Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Evacuation form Afghanistan- women?

309 replies

Aprilinspringtimeshower · 17/08/2021 12:41

So saw this article and the accompanying photo www.theguardian.com/world/2021/aug/17/afghanistan-striking-image-appears-to-show-640-people-fleeing-kabul-in-packed-us-military-plane?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other

This is what concerns me- where are the women? The overwhelming majority of people on that plane are men, adult males. There are a few women and some children.
Yet it is the women who are in greatest danger. Young girls, older women. Single women who won’t be able to support themselves once stopped from going outside unaccompanied, professional women who will be banned from working .

Everyone said that the war was about women’s right and way of life. And that what is happening now is a danger to the rights and well-being of women.

Surely it is women who are the ones that need to get out of the country safely and be offered asylum- so where are they? Why wasn’t that plane full of mostly women or even equal amounts of women and the men that accompany them.

I don’t hear the government saying anything to target protection and refuge for women specifically. And to young girls and women who are in real danger

AIBU that it is always the men that get the preference, and that really no one cares enough to actually provide proper protection to the women and girls ..it’s just all sound bites and noble words

OP posts:
Paulinna · 17/08/2021 14:21

I think this tells you everything you need to know about the behaviour of men in those countries. The army just surrendered without firing a single shot and didn’t even try to defend their women and children from the Taliban. And now the men are taking up seats on refugee flights that could have been filled by women and children. The news reported that women were standing back from the crowds pushing to get on planes because of the risk of sexual assault. Basically the women are second class citizens and the men don’t respect them.

LooksGood · 17/08/2021 14:18

@HyacynthBucket

OP I agree with everything you have written here, also BrilloPad. To be a woman a or girl in Afghanistan right now or into the future is a terrible fate. What can we do to help them? Women everywhere should be horrified at what is happening to other women and children there, and wanting to do something on their behalf, but what? I saw on TV that UNICEF is staying on and the Taliban had agreed to let them continue working. .
That's a bright spot in all this and good to know
MotionActivatedDog · 17/08/2021 14:16

And how sure are you that all of those weren’t men from the Taliban - I don’t think random men would’ve have been standing around

I’ve no reason to believe they weren't taliban- I don’t think I said I did? Confused

That doesn’t change the fact that this will be the reason those women didn’t get to the airport, does it?

LooksGood · 17/08/2021 14:15

I did a breakdown of this kind of situation with historical data, once. Circumstances differ each time, but:

If we were talking about an orderly evacuation where there's a clear route to safety, and you get to pack your wife and child on the bus while you fight on, wait for the next - we'd have one situation. That's not this. There are no lifeboats.

This is a dangerous escape route - you might as well carry a banner saying American collaborator as head for that airport. It's an uncertain one - they are not evacuating just anyone. They are processing visas, i.e. refusing people. In circumstances I've studied, families that tried to reunite quickly seemed more likely to become casualties. Separate, staggered escapes worked better.

And yes, people can send for families. Get out, persuade host country you can support them, and allowing them to leave is on the table for diplomatic negotiations.

If we want to help, we should put pressure on the government to keep processing, keep accepting, keep negotiating. Not demand that men sit down and wait to die for the mess we have helped create.

TractorAndHeadphones · 17/08/2021 14:12

@MotionActivatedDog

Article in the guardian earlier with a quote from a woman who was being evacuated from her university on Sunday, no men would help them leave. They wouldn’t take them in their cars as didn’t want to be responsible for a woman. The men outside watching the women leave were taunting them with comments telling them to go and buy a burqa and saying “I will marry 4 of you in a day”.

This is why women and children aren’t being seen on the photos.

And how sure are you that all of those weren’t men from the Taliban - I don’t think random men would’ve have been standing around .
TractorAndHeadphones · 17/08/2021 14:11

@Belleager

The Uk have said they are planning on evacuating women and children so they will make sure its women and children.

The UK can do that if it sticks with its current policy of processing slowly and grudgingly from refugee camps. Whether they'll manage it in Kabul on the ground remains to be seen. They're not exactly covering themselves with glory so far.

The mess they've made - and the US and other countries - affects men too. Rhetoric which only allows women and children to be vulnerable refugees plays well politically and stokes anti-refugee feeling. Men can be vulnerable and betrayed by international forces too (and of course most men, women and children come in family groups)

And I don't remember women's rights being the driver - wasn't it War on Terror and Winning Hearts and Minds to the Western Way?

I took that to mean that they will be evacuating families - but that also refers to people whom they’ve worked with. Not that they’re going to take all women/kids that turn up and ignore the men.

Also women first is only sensible if they’re the primary carer of children. I don’t see why a childless adult of any gender had priority over the other. At the end of the day only the lucky ones escapee anyway.

HyacynthBucket · 17/08/2021 14:06

OP I agree with everything you have written here, also BrilloPad. To be a woman a or girl in Afghanistan right now or into the future is a terrible fate. What can we do to help them? Women everywhere should be horrified at what is happening to other women and children there, and wanting to do something on their behalf, but what? I saw on TV that UNICEF is staying on and the Taliban had agreed to let them continue working. .

Alonelonelyloner · 17/08/2021 14:04

I DO JUDGE, I JUDGE. WE ALL DO

historically there have been multiple situations where people have had to be evacuated. And I know more about this situation than many. It is noticeable, the lack of women. It is a cultural issue and it is fucked up beyond reasoning by western standards and I DO JUDGE.

Judging those who do judge is actually you in your western ivory castle refusing to see that this is not so bloody simple and there is a fuck tonne of sexism involved.

LooksGood · 17/08/2021 14:03

@kurtney

Staying with your wife and children because you can't all get out together isn't going to help them. Wouldn't you encourage your dad / brother / son / husband to get the hell out and away from you in this awful situation? For your kids' sake, too?

I absolutely would but there's no way on earth my dad/husband/brother would have left us behind at the mercy of a brutal woman hating regime. The idea that these men have left their female relatives behind and are going to 'send for them later' is laughable and anyone who thinks they are is incredibly naive.

And I don't care how much that 'makes your skin crawl' 🙄

But their families are in more danger if they are with them! Who knows what arrangements they've made - extended family, different routes. But the choices they are facing are not the choices you are describing.
MotionActivatedDog · 17/08/2021 14:01

Article in the guardian earlier with a quote from a woman who was being evacuated from her university on Sunday, no men would help them leave. They wouldn’t take them in their cars as didn’t want to be responsible for a woman. The men outside watching the women leave were taunting them with comments telling them to go and buy a burqa and saying “I will
marry 4 of you in a day”.

This is why women and children aren’t being seen on the photos.

Belleager · 17/08/2021 14:01

The Uk have said they are planning on evacuating women and children so they will make sure its women and children.

The UK can do that if it sticks with its current policy of processing slowly and grudgingly from refugee camps. Whether they'll manage it in Kabul on the ground remains to be seen. They're not exactly covering themselves with glory so far.

The mess they've made - and the US and other countries - affects men too. Rhetoric which only allows women and children to be vulnerable refugees plays well politically and stokes anti-refugee feeling. Men can be vulnerable and betrayed by international forces too (and of course most men, women and children come in family groups)

And I don't remember women's rights being the driver - wasn't it War on Terror and Winning Hearts and Minds to the Western Way?

Normaigai · 17/08/2021 14:01

Also to add, have you seen that airport? The reason that there are so few children there is that it wasn't at all a safe place for a child to be. You'd only take your child if you felt that there was a serious chance you would get on a plane or if you felt your child's life was at risk. You certainly wouldn't be running with w child next to a moving plane trying to push them on.

I'm sure a lot of the men getting evacuated would have loved to have their families with them, but if they're facing being shot at dawn because they were working as an interpreter and so have an argument they can get on a flight, but know that there isn't any realistic hope their children will get the same treatment, I can't criticise any family or individual who made the choice to save who they realistically could. I suspect there will also be several people who refused to leave their families.

Slipperfairy · 17/08/2021 13:58

I guess it's weighing up the risks and self preservation too.
Man stays= no real value to new regime;probably going to be killed.
Woman and girls stay= they have some value- even if abhorrent. Less likely to actually be killed.

Man runs- might actually make it. Easier to find somewhere to stay.
Whole family run- hard to do. Hard to find somewhere to stay. Women and girls still face that of rape etc.

If dh were likely to be killed, then he'd have to go.

FizziWater · 17/08/2021 13:58

@Valorgreen

So they just abandon their wives? Their teenage daughters? Their young children? Hmmm…

I've seen a few posts like this and, honestly, those who make them make my skin crawl.

How fucking dare you judge those who are fleeing for their lives. What gives you that right? If you're so concerned about the fate of women in Afghanistan go and help instead of sitting in your privilege casting judgement on those who had to choose between leaving everything behind or being executed for daring to try and change their country.

Absolutely. There was a young Afghan man on Breakfast TV this morning. He had worked as an interpreter for the army and is one of 1000 now in the UK. There are another 15000 former interpreters still there. The British Government knew this was coming and could have got more out. They will be killed.

You cannot repatriate half population of 38 million, the only way to protect all the women was never to pull out of Afghanistan.

kurtney · 17/08/2021 13:57

Staying with your wife and children because you can't all get out together isn't going to help them. Wouldn't you encourage your dad / brother / son / husband to get the hell out and away from you in this awful situation? For your kids' sake, too?

I absolutely would but there's no way on earth my dad/husband/brother would have left us behind at the mercy of a brutal woman hating regime. The idea that these men have left their female relatives behind and are going to 'send for them later' is laughable and anyone who thinks they are is incredibly naive.

And I don't care how much that 'makes your skin crawl' 🙄

TractorAndHeadphones · 17/08/2021 13:57

@Wheretoeattweenandteen

In this situation I know my much older dB would run first and save himself as would many uncles and cousins. Df wouldn't and to be honest, dh would never leave our girls but he might leave me Blush
It’s not selfish to want to live. And in this situation the men have it ‘marginally’ better. Yes they may not be raped and allowed to go to school but it will be a mainly religious education. And plenty are brutalised and killed. I’m presuming that the push to evacuate women is in their capacity as primary carers of children. But otherwise there’s no reason to pick an adult woman over a man (if gender’s the sole criteria).
LooksGood · 17/08/2021 13:48

They're not helping their families by staying with them if they can't get them out with them. I was reading an article yesterday about an interpreter on the run. He had left his extended families' village because they would all be endangered if he was found there.

Staying with your wife and children because you can't all get out together isn't going to help them. Wouldn't you encourage your dad / brother / son / husband to get the hell out and away from you in this awful situation? For your kids' sake, too?

LooksGood · 17/08/2021 13:43

If they were evacuating women and girls because of the Taliban's attitude to them, that would be 19 million people.

The flights are for people who have worked with the US. Presumably, their dependents too if they are on the spot. Many of these men will already have been in hiding or based away from families for work. They should get out asap. I hope the US and UK and other states involved will do everything they can to get women at risk out too, but that's likely to be from border crossings and perhaps sponsored and negotiated visas. UK has already given up on getting everyone who worked for them out.

Slipperfairy · 17/08/2021 13:42

sheworeyellow ah, dangers of skim reading everything. just found this though: www.newscientist.com/article/dn22119-sinking-the-titanic-women-and-children-first-myth/

Interestingly, the Titanic actually bucked the general trend.

TractorAndHeadphones · 17/08/2021 13:42

[quote Sylvvie]@Aprilinspringtimeshower

And still the troops (Yes, UK as well) were taking under the table payments so the men could rape women and children and also continue to live by their own rules in some areas.

It was never about women and kids and the only reason they are saying it now is to justify the entire shitshow, all 20 years of it. It was about money.[/quote]
Where exactly has then been said? I’ve read several publications and nobody’s pretended that the war was about human rights.

It was to flush out terrorists groups. And the ‘nation-building’ presumably for the same end.

All for naught as the Taliban are well funded, well organised and can afford to sit out for however many decades.

Blossomtoes · 17/08/2021 13:41

@Valorgreen

So they just abandon their wives? Their teenage daughters? Their young children? Hmmm…

I've seen a few posts like this and, honestly, those who make them make my skin crawl.

How fucking dare you judge those who are fleeing for their lives. What gives you that right? If you're so concerned about the fate of women in Afghanistan go and help instead of sitting in your privilege casting judgement on those who had to choose between leaving everything behind or being executed for daring to try and change their country.

👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 Very well said.
Wheretoeattweenandteen · 17/08/2021 13:41

In this situation I know my much older dB would run first and save himself as would many uncles and cousins.
Df wouldn't and to be honest, dh would never leave our girls but he might leave me Blush

Valorgreen · 17/08/2021 13:39

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Steakandcheeseplease · 17/08/2021 13:39

@RoseAndRose

The men will be thise who have worked for the international organisations - the interpreters, drivers etc.

They are more numerous than women employees simply because of the nature of the employment market there and the huge under-representation of women in most roles.

When people say we have a moral duty to rescue those who are at risk of execution because we employed them, this is what it look like.

Those who have been employed by foreigners are the highest risk if left behind. It's not like the risk men v women amongst those who have not worked for foreign organisations.

Remember that plane was well after the civilian side of the airport had closed. It wasn't for thise who just turned up

This with bells on. Four interpreters were murdered out side their homes on Thursday night these wherever brave men who helped the west speak to people they wouldn't normally be able to speak to. These people are in grave danger too. The Uk have said they are planning on evacuating women and children so they will make sure its women and children.
Alonelonelyloner · 17/08/2021 13:39

It was the very first thing I thought of when I saw the footage.

In essence nobody in power - or anyone with any sway actually really gives a fuck about women. Some women do. Some men do, but these aren't the people that truly matter in emergency situations and even husbands and sons are running for the fucking planes rather than help their wives and daughters.
I am beyond disgusted with humanity generally. Seriously.
When I studied exodus from the USSR at the very beginning it was amazing how many women were left to rot basically. It is nothing new.

No brave new world for women. Just the same old shit. Day after Day.

Swipe left for the next trending thread