Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Evacuation form Afghanistan- women?

309 replies

Aprilinspringtimeshower · 17/08/2021 12:41

So saw this article and the accompanying photo www.theguardian.com/world/2021/aug/17/afghanistan-striking-image-appears-to-show-640-people-fleeing-kabul-in-packed-us-military-plane?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other

This is what concerns me- where are the women? The overwhelming majority of people on that plane are men, adult males. There are a few women and some children.
Yet it is the women who are in greatest danger. Young girls, older women. Single women who won’t be able to support themselves once stopped from going outside unaccompanied, professional women who will be banned from working .

Everyone said that the war was about women’s right and way of life. And that what is happening now is a danger to the rights and well-being of women.

Surely it is women who are the ones that need to get out of the country safely and be offered asylum- so where are they? Why wasn’t that plane full of mostly women or even equal amounts of women and the men that accompany them.

I don’t hear the government saying anything to target protection and refuge for women specifically. And to young girls and women who are in real danger

AIBU that it is always the men that get the preference, and that really no one cares enough to actually provide proper protection to the women and girls ..it’s just all sound bites and noble words

OP posts:
2bazookas · 17/08/2021 21:13

Many Afghan men were employed by US and UK military forces in various capacities, for instance as translators, and that puts them at exceptional risk from retaliation by the Taliban. Most of those Afghan allies of the West, were male. We have a moral obligation to get them out safely.

FemmePerdue · 17/08/2021 21:12

@TractorAndHeadphones erm no the question is: is the prioritisation of men over women fair?
Your argument being: some men will die, so yes.
I fail to agree with your yes until the suffering of the women at immediate risk of harm is taken into equal account and given the same gravitas as death.

If you can do this then I might agree with your yes. Until then I'm not convinced. I'd tend to think the original unfairness in the system is permeating through the rescue.

It seems like people on here are hoping that maids' names don't make the list so they are safe.

I'll repeat myself, men are the story tellers here. The only names worth putting on those lists are male. The list writers will definitely know which women to target before they go for the indiscriminate debauchery.

LifesNotEnidBlyton · 17/08/2021 21:12

@Normaigai

LifesNotEnidBlyton After my comment. I'm generally brilliant but predicting the future isn't in my skill set.

She also only commented after you commented on her post! If you don't want people to keep arguing with you then stop arguing with them. If you want to keep arguing with people fine, I don't care, but then stop complaining people are unfairly picking on you.

You are again wrong. The only post I had on this thread wasnt to anyone. Not one person, it was just a comment. Since then the only people I have commented to by username are people who have done so to me, so you are wrong with your idea I just should comment to them if I dont want them to to me. Becuase I didnt. I only replied. I have been taught if I am addressed I should answer. So my answer to each person who has has been to ask that we agree to disagree and that they dont keep only addressing me when there is a group chat happening, so those people who do are obviously picking me out, becuase they spoke to me first, just as you did, and all I am doing is replying as is polite and normal.
Normaigai · 17/08/2021 21:09

[quote FemmePerdue]@Normaigai women are actively making that decision to give up their spaces for men and boys because they see death as worse than rape.
And using the phrase "because of her sex" hides the fact that it is her sex which has made her relationship with the westerners invisible - if she is one of the women in imminent danger.
It seems what women consider a normal risk calculation becomes uncomfortable if the sexes are reversed?[/quote]
But that's choice isn't it? A man can give up his place, a woman can give up her place. I don't think anyone should be suggesting that a man who decides to take up their place (or force their way on through which isn't going to be an option for the vast majority of women for strength reasons) is doing anything wrong. The reality is that your average Afgan with no international connections isn't hanging around Kabul airport. Everyone there has reason to be afraid. The idea that men on the plane are cowards who don't care about their families is (a) blaming the wrong people, and (b) coming from an assumption that an Afghan man somehow loves his family less than 'other men'. I'm sure there are people on that plane who took up the place without a second thought or a twinge of guilt. There have been lots of reasons to explain why someone might take up their place because it is genuinely the best thing. I'd argue that there are likely to be more of the latter (but ultimately only they know) - there aren't many people who wouldn't have anyone they were leaving behind that they cared about even if it was brother/friend rather than wife and children.

LifesNotEnidBlyton · 17/08/2021 21:08

"Today 20:39 TractorAndHeadphones

LifesNotEnidBlyton

You are wrong. That isn't what has happened. My comment wasn't about British vs Afghan men.it was factual and followed with my thoughts. This has been gone over again and again. As for people disagreeing with me that has been gone over too. There was no need for everyone who disagreed to individually comment back to me when it is a group talk with more people who posted in line with me and when I have already said we can agree to disagree. So by continuing to comment individually it shows people only want to have an argument and gang up instead of contributing to the group talking about it without commenting to only one person in a comment.

You said it yourself, it’s a forum , people can post what they like - except when they reply/quote you, then they’re ‘ganging up’?
The thread’s moved on, everyone’s forgotten you now so you can have your tea in peace 😇"

No you don't seem to understand. What I said was that everyone can post what they want but when there is a group of people saying something and then people start commenting to an individual comment and that commenter asks to agree to disagree but people commenting individually to them then theres no need for it becuase it's just them trying to have an argument. Just like you have done now with your sarcastic reply. All I have done is commented back to people who have put a "quote" to me, and you are wrong that I was the only one still doing so becuase the comment you have put above was in reply to a comment I pit to someone who just a few posts up thread and has said to me but you still, when I hadn't put your username, felt the need to put mine so that's ironic.

Anyway as I've said we can agree to disagree with the people who have commented to me with my posts in their comments. Anyone else who does comment with my posts or who puts my username and I then reply isnt me continuing this. I've already asked that people don't if they don't agree because we can agree to disagree. So if people do then they are continuing it and I'm just being polite by not ignoring a direct comment.

LooksGood · 17/08/2021 21:05

[quote FemmePerdue]@Normaigai women are actively making that decision to give up their spaces for men and boys because they see death as worse than rape.
And using the phrase "because of her sex" hides the fact that it is her sex which has made her relationship with the westerners invisible - if she is one of the women in imminent danger.
It seems what women consider a normal risk calculation becomes uncomfortable if the sexes are reversed?[/quote]
I'm not sure I follow. Are you saying that we know that women in the situations you've described have gained visas and not used them so men can get to safety first?

Or that these women aren't considered worthy of visas so won't be on those planes anyway?

The second seems more likely to me. I'd hope too that women's role would be considered less important even by their oppressors, leaving them a bit safer.

lllllllllll · 17/08/2021 21:03

They aren’t just preventing girls going to school

They are going into towns demanding names of all unmarried girls and women over 12 to take as sex slaves. I’m sure their forced “husbands” will be ever so kind to them

Exactly. So sick of the ignorant fools on these threads.

SionnachRua · 17/08/2021 21:02

are any of those men talking about their maids or cleaners? Did they even know they had them? Did they even see the women who worked for it with them?

Most seem to have been low level soldiers trying to train the ANA so no. I'm sure if there are highers up floating about, they might have had maids - if I find them, I'll let you know. But there seems to be no doubt amongst the soldiers that the interpreters they knew would have been killed very quickly (or possibly slowly but they're certainly dead).

Personally I can't get worked up about American collaborators fleeing certain death. Them remaining in the country would only endanger their wives and children. And I can't imagine that they could easily get their wives and children on the flight with them, not when so many others who worked with the military need to go too.

TractorAndHeadphones · 17/08/2021 21:01

@Queenelsarules

Not on the basis of their sex they don't, which doesn't make it not awful, but a man is not at risk solely by virtue of being a man, a man has not had his humanity taken from him and been made the property of a male relative, the situation for women in Arlfghanistan is dire. Not only women who aided the military, not only women who object to the regime, not only women who resist the regime, all women by virtue of their sex, regardless of job, or status, by virtue of their biological sex their autonomy has been stolen from them. The oppression of women by this regime is systemic and total. This is distinct to how men are treated by this regime and it is disingenuous at the very least to claim otherwise.
Nobody has claimed otherwise. Thé question is not who has it worse. Thé question is should women be prioritised for rescue over men? The answer (in the absence of context) is no. What you’re saying is that men should be left to die over women since they can’t take everybody. Luck and eligibility are (under these conditions) the only way to decide that are ‘fair’
Normaigai · 17/08/2021 21:01

LifesNotEnidBlyton After my comment. I'm generally brilliant but predicting the future isn't in my skill set.

She also only commented after you commented on her post! If you don't want people to keep arguing with you then stop arguing with them. If you want to keep arguing with people fine, I don't care, but then stop complaining people are unfairly picking on you.

FemmePerdue · 17/08/2021 20:59

@Normaigai women are actively making that decision to give up their spaces for men and boys because they see death as worse than rape.
And using the phrase "because of her sex" hides the fact that it is her sex which has made her relationship with the westerners invisible - if she is one of the women in imminent danger.
It seems what women consider a normal risk calculation becomes uncomfortable if the sexes are reversed?

powershowerforanhour · 17/08/2021 20:59

a lot of women will be connected to the westerners in some way for example as maids, cleaners or nannies.

Hopefully those jobs will be held in such contempt that they're not really considered jobs and not worth a name on a list or a bullet.

Normaigai · 17/08/2021 20:57

ancientgran, there have been (reputable) links provided earlier on the thread that some people did force themselves on the plane. That's why it was as full as it was.

I think the position for the people who were granted visas and directed to be on the plane is pretty obvious but the same point applies - of my husband was given a seat and not me and the children, by far the most sensible thing would have been for him to take it. How does him refusing help me and the children?

kungfupannda · 17/08/2021 20:57

It's also worth remembering that what we are discussing is a photo. It's not just something someone saw in passing and told everyone else about. Someone took the photo, selected it from among all the others no doubt taken at the same time, and printed it or posted it on social media or in the media. There's always going to be an agenda when someone chooses to circulate a picture in a situation like this. That agenda might be an honest 'Look. Isn't this terrible. What can we do?' Or it might be an implied 'Look at these awful, cowardly men abandoning their women to save their own skins. Weren't we quite right to leave them all to it?'

And as another poster commented, it might not even be a planeload of Afghan men.

LifesNotEnidBlyton · 17/08/2021 20:57

@Normaigai

LifesNotEnidBlyton if you look at the thread, the only person still talking about the comments you made is you.
Actually it isn't. My comment then was to Siepie but "quote" failed. She/he commented to me individually just a few comments up the thread, so you are wrong.
ancientgran · 17/08/2021 20:55

[quote FemmePerdue]@SionnachRua are any of those men talking about their maids or cleaners?
Did they even know they had them? Did they even see the women who worked for it with them?
Brave men telling stories about brave men in war zones are telling the truth. A story as old as time.
But the level of instant death or rape the women face is unknown. They don't exist in these stories.[/quote]
That seems strange to me, I've seen various Afghan women being interviewed. I saw an interview today with a young female journalist who is in hiding. I've also seen female politicians being interviewed. So I think women's stories are being included.

Normaigai · 17/08/2021 20:53

@Queenelsarules

Not on the basis of their sex they don't, which doesn't make it not awful, but a man is not at risk solely by virtue of being a man, a man has not had his humanity taken from him and been made the property of a male relative, the situation for women in Arlfghanistan is dire. Not only women who aided the military, not only women who object to the regime, not only women who resist the regime, all women by virtue of their sex, regardless of job, or status, by virtue of their biological sex their autonomy has been stolen from them. The oppression of women by this regime is systemic and total. This is distinct to how men are treated by this regime and it is disingenuous at the very least to claim otherwise.
I don't think anyone's suggesting otherwise. Does that mean a man who is is at risk because of their job has to give up their place to a woman who is at risk because of her sex? How does that work through - there are young boys on that plane. Should they have had to give up their space to a woman? If not, why not? There's a strong argument a young boy left with grandparents is safer than the average Afghan woman at the moment.

Note I am not saying that they should have refused to take children (of course they shouldn't!), just that there is no good outcome here. There aren't enough places for everyone who deserves one. Blaming the people who got places for taking then is wrong.

ancientgran · 17/08/2021 20:52

@Wheretoeattweenandteen

Life is not Enid Blyton, the networks and the way things are structured are very different in counties like Afghanistan. The more modern richer families may be looser and more progressive but otherwise women are controlled and Co ordinated by family hierarchy and "uncles" etc.

In a sad article yesterday, the man a liberated girl feared the most knocking on her door after the fall of the kabul was her uncle who married her off age 12 to a cousin (financial Times)

There are layers upon layers of repression.
As pp have said I'm sure some of families are genuine and lovely.
Like tyere are any where in the world.

I am estranged from my dB and he's the absolute last person I'd want to have any jurisdiction over me. It would make my life miserable.

For men who have not worked for the West, I really don't think it could be argued that their lives will be as bad as for the girls.

They whole world, the un everyone is crying out for the girls!!

For men who have not worked for the West, I really don't think it could be argued that their lives will be as bad as for the girls. That's why they are prioritising the men who worked for the west and then women and girls. Although I have to say I'm not sure many women are going to be happy leaving little sons behind when they can escape with their daughters.
kungfupannda · 17/08/2021 20:52

Yes, it's a group talk - not just everyone shouting into the void. Someone says something, then someone else adds something or agrees or disagrees, then the first person might choose to defend what they said or clarify it or concede a point made by someone else, and so it goes on. You cannot come on a public forum, comment on an emotive issue and then demand that everyone ignore your comment.

The reason people are going 'over and over' it is that you're not engaging with any sort of on-topic discussion - just telling everyone to stop commenting on what you posted.

Personally, I am hugely uncomfortable with your comment about 'these men' when referring to swathes of foreign refugees. You keep saying that you weren't referring specifically to Afghan men, but it is implicit in your comment that you included them. Every one of those men is an individual with a story and a family and a set of circumstances specific to them. To lump them together negatively as 'these men' when referring to them leaving their family behind to face danger without them, and then to compare them to British men is textbook othering, and it's particularly unfair when we're all commenting safely from behind our computer screens with absolutely no knowledge of what the people we're glibly discussing have been through and are still going through. Maybe they are a homogenous mass of selfish wife-abandoners. I doubt it though.

You keep saying 'it was a small comment.' There's no such thing as a small comment on such a massive issue and it's disingenuous to try and downplay it like that. If it's your opinion, then it's your opinion. Own it. Defend it or clarify it if you want to, but don't try and silence other people who see it as part of a much larger and troubling issue, ie the way we are being manipulated into viewing some groups and cultures as intrinsically 'other'.

I have been polite, as have other posters, but this is getting a bit ridiculous. People are commenting on what you've said, which is exactly what these forums are for. If you don't want to engage with them, then don't, but everyone is absolutely entitled to comment.

FemmePerdue · 17/08/2021 20:51

@SionnachRua are any of those men talking about their maids or cleaners?
Did they even know they had them? Did they even see the women who worked for it with them?
Brave men telling stories about brave men in war zones are telling the truth. A story as old as time.
But the level of instant death or rape the women face is unknown. They don't exist in these stories.

ancientgran · 17/08/2021 20:48

@Normaigai

Would I have left my children if the roles were reversed and I was the one who had the risky job? I can't imagine it but equally I suspect my husband would have been screaming at me to go. Doubt I'd have been strong enough to stand a chance of getting on though.
I don't think they are fighting their way on to the military planes, the evacuation of the interpreters etc are planned and organised and I think the civilian flights have stopped.
Queenelsarules · 17/08/2021 20:41

Don't know why quote is not working, but thst reply was @tractorandheadphones

TractorAndHeadphones · 17/08/2021 20:39

@LifesNotEnidBlyton

You are wrong. That isn't what has happened. My comment wasn't about British vs Afghan men.it was factual and followed with my thoughts. This has been gone over again and again. As for people disagreeing with me that has been gone over too. There was no need for everyone who disagreed to individually comment back to me when it is a group talk with more people who posted in line with me and when I have already said we can agree to disagree. So by continuing to comment individually it shows people only want to have an argument and gang up instead of contributing to the group talking about it without commenting to only one person in a comment.
You said it yourself, it’s a forum , people can post what they like - except when they reply/quote you, then they’re ‘ganging up’? The thread’s moved on, everyone’s forgotten you now so you can have your tea in peace 😇
Queenelsarules · 17/08/2021 20:39

Not on the basis of their sex they don't, which doesn't make it not awful, but a man is not at risk solely by virtue of being a man, a man has not had his humanity taken from him and been made the property of a male relative, the situation for women in Arlfghanistan is dire. Not only women who aided the military, not only women who object to the regime, not only women who resist the regime, all women by virtue of their sex, regardless of job, or status, by virtue of their biological sex their autonomy has been stolen from them. The oppression of women by this regime is systemic and total. This is distinct to how men are treated by this regime and it is disingenuous at the very least to claim otherwise.

SionnachRua · 17/08/2021 20:37

Reddit is full of American soldiers talking about the interpreters and drivers they knew from tours in Afghanistan. Many are saying that it was a given if Afghanistan was taken by the Taliban, those men would be killed instantly. Too many of them have already been abandoned by the foreign commanders they helped, leaving them to certain death - I don't begrudge any of them who manage to escape.