Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Evacuation form Afghanistan- women?

309 replies

Aprilinspringtimeshower · 17/08/2021 12:41

So saw this article and the accompanying photo www.theguardian.com/world/2021/aug/17/afghanistan-striking-image-appears-to-show-640-people-fleeing-kabul-in-packed-us-military-plane?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other

This is what concerns me- where are the women? The overwhelming majority of people on that plane are men, adult males. There are a few women and some children.
Yet it is the women who are in greatest danger. Young girls, older women. Single women who won’t be able to support themselves once stopped from going outside unaccompanied, professional women who will be banned from working .

Everyone said that the war was about women’s right and way of life. And that what is happening now is a danger to the rights and well-being of women.

Surely it is women who are the ones that need to get out of the country safely and be offered asylum- so where are they? Why wasn’t that plane full of mostly women or even equal amounts of women and the men that accompany them.

I don’t hear the government saying anything to target protection and refuge for women specifically. And to young girls and women who are in real danger

AIBU that it is always the men that get the preference, and that really no one cares enough to actually provide proper protection to the women and girls ..it’s just all sound bites and noble words

OP posts:
LifesNotEnidBlyton · 17/08/2021 18:02

@ancientgran

Well, aptly with your username, that was years ago. Obviously some men would and some wouldn't, that wasn't in question there, it was more what I thought more likely. Armed forces and people in jobs like your husband are a bad example anyway because 1. They would actually have a job to do and 2. Nowadays we likely wouldn't treat families like that, the armed forces being the one I know most about, have more in the way of family being kept close to their serving members than they did forty odd years ago.
But I still believe that more men here would want to stay with their family than the numbers elsewhere, that is just my thoughts, and what the comments are for.

kungfupannda · 17/08/2021 18:00

@LifesNotEnidBlyton

The same thing happens with tons of people who leave their country for asylum. It is quite the look into the way these men think of you ask me. That they will leave their wives and children to face whatever they have left behind and come here themselves. Because if Britain became somewhere we needed to leave for asylum elsewhere tommorow I do not believe that most men would leave their families, most men I know would actually send their wives and children before themselves and wouldn't think to leave them.
Send them before them into what exactly? An airport which might be raided by the Taliban at any moment, with those trying to flee imprisoned or shot? A leaky boat that might sink, drowning everyone on board? A trek over mountains crawling with hostile forces? A refugee camp that might be taken over at any minute?

If there's an orderly evacuation with outside help, guaranteed safe passage and a clear promise of something better at the other end, I would imagine most people would want their families to go ahead of them. But that's not what this was. I can't imagine anyone went to that airport calmly confident of boarding a plane and getting away safely, thinking 'Bollocks to my wife and kids. I'm all right Jack.'

ancientgran · 17/08/2021 17:57

@Blossomtoes

Because if Britain became somewhere we needed to leave for asylum elsewhere tommorow I do not believe that most men would leave their families, most men I know would actually send their wives and children before themselves and wouldn't think to leave them

If my bloke had a price on his head and was guaranteed to be killed, I’d want him to go as fast as possible. I’d make him go.

Too true and the same for my sons and grandsons.
powershowerforanhour · 17/08/2021 17:57

There is that, ancientgran. Also, if you tried to hide your interpreter husband and the Taliban came calling and held a gun to your toddler's head, you'd be hard pushed not to grass him up. Whereas if you can prove he's in another country out of reach, they might pull the trigger out of spite anyway but there is less incentive for them to threaten to do so.

TractorAndHeadphones · 17/08/2021 17:56

*to imply not to say

Blossomtoes · 17/08/2021 17:55

Because if Britain became somewhere we needed to leave for asylum elsewhere tommorow I do not believe that most men would leave their families, most men I know would actually send their wives and children before themselves and wouldn't think to leave them

If my bloke had a price on his head and was guaranteed to be killed, I’d want him to go as fast as possible. I’d make him go.

TractorAndHeadphones · 17/08/2021 17:55

@LifesNotEnidBlyton

The same thing happens with tons of people who leave their country for asylum. It is quite the look into the way these men think of you ask me. That they will leave their wives and children to face whatever they have left behind and come here themselves. Because if Britain became somewhere we needed to leave for asylum elsewhere tommorow I do not believe that most men would leave their families, most men I know would actually send their wives and children before themselves and wouldn't think to leave them.
Thread after thread after thread regarding feckless men here on Mumsnet who won't even give a penny towards their own children - and you honestly believe that British men would be so selfless?

I refer you back to @kungfupannda's post about 2 pages ago.

Like everyone else on earth there are good and bad people but to say that the 'majority' of Afghan men are happy to abandon their wives while the 'majority' of British men would not is nonsense.

ancientgran · 17/08/2021 17:51

An Afghan man who worked with the UK/US might be a danger to his family. If you want to punish a man raping and murdering his wife and daughters in front of him is not unknown.

Burnt0utMum · 17/08/2021 17:48

@LifesNotEnidBlyton

The same thing happens with tons of people who leave their country for asylum. It is quite the look into the way these men think of you ask me. That they will leave their wives and children to face whatever they have left behind and come here themselves. Because if Britain became somewhere we needed to leave for asylum elsewhere tommorow I do not believe that most men would leave their families, most men I know would actually send their wives and children before themselves and wouldn't think to leave them.
You make it seem like fleeing is the easy option when in fact it is not. You are judging the situation from the outside and you can't possibly know what you or anyone else would do or indeed what it would make sense to do in that situation. The Afghan men I know are deeply loyal to their families and see themselves are protectors and providers. Obviously not all men will be that like but the vast majority won't be leaving their families for selfish reasons. Also, a lot may be single and not have a family to worry about so why shouldn't they get to safety if they can?
ancientgran · 17/08/2021 17:47

@Wheretoeattweenandteen

Ancient gran, sexism because we are dealing with a country that is.....

Sexist? Hmm

Do you think women hold equal rights in Afghanistan?

We are talking about who was being evacuated on the planes. It might have been sexist that women weren't interpreters but the military have a moral duty to those men because of what they did not because of their sex.
ancientgran · 17/08/2021 17:45

@LifesNotEnidBlyton

The same thing happens with tons of people who leave their country for asylum. It is quite the look into the way these men think of you ask me. That they will leave their wives and children to face whatever they have left behind and come here themselves. Because if Britain became somewhere we needed to leave for asylum elsewhere tommorow I do not believe that most men would leave their families, most men I know would actually send their wives and children before themselves and wouldn't think to leave them.
Really? My husband is a retired senior police officer, he went on a War Duties course. Cold war times and officers being trained about what to do when the invasion happened. They were told they would all report to nearest police station, they would live there or could be moved elsewhere but they would be fed and given somewhere to sleep and would be in a protected building with firearms.

My husband asked about his wife and children and was told it was his duty to report, we would have to fend for ourselves. He said he thought officers would be more committed if their families were also cared for. He was told he was a disgrace and a coward and should be ashed of himself. Not just by course leaders but by his colleagues on the course. All male officers, it was before the womens service merged in the mid 70s.

So no I don't think British men would necessarily be an different, my husband was a lone voice wanting his wife and children to be safe. Some men would and some men wouldn't, here, Afghanistan or elsewhere.

Wheretoeattweenandteen · 17/08/2021 17:39

Ancient gran, sexism because we are dealing with a country that is.....

Sexist? Hmm

Do you think women hold equal rights in Afghanistan?

Wheretoeattweenandteen · 17/08/2021 17:38

No tractor it's not that article.

ancientgran · 17/08/2021 17:37

At the end of the day the British and US military have a moral duty to help the people (mainly men I imagine) who helped them and are now in danger. They can't evacuate the whole country so they start with the people who are at high risk and who they have an obligation to help.

Why does everything have to be made out to be sexism?

Also I saw a report on Sky and it seemed like a lot of the planes with mainly men weren't actually Afghans, they were other countries evacuating their embassy staff and nationals, I think the plane they showed was Indian nationals being evacuated. So again if the military, business and embassy people are mainly men, highly likely I would have thought, then that is who will be on the planes.

LifesNotEnidBlyton · 17/08/2021 17:34

The same thing happens with tons of people who leave their country for asylum. It is quite the look into the way these men think of you ask me. That they will leave their wives and children to face whatever they have left behind and come here themselves. Because if Britain became somewhere we needed to leave for asylum elsewhere tommorow I do not believe that most men would leave their families, most men I know would actually send their wives and children before themselves and wouldn't think to leave them.

TractorAndHeadphones · 17/08/2021 17:28

@Wheretoeattweenandteen

Tractor and headphones can I ask why you have @ me? It's usually when someone has not been on the thread or their post is lost in a fast moving thread.

It feels aggressive because I'm posting and I'm right here.

Have you read it?

Is it? I only use it when I can’t quote - and the thread isn’t exactly slow I’m presuming you’re referring to the Yvonne Ridly article (there have been a few by this point but I think that’s the one)
huniepop · 17/08/2021 17:28

@StoneofDestiny

Common sense dictates you prioritise those at immediate threat of death if they stay - those who were interpreters for instance or even those who worked for The British Council. Any connection to working the the British or US government put a death sentence on their head.

Yep, but probably torture as well. It's may well be more than just a bullet to the head, especially if they find out that you specifically helped the military

StoneofDestiny · 17/08/2021 17:26

Common sense dictates you prioritise those at immediate threat of death if they stay - those who were interpreters for instance or even those who worked for The British Council. Any connection to working the the British or US government put a death sentence on their head.

huniepop · 17/08/2021 17:26

@Wheretoeattweenandteen

Hunipop of course its sexist why is the woman alone,

Her family should all be with her!
Going as... A family.

But what is sexist? How, who?

Society? Yes, that's why women aren't able to travel alone/safely. I don't get the sexist argument. Is the point that the men fleeing are sexist for leaving their families?

Hardly an easy choice to make. Not possible to drag the whole family. They live it everyday, they know better than us

powershowerforanhour · 17/08/2021 17:23

Male refugees & migrants have long been cast as a vector of political violence & a threat to western liberalism to justify both invading their countries and denying them safety / refuge*

When has the potential for violence of male refugees and migrants been used as an excuse to invade their countries of origin?

Wheretoeattweenandteen · 17/08/2021 17:16

Tractor and headphones can I ask why you have @ me? It's usually when someone has not been on the thread or their post is lost in a fast moving thread.

It feels aggressive because I'm posting and I'm right here.

Have you read it?

Wheretoeattweenandteen · 17/08/2021 17:15

Hunipop of course its sexist why is the woman alone,

Her family should all be with her!
Going as... A family.

TractorAndHeadphones · 17/08/2021 17:14

@Wheretoeattweenandteen do you disagree with the author?

Wheretoeattweenandteen · 17/08/2021 17:12

Torque wench,

It's am aghast at that article.

I am staggered, its awful, absolutely awful.

LooksGood · 17/08/2021 17:10

@Saidtoomuch

What happened in this case? Did their sisters join them? If so, how old are they now and can the girls speak English well now, are they in education or work here? *@powershowerforanhour* I don't know him well and it was a few years ago, but yes, they are very "western" and very well educated, quite sucessful I believe. I did omit an important fact in trying to be evasive, so as not to be recognised, but his brother actually died during the journey. The then boy and his travelling companions buried him at the roadside.
Reality is messy, and people are driven by fear and hope, not guarantees.

The Afghan refugee I know, same story. Escaped with other young males. Was eventually able to bring some women from his family to join him here. Half the men died on route.

Swipe left for the next trending thread