Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Evacuation form Afghanistan- women?

309 replies

Aprilinspringtimeshower · 17/08/2021 12:41

So saw this article and the accompanying photo www.theguardian.com/world/2021/aug/17/afghanistan-striking-image-appears-to-show-640-people-fleeing-kabul-in-packed-us-military-plane?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other

This is what concerns me- where are the women? The overwhelming majority of people on that plane are men, adult males. There are a few women and some children.
Yet it is the women who are in greatest danger. Young girls, older women. Single women who won’t be able to support themselves once stopped from going outside unaccompanied, professional women who will be banned from working .

Everyone said that the war was about women’s right and way of life. And that what is happening now is a danger to the rights and well-being of women.

Surely it is women who are the ones that need to get out of the country safely and be offered asylum- so where are they? Why wasn’t that plane full of mostly women or even equal amounts of women and the men that accompany them.

I don’t hear the government saying anything to target protection and refuge for women specifically. And to young girls and women who are in real danger

AIBU that it is always the men that get the preference, and that really no one cares enough to actually provide proper protection to the women and girls ..it’s just all sound bites and noble words

OP posts:
Normaigai · 17/08/2021 20:33

LifesNotEnidBlyton if you look at the thread, the only person still talking about the comments you made is you.

LifesNotEnidBlyton · 17/08/2021 20:29

You are wrong. That isn't what has happened. My comment wasn't about British vs Afghan men.it was factual and followed with my thoughts. This has been gone over again and again. As for people disagreeing with me that has been gone over too. There was no need for everyone who disagreed to individually comment back to me when it is a group talk with more people who posted in line with me and when I have already said we can agree to disagree. So by continuing to comment individually it shows people only want to have an argument and gang up instead of contributing to the group talking about it without commenting to only one person in a comment.

Normaigai · 17/08/2021 20:27

@LooksGood

Isn't being everything to our children a recent cultural norm too though, and a bit of a first- world luxury? Look at all the Filipinas who leave children with extended family to work here and make a better life for them. At labourers in Dubai sending cash home.

Send your wife and children to relative safety with (say) her elder brother who lives a quiet life and hasn't dabbled in politics. Get to the airport. Get on the plane. Get to safety. Get them out. If that's an option, rather than expose them to danger in the streets and airport, life in a refugee camp, people smugglers and channel crossings, do you think men - and women? - should choose differently?

Agree with this too. I wouldn't blame any parent for going if the child could be left with extended family.
StrawberryFizz26 · 17/08/2021 20:25

I've not read the full thread but wanted to come on to share this link, it's template letter which is sent to your MP, takes seconds to complete.

action.helprefugees.org/page/88374/action/1

Normaigai · 17/08/2021 20:25

I agree with that FemmePerdue. There absolutely are women at risk as well and I agree their stories won't get heard. It doesn't stop the fact that the men on that plane aren't 'cowardly' for being on there. There are no good outcomes here sadly.

LooksGood · 17/08/2021 20:23

Isn't being everything to our children a recent cultural norm too though, and a bit of a first- world luxury? Look at all the Filipinas who leave children with extended family to work here and make a better life for them. At labourers in Dubai sending cash home.

Send your wife and children to relative safety with (say) her elder brother who lives a quiet life and hasn't dabbled in politics. Get to the airport. Get on the plane. Get to safety. Get them out. If that's an option, rather than expose them to danger in the streets and airport, life in a refugee camp, people smugglers and channel crossings, do you think men - and women? - should choose differently?

FemmePerdue · 17/08/2021 20:22

And to be clear for those who don't get it: a lot of women will be connected to the westerners in some way for example as maids, cleaners or nannies.
You most likely have never heard of how dangerous life is about to become for them. Their roles were most likely not story worthy. A different type of glass ceiling.
Their stories are not going to be told by their men - until their men are safe.

Normaigai · 17/08/2021 20:14

Would I have left my children if the roles were reversed and I was the one who had the risky job? I can't imagine it but equally I suspect my husband would have been screaming at me to go. Doubt I'd have been strong enough to stand a chance of getting on though.

TractorAndHeadphones · 17/08/2021 20:13

@FemmePerdue

I'm not sure how many people in this thread have lived in war zones but all this the men will be executed instantly stuff is true. What is also true is the reason the men's stories are told: because they are men.

The mere fact we don't know the stories of the women in places were men are the story tellers is a thing all by itself.

One way (of many) of honouring those who have been or will killed, is to continue to be the voices of those who have been raped and who minimise their ordeals because of the ongoing murders.

'We don't know'? There are plenty all over the place... have a quick Google
Normaigai · 17/08/2021 20:12

If me, my husband and children were at that airport because we had fear of reprisals because of my husband's work (and the reality is in Afghanistan it is far more likely to be my husband who was connected with the government/foreign military) and we acknowledged there was no way the children would be able to force themselves on the plane (have you seen the pictures? Not a hope), I imagine I may well have been screaming at my husband to get himself on that plane. I can't guarantee it (because who knows until you're in that situation) and I can't guarantee he would have gone, but the best thing for the family almost certainly would have been for him to go if he possibly could. How would him getting shot/tortured help me and the children? If he gets out at least there's hope he might be able to get us out.

FemmePerdue · 17/08/2021 20:10

I'm not sure how many people in this thread have lived in war zones but all this the men will be executed instantly stuff is true.
What is also true is the reason the men's stories are told: because they are men.

The mere fact we don't know the stories of the women in places were men are the story tellers is a thing all by itself.

One way (of many) of honouring those who have been or will killed, is to continue to be the voices of those who have been raped and who minimise their ordeals because of the ongoing murders.

Burnt0utMum · 17/08/2021 19:42

I really think calling them cowards is disgusting. @ALongHardWinter you should be ashamed of that comment.

TractorAndHeadphones · 17/08/2021 19:40

@Wheretoeattweenandteen

Tractor, its the womens rights the UN are "particularly" concerned about.

It's the loss of women's rights that's being singled out the world over.

Why do you think that is?

I didn’t say that it’s untrue. But is it justification for prioritising women? In an emergency situation pp have already explained the justification for men going ahead. However if there’s a visa processing facility - I disagree that women should be flown out over men. whoever gets there first should get processed first.

Finally there’s there’s the small matter of not everybody qualifying for asylum. Countries are not flying out random people to rescue them based on general humanitarian grounds. They’re flying out (as already discussed) people whom they have worked with and promise safety to. The discussion of their sex isn’t relevant here.

LooksGood · 17/08/2021 19:38

@Wheretoeattweenandteen

Tractor, its the womens rights the UN are "particularly" concerned about.

It's the loss of women's rights that's being singled out the world over.

Why do you think that is?

Because the Taliban's last government attacked women's rights. Because the UN has a remit to work on the ground to preserve these rights, if possible, and is negotiating to do so: www.reuters.com/world/asia-pacific/unicef-says-some-taliban-support-education-afghan-girls-2021-08-17/ Because xenophobia and racism worldwide are triggered by male refugees, but women and children appeal more to protective instincts.

Has the UN asked the UK and US to evacuate women and children instead of their former employees?

Women are in a terrible situation in Afghanistan. Men who are on a Taliban hitlist need help to escape, urgently. Other men are more likely than women and children to be able to survive border crossings and refugee camps and end up here. Some women and children will survive because their men get away now. Some will get away later for that reason.

Can we not care about women and children and about men at risk of torture and execution?

Fangdango · 17/08/2021 19:28

@ALongHardWinter

Exactly what I was thinking, before I'd even seen the pictures. I thought 'What's the betting that any mass evacuation from Afghanistan will be practically all men,the same as it seems to be on these boats crossing the channel'. Seems to me that they only think of themselves,leaving their women and children to face the dangers alone. Cowards.
So if this boy's father had been able to leave him with extended family? If his elder brother had been able to travel alone? That would have made them cowards? Are you sure that's what you think, when you see men crowded into deathtraps at sea?

Alan Kurdi - he's only unusual because we've seen the photos.

Evacuation form Afghanistan- women?
SchrodingersImmigrant · 17/08/2021 19:24

While the women are getting a horrible, horrible deal, many people are forgetting that the countries which went there with their armies dropped many, many the male interpreters, soldiers and workers like a hot coal the second shit hit the fan. They are being executed, murdered. Have been for weeks.
Everyone in there is getting fucked. It's very easy to judge from afar and few pics in news...

Wheretoeattweenandteen · 17/08/2021 19:21

Tractor, its the womens rights the UN are "particularly" concerned about.

It's the loss of women's rights that's being singled out the world over.

Why do you think that is?

TractorAndHeadphones · 17/08/2021 19:17

@Queenelsarules

Women in Afghanistan are oppressed and have their human rights removed on the basis of their biological sex not their gender. They deserve priority in terms of asylum and evacuation due to risk of forced marriage, rape, deprivation of liberty and death.
And men don’t face the above (except for forced marriage and rape)?
LooksGood · 17/08/2021 19:16

@Proudboomer

This thread is under the assumption that these 600 on the cargo plan where a planned evacuation. They were not.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-58242733

On Sunday, panicked civilians had scrambled up the loading ramp, Defense One quoted a US official as saying, but the crew decided it was best to take off rather than force the Afghans off the plane.
This is just a case of the strongest forcing their way on and lucky for them the pilot decided to take off anyway.

They were both people scheduled to be on the flight and people who pushed their way on board:

The US defence official quoted by Defense One, says the flight from Kabul to Qatar was one of several which managed to extract hundreds of Afghans from Kabul.

Glad they made it. But if most leaving Kabul Airport, with clearance or not, are men - we've explained why many times over on the thread. Some good info in that article too, thanks.

Siepie · 17/08/2021 19:14

@LifesNotEnidBlyton

My previous comments seem to have been jumped on by a few posters. So, for anyone else I just want people to know there's no need because I can see people don't agree. That's ok and not everyone will, it was just my thoughts, but there's no need to derail the OPs thread or have an argument when we should all be able to comment freely so it'd be good to agree to disagree.Smile Smile
Everyone can comment freely, not just you. That means that people are free to disagree with you.

You can't post sweeping statements about Afghan men versus British men and not expect people to reply.

Proudboomer · 17/08/2021 19:04

This thread is under the assumption that these 600 on the cargo plan where a planned evacuation.
They were not.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-58242733

On Sunday, panicked civilians had scrambled up the loading ramp, Defense One quoted a US official as saying, but the crew decided it was best to take off rather than force the Afghans off the plane.
This is just a case of the strongest forcing their way on and lucky for them the pilot decided to take off anyway.

DewDew83 · 17/08/2021 18:57

Exactly what I was thinking, before I'd even seen the pictures. I thought 'What's the betting that any mass evacuation from Afghanistan will be practically all men,the same as it seems to be on these boats crossing the channel'. Seems to me that they only think of themselves,leaving their women and children to face the dangers alone. Cowards.
What an awful person you are.

Queenelsarules · 17/08/2021 18:56

Pervious rely was meant to quote an earlier reply which suggested that anyone not a primary care 9f children whatever their gender was at equal risk.

Queenelsarules · 17/08/2021 18:54

Women in Afghanistan are oppressed and have their human rights removed on the basis of their biological sex not their gender. They deserve priority in terms of asylum and evacuation due to risk of forced marriage, rape, deprivation of liberty and death.

Blossomtoes · 17/08/2021 18:50

@ALongHardWinter

Exactly what I was thinking, before I'd even seen the pictures. I thought 'What's the betting that any mass evacuation from Afghanistan will be practically all men,the same as it seems to be on these boats crossing the channel'. Seems to me that they only think of themselves,leaving their women and children to face the dangers alone. Cowards.
Oh, do RTFT. The reason has been explained ad infinitum.