Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Evacuation form Afghanistan- women?

309 replies

Aprilinspringtimeshower · 17/08/2021 12:41

So saw this article and the accompanying photo www.theguardian.com/world/2021/aug/17/afghanistan-striking-image-appears-to-show-640-people-fleeing-kabul-in-packed-us-military-plane?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other

This is what concerns me- where are the women? The overwhelming majority of people on that plane are men, adult males. There are a few women and some children.
Yet it is the women who are in greatest danger. Young girls, older women. Single women who won’t be able to support themselves once stopped from going outside unaccompanied, professional women who will be banned from working .

Everyone said that the war was about women’s right and way of life. And that what is happening now is a danger to the rights and well-being of women.

Surely it is women who are the ones that need to get out of the country safely and be offered asylum- so where are they? Why wasn’t that plane full of mostly women or even equal amounts of women and the men that accompany them.

I don’t hear the government saying anything to target protection and refuge for women specifically. And to young girls and women who are in real danger

AIBU that it is always the men that get the preference, and that really no one cares enough to actually provide proper protection to the women and girls ..it’s just all sound bites and noble words

OP posts:
Porcupineintherough · 17/08/2021 17:07

@LadyGnome well quite. The average Afgan woman wouldnt be granted asylum under our current rules. The way it works is, person under direct, personal threat eg interpreter gets out, gets granted asylum and can then ask for family to join them.

AICM · 17/08/2021 16:59

If my brother's name was on a list, specifically my brother not just all men his age, and he was in immediate risk of torture and death I would be delighted to see him escape.

huniepop · 17/08/2021 16:59

@Slipperfairy

I guess it's weighing up the risks and self preservation too. Man stays= no real value to new regime;probably going to be killed. Woman and girls stay= they have some value- even if abhorrent. Less likely to actually be killed.

Man runs- might actually make it. Easier to find somewhere to stay.
Whole family run- hard to do. Hard to find somewhere to stay. Women and girls still face that of rape etc.

If dh were likely to be killed, then he'd have to go.

Very true

LadyGnome · 17/08/2021 16:56

Tractor
Being well educated is one of things that made DH and some of his friends a target. They were seen by the regime as more of a threat - probably more likely to ask awkward questions - organise etc. He didn't have a lot of money but he was in his 20's and fit so could get out.
I think you are right that a generalised threat isn't enough - you have to be at risk as an individual to claim asylum.

huniepop · 17/08/2021 16:56

@Wheretoeattweenandteen

April at most other huge migrations have had plenty of women along as well. Of course they have.

Isn't it rather sexist to assume women can't flee?

But confusing because people flee from terror, but some people claim women are too weak to also flee the terror but they are strong enough to stay and face the terror that men flee from?

Doesn't make any sense.

Why would it be sexist? It's always going to be harder for a woman and kids than for a single man, especially given how a lone woman might be treated

Wheretoeattweenandteen · 17/08/2021 16:56

Pauliaa I agree.

I also agree that any one who has a death sentence on them needs help now. Of course they do.

Anyone who helped the military etc should be got out.

It doesn't have to be an either or situation. I just hope however that some pressue is brought to bear on a male dominated society that the west would like to save women and children before males who don't have links to West or immediately will be killed because as Paulaa said, being forcibly married, locked inside your house, beaten, kicked spat at and forced to have children for the rest of your life is a worse fate than being forced to grow a beard and whatever else they make then do.

Wheretoeattweenandteen · 17/08/2021 16:51

If your a girl /woman raised in a man's world where men's allow you to have someone freedom but where you are separated from men at every turn and made to live life in a different lane then maybe you would be thrilled your brother got out because you feel he's more important?

TractorAndHeadphones · 17/08/2021 16:47

@LadyGnome

DH was a refugee when I met him (20+ years ago) i.e. had been granted asylum and was a stateless person. He was the only member of his family who got out when there was a civil war in his country. Did any of his family resent it - no. He was the one at highest risk because of his political involvement and profession at the time. That didn't mean the rest of his family weren't at risk but simply that they weren't at heightened risk. He may have put the family at risk if he had stayed with them because he would have drawn the attention the military who were trying to supress dissent. Fortunately, his country has moved on and is less dangerous now so he has been able to visit his family - nobody has ever questioned the fact he left - the people living in the situation understood why.

I really don't think we can judge from the outside.

p.s. DH is Muslim from a majority Muslim country and his values and attitudes aren't materially different from mine so I think we can avoid the generalisations about certain types of refugees.

Refugees are generally well-educated and ‘Westernised’ because they a)have the money to escape and b) are the ones allowed to stay because of ‘high risk’, e.g political involvement. The grounds to claim asylum are strict and simply ‘fleeing a war-torn country’ isn’t grounds for approval. Religious dogma is a tool to subjugate the poor. It isn’t followed by the rich elite.
VladmirsPoutine · 17/08/2021 16:46

Male refugees & migrants have long been cast as a vector of political violence & a threat to western liberalism to justify both invading their countries and denying them safety / refuge when the inevitable happens. We are now witnessing this in acute action.

Jenasaurus · 17/08/2021 16:44

@LooksGood

If they were evacuating women and girls because of the Taliban's attitude to them, that would be 19 million people.

The flights are for people who have worked with the US. Presumably, their dependents too if they are on the spot. Many of these men will already have been in hiding or based away from families for work. They should get out asap. I hope the US and UK and other states involved will do everything they can to get women at risk out too, but that's likely to be from border crossings and perhaps sponsored and negotiated visas. UK has already given up on getting everyone who worked for them out.

If all women and children were evacuated, the Taliban would eventually come to a halt with no one to have the next generation with.
Burnt0utMum · 17/08/2021 16:43

I think we should just be glad that the people on that plane are at least getting out. It can't have been easy for any of them especially for those who have had to leave family behind and I don't think there's anything to be gained from passing judgment. It's impossible to get all women and children to safety so I agree that those people who are most at risk of immediate execution should be prioritised right now.

Someone very close to me is an Afghan immigrant. People travelling with him died along the way due to the hostile conditions and gruelling walking. They were left behind to die. He nearly drowned crossing from Turkey to Greece and was beaten and had all his belonging taken by border controls. He was a young, fit man and really struggled so I really do understand why not as many women and children make the journey. I don't think it's right to judge anyone who is in a position of even having to contemplate fleeing in such circumstances. Men and women will just be doing the best they can and trying to make the right decision for themselves and their families in unimaginable conditions.

CovidCorvid · 17/08/2021 16:37

If it was mainly the translators, etc who were prioritised initially then maybe they felt they had no choice to leave their wives and kids? And of course some may be single. If they stay they will be killed and of no use to their wives or kids. If they are alive even in a different country then if they get work they can send money and also will have a chance to petition for their family to be allowed over to whichever country they’re in?

Hopefully if anyone has had to leave wives and kids they will have left them with extended family so as safe as possible….and potentially safer than if such a man on a taliban hit list had stayed!

What an awful situation they find themselves in….having to make dreadful choices with no real time to consider. Through no fault of their own.

Porcupineintherough · 17/08/2021 16:35

@kungfupannda good post. Wont cut any ice with the racists upthread though.

VladmirsPoutine · 17/08/2021 16:33

@kungfupannda Excellent post!

LadyGnome · 17/08/2021 16:31

DH was a refugee when I met him (20+ years ago) i.e. had been granted asylum and was a stateless person. He was the only member of his family who got out when there was a civil war in his country. Did any of his family resent it - no. He was the one at highest risk because of his political involvement and profession at the time. That didn't mean the rest of his family weren't at risk but simply that they weren't at heightened risk. He may have put the family at risk if he had stayed with them because he would have drawn the attention the military who were trying to supress dissent.
Fortunately, his country has moved on and is less dangerous now so he has been able to visit his family - nobody has ever questioned the fact he left - the people living in the situation understood why.

I really don't think we can judge from the outside.

p.s. DH is Muslim from a majority Muslim country and his values and attitudes aren't materially different from mine so I think we can avoid the generalisations about certain types of refugees.

RoseAndRose · 17/08/2021 16:21

From BBC:

"Vice Adm Sir Ben Key, who is running the UK's evacuation programme in Afghanistan, said the UK hoped to help 6,000 to 7,000 British nationals and eligible Afghan staff to leave - but that figure was dependant on the security situation.

"Afghans considered eligible to resettle in the UK include workers for the British government, interpreters, cultural advisers and embassy staff. Others eligible are those deemed to be at high and imminent risk.
Foreign Secretary Dominic Raab earlier said the UK was looking at a "bespoke arrangement" for Afghan refugees, with full details to be set out in due course.

"A new resettlement scheme will be aimed at helping those most in need - including women and girls - to come to the UK, No 10 has said"

Now, it might be different priorities on a US flight, but it looks as ifbUK is first looking after thise who have been put at imminent risk of death from their association with us. I think it would be wrong to do otherwise

Steakandcheeseplease · 17/08/2021 16:17

@kungfupannda

I hate the narrative that is building around these pictures. Every time I think of what is happening in Afghanistan, the suffering of the women is what I think about. I'd love to see flight after flight landing at Gatwick or Heathrow, packed full of women, saved from the brutality of the Taliban. But the fact is that not one of us sat safely behind our keyboards - and behind our privilege - knows the situation of any of the men on that plane.

Many countries have a cultural expectation that men go on ahead and try to find a way to bring their families after them. It may even be that staying with your wife and children rather than trying to find a way out would be seen as failing in your duty as a husband/father. And if, as I strongly suspect, those men were translators/local guides etc, they would almost certainly die if they stayed, whereas their families may be desperately hoping to keep their heads down and survive. They may even put their wives and children at greater risk by not getting out. These would have been decisions made in desperate, unimaginable circumstances and the truth is that most of us are very, very lucky to know fuck all about it.

The implication that the men on that plane all abandoned their families without a backward glance to save themselves is part of the same narrative of othering refugees that we've seen with Syria and with the boats crossing the channel. They're lesser. They don't love their children. They don't care about their wives. And it's a narrative that is damaging to all Afghan people - women as well as men. If they don't feel things the same way we do, then why should we care about them?

I've seen lots of comments online today about what people think they would have done in the same situation. None of us have a clue what we'd do. I'd very much like to think I'd be calm and resourceful and that we'd stick together as a family no matter what. But thinking about it, if I had the kids to think about and I knew about the chaos at the airport, I might be inclined to bury my head in the sand, stay quietly at home and hope to be overlooked. And if DP was at high risk of being murdered for his job I'd probably be doing everything in my power to persuade him to take the slim chance of getting on a plane out of there.

Or maybe I'd be curled up in a corner crying hysterically because it turned out that I had absolutely no idea how scared I'd really be in that situation.

Great post! Here here!
Saidtoomuch · 17/08/2021 16:13

What happened in this case? Did their sisters join them? If so, how old are they now and can the girls speak English well now, are they in education or work here?
@powershowerforanhour
I don't know him well and it was a few years ago, but yes, they are very "western" and very well educated, quite sucessful I believe. I did omit an important fact in trying to be evasive, so as not to be recognised, but his brother actually died during the journey. The then boy and his travelling companions buried him at the roadside.

TractorAndHeadphones · 17/08/2021 16:11

@kungfupannda

I hate the narrative that is building around these pictures. Every time I think of what is happening in Afghanistan, the suffering of the women is what I think about. I'd love to see flight after flight landing at Gatwick or Heathrow, packed full of women, saved from the brutality of the Taliban. But the fact is that not one of us sat safely behind our keyboards - and behind our privilege - knows the situation of any of the men on that plane.

Many countries have a cultural expectation that men go on ahead and try to find a way to bring their families after them. It may even be that staying with your wife and children rather than trying to find a way out would be seen as failing in your duty as a husband/father. And if, as I strongly suspect, those men were translators/local guides etc, they would almost certainly die if they stayed, whereas their families may be desperately hoping to keep their heads down and survive. They may even put their wives and children at greater risk by not getting out. These would have been decisions made in desperate, unimaginable circumstances and the truth is that most of us are very, very lucky to know fuck all about it.

The implication that the men on that plane all abandoned their families without a backward glance to save themselves is part of the same narrative of othering refugees that we've seen with Syria and with the boats crossing the channel. They're lesser. They don't love their children. They don't care about their wives. And it's a narrative that is damaging to all Afghan people - women as well as men. If they don't feel things the same way we do, then why should we care about them?

I've seen lots of comments online today about what people think they would have done in the same situation. None of us have a clue what we'd do. I'd very much like to think I'd be calm and resourceful and that we'd stick together as a family no matter what. But thinking about it, if I had the kids to think about and I knew about the chaos at the airport, I might be inclined to bury my head in the sand, stay quietly at home and hope to be overlooked. And if DP was at high risk of being murdered for his job I'd probably be doing everything in my power to persuade him to take the slim chance of getting on a plane out of there.

Or maybe I'd be curled up in a corner crying hysterically because it turned out that I had absolutely no idea how scared I'd really be in that situation.

Hear hear! And strangely none of the ‘women and children’ posters have responded to the inevitable question of what theyre going to do about all 19 million of them
Blossomtoes · 17/08/2021 16:11

Nice to see some insight @kungfupannda.

Fangdango · 17/08/2021 16:06

@kungfupannda

I hate the narrative that is building around these pictures. Every time I think of what is happening in Afghanistan, the suffering of the women is what I think about. I'd love to see flight after flight landing at Gatwick or Heathrow, packed full of women, saved from the brutality of the Taliban. But the fact is that not one of us sat safely behind our keyboards - and behind our privilege - knows the situation of any of the men on that plane.

Many countries have a cultural expectation that men go on ahead and try to find a way to bring their families after them. It may even be that staying with your wife and children rather than trying to find a way out would be seen as failing in your duty as a husband/father. And if, as I strongly suspect, those men were translators/local guides etc, they would almost certainly die if they stayed, whereas their families may be desperately hoping to keep their heads down and survive. They may even put their wives and children at greater risk by not getting out. These would have been decisions made in desperate, unimaginable circumstances and the truth is that most of us are very, very lucky to know fuck all about it.

The implication that the men on that plane all abandoned their families without a backward glance to save themselves is part of the same narrative of othering refugees that we've seen with Syria and with the boats crossing the channel. They're lesser. They don't love their children. They don't care about their wives. And it's a narrative that is damaging to all Afghan people - women as well as men. If they don't feel things the same way we do, then why should we care about them?

I've seen lots of comments online today about what people think they would have done in the same situation. None of us have a clue what we'd do. I'd very much like to think I'd be calm and resourceful and that we'd stick together as a family no matter what. But thinking about it, if I had the kids to think about and I knew about the chaos at the airport, I might be inclined to bury my head in the sand, stay quietly at home and hope to be overlooked. And if DP was at high risk of being murdered for his job I'd probably be doing everything in my power to persuade him to take the slim chance of getting on a plane out of there.

Or maybe I'd be curled up in a corner crying hysterically because it turned out that I had absolutely no idea how scared I'd really be in that situation.

Hear hear - great post. Thank you.
Fangdango · 17/08/2021 16:03

@powershowerforanhour

The article torquewench put up on a the previous page is worth a read. Not saying that we shouldn't take refugees but we should keep our eyes open.
We should. Learn from best practice. Education, right to work, settlement patterns. England for example doesn't guarantee English language education. Wales and Scotland do. Right to work (and support a family) depends on speed of processing. Oh and right to (for example) drive a car. It's years not months. Settlement - Syrian refugee scheme in Wales worked to move people in extended family / community groups, without saturating certain areas, for example.

Reunite families asap or get mentors and imams to help support young men. Avoid the obvious risks of isolation, inactivity, incomprehension. Refugees aren't saints and shouldn't be expected to sit around idle and grateful. I don't know what the profile and treatment of Afghan refugees in Austra five years ago would have been. It's not a monoculture, and the circumstances people are fleeing have changed. So yes, assess risks and address them.

kungfupannda · 17/08/2021 16:02

I hate the narrative that is building around these pictures. Every time I think of what is happening in Afghanistan, the suffering of the women is what I think about. I'd love to see flight after flight landing at Gatwick or Heathrow, packed full of women, saved from the brutality of the Taliban. But the fact is that not one of us sat safely behind our keyboards - and behind our privilege - knows the situation of any of the men on that plane.

Many countries have a cultural expectation that men go on ahead and try to find a way to bring their families after them. It may even be that staying with your wife and children rather than trying to find a way out would be seen as failing in your duty as a husband/father. And if, as I strongly suspect, those men were translators/local guides etc, they would almost certainly die if they stayed, whereas their families may be desperately hoping to keep their heads down and survive. They may even put their wives and children at greater risk by not getting out. These would have been decisions made in desperate, unimaginable circumstances and the truth is that most of us are very, very lucky to know fuck all about it.

The implication that the men on that plane all abandoned their families without a backward glance to save themselves is part of the same narrative of othering refugees that we've seen with Syria and with the boats crossing the channel. They're lesser. They don't love their children. They don't care about their wives. And it's a narrative that is damaging to all Afghan people - women as well as men. If they don't feel things the same way we do, then why should we care about them?

I've seen lots of comments online today about what people think they would have done in the same situation. None of us have a clue what we'd do. I'd very much like to think I'd be calm and resourceful and that we'd stick together as a family no matter what. But thinking about it, if I had the kids to think about and I knew about the chaos at the airport, I might be inclined to bury my head in the sand, stay quietly at home and hope to be overlooked. And if DP was at high risk of being murdered for his job I'd probably be doing everything in my power to persuade him to take the slim chance of getting on a plane out of there.

Or maybe I'd be curled up in a corner crying hysterically because it turned out that I had absolutely no idea how scared I'd really be in that situation.

AICM · 17/08/2021 16:02

Even when the reason why has been explained time and time and time again some people still don't get it. Unbelievable.

powershowerforanhour · 17/08/2021 15:57

We asked this of a refugee acquaintance. Not the airport scene, but refugees in general. At 14yo he and his brother fled their home country and made their way on foot to the UK. His parents sent the sons as they were the ones who had the best chance of survival. They were unlikely as males to get abused or picked out by people traffickers, and being male were stronger for the journey and more able to fight their way through if needed. The males once settled could then make arrangements for their families to join them.

What happened in this case? Did their sisters join them? If so, how old are they now and can the girls speak English well now, are they in education or work here?

Swipe left for the next trending thread