Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that this isn’t comedy

83 replies

Feelingoktoday · 17/08/2021 17:38

I really do not find this funny and it is being funded by the Arts Council ie public monies. I’ve lost my sense of humour.

To think that this isn’t comedy
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
OneTC · 21/08/2021 08:49

Cos I'm not one of those people I always wait and see what something actually is before getting into a froth about it

Sounds pretty shit though, in précis

Polkabott · 21/08/2021 07:29

As if some people are using South Park as a gotcha- a programme intended to be as offensive as they could get away with, and not funded by government funding, funnily enough. The plot line of that is also purposefully ridiculous, and shock, people could be offended by more than one thing; albeit as we are on about biological sex, not sure why it would be womens job to complain about it.

If the subject matter they wished to show was top surgery, there are so many options other than this, which at the root is a commentary about how they evidently feel women less deserving, or at least equally so of the surgery because of cancer than their me me me I want. What's annoying is that the criticism is being held up as anti-trans, when it's not, there are loads of different plots they could follow re top surgery, and the fact its a comedy somehow doesn't seem like a deep and meaningful commentary on the desperation some face.

DrSbaitso · 21/08/2021 07:28

@BrozTito

Dont go see it then. I hate this trans bullshit but most of you seem think boycotts are brilliant when used for your purposes but 'censorship' when used against.
I actually don't think anyone has suggested it be banned. They've just expressed their offence and, in some cases, complained to the Arts Council. Objection isn't censorship and nor is a refusal of funding.
BrozTito · 21/08/2021 06:48

I bloody love going to see patronisng middle class productions about how they imagine outside of london or leeds to be like that one, Gasp0de. "Mam'. Now that is comedy.

BrozTito · 21/08/2021 06:43

Dont go see it then. I hate this trans bullshit but most of you seem think boycotts are brilliant when used for your purposes but 'censorship' when used against.

thinkingaboutLangCleg · 21/08/2021 06:34

The theatre has amended the details so that you can’t find out anything about this particular performer. I have complained to the Arts Council. It’s not funny in any sense however woke you may be. I don’t find it funny that young females want to cut off their healthy breasts either.

I agree, Feeling. This is sickening on so many levels.

DewDew83 · 18/08/2021 18:35

I'm not saying this at all.
I'm saying at least be original if you're going to be crap.
My comment was not a response to you.

Although (1) how do you know it's crap? and (2) as an apparent South Park watcher, you've probably seen the s5 episode 'The Simpsons Already Did It', the concept of which is that there are very few (if any) truly original comedic plots.

GeorgeMichaelBluth · 18/08/2021 18:15

@DewDew83

Oh wow, I see people are actually complaining.

Per my (and another poster's) previous posts, this is basically the same plot as the Medicinal Fried Chicken episode of South Park, that first aired probably about 8 years ago and has been re-run plenty of times without any notable controversy.

If something can be a comedic plot on extremely popular tv show, I don't see why it can't also be in a play.

I'm not saying this at all. I'm saying at least be original if you're going to be crap.
TooBigForMyBoots · 18/08/2021 18:06

YABU OP. You haven't seen the show, you have no idea how funny it is. And even if you did, comedy is subjective.

It is unreasonable and ridiculous to complain about something that you know nothing about.🙄

DewDew83 · 18/08/2021 17:53

Yes I know - but the poster is saying we shouldn’t complain just because a similar story was in South Park. I’m just saying South Park is pretty sexist and not a good bar to measure things by.
Is it pretty sexist? It's done at least a couple of quite feminist episodes and a couple of overtly gender-critical episodes, including a recent(ish) one on women's sports.

Feelingoktoday · 18/08/2021 17:48

@DewDew83

I’m not sure South Park, Family Guy or Simpsons are good role models. But go ahead let’s not complain about anything and we will be back to Benny Hill and other dodgy racist 1960s shows and saying they are fine too But we're talking about popular, contemporary comedy, not something decades old where standards have changed.
Yes I know - but the poster is saying we shouldn’t complain just because a similar story was in South Park. I’m just saying South Park is pretty sexist and not a good bar to measure things by.
OP posts:
Theythinkitsalloveritisnow · 18/08/2021 17:48

It's horrible

But it does seem to be an excellent example of the vacuous narcissism that the whole gender identity movement seems to be based on

DewDew83 · 18/08/2021 17:45

I’m not sure South Park, Family Guy or Simpsons are good role models. But go ahead let’s not complain about anything and we will be back to Benny Hill and other dodgy racist 1960s shows and saying they are fine too
But we're talking about popular, contemporary comedy, not something decades old where standards have changed.

Feelingoktoday · 18/08/2021 17:42

@DewDew83

Oh wow, I see people are actually complaining.

Per my (and another poster's) previous posts, this is basically the same plot as the Medicinal Fried Chicken episode of South Park, that first aired probably about 8 years ago and has been re-run plenty of times without any notable controversy.

If something can be a comedic plot on extremely popular tv show, I don't see why it can't also be in a play.

I’m not sure South Park, Family Guy or Simpsons are good role models. But go ahead let’s not complain about anything and we will be back to Benny Hill and other dodgy racist 1960s shows and saying they are fine too
OP posts:
Feelingoktoday · 18/08/2021 17:39

@Snoozysnoozy

You don't have to watch it. You could've ignored it and no-one here would even have known it existed.
Why on Earth would I do that? What would that achieve if we all start ignoring abusive stuff?
OP posts:
DewDew83 · 18/08/2021 17:33

Oh wow, I see people are actually complaining.

Per my (and another poster's) previous posts, this is basically the same plot as the Medicinal Fried Chicken episode of South Park, that first aired probably about 8 years ago and has been re-run plenty of times without any notable controversy.

If something can be a comedic plot on extremely popular tv show, I don't see why it can't also be in a play.

DewDew83 · 18/08/2021 16:56

Sounds similar to an episode of South Park, where Randy (and then half the town) tries to give himself cancer so that he could bet a medical marijuana prescription.

Was quite funny tbf.

LimitIsUp · 18/08/2021 16:49

@ScreamingMeMe

That play, but unironically.
What the actual fuck!
Snoozysnoozy · 18/08/2021 16:27

You don't have to watch it. You could've ignored it and no-one here would even have known it existed.

ScreamingMeMe · 18/08/2021 16:05

That play, but unironically.

To think that this isn’t comedy
ElvisPresleyHadABaby · 18/08/2021 14:03

Not very funny to me, like trying to prove that they deserve their double mastectomies sooner than cancer patients, many of whom also have to wait. I hate the implication that it's of equal importance.

GeorgeMichaelBluth · 18/08/2021 13:56

South Park actually did this with a character who gave himself testicle cancer so he could get a prescription for weed. So it's not even original.

2bazookas · 18/08/2021 13:46

Another trans man inadvertently revealing his REAL attitude to women.

DelphiniumBlue · 18/08/2021 13:27

Tasteless in the extreme. Reminds me of the plot of "The Producers" and the song from there, "Springtime for Hitler". Somebody wins if it makes a loss?