronic pain is hugely life limiting and knowing people are out there who CAN treat it for me but refuse to, is devastating.

Right now, when the NHS is on it's knees, when essential, urgent life saving treatment has had to be postponed and lives have been lost because of it, those people who can be treated safely, quickly and effectively must be prioritised, I agree.

On the subject of this thread, I don't think the person the OP referenced was being 'fat shamed'. But having experienced decades of going into the doctors for unrelated ailments and being told I just need to lose weight (chronic tonsillitis for example and an infected insect bite!), I can understand how someone in her position was anxious and defensive before they went into the appointment and any mention of her weight was therefore taken badly.

IsItWorthTheHassle · 18/08/2021 16:59

have you not heard the stories of overweight people being more at risk from dying than those with a healthy BMI?

I thought we were all due to die at some point, if being a healthy BMI means you don’t need to, maybe I should take more notice then Grin

BrumCahoots · 18/08/2021 16:50

She sounds an idiot ... of course that's not fat shaming ... they are concerned for her health

Outfoxedbyrabbits · 18/08/2021 16:49

I think doctors are damned if they do and damned if they don't in this area. My colleague's mum is very overweight, she has bad knees, gets breathless very easily and had been told that she is pre-diabetic, all of which would improve with weightloss and/or a healthier diet. However, she maintains that no doctor has ever told her she should lose weight for her health Hmm so she won't do it. My colleague's aunt apparently used to be concerned for her and try to encourage her but has now given up. Should a doctor have told her to lose weight? Would she actually do it if they did? (Is it really true that they never have!?)

Tigerstripe20 · 18/08/2021 16:46

In my GP surgery , the nurses and some Gp's seem petrified to use the 'F' word
When I was diagnosed with Diabetes the nurse kept stuttering trying to tell me I need to lose weight, I joked and said 'yep I know I am fat' and she said I am so sorry but we are just not allowed to tell anyone they need to lose weight.
A reasonably intelligent person without any medical issues should be able to recognise that being overweight is not healthy or helpful in their long term life...I am overweight and have a medical condition that could make it harder to lose weight but I know that what I put in my mouth does'nt help!
Reverse shaming a medical professional for daring to advise her is disgusting in itself as they will have to explain and potentially be the subject of an investigation should she die on the operating table.

Twinkie01 · 18/08/2021 16:28

@Flatdisco

It's not actually proven weight has a negative impact on health but doctors have been taught this is true and have no reason to learn off their own backs so keep spouting this as truth.
Of course being overweight has a negative effect on health, have you not heard the stories of overweight people being more at risk from dying than those with a healthy BMI? All the photos of supposedly healthy people who have passed away who are quite obviously not perfectly healthy due to their size.

Add to it increased risks of certain cancers, heart disease, diabetes, joint problems to name but a few.

Babdoc · 18/08/2021 16:21

I’m a retired anaesthetist. Obese patients are at serious risk during anaesthesia and during the post op period.
As part of informed consent, I always had to warn patients in advance of this.
I remember one morbidly obese woman, where I struggled with an extra long spinal needle to find her intrathecal space through the inches of fat, as she was unfit for general anaesthetic.
Three years later, she was listed for another procedure. I picked up her notes, saw my previous op sheet, and quailed at the thought of struggling with her again.
I walked into the anaesthetic room - and thought I’d got the wrong patient, looking at the slim woman waiting for me.
She burst out laughing and said “You didn’t recognise me, did you! I listened to your warnings last time, and I’ve lost five stone.”
We ended up hugging and I told her I was hugely proud of her.
Giving patients the facts about the dangers of obesity, in a respectful and nonjudgmental way, can be life changing. It is certainly not “fat shaming” - a ridiculous term.

MsTSwift · 18/08/2021 16:21

As you age it’s an actual effort to stay a healthy weight. I was always naturally slim and ate what I wanted without a second thought but now heading to my late 40s I intermittent fast most days and do an hour of cardio daily to stay size 10. I can see why people don’t do it.

SoreusBacchus · 18/08/2021 16:10

Because they’re supposed to take an interest in your health, is it really that difficult to think about? Because asking people if they’d considered their weight and if they’d made any changes would come across infinitely better than just saying “you need to lose weight” at every appointment. It’s hardly as if the current methods are successful

We're talking about surgeons and anaesthetists at a hospital. They don't care if you've considered it or what changes you've made already, it's not relevant to them. They are concerned if your current weight makes surgery inadvisable or impossible, and what the next step is.

Your weight is your responsibility, not everyone elses.

Feckingirritated · 18/08/2021 16:02

@SoreusBacchus

The thing that gets me the most is that medical people/well wishers who initiate this kind of conversation never acknowledge that losing weight is a longterm process, and that you aren’t necessarily going to have visible change immediately. I’ve also found that they rarely want to hear about the changes you’ve already made

Well, why would they state the obvious? They, you and everyone else knows its a long term process, it doesn't need to be spelled out!
And they don't want to hear about the changes you've already made if they haven't made much difference...they aren't too relevant.

Because they’re supposed to take an interest in your health, is it really that difficult to think about? Because asking people if they’d considered their weight and if they’d made any changes would come across infinitely better than just saying “you need to lose weight” at every appointment. It’s hardly as if the current methods are successful.
SoreusBacchus · 18/08/2021 15:59

If I had to choose between killing myself because I am in pain, and dying on the table trying to become pain free for the first time in 17 years (!), I know which I would choose. And I would celebrate the surgeon who chose to give me that chance, not sue them

I think you're failing to realise that if a surgeon operated on you even though their clinical judgement says it is dangerous to do so, and you die, they will actually have killed you. A waiver is not going to help them live with that.
No surgeon will do an operation that they believe has an unacceptable level of risk.

Ilovewheelychairs · 18/08/2021 15:56

I am in two minds about this. I am hugely overweight. I am aware of this. However, I also have chronic (often debilitating) pelvic pain. Everybody I have spoken to, including the gynaecologists at the hospital, admit that they think it is endometriosis and possible adenomyosis. And that this is probably also the cause of my infertility (and multiple early miscarriages).

However, they refuse to treat me (a laparoscopy) until I lose weight. But I am chronic pain, in all probability caused by a condition that is in no way caused by my weight. I am stuck in a cycle of being in pain every day, unable to exercise as much as I would like because of the pain, and hormonally all over the place. Yes, I am chronically depressed. Because I am in chronic pain. And because my desire to be a Mum is overwhelming and apparently fat people don't get to be parents (or at least no support towards being able to conceive).

I would happily, willingly (and have offered to!) sign a waiver and pay privately for any surgeon to do the operation needed for me to end the pain I am in. I understand I have more risks than someone of a lower BMI. I accept this. I understand that the surgery may be more complex, and that I may need to have an ICU bed ready in case something goes wrong. I am prepared to pay for that. I understand that due to my weight the risk that I may die in surgery is increased. I will sign away their liability. I am happy and willing to do this.

Not one surgeon will touch me despite all of this. If I was a particularly complicated case, if I smoked, even if I was a drug user, if I was very young or very old, NONE of those things would rule me out of the thing that I need to be out of pain. It is only weight that they are allowed to use as a reason to refuse outright without looking at any of my other medical data (pristine in my case, I am a picture of health!)

I understand that risks are higher, and that doctors and other healthcare professionals MUST, as part of their duty inform patients of the increased risk of morbidity, delayed wound healing etc etc. And that the patient must sign to say they are aware of that and be given the option to wait, lose some weight and come back with the lower risks. But right now, my life feels not worth living. My mental health is in tatters, BECAUSE of this condition that they refuse to treat. If I had to choose between killing myself because I am in pain, and dying on the table trying to become pain free for the first time in 17 years (!), I know which I would choose. And I would celebrate the surgeon who chose to give me that chance, not sue them.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 18/08/2021 15:09

@SoreusBacchus

It still confuses me how they'll recognise anorexia as an ED caused by poor MH but will not recognise use that overeating is the same - just an opposite effect

You must be very confused indeed because fat does not equal the opposite of anorexic. Most people who are overweight do not have any kind of eating disorder and its not usually caused by poor mental health.
Most people are fat because they eat and drink a bit too much and don't take enough exercise. It really is as simple as that for the majority.

I wish people would stop pathologising everything, its so unhelpful. To pretend that 65% of UK adults have an eating disorder caused by mental health issues is astoundingly silly.

I sadly have to agree. It did provode me with some more exvuses of why I possibly couldn't lose the weight.

Of courses some people have mh issues etc, but I agree that lots of us simply got on too well with food and then learned to swim in denial. And yes. As some pp mentions, very little overeating can ampunt 5o considerable weightgain over the time

SoreusBacchus · 18/08/2021 14:44

The thing that gets me the most is that medical people/well wishers who initiate this kind of conversation never acknowledge that losing weight is a longterm process, and that you aren’t necessarily going to have visible change immediately. I’ve also found that they rarely want to hear about the changes you’ve already made

Well, why would they state the obvious? They, you and everyone else knows its a long term process, it doesn't need to be spelled out!
And they don't want to hear about the changes you've already made if they haven't made much difference...they aren't too relevant.

Feckingirritated · 18/08/2021 14:42

The thing that gets me the most is that medical people/well wishers who initiate this kind of conversation never acknowledge that losing weight is a longterm process, and that you aren’t necessarily going to have visible change immediately. I’ve also found that they rarely want to hear about the changes you’ve already made.

It’s one thing to say that losing weight is necessary before an operation, but the likelihood is that by the time the patient has reached that stage, they’ve been told about their weight repeatedly, and likely had some of their symptoms dismissed due to the weight. So I’m sympathetic to the situation. The medical profession really needs to rethink how it addresses it’s patients as a whole, there seems to be a lot of dismissal because patients aren’t experts when they are in fact the only people who truly understand what’s happening in their bodies

ddl1 · 18/08/2021 14:42

It would be wrong for a doctor just to assume that whatever health problems an overweight patient has are just the result of their weight, and to refuse to investigate further. Which does sometimes happen. However, many operations are more dangerous for overweight people, and I don't think it's unreasonable or 'fat shaming' to refuse to carry out the surgery unless or until the patient loses weight (assuming of course that the surgery is not urgent).

SoreusBacchus · 18/08/2021 14:34

It still confuses me how they'll recognise anorexia as an ED caused by poor MH but will not recognise use that overeating is the same - just an opposite effect

You must be very confused indeed because fat does not equal the opposite of anorexic. Most people who are overweight do not have any kind of eating disorder and its not usually caused by poor mental health.
Most people are fat because they eat and drink a bit too much and don't take enough exercise. It really is as simple as that for the majority.

I wish people would stop pathologising everything, its so unhelpful. To pretend that 65% of UK adults have an eating disorder caused by mental health issues is astoundingly silly.

Swipe left for the next trending thread