Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Evacuation form Afghanistan- women?

309 replies

Aprilinspringtimeshower · 17/08/2021 12:41

So saw this article and the accompanying photo www.theguardian.com/world/2021/aug/17/afghanistan-striking-image-appears-to-show-640-people-fleeing-kabul-in-packed-us-military-plane?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other

This is what concerns me- where are the women? The overwhelming majority of people on that plane are men, adult males. There are a few women and some children.
Yet it is the women who are in greatest danger. Young girls, older women. Single women who won’t be able to support themselves once stopped from going outside unaccompanied, professional women who will be banned from working .

Everyone said that the war was about women’s right and way of life. And that what is happening now is a danger to the rights and well-being of women.

Surely it is women who are the ones that need to get out of the country safely and be offered asylum- so where are they? Why wasn’t that plane full of mostly women or even equal amounts of women and the men that accompany them.

I don’t hear the government saying anything to target protection and refuge for women specifically. And to young girls and women who are in real danger

AIBU that it is always the men that get the preference, and that really no one cares enough to actually provide proper protection to the women and girls ..it’s just all sound bites and noble words

OP posts:
TractorAndHeadphones · 17/08/2021 21:48

Also this is an interesting discussion actually barring the derailers!

TractorAndHeadphones · 17/08/2021 21:48

@Normaigai

You see this discussion is interesting unlike and argument on who should shut up first. Should the 'list makers' have an obligation to recognize that if there are women and men who both qualify, the woman may/will be less likely to come forwards because they think they're less worthy. And is so, is processing first come first serve acceptable or is it inherently sexist. And if inherently sexist (which I suspect it probably is), is it the type of sexism that is acceptable in the rushed circumstances or is it only acceptable because women are excepted to accept sexism. If for some reason, it was all women applying on first come first serve, are we sure the planes would be filled with women.
A woman who works in eligible roles in a place like Afghanistan is no shrinking violet. I can guarantee that. They would be the first to demand their rights. Or be well connected enough such that they get given them anyway.

The problematic assumption here is that there's an orderly queue of people lining up with papers 'proving' eligiblity.

In reality intelligence services are a messy network of transactions, most of which take place undercover with as little proof as possible. There is no single way of proving eligibility. It'll be a mixture of people vouching for colleagues, people having some proof (say some insider knowledge) and people who have no business being eligible but knowing the right person and slipping through.

The ones on the first planes out are those who were contactable on short notice and known to the military. Direct employees on the payroll. Translators, engineers, etc. Not all Afghans - a lot of the men look like foreign nationals employed by the military (who might not have any family in Afghanistan, so no women to consider).

The next batch will likely be more balanced because people will have had time to gather up their families and make their way to the processing centres (or whatever it is) amidst the turmoil. Even for these it's not about men vs women but who can prove their identity. A well connected woman who has a brother who already left for example and whom the Taliban know - she would go ahead of a translator whom nobody knows and has no proof of connection.

A neat 'binary' scenario in which there is ' a man and woman who both qualify and it's really really obvious' is very unlikely. A 'woman not coming foward' is as unlikely as a 'man not coming forward' because people would go as a family - unless there's no time, and the choice if for whoever's eligible (man or woman) to wait for family or go ahead first.

NOW CAVEAT : the only scenario I can think of is that a man and woman who both qualify but cannot prove it. But they believe the man instead of the woman. Then yes, this is sexist. However again it's unlikely that a man or woman turn up alone.

LooksGood · 17/08/2021 21:47

@pollylocketpickedapocket

Well speaking as a parent(mother) I’d stay and be bloody executed and let my daughter go than leave her at the mercy of the taliban. At least she’d have a chance at life.
I'm sure lots of people on that plane would die for their children, as you would.

But who's going to give a visa to an unaccompanied child? We can't judge people on fantasy scenarios.

LifesNotEnidBlyton · 17/08/2021 21:47

There has been some real irony on this thread from people who want to be able to comment to individuals but when that person stands up for themself and says it's turning into bullying and asks people not to comment individually to them because it is derailing the thread those posters then make it out to be the fault of the person they did this too.

It's easy to not contribute to the important problem and just to pick on individuals but then blame them.

This thread has totally lost its intention.

Some real bullies out in force against people who dont agree with them.

Normaigai · 17/08/2021 21:45

@snowballer

You seriously expect Afghani men to stand to one side for women? It won't happen, the Taliban may be the extremists but within the culture women are less than second class citizens.

If you know so much, at least get the terminology correct. "Afghani" is a unit of currency. "Afghan" denotes nationality. It's a common mistake but one worth getting right when making such sweeping generalisations

I also suspect that there are a number of the Afgan men who do think of women as second class citizens who would prefer to die than have the the shame of their wife being raped. If you view your wife as your property, not being capable of protecting her is a pretty big deal. It's not as simple as 'my wife, my property, what happens to her doesn't matter to me'.
youvegottenminuteslynn · 17/08/2021 21:45

@LifesNotEnidBlyton

I posted just one small comment on a thread to share my thoughts, and then I left the thread. Since then I have had comment after comment individually to me

If multiple people make 'comment after comment' taking issue with something you say, isn't it worth reflecting on whether what you said is the issue rather than expressing your anger at people taking issue with what you said? I think so.

I guess we'll have to agree to disagree on your approach to this.

Porcupineintherough · 17/08/2021 21:42

@pollylocketpickedapocket but that's not how it works is it? If you are entitled to a place on an evacuation flight, you cant just send your daughter in your place. And what would you do - just send her to travel through Kabul on her own and hope the Taliban dont stop her? Send her to the airport and hope she doesnt get shot?

Normaigai · 17/08/2021 21:42

@pollylocketpickedapocket

Well speaking as a parent(mother) I’d stay and be bloody executed and let my daughter go than leave her at the mercy of the taliban. At least she’d have a chance at life.
Yes of course (although none of us actually know what we would really do unless we've been unlucky enough to be in that situation) but it's not clear that's an option that anyone legitimately got to make. It's not like the US visa people were saying 'you can nominate someone else to go in your place if you want'!
Blossomtoes · 17/08/2021 21:42

Can we agree not to engage with a certain poster any more? This is is such a heartfelt and important thread and the constant derailments are incredibly distracting.

snowballer · 17/08/2021 21:41

You seriously expect Afghani men to stand to one side for women? It won't happen, the Taliban may be the extremists but within the culture women are less than second class citizens.

If you know so much, at least get the terminology correct. "Afghani" is a unit of currency. "Afghan" denotes nationality. It's a common mistake but one worth getting right when making such sweeping generalisations

Normaigai · 17/08/2021 21:38

@SchrodingersImmigrant

There are stories of and from women out there as well. There is an article about female soldiers in Afganistan and the fear of payback, in my native newspapers. It's really sad. Incredibly brave
Did you see Rangina Hamid's interview? I watched it live and it was heartbreaking. So brave.
pollylocketpickedapocket · 17/08/2021 21:38

Well speaking as a parent(mother) I’d stay and be bloody executed and let my daughter go than leave her at the mercy of the taliban. At least she’d have a chance at life.

LifesNotEnidBlyton · 17/08/2021 21:38

@youvegottenminuteslynn

Goodness me *@LifesNotEnidBlyton* you're starting to make a thread about a humanitarian crisis all about you.

You wanted people to agree to disagree. If your version of that is people disengaging and not tagging one another etc then disengage yourself.

Or you could hide the thread if it's upsetting you. It's not all about you and it's in me-railing territory now.

What a sarcastic and ignorant comment. One commented I posted just one small comment on a thread to share my thoughts, and then I left the thread. Since then I have had comment after comment individually to me, and as i have been taught it is polite to answer when addressed i answered and said we could agree to disagree so the thread wasnt derailed or turned into an argument. Again and again I tried this as the comments continued to address only me. Nowhere have I posted a comment individually to anyone who did not do so to me first, and you might think that I should just ignore people talking to me but when all I've done is commented normally and they have continued the argument after I have tried to deescalate I've a right to stand up to them, and people like you are the ones making it about themselves, and then you have the audacity to say that I should be th one to just ignore bullying and not asking why they have kept talking only to me so you are wrong and obviously not to good with irony of your ignorance.
JudgeJ · 17/08/2021 21:35

@manhattenrain

The children and women should have been the priority as they are the ones in greatest of danger. 💔
You seriously expect Afghani men to stand to one side for women? It won't happen, the Taliban may be the extremists but within the culture women are less than second class citizens.
SchrodingersImmigrant · 17/08/2021 21:34

There are stories of and from women out there as well. There is an article about female soldiers in Afganistan and the fear of payback, in my native newspapers. It's really sad. Incredibly brave

Normaigai · 17/08/2021 21:33

Lots of typos. I suspect you get my point.

Although I don't want to detract from how horrific this is for everyone involved.

Normaigai · 17/08/2021 21:32

You see this discussion is interesting unlike and argument on who should shut up first. Should the 'list makers' have an obligation to recognize that if there are women and men who both qualify, the woman may/will be less likely to come forwards because they think they're less worthy. And is so, is processing first come first serve acceptable or is it inherently sexist. And if inherently sexist (which I suspect it probably is), is it the type of sexism that is acceptable in the rushed circumstances or is it only acceptable because women are excepted to accept sexism. If for some reason, it was all women applying on first come first serve, are we sure the planes would be filled with women.

2bazookas · 17/08/2021 21:30

Everyone said that the war was about women’s right and way of life

No, they did not . That's not what the war was about so please don't spread fake news. It absolutely beggars belief that America's reason for going to war there 20 years ago has been so swiftly forgotten.

All the wars in Afghanistan have been about territory, politics, power; invaders pursuing revenge, control, territorial and military agendas.

Britain has been to war four times in Afghanistan. Never about women. USSR spent 10 years at war with Afghanistan (1979-89) , not about women , and USA 20 years not about women.

You can easily google Afghanistans bloody history.

LifesNotEnidBlyton · 17/08/2021 21:30

[quote Burnt0utMum]@LifesNotEnidBlyton Your original comment implied that Afghan men were simply abandoning their families and that British men were somehow better as more of them wouldn't do that. The comment was based on pure conjecture. It's not even possible to base it on fact unless the UK somehow goes through a similar situation to what's happening in Afghanistan now. It created a sense of them and us that simply shouldn't exist especially in these horrific circumstances and it needed calling out.[/quote]
The comment, as I have explained again and again, was just a simplified way of putting my thoughts. You took it another way than it was. You are saying what my comment was but say implied and it only implied it to you and a few people who commented back. It isnt your job to "call people out", and more so when you dont actually know more about what the person thinks and are wrong.

Normaigai · 17/08/2021 21:27

[quote FemmePerdue]@normaigai I don't believe in calling anyone a coward. I do know some have used that term on here. I haven't.

And the thing with choice is it is influenced by the stories we tell ourselves.
If I believe that death is worse than rape then we have ourselves a no brainer.
If I believe my family will be safeish without me I have a no brainer.
If I believe that a bit of flogging is better than my husband being tortured then again no brainer.
If being flogged but alive is part of being safe then yes I can stay behind.
That the men believe they deserve a place on the planes, that I do not question.
What I do question is why so few women see themselves as worthy of that spot despite what I believe to be more than quite a few being compromised.[/quote]
I think that it is likely women thought of themselves as less worthy and there will be a massive amount of social conditioning going into that decision (and even more so in a society like Afghanistan). Plus a woman would be judged far far harder for leaving her children.

I mean this genuinely. Is there a story which suggests that a lot of women have given up places or is it that your view is they haven't been pushing as hard for them as the men because they think they don't deserve them?

TractorAndHeadphones · 17/08/2021 21:26

[quote FemmePerdue]@TractorAndHeadphones erm no the question is: is the prioritisation of men over women fair?
Your argument being: some men will die, so yes.
I fail to agree with your yes until the suffering of the women at immediate risk of harm is taken into equal account and given the same gravitas as death.

If you can do this then I might agree with your yes. Until then I'm not convinced. I'd tend to think the original unfairness in the system is permeating through the rescue.

It seems like people on here are hoping that maids' names don't make the list so they are safe.

I'll repeat myself, men are the story tellers here. The only names worth putting on those lists are male. The list writers will definitely know which women to target before they go for the indiscriminate debauchery.[/quote]
But nobody's prioritising men over women!

  1. In the U.S plane : They're prioritising people who worked with the Western military. So whether they're men, women, Martians or giraffes is irrelevant. If as many women worked with the militaries then the plane would be full of them.

The men who got on forced their way in and were not supposed to be there. The pilot took off instead of kicking them out. Nobody prioritised them.

  1. At processing centers: Presumably first come first served processing. Those who are eligible will be extradited. Those who are not left. Eligibility again has nothing to do with sex.

So please tell me as of this moment - where have men been prioritised over women solely because they are men?

There's also the case of refugees crossing borders as happened with Syria but that's unrelated as we are specifically discussing Afghanistan.

FemmePerdue · 17/08/2021 21:22

@normaigai I don't believe in calling anyone a coward. I do know some have used that term on here. I haven't.

And the thing with choice is it is influenced by the stories we tell ourselves.
If I believe that death is worse than rape then we have ourselves a no brainer.
If I believe my family will be safeish without me I have a no brainer.
If I believe that a bit of flogging is better than my husband being tortured then again no brainer.
If being flogged but alive is part of being safe then yes I can stay behind.
That the men believe they deserve a place on the planes, that I do not question.
What I do question is why so few women see themselves as worthy of that spot despite what I believe to be more than quite a few being compromised.

Normaigai · 17/08/2021 21:22

[quote FemmePerdue]@TractorAndHeadphones erm no the question is: is the prioritisation of men over women fair?
Your argument being: some men will die, so yes.
I fail to agree with your yes until the suffering of the women at immediate risk of harm is taken into equal account and given the same gravitas as death.

If you can do this then I might agree with your yes. Until then I'm not convinced. I'd tend to think the original unfairness in the system is permeating through the rescue.

It seems like people on here are hoping that maids' names don't make the list so they are safe.

I'll repeat myself, men are the story tellers here. The only names worth putting on those lists are male. The list writers will definitely know which women to target before they go for the indiscriminate debauchery.[/quote]
I do see your point but I think that's the fault of the list makers and it does need to be challenged. To put it in context though, someone posted up thread, that a visa had been denied to a man guarding British Embassy bodyguards because he worked for a contractor, not directly for the Embassy. If there is a group of women who worked directly for the government who have been left off the 'list' then I am completely behind you. Should the cleaners of the embassy (assuming female) get the same priority as the security guards? Absolutely but I haven't seen anything to suggest they haven't. I think that it's is highly unlikely that anyone who worked much further down the chain (for example a cleaner or a driver to a foreigner not in any way contracted to the embassy) are going to get a look in though. I suspect that it's far more likely that 'female' roles wouldn't have been contracted directly though and so objectively women will be disadvantaged, it's just I don't see a good option to fix that at this stage.

I agree women's voices aren't heard but I suspect it wouldn't have made much difference here and that still isn't a reason a man should be blamed for taking up a place.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 17/08/2021 21:22

Goodness me @LifesNotEnidBlyton you're starting to make a thread about a humanitarian crisis all about you.

You wanted people to agree to disagree. If your version of that is people disengaging and not tagging one another etc then disengage yourself.

Or you could hide the thread if it's upsetting you. It's not all about you and it's in me-railing territory now.

Burnt0utMum · 17/08/2021 21:21

@LifesNotEnidBlyton Your original comment implied that Afghan men were simply abandoning their families and that British men were somehow better as more of them wouldn't do that. The comment was based on pure conjecture. It's not even possible to base it on fact unless the UK somehow goes through a similar situation to what's happening in Afghanistan now. It created a sense of them and us that simply shouldn't exist especially in these horrific circumstances and it needed calling out.