Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Being upset and angry because my ex's girlfriend pierced my daughter's ears?

380 replies

thecatmother · 17/08/2021 10:11

Basically, I co parent with my ex and it was his time with DD(9). Him and his GF took her away for a weeks break, all lovely. Yesterday she came home and was hiding her ears behind her hair, and also looking very sheepish. I had her on my lap, giving her a cuddle and realised that her ears got pierced.
I kept my cool and complimented the pretty earrings that she had in, but when I spoke to my ex later, he had no clue and he had to ask his GF. Apparently the GF went to the shops with my DD and thought it was a nice thing for them to do together.
My ex is apologetic, I'm just so upset. On top of that the earrings are just costume jewelry and now I need to take her to the proper place to make sure that the piercing is clean and healing.
We have never even talked about having her ears pierced, I feel that I was blindsided. I would have much preferred them to bond over a shopping or a fun activity, not over my child getting her ears pierced.
In front of DD I'm all positive, as obviously she is excited and feeling all glamorous, but I'm so sad inside.
I know it's only pierced ears, but I did cry last night.

OP posts:
lastcall · 17/08/2021 11:15

the GF was completely out of order and may well have broken the law doing this. I'd point this out calmly.

Get her ears checked and buy her some nice earrings.

check with her school and explain what has happened. A lot of schools don't allow earring to be worn during PE, etc

AlternativePerspective · 17/08/2021 11:13

So your DD likes to wear clip-on earrings and now she has them pierced.

TBH I’m not convinced that she didn’t ask. She’s at an age where a lot of her friends will have had them done.

And suggesting that the DD may have asked for it to be done doesn’t take away from the fact the GF behaved inappropriately, but if she did ask, then she needs to be given a very stern message that asking someone you know will give in because you know your parents won’t is absolutely not on and won’t be tolerated, and I would make her have the earrings taken out and the holes healed.

And then I would deal with the GF separately.

Ducksurprise · 17/08/2021 11:10

@Lanique

Op I'd be furious.

But I also want to say you've handled this beautifully with your dd. She's lucky to have you.

I agree completely, so often on threads like this the child gets forgotten in the fury. Posts such as

I'd also request that the GF apologises to your daughter for putting her in such an uncomfortable position

Fail to see that this puts a child in an equally difficult position.

Abhannmor · 17/08/2021 11:08

His gf has no boundaries then. This is quite a transgression. He needs to mark her card. No tattoos. Etc.

AnonymousCheerleader · 17/08/2021 11:08

I took my niece (13) to get her seconds done. The piercing place insisted on calling her dad as my ID had a different name to my nieces (and I wasn't pretending to be her mum).

The piercing place doesn't seem to have done any checks.

AlternativePerspective · 17/08/2021 11:06

Are you 100% sure your ex didn't know and didn't encourage it? How much time is your DD spending with his new partner alone? Why is he not spending his time with her?

Firstly, men can be particularly in observant, and if the DD has long hair then it wouldn’t be that hard to hide them. After all, OP didn’t realise until the DD was sat on her lap. It wasn’t something she initially noticed either.

WRT why the DD spent time alone with the GF, why not? I’m sure the OP doesn’t spend 24/7 with her DD? This idea that time with the other parent is “contact time” and only he should be spending time with the child is ridiculous. Yes if he’s constantly palming off his DD on to other people then it’s an issue, a shopping trip with a GF who presumably lives there and is part of their lives shouldn’t be perceived as a problem or inappropriate. I’m referring to that in general obviously, without taking the piercing into account.

With regards to the GF having had her ears pierced, I would be fuming, but I would also not dismiss the idea that it was your DD’s wish and that she didn’t ask for it because she knew that you and her dad said no.

Before going in with all guns blazing I would get all the actual facts. I.e. did the girlfriend really suggest it or did she just agree to it? Because while both are inappropriate there is a difference.

Also, did the GF tell the DD to keep it a secret from her parents or did DD decide she could keep it a secret because she knew what her parents’ reaction would be. I personally suspect it was DD who decided to keep it secret because the GF, as a grown woman, would have known that she couldn’t keep it secret for ever, but DD is young enough to not have realised that.

But to suggest that an adult is encouraging a child to keep secrets from her other parent has potentially very sinister connotations, and if it’s not true then it puts a different spin on things.

You need to talk to your DD and be absolutely sure that she didn’t ask and the girlfriend just agreed.

The GF was 100% in the wrong,Even if she did only agree, as were the shop, although I’m not entirely sure how these shops enforce the “only a parent or guardian may sign,” law as it’s impossible to prove that you’re a child’s parent.

But I think you need to be led by what actually happened, rather than by your initial shocked reaction. IYSWIM.

Meeklynamechanged · 17/08/2021 11:06

I can't help but think this was a deliberate attempt to upset you or assert dominance of some kind, unless she is completely dim in which case I wouldn't want DD left in her sole care anyway.

99.9% of adults would know that this isn't acceptable without the expressed permission of parents.

SpaceBethSmith · 17/08/2021 11:03

I second contacting the piercing place, a friend of mine owns a tattoo/piercing studio and requires ID for the parent and the child.

evtheria · 17/08/2021 11:01

PS
I’d try to get in contact with the place it was done at, to let them know they’ve pierced the ears of a child without parental consent. She may have outright lied, or they may have just not even asked, but either way their training should be refreshed.

Lanique · 17/08/2021 11:00

Op I'd be furious.

But I also want to say you've handled this beautifully with your dd. She's lucky to have you.

Forgothowmuchlhatehomeschoolin · 17/08/2021 10:59

Literally 100% of us saying yanbu!
I took dd out to celebrate afterwards as l think this is such a big deal.
My god l am fuming for you OP.

SpaceBethSmith · 17/08/2021 10:58

She needs to get back in her lane.

She didn’t ask yours or your ex’s permission.

She thought it was a nice thing to do.

Did your DD even want them pierced?

PandorasMailbox · 17/08/2021 10:58

It has very little to do with love imo. The GF's playing favourites. Trying to be the cool 'mum'.

Like a PP has said, this could escalate in other things as she gets older. I'd be utterly incensed if someone did this to one of my daughters.

ComeonJulia · 17/08/2021 10:58

This woman has absolutely no right to make any kind of decision in relation to your daughter.
Not even minor things, let alone this!
I would be absolutely livid. She doesn’t get alone time with your daughter anymore as she can’t be trusted.

AlmostSummer21 · 17/08/2021 10:55

@FeatheredHope

I would be raising merry hell with the shop that did it for a start.
Why?

They don't insist on photo ID & birth certificates for proof of parentage. They simply require an adult is present.

urbanbuddha · 17/08/2021 10:54

I would hate the piecing but also be concerned that there's an adult in your daughters life who is encouraging grown up behaviour and secrets from her parents. That's not a good thing at all.

Totally agree.

Visit the shop to find out exactly what happened and whether or not they thought your ex's girlfriend was her mother. There's no age requirement in England and Wales but some places set their own age limit.
Leave your DD with someone else and go visit your ex and his gf.
Ask why there is no aftercare leaflet. Bacterial infections can lead to blood poisoning or toxic shock syndrome in severe cases.
Explain that the school might object for safety reasons.
Tell them that in future you expect to be consulted about anything like this.
Explain slowly and in words of one syllable that the gf has crossed a line and that it won't happen again.
I hope your DD's ears heal properly.

MrsHuntGeneNotJeremyObviously · 17/08/2021 10:54

If she has a history of overstepping,bid be more inclined to send her a really scary solicitors letter outlining potential consequences of her behaviour - a warning shot, if you like.
I too thought this was a new gf who is a bit thick, not someone playing mummy with your child.

Forgothowmuchlhatehomeschoolin · 17/08/2021 10:52

Jesus christ l would do my nut at this.
How on earth did she think that was OK?
My dd had hers done this summer also aged 9 but it was a long time coming - we talked about it for months and dh and l made her earn it as such (keep bedroom tidy, work well at school etc).
Dh joked on holiday he nearly took her into Claire's to get them done when l was in the toilet but even that l would have freaked out about because l wanted someone l knew to do them and had already booked her in.
Honestly this is not OK but not sure what you can do without upsetting your dd.

MrsHuntGeneNotJeremyObviously · 17/08/2021 10:52

When people use the word 'assault' they mean that a child can't really give meaningful consent by themselves. It needs backing up. Which is what the concept of 'Parental Responsibility' is for. Parents are considered to know what their children really want, since they know them best and parents are the ones who are legally deemed able to decide for children. So it's assault in the sense that what gf did doesn't meat those conditions, not that it's the same as hitting someone.

girlmom21 · 17/08/2021 10:51

I'd also request that the GF apologises to your daughter for putting her in such an uncomfortable position

GCrebel · 17/08/2021 10:51

It could be assault. GF doesn’t have parental responsibility so cannot give consent.

evtheria · 17/08/2021 10:50

As a stepparent I am amazed she thought that was okay!

girlmom21 · 17/08/2021 10:50

@thecatmother

To those who are questioning my ex not noticing- I Know!!!! Me too!! The only redemption for him is that DD has always been a fan of stick on earrings and allowed clip ons during the holidays. His GF does like to play mummy and I did have this problem about 2 years ago, when she would totally take over when the DD was with them and my ex had no clue what DD ate or did during their time together. I do appreciate that she means well and that she loves my child, but I need her in her lane, firmly!
Oh wow I assumed this was a new GF to be honest who didn't understand her boundaries - but she's been around for quite a while! Do you have any kind of relationship with her? It might come across more bluntly from you than it would from your ex. I'd have a word directly if you can.
Dozer · 17/08/2021 10:49

WTF!

Would seek face to face meeting with your ex, alone, to discuss what happened, your concerns about his GF’s actions and judgment, and what he plans to do to avoid anything like this happening again.

Also agree with PPs about the need for a conversation - or three - with DD. Important to help her understand parent vs GF roles, consent etc.

Bootskates · 17/08/2021 10:47

I would definitely make sure gf knew not to even think of doing anything like this in future without asking you and DD dad first. So irresponsible.

I knew a girl who's dad's partner did stuff like this, as the girl grew older it graduated to buying cigarettes and alcohol for her and phoning the school pretending to be mum saying the girl was unwell whenever she wanted to bunk off.