Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Evacuation form Afghanistan- women?

309 replies

Aprilinspringtimeshower · 17/08/2021 12:41

So saw this article and the accompanying photo www.theguardian.com/world/2021/aug/17/afghanistan-striking-image-appears-to-show-640-people-fleeing-kabul-in-packed-us-military-plane?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other

This is what concerns me- where are the women? The overwhelming majority of people on that plane are men, adult males. There are a few women and some children.
Yet it is the women who are in greatest danger. Young girls, older women. Single women who won’t be able to support themselves once stopped from going outside unaccompanied, professional women who will be banned from working .

Everyone said that the war was about women’s right and way of life. And that what is happening now is a danger to the rights and well-being of women.

Surely it is women who are the ones that need to get out of the country safely and be offered asylum- so where are they? Why wasn’t that plane full of mostly women or even equal amounts of women and the men that accompany them.

I don’t hear the government saying anything to target protection and refuge for women specifically. And to young girls and women who are in real danger

AIBU that it is always the men that get the preference, and that really no one cares enough to actually provide proper protection to the women and girls ..it’s just all sound bites and noble words

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Aprilinspringtimeshower · 20/08/2021 16:38

@2bazookas

Everyone said that the war was about women’s right and way of life

No, they did not . That's not what the war was about so please don't spread fake news. It absolutely beggars belief that America's reason for going to war there 20 years ago has been so swiftly forgotten.

All the wars in Afghanistan have been about territory, politics, power; invaders pursuing revenge, control, territorial and military agendas.

Britain has been to war four times in Afghanistan. Never about women. USSR spent 10 years at war with Afghanistan (1979-89) , not about women , and USA 20 years not about women.

You can easily google Afghanistans bloody history.

Just stepping back into my post here. I did not say this is what the reason was originally. But if you look at the last 5 years or so of US/UK “ occupation” to “keep peace” this is and has been given as a reason over and over. Hence why in last few days UK Gov has had to come out with statements of giving resettlement priority to women and girls. I didn’t actually say I feel it is hypocritical that they now use the “it’s all about female subjugation” argument for remaining in Afghanistan for years then fail to have a plan to ensure women’s freedoms when they withdrew, but it sure felt hypocritical looking at the pictures and hearing stories of high profile women like journalists being left to face the consequences of us/uk sudden withdrawal. It was sort of point of my post. The hypocrisy. Things have moved on a bit in last few days since I posted and I am now hearing more about this conundrum of how to protect the women and girls in the media. However, it is a good discussion thread, and it’s been really interesting to read people’s counter debates and arguments
OP posts:
Normaigai · 18/08/2021 18:58

Agree that it isn't inherently true that women are always last. There are occasions where it works in our favour but they're few and far between. I live in a Muslim country. It is very very common for me to be put to the front of a queue because I'm female. Saved me hours in vaccination queues! There are equally (more) shit things I have to put up with because I'm female, but it's never all 100% bad.

Still when push comes to shove about things that really impact men, in my experience their voices are always the ones heard most clearly.

LevantHera · 18/08/2021 16:35

And the awful videos on various media now of people desperately passing their babies forward to be saved. How absolutely harrowing.

ancientgran · 18/08/2021 16:09

I don't agree that women are always last. I know it was years ago but I had to travel to a middle eastern country. I was a single woman travelling with two young children. Due to diplomatic issues with the UK I couldn't fly direct so had to go to another nearby country, stay over night and get a flight the next day. Unfortunately the country had issues with other countries overnight and lots of flights stopped.

I got to the airport and found a stampede for checkin, not quite like Afghanistan this week but similar on a smaller scale. I was the only woman on the flight, nearly all men from the country I was in or neighbouring countries but a handful of Brits/Americans. However long I was in the queue I was still at the back. A man in uniform, don't know if he was security/police/military, approached me took my bag and whisked me to the front of the queue. I was so grateful.

Unfortunately the British/American men weren't as helpful. They had a whip round, paid a bribe to an official and went straight to the plane. Although they had been talking to me about the situation it didn't seem to worry them to leave a woman and two children in that situation. I bet the official wouldn't have "charged" extra for me, they just didn't care. Thank heavens the middle eastern man in uniform was kinder.

Just remembered when we got on the plane armed men in uniform got on and started detaining some passengers and dragging them off. I then got to the country I was going to and at immigration they insisted I fill out a form in arabic. Again the British/American men seemed to be whisked through, they were ahead of me. Eventually a well dressed man, he sounded French, was dashing past when he stopped and came and asked me what was wrong. I explained and he got into a discussion with the officials who stamped my passport and let me through.

The most interesting/scary journey I have ever done. The people I was visiting arranged for a man to fly back to the intermediary country with me.

So there are some knights in shining armour, well there were 30 years ago.

Susannahmoody · 18/08/2021 15:14

But so many posters on this forum see everything through the prism of girls and women are always the biggest victims. It's almost as if men don't even count.

^

I'll take that liberty. It'd be nice if for just once women counted first.

Susannahmoody · 18/08/2021 15:12

How can this be news to people? How can you find this surprising??

Women are always last.

Slipperfairy · 18/08/2021 15:07

I'm a feminist. I spend a lot of time lurking and occasionally posting on the fwr boards. I still see why, rationally, men have been going first. A lot of the comments I see on sm about how terrible it is that women are being left behind, are coming from people who ordinarily don't really think about women's rights, or think that we're already equal. A lot of it seems, as other pp have suggested, to be thinly disguised xenophobia and othering.

It is possible to feel horror at what could be about to befall so many women, but also understand why this is the way it is.

OhWhyNot · 18/08/2021 14:53

It’s a miserable existence for all apart from those senior members of the Taliban

It’s an existence of fear.

Fearful young men join out of fear they will have to prove themselves. Guns in the hands of young men who are afraid well we know what happens we know from how terrible soldiers from all cultures have acted

Women and girls hide, families know what the future holds for their children

It’s hell for all (but yes less freedoms for women and girls)

There are times when I think our fights just pale into insignificance and these past few days I have felt that. I live with choices that I am always thankful for

Marguerite2000 · 18/08/2021 14:27

@Balonzette

Women are not MORE at risk than men. The risk to women is awful, but tell the men facing brutal execution that they aren't as at risk as their female relatives.
Exactly. People also tend to forget the plight of gay men. They face execution by stoning or being crushed to death. But so many posters on this forum see everything through the prism of girls and women are always the biggest victims. It's almost as if men don't even count.
cnn27 · 18/08/2021 13:02

Those of you criticising the men have no idea of their personal circumstances, the dangers they would have faced if they had stayed and how they came to get a place on that plane. As many people have pointed out, they are likely to be those who were in immediate danger of being executed.

It's such typical western behaviour to make assumptions and judge like this. These people are living through a hell which you will hopefully never come close to experiencing. Maybe instead of sitting around complaining on forums about stuff you don't know about, perhaps you could look into ways of actually helping women and girls in Afghanistan by donating etc.

OhWhyNot · 18/08/2021 12:48

If you have a son and a daughter the son will be beheaded by the Taliban because he has been involved with the government military this is an absolute

Your daughter married off

Who do you choose to leave the country

Plus a deep rotted belief that your son can survive in another country alone but your daughter can’t without her family around her

That is what the choice is for many families it’s about survival not who will have the easier life

We can’t view it from our perspective as it’s not a choice we shall ever have to make

It is a deeply misogynistic society but for families choices are being made about who will survive not who will suffer more

Blossomtoes · 18/08/2021 12:43

This article is 95% conjecture.

It’s not, it’s based on statistical evidence.

Not one actual bloody fact or reporting

See above - it quotes real, evidence based figures and everything.

And written by a man

Must be wrong then. He is a specialist in international refugee law and immigration economics which means there’s a good chance he knows more about the subject than you or me.

Keke94LND · 18/08/2021 12:30

@SchrodingersImmigrant

I don't think anyone here is "men's rights activist". It's not activism to point out that these particular men and many others are in risk of life and that everyone in there is fucked
yeah, I wasn't talking about people on this thread, I was talking generally as a response to OP and what they were saying
FightingtheFoo · 18/08/2021 12:28

[quote DuncinToffee]Article in the Washington Post on this subject

www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/2021/08/17/women-flight-refugees-afghanistan-kabul/[/quote]
This article is 95% conjecture.

Not one actual bloody fact or reporting.

And written by a man.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 18/08/2021 11:54

I don't think anyone here is "men's rights activist".
It's not activism to point out that these particular men and many others are in risk of life and that everyone in there is fucked

Keke94LND · 18/08/2021 10:41

Yep, do you ever notice how men's rights activists always bring up the whole titanic thing and 'women and children first' and how oppressed they are because of this..........

Having said that, everyone in that country deserves to get out, men included

DuncinToffee · 18/08/2021 10:35

I guess I still had my free article then. The article is explaining, as many posters on here have, why there are more men fleeing compared to women.

That it is not true that men are largely simply 'abandoning' women. More likely that they are setting things in motion to try to help women and children reach safety in the future.

That gender inequalities, particularly in Afghanistan, often meant that is younger men who are sent to support the families they had to leave.

Wheretoeattweenandteen · 18/08/2021 09:32

Dincin that article is behind a pay wall.

Very very sad picture of a woman attacked and left on the ground today, surrounded by men and not one helping her, cradling her head Sad

DuncinToffee · 18/08/2021 09:01

Article in the Washington Post on this subject

www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/2021/08/17/women-flight-refugees-afghanistan-kabul/

meditrina · 18/08/2021 08:56

Women as a population might be more at risk, specific people who have performed certain roles will be at most risk

I agree. And when it is us who put those people in those roles, do we abandon them or do all we can for their safety?

Which of course can only mean prioritising them for evacuation

ancientgran · 18/08/2021 08:52

@Balonzette

Women are not MORE at risk than men. The risk to women is awful, but tell the men facing brutal execution that they aren't as at risk as their female relatives.
Women as a population might be more at risk, specific people who have performed certain roles will be at most risk.
ancientgran · 18/08/2021 08:51

@FemmePerdue

And to be clear for those who don't get it: a lot of women will be connected to the westerners in some way for example as maids, cleaners or nannies. You most likely have never heard of how dangerous life is about to become for them. Their roles were most likely not story worthy. A different type of glass ceiling. Their stories are not going to be told by their men - until their men are safe.
So the taliban are looking for revenge. They can go after interpreters who helped the enemy possibly doing things like translating in interrogations of taliban prisoners or they can go after someone who cleaned the toilets in an embassy. I wonder who they would hunt down first?
Balonzette · 18/08/2021 08:50

Women are not MORE at risk than men. The risk to women is awful, but tell the men facing brutal execution that they aren't as at risk as their female relatives.

TractorAndHeadphones · 18/08/2021 08:46

@FemmePerdue

I do not believe anyone here thinks it right that men of any age should be left to die.

The question is why does it not feel as outrageous that the women and children are actually being left behind?
Somehow if we left these men behind it would be an absolute scandal but leaving a majority of women behind can be considered collateral damage. Somehow the women didn't do the right jobs, didn't suffer enough, weren't official enough or have the right connections to be important enough to be rescued or for it to be a scandal that not enough of them would make it out.

And yes I saw that pic. It unfortunately is difficult to weigh that picture against the stream of fleeing men that we've witnessed over the past few days.

And as you say, no one wants to get on a military aircraft and still not be safe. I wish them all safe journeys and good luck in the next part of their lives. It's not going to be easy.

What is the point of outrage when there’s no alternative? From an emotional point of view I think yes - there should be more women. And because of my background I find it appalling that most escapees will at least be our equivalent of middle class. Educated, privileged. If you’re poor you’re fucked just like everywhere else.

However from a practical point of view - what else do you expect them to do? Actively seek out women? Turn away the men who’d worked for them? Create some sort of safe passage (if possible they’d have done that)

I’d much rather be outraged at the governments (including our own) that have caused this. And left people to squabble over scraps.

Wheretoeattweenandteen · 18/08/2021 08:39

" the original unfairness in the system is permeating through the rescue"

Says it all

Great posts Femme Perdue.

Women are controlled by so many layers and in so many ways within the system and within their own family.

One girls story in the financial Times said, the person she and her mum and sisters are dreading knocking on the door now the wedge of American protection has gone is : her uncle.

The uncle who engaged her to her cousin when she was 12.

Swipe left for the next trending thread