Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Evacuation form Afghanistan- women?

309 replies

Aprilinspringtimeshower · 17/08/2021 12:41

So saw this article and the accompanying photo www.theguardian.com/world/2021/aug/17/afghanistan-striking-image-appears-to-show-640-people-fleeing-kabul-in-packed-us-military-plane?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other

This is what concerns me- where are the women? The overwhelming majority of people on that plane are men, adult males. There are a few women and some children.
Yet it is the women who are in greatest danger. Young girls, older women. Single women who won’t be able to support themselves once stopped from going outside unaccompanied, professional women who will be banned from working .

Everyone said that the war was about women’s right and way of life. And that what is happening now is a danger to the rights and well-being of women.

Surely it is women who are the ones that need to get out of the country safely and be offered asylum- so where are they? Why wasn’t that plane full of mostly women or even equal amounts of women and the men that accompany them.

I don’t hear the government saying anything to target protection and refuge for women specifically. And to young girls and women who are in real danger

AIBU that it is always the men that get the preference, and that really no one cares enough to actually provide proper protection to the women and girls ..it’s just all sound bites and noble words

OP posts:
Wheretoeattweenandteen · 18/08/2021 08:27

So...

It's the fault of those who encouraged women to put their head above the parapet but nothing to do with a culture that already traps women?
You don't think the culture itself needs work?

kungfupannda · 18/08/2021 08:00

@Mandalay246

How fucking dare you judge those who are fleeing for their lives. What gives you that right? If you're so concerned about the fate of women in Afghanistan go and help instead of sitting in your privilege casting judgement on those who had to choose between leaving everything behind or being executed for daring to try and change their country.

Well said. Some people on this thread are extremely lacking in imagination and empathy. They have absolutely no idea what life is like for people in a country such as Afghanistan, and I would really like to know exactly what is is they are doing to help. Some of you live in such bubbles of privilege and seem unable to understand how very different life is for others and how things are never as black and white as they think.

I know. The fucking arrogance of it. To look at pictures of terrified people escaping death and brutality and criticise them for not fleeing in a way that is culturally palatable to us.

Let me be very clear. I want to see women coming out of Afghanistan. I want us to somehow find a way to extract every women with a price on her head, and as many other women as we possibly can. When I think of Afghanistan, it's women I immediately think of, not men. It's not that I don't care about the men, but it's the women who are at the forefront of my mind.

But my concerns for the female population as a whole, and for the specific high-risk women whose stories we have heard, have nothing to do with the pictures of men being evacuated, or the response to those pictures. It's being treated as an either/or calculation, as if those specific men could have given up their places on the plane to specific women. It wouldn't have happened. If someone had refused their place, those processing the applications would have moved onto the next person in line. Who would probably have been a man, for various reasons, including a whole load of sexism.

We probably could have got a lot of women out of there. We fucked up, and in doing so put most of them out of reach. The women on that plane are no doubt the ones with the right qualifications or connections and who lived close enough to the airport to get there. There will be high-profile women all over the country who should, morally, have been on one of those planes, but who had no hope of getting there or fighting through the red tape and restrictions to get a place.

There's a shitload of sexism and women being thrown under the bus going on, but the lack of women in those pictures is almost certainly not the fault of the men in those pictures. Most immediately, it's the fault of those who created a society in which those women felt safe to stick their heads above the parapet and then fucked off without putting any sort of structure in place to give them a chance of saving themselves.

Maybe that's what's behind all the outrage. People look at those pictures and see someone convenient they can blame instead of looking at our own country's culpability and incompetence. Some of the students in that visa fuck-up were women. We could have got them out. We didn't. We didn't give enough of a shit about them to follow through on a promise we made to them. Not enough time to process their applications? Fuck right off.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 18/08/2021 07:27

@redtshirt50

To the poster saying the men in their lives would never leave them, even if it meant certain death - you simply cannot know this and it's not a fair statement to make.
Everyone's a hero in their shower imaginations. Reality is fundamentally different. None of us can aay at all how they would behave in situation facing death or a serious threat unless they've been it in. Then their guess can be more accurate. Doesn't stop peoppe trying to make themselves look like better humans with "I would neveeeer"tho.
Normaigai · 18/08/2021 03:37

@ResIpsaLoquiturInterAlia

Could it simply be a fact that women and girls are systematically controlled by the extreme Islamist medieval barbaric cavemen as second class being deliberately forced and kept indoors as if slaves? I understand education for girls is prohibited and they are forced into sexual slavery by the Taliban extremists against their will from a very young age in forced marriages like those found throughout this region including neighbouring developing south Asia Indian subcontinent etc. Only a few brainwashed girls from parts of inner city east London and other large European cities want to escape there to join their crusade as child brides (as widely reported on in global mainstream news media).
The Taliban isn't ISIS. You're talking about ISIS. I'm not aware of brainwashed girls from London leaving to join the Taliban! It's never been a thing.
redtshirt50 · 18/08/2021 03:14

To the poster saying the men in their lives would never leave them, even if it meant certain death - you simply cannot know this and it's not a fair statement to make.

ResIpsaLoquiturInterAlia · 18/08/2021 02:47

Could it simply be a fact that women and girls are systematically controlled by the extreme Islamist medieval barbaric cavemen as second class being deliberately forced and kept indoors as if slaves? I understand education for girls is prohibited and they are forced into sexual slavery by the Taliban extremists against their will from a very young age in forced marriages like those found throughout this region including neighbouring developing south Asia Indian subcontinent etc. Only a few brainwashed girls from parts of inner city east London and other large European cities want to escape there to join their crusade as child brides (as widely reported on in global mainstream news media).

Mandalay246 · 18/08/2021 02:22

How fucking dare you judge those who are fleeing for their lives. What gives you that right? If you're so concerned about the fate of women in Afghanistan go and help instead of sitting in your privilege casting judgement on those who had to choose between leaving everything behind or being executed for daring to try and change their country.

Well said. Some people on this thread are extremely lacking in imagination and empathy. They have absolutely no idea what life is like for people in a country such as Afghanistan, and I would really like to know exactly what is is they are doing to help. Some of you live in such bubbles of privilege and seem unable to understand how very different life is for others and how things are never as black and white as they think.

FemmePerdue · 18/08/2021 02:06

I do not believe anyone here thinks it right that men of any age should be left to die.

The question is why does it not feel as outrageous that the women and children are actually being left behind?
Somehow if we left these men behind it would be an absolute scandal but leaving a majority of women behind can be considered collateral damage. Somehow the women didn't do the right jobs, didn't suffer enough, weren't official enough or have the right connections to be important enough to be rescued or for it to be a scandal that not enough of them would make it out.

And yes I saw that pic. It unfortunately is difficult to weigh that picture against the stream of fleeing men that we've witnessed over the past few days.

And as you say, no one wants to get on a military aircraft and still not be safe. I wish them all safe journeys and good luck in the next part of their lives. It's not going to be easy.

MobyDicksTinyCanoe · 18/08/2021 01:40

Such a shame that photo was heavily cropped to appeal to the gammonista and people who think young men barely into their 20s should be left to die.
Here's the original. I hope all of those on the plane and many more reach safety.

Evacuation form Afghanistan- women?
ClareBlue · 18/08/2021 01:19

Yes, you're right. It is just the number if different threads around the whole topic and this probably isn't the right angel on this thread. I'm leaving it as I not sure about the areas around this.

FemmePerdue · 18/08/2021 00:54

@clareblue that's a lot of mental leaps. It seems to center men in a debate about evacuating women?

ClareBlue · 18/08/2021 00:26

We sent in our sons and young men 20 years ago to fight in a distant Country against a enemy they couldn't engage in traditional warefare. In the meantime we had interlectual debate about the legacy of the flag they fought under, cancelled people who wouldn't condem leaders of the last generation who fought an enemy, ripped down statues and vilified patriotic thoughts, and they literally gave their lives to protect women and children from real persecution. But on returning the intellectual debate was about toxic masculinity, they said not all men and tried to understand but we're then labelled part of the problem for saying that. The communities that provided the men that died fighting against a regime that persecuted women were labelled ignorant bigots for voting against a European project that had no relevance or meaning in their lives but all they could see was migration of people that competed for housing and healthcare and jobs whilst they tried to support their families. The elite debated BLM but they don't see colour when their black buddy is bleeding out in Helmand or their mixed race Corporal is the first to check the incendery device. But the interlectual elite say they are entitled while privaleged and ate part of the problem. They come back home and can not understand someone losing their livlihood for using an incorrect pronoun and been labelled transphobic, when they have seen homosexual people hanging in the street. But they are labelled part of the problem.

And now we want them to go and do it all again.

MistySkiesAfterRain · 17/08/2021 23:10

Just thought I'd share - some interesting stats. Around 2/3 of those seeking/granted asylum in the UK in the last decade were male.

migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/resources/briefings/migration-to-the-uk-asylum/

Normaigai · 17/08/2021 22:33

I think my main hope is the Taliban have learnt enough about PR in 20 years that they may not go in as hard as we all fear because they recognised they need to play the game for aid money. There's clearly not full control over the action of individuals and there is no suggestion Afghanistan is going to be somewhere you want to be a woman or someone with the wrong foreign connections but maybe, just maybe, it will be better than 20 years ago. I have to believe that the last 20 years hasn't been entirely for nothing. It may be completely naive but I'd prefer to keep that naivity as long as possible because what can I legitimately do to change anything?

Anyway, it's very late here (not the UK) so I will leave the remainder of the discussions to others.

TractorAndHeadphones · 17/08/2021 22:23

@Normaigai

I think the figures I saw (I think for the UK) is that withdrawal was announced in April (?). By August they had processed 2000 of the 20000 people they agreed were eligible (and that's on the direct employment rules). Only earlier this month they told the British Council scholarship winners 'sorry we can't process your visas, you need to defer a year'. This is the disgrace. We knew we were withdrawing. There were a lot of people predicting this outcome (within 6 months of not this quickly) and the governments didn't have a plan that would have saved people even if it had taken six months.
Yes agreed.. and leaving people to fight over scraps...
TractorAndHeadphones · 17/08/2021 22:22

@Normaigai

I think there is a group of women working directly for foreign governments who are extremely vocal. There will be other women who are just trying to do a day's work - remember it's been 20 years of this probably being a risk that's worth the extra pay. It's only relatively recently that risk profile has changed and by then it was probably too late.

I agree with you though that there isn't a neat orderly line. Even within that women (and people with children) are inherently less likely to make it to the front (strength/size even ignoring any cultural issues) and there simply hasn't been time for everyone to be processed.

My honest view is that the nature of first come first serve probably is inherently sexist but overall it's also a type of sexism that it's just not realistic to fix in these circumstances. People are doing the best they can. The people processing the visas also (mainly) aren't the ones to blame and a lot are staying at great personal risk when they are guaranteed a spot on the next flight they want.

What I would find interesting is a review on whether the sex effectively plays a role in the decision on who is contracted directly and who isn't. Are 'female' roles more likely to be contracted out and as a result less likely to be considered worthy of protection.

'Female' roles are more likely but only because they're the lower paid roles like cooking,cleaning, etc. Many of the roles that require clearance will be held by men which is probably indirectly sexist. I don't know if embassy support/admin staff count. However there's also the overarching matter of 'connections' - Afghanistan is riddled with corruption. What is likely to actually happen is that those who can will pay off the relevant people to let their whole families go - women, children, the lot. The middle/upper classes who have managed to scrape together some money. Once the internationals have gotten as many people out as they deem fit they'll leave... and the rest will have to fend for themselves.

Of course this depends on whether the Taliban hold off and allow people to escape - it is in their interests to let some through, as long as they have enough remaining to make an example of.

Normaigai · 17/08/2021 22:07

I think the figures I saw (I think for the UK) is that withdrawal was announced in April (?). By August they had processed 2000 of the 20000 people they agreed were eligible (and that's on the direct employment rules). Only earlier this month they told the British Council scholarship winners 'sorry we can't process your visas, you need to defer a year'. This is the disgrace. We knew we were withdrawing. There were a lot of people predicting this outcome (within 6 months of not this quickly) and the governments didn't have a plan that would have saved people even if it had taken six months.

kungfupannda · 17/08/2021 22:00

@TractorAndHeadphones

Also this is an interesting discussion actually barring the derailers!
Can't quote your long post for some reason, so replying to this one. Very balanced post putting your finger on something I was trying to work out how to articulate. The group of men pictured leaving have been cast up as somehow taking something that could otherwise have gone to women and children, but that's not how it will be working. There are multiple groups of people at more risk than others for various reasons, but not all of them have a chance at a spot on a plane out of there. For some it will be as simple as living too far from the airport to risk trying to get there. Most of the men pictured will fall into a prioritised category. There may be women equally or more at risk but not in a way that bumps them up the evacuation list of a foreign power. There's a lot of sexism tied up in the reasons why that is the case, but it's not a simple 'man vs woman - man wins' calculation.

And all of this is a distraction from the very serious questions that need to be levelled at our own government and others about the way this has been allowed to play out. We could have saved an awful lot of those at-risk women - and men.

Normaigai · 17/08/2021 22:00

@Wheretoeattweenandteen

the original unfairness in the system is permeating through the rescue

Yes ^^ this.

Yes also to this! Exactly.
Normaigai · 17/08/2021 21:59

I think there is a group of women working directly for foreign governments who are extremely vocal. There will be other women who are just trying to do a day's work - remember it's been 20 years of this probably being a risk that's worth the extra pay. It's only relatively recently that risk profile has changed and by then it was probably too late.

I agree with you though that there isn't a neat orderly line. Even within that women (and people with children) are inherently less likely to make it to the front (strength/size even ignoring any cultural issues) and there simply hasn't been time for everyone to be processed.

My honest view is that the nature of first come first serve probably is inherently sexist but overall it's also a type of sexism that it's just not realistic to fix in these circumstances. People are doing the best they can. The people processing the visas also (mainly) aren't the ones to blame and a lot are staying at great personal risk when they are guaranteed a spot on the next flight they want.

What I would find interesting is a review on whether the sex effectively plays a role in the decision on who is contracted directly and who isn't. Are 'female' roles more likely to be contracted out and as a result less likely to be considered worthy of protection.

LifesNotEnidBlyton · 17/08/2021 21:56

Good that people are finally agreeing with me. Even if they did need to make it out to their idea. This thread has attracted the bullies it seems. Who want to comment to people but cry derailment when the person they pick on says something back.... and tells then that by commenting back it was they who were derailing.... and continuing to do so by then talking like children about the person they want everyone to not talk to anymore, and will likely do so again when they see that said person is still calling out their behaviour.

TractorAndHeadphones · 17/08/2021 21:51

Also to add - above last scenario while possible is also unlikely because of the low number of women in the service. Even in 'empowered' countries like the U.K the number of women in intelligence and diplomatic services is shockingly low.

I suppose the biggest sexism is if a man manages to blag his way through and a woman doesn't as happens every day in multiple job interviews and workplaces across the U.K. Given that they both have no connection at all . More stringent proof demanded of the man compared to the woman..

kungfupannda · 17/08/2021 21:51

@Blossomtoes

Can we agree not to engage with a certain poster any more? This is is such a heartfelt and important thread and the constant derailments are incredibly distracting.
Agreed.
LifesNotEnidBlyton · 17/08/2021 21:50

[quote youvegottenminuteslynn]@LifesNotEnidBlyton

I posted just one small comment on a thread to share my thoughts, and then I left the thread. Since then I have had comment after comment individually to me

If multiple people make 'comment after comment' taking issue with something you say, isn't it worth reflecting on whether what you said is the issue rather than expressing your anger at people taking issue with what you said? I think so.

I guess we'll have to agree to disagree on your approach to this. [/quote]
As said people can have thoughts of thier own. I wasnt the only poster to think as I did. But unfortunately the only people who got individual comments back were the people who a group of posters didnt agree with. You can post on a thread another sort of thought without it turning into a thread about your comment, and when I explained people still kept commenting just to me, so I think if people really cared about the thread they wouldn't have turned it into this and it is them who have made the thread about a comment they didn't agree with ironically.

Wheretoeattweenandteen · 17/08/2021 21:50

the original unfairness in the system is permeating through the rescue

Yes ^^ this.