Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is DS’ diet really that bad?

458 replies

enuquer · 17/08/2021 13:25

Please be kind.

DS is 2, will be 3 at the end of the year. His daily diet is usually

Breakfast: weetabix or rice krispies/corn flakes

Morning snack: an orange or a yoghurt

Lunch: Ham sandwich with an orange or yoghurt (whatever he doesn't have for snack) and some wotsits or quavers

Afternoon snack: 2 biscuits or a small packet of chocolate buttons

Dinner: pasta/pizza/ sausage and mash with carrots/fish fingers/chicken nuggets/ the occasional McDonald's happy meal (probably once or twice a month)

Dessert: ice cream or a small chocolate bar

Then he sometimes has chips if me and DP have had a takeaway, and he isn't asleep yet.

The only fruit and veg he'll eat are oranges and carrots. During the day he does drink water or apple juice and has a bottle of milk before bed.

We recently stayed at my mum's as my mum said that he shouldn't be eating those foods and his diet is awful.

Is it really that bad?

OP posts:
ShingleBeach · 18/08/2021 08:04

@NanooCov

DP needs to start eating whatever the family meal is and not eating separately and caving to your son. It sounds like it is learned behaviour given you said he would eat anything a year ago.
My children ate everything enthusiastically post weaning…. And then at about 2, 2.5 started to refuse many things they previously enjoyed.

It is a well known pattern and especially affects fruit and veg. There is some theory that says it is a instinctive and based in evolution, designed to prevent toddlers helping themselves to every poisonous berry and plant they come across.

But easy access to the deliberately addictive pull of salt and sugar in processed food and lack of good role modelling from Dad can’t help.

NanooCov · 18/08/2021 07:55

DP needs to start eating whatever the family meal is and not eating separately and caving to your son. It sounds like it is learned behaviour given you said he would eat anything a year ago.

HaveringWavering · 18/08/2021 07:49

[quote lannistunut]@HaveringWavering I just looked at a small pot because that is a known size of a yogurt and the size of pot I gave. People can look at the size/sugar content of their own yogurt if interested. I have seen people give two small yogurts (petit filous size), we each have to look at our own habits I guess.

The facts are that at >10% sugar by weight, yogurts are unhealthy foods, but many people consider them healthier than e.g. biscuits or ice cream.

It is often healthier to give a large portion of a healthy food than a small portion of an unhealthy food. My younger child ate a lot of yogurt because they did not like cheese, because it was plain yogurt I did not have to limit it.[/quote]
A “small pot” for a child is not the 100g size that you looked at though. OP did not say that she was giving her child two pots. You exaggerated the amount of sugar that OP was likely to be giving her child in yoghurts, which came across as judgmental and scaremongering.

lannistunut · 18/08/2021 07:42

And some have more sugar in than the middle one I selected btw.

lannistunut · 18/08/2021 07:41

@HaveringWavering I just looked at a small pot because that is a known size of a yogurt and the size of pot I gave. People can look at the size/sugar content of their own yogurt if interested. I have seen people give two small yogurts (petit filous size), we each have to look at our own habits I guess.

The facts are that at >10% sugar by weight, yogurts are unhealthy foods, but many people consider them healthier than e.g. biscuits or ice cream.

It is often healthier to give a large portion of a healthy food than a small portion of an unhealthy food. My younger child ate a lot of yogurt because they did not like cheese, because it was plain yogurt I did not have to limit it.

HaveringWavering · 18/08/2021 07:32

[quote lannistunut]@HaveringWavering I just looked on a yogurt brand's website, for example 11g/100g = >13g in a small pot. Have just checked now, an M&S yogurt is the same, 11g/100g. Some were higher, some lower.

Obviously every yogurt is different, and clearly smaller yogurts are smaller (!), but fruit yogurt is as unhealthy as ice-cream (just looked it up: 12g/100ml).

Lots of people eat too much sugar, many UK children do, it causes a lot of health problems.

The NHS includes fruit yogurts on their top offenders list for high sugar diets: www.nhs.uk/live-well/eat-well/top-sources-of-added-sugar/[/quote]
But why use adult products and portion sizes as reference in the context of a discussion about children’s diets?

scrapITupAndSTARTagain1 · 18/08/2021 06:45

All these people saying 'they won't eat anything else...' I'm sorry but how do they get access to that kind of food? It's not like a 2yo goes to the shops and chooses what to have. It is really that simple-if you don't buy it they won't eat it. I agree that there is no reason for a toddler to eat chocolate, or crisps, you don't miss what you don't know.

Also a child will not starve themselves so he might refuse at first but will he keep refusing if there's literally nothing else to eat except what you cook and serve?

Your DP needs to be on board though as otherwise all your efforts are undermined and the child see it.

lannistunut · 18/08/2021 06:12

@HaveringWavering I just looked on a yogurt brand's website, for example 11g/100g = >13g in a small pot. Have just checked now, an M&S yogurt is the same, 11g/100g. Some were higher, some lower.

Obviously every yogurt is different, and clearly smaller yogurts are smaller (!), but fruit yogurt is as unhealthy as ice-cream (just looked it up: 12g/100ml).

Lots of people eat too much sugar, many UK children do, it causes a lot of health problems.

The NHS includes fruit yogurts on their top offenders list for high sugar diets: www.nhs.uk/live-well/eat-well/top-sources-of-added-sugar/

Coyoacan · 18/08/2021 02:40

I have a very small family, but my own dd was a very picky eater as a child, so OP and other parents have my sympathies. However my dgd is the complete opposite and eats a wonderful range of healthy food, so the sweeping criticism of the advocates of feeding children healthy food are very jarring.

Heliachi · 18/08/2021 02:03

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

HaveringWavering · 18/08/2021 01:02

I am pro yoghurt!

HaveringWavering · 18/08/2021 01:00

[quote BackBoiler]@HaveringWavering about the yogurt. Munch bunch....this is quite a bit bigger than the small pots you mentioned previously so there is going to be more sugar! No matter how grim you think it sounds Wink[/quote]
Yes I realised that. My point was that even a bigger pot had less sugar in it than that poster said was in a small pot of fruit youghurt. I just thought that the flavour sounded a bit artificial, my point was that even the ones that sound quite unhealthy are not as unhealthy as that poster claimed.

BackBoiler · 18/08/2021 00:42

I'm comparing the petit filous and munch bunch Grin but I'm still in agreeable about why is yogurt so frowned upon. Some make it sound like crack for kids

BackBoiler · 18/08/2021 00:38

@HaveringWavering about the yogurt. Munch bunch....this is quite a bit bigger than the small pots you mentioned previously so there is going to be more sugar! No matter how grim you think it sounds Wink

BackBoiler · 18/08/2021 00:36

My kids who are older are allowed one sweet snack a day. Biscuits on return from school or a dessert. They are allowed one savoury....eg crisps, small sausage roll, cheese string, pepperami etc. I think other than the extra chips and extra sweet thing it's fine. One of my kids will not drink water only milk and squash. The other two will not drink milk!

He is fed and happy but maybe just try and divert the treat foods a bit maybe. He is small and he will start to try more as he gets older if you are offering Smile

badg3r · 18/08/2021 00:21

It sounds like there are two factors at play. Firstly at two kids do go through a phase of being fussy. It's a developmental stage to be suspicious of new things so they don't eat anything poisonous. The advice is generally to just keep offering, let everyone serve themselves, and make sure there is a safe food that you know they will est available.

The second and bigger problem is your DP. He is showing your child that it is ok to not eat what is on offer and to choose something really unhealthy instead. I think you need to have a chat with him about all eating the same. If he still wants the pizza he can eat it when you kid can't see but you all sit down and eat the same meals together. Yeah there will probably be some pushback from your child but he's just resting limits.

gmwardy · 18/08/2021 00:12

I don’t think it’s that bad, bit too much chocolate but nothing too hard to fix!

Does he like fish as well as fish fingers? My youngest likes the lightly dusted lemon sole from aldi!
what about a roast dinner?
curry with hidden veg?
stir fry?
Don’t beat yourself up OP, at this age when they’re in a fussy phase sometimes it’s just lucky they’ve actually eaten! I’m jealous of you with the ham sandwiches for lunch mind, none of mine ever liked a sandwich x

Cheeseplantboots · 18/08/2021 00:11

That’s not bad at all. My 14 year old ears no vegetables (except corn on the cob) or fruit (except orange juice) . We’ve tried everything.

I think you could cut back on the snacks or replace with healthier ones though.

Aria999 · 18/08/2021 00:05

We have the stonyfield yoghurts which have 4g of added sugar in a 99g portion of yoghurt.

HaveringWavering · 18/08/2021 00:00

@lannistunut

Yoghurt is fine. I'm struggling to understand the yoghurt hate

Plain yogurt, fine. Fruit/flavoured yogurt has 10g, 12g, 15g or even more sugar in a small pot, which for a young child is way too much.

Where do you get this from? I just checked. A 47g pot of Petit Filous has 5.6g of sugar. Even there Peppa pig ones are the same.

A Yeo valley little Yeo fruit yoghurt (90g) has 7.3g of sugar and even a fairly grim-sounding Munch bunch double up strawberry and vanilla flavour yoghurt (85g) has 9.4g.

Yeo valley do a no added sugar 47g mango and vanilla pot that contains 2.6g.
The collective Apple & blackcurrant 100g “suckie”- 7.6g.
Tesco own strawberry FF pouch (80g) 6.1g sugar.

An adult 120g Yeo Valley fruit yoghurt contains 11.1g of sugar but OP unlikely to be feeding that to her 2 year old.

TheLette · 17/08/2021 22:59

It's tough getting them to eat veggies but do keep trying. My 2 year old would only eat peas and sweetcorn, but now, aged nearly 4 she will eat a lot more veggies. We always have a green vegetable with our evening meal and she usually has some salad veg (a few cherry tomatoes and cucumber, normally) with lunch. She is less keen on the evening veg so I serve it to her before the rest of her dinner, as she will usually eat it that way. Unfortunately you just have to keep plugging away - the more they are exposed to veg, the more likely they will be to eat it.

The book series Supertato is very helpful. Kids love it and you can remind them that they need their superveggies to get big and strong.

In terms of treats I only allow one artificially sugary treat (which would include a flavoured yogurt, but exclude Greek / plain yogurt) a day. So if she has a cake during the day, no ice cream for pudding. Otherwise she would just eat sweet sugary things all the time. No juice allowed in my house although she is occasionally allowed one of those smoothie box things (maybe once or twice a week).

imnotsure1 · 17/08/2021 22:57

Pretty similar to my very fussy 5 year old although we don't offer ice cream, chocolate or juice at home. She will eat fresh chicken, beef or lamb provided no sauce though. Have you offered these instead of frozen alternatives?

Her older and younger siblings eat very well so I'm hoping she grows out of it.

Personally I'd ditch the treats and juice right away as they are the worst for teeth etc. An active child should be able to cope on pasta and ham sandwiches in the short term.

LemonRoses · 17/08/2021 22:49

It’s setting him up for a lifetime of poor eating habits. How often is he eating with you and getting a wider variety of proper food?

cakewench · 17/08/2021 22:47

He’s going to eat what his parents eat, generally speaking, so it doesn’t matter if you’re (sometimes) making home cooked meals but your DP has decided to eat something more beige and fun. DS will see beige fun food and of course he will decide that must be an option, so he will hold out for that.

I’m not being judgemental, we do have fun food a couple of times a week, but it’s always accompanied by vegetables (peas, broccoli) and we do all eat vegetables regularly. Also, chocolate isn’t a snack really, snack should be something a bit more substantial, protein (like a cheese or yogurt) or fruit.

OrganicAvocado · 17/08/2021 22:15

Hmm. I have heard of worse diets. That’s a lot of sugar though. We don’t do “dessert” as such. Occasionally we have an ice lolly or a pudding but less than once a week, and chocolate is not a “snack” in our house. It’s an occasional treat.
My daughter is vegan and as a toddler she ate porridge or toasted bagel for breakfast, pasta or rice with red beans, lentils or chickpeas, green beans, baby corn and vegan cheese for lunch, and maybe potato waffles with a vegan sausage, lettuce and carrot for dinner. Snack was fruit or crackers, but never chocolate or sweets. She was a very fussy eater and refused any sauces, but the actual food was and still is healthy healthy.

Swipe left for the next trending thread