Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to break the best mate code ?

118 replies

Butterfingers1977 · 17/08/2021 01:32

I really need some opinions as have had to keep this secret in RL and o think I need perspective -;will try to be brief !
Had a on/off casual relationship from when I was 18 to 26 and we had an unplanned ,but much loved son who is now 18. No hard feelings , good friendship to base smooth co- parenting on , all good. I had a horrid marriage of 13 years in between that I have been out of for over a year. DH dad been very supportive , friendship resumed how it had been and he is a complete rock and someone I consider 100% trustworthy and am very happy and lucky to have in my life.
He has a best friend that he has had for about five years or so , previously I had only briefly met him once. When they were both on a drunken night out. Few months ago , DH 's dad ( I don't really see him as an ex partner tbh) I must have come up in conversation , and he gave his best mate my number and said why don't you take her out ? So he messaged me a few times , we agreed to go out in a date.
Ds dad was not happy when o mentioned it in conversation and was very much that no he would not like that it made him uncomfortable and it was breaking the mates ' code. So i duly cancelled the date , but as I thought about it I felt a bit resentful as I really got on well with this bloke and I thought it might be fun. We sort of tried to stop texting but unsuccessfully. Fast forward four months and we have been chatting and really really want to go out properly and see whee it goes but we both feel more than a bit conficted as DSdad has expressly said it would not be a good idea.
So I suppose my AIBU is , AIBU to still go out with this man even though it feels like we have to do it in secret ? We are both single , consenting adults. Or would it be too much of a risk for an old friendship to take ?

OP posts:
PluggingAway · 17/08/2021 07:02

Just do it.

You were never properly together and even if you were, he isn't allowed to police who you go out with. Also your son is 18. The co-parenting thing is going to require less and less contact between you and his dad from now. Your DS might well move out in the next couple of years and it will matter even less.

Butterfingers1977 · 17/08/2021 07:00

Sorry April - it's DSdad that passed my number to his best mate. The dynamic is between us three xx sorry for confusion x

OP posts:
Aprilx · 17/08/2021 06:59

I still don’t understand. So it was DS’s dad not DH’s dad that passed on your number but also DS’s dad that is angry and does not want you to go out with the person he gave y our number to. Makes no sense. Confused

Butterfingers1977 · 17/08/2021 06:59

And you are right - it would be less complex to get it out now - I think that is what is sitting on my mind. And that is what I posted the thread for as it is obviously NOT sitting right at all x

OP posts:
Butterfingers1977 · 17/08/2021 06:58

Yes that's fair enough I think - But DS is grown adult now so parenting not such an issue . But it is interesting how you said you felt when two friends were together and you invevitably got stuck in the middle . Thank you that's a very valid point of view. Xx

OP posts:
stayathomer · 17/08/2021 06:54

I can totally see why it'd be weird for him, imagine you properly get together and them him and his friend are dealing with parenting side by side. Even before that I once had 2 lots of friends living together so they'd be going places without me etc or if they were fighting I was in the middle (not necessarily put there but inevitably they'd be talking to me about the other etc) but you sound si close so maybe it's just going to be something you both have to battle through. If you are as close to ds' dad I'd say tell him now and argue it out, because it will be 10 times more complicated when it gets more serious

Butterfingers1977 · 17/08/2021 06:53

50Hekatestorch lol fair enough Grin

OP posts:
Butterfingers1977 · 17/08/2021 06:53

06:51Iggly I thought that too ! Hmm but we live in a small town , we always got on , had a laugh and occasionally slept together ; it was the 90s ...we just got caught Grin

OP posts:
Butterfingers1977 · 17/08/2021 06:52

Ok , I think I am going to try and have an adult discussion with DS dad again , and try to understand where he is coming from . But by even opening the discussion again , I risk losing his respect to some degree too. He knows I have been on a few distastrous dates recently, so am pretty sure it's not about holding a candle . He was pretty clear on this , so maybe I will try again to talk to him , or ask his friend to .

OP posts:
Iggly · 17/08/2021 06:51

@unidentifed

You were in a "casual" relationship with the father of your child? YABU for even saying that. Couldn't be bothered to read past that.
How is that helping
Hekatestorch · 17/08/2021 06:50

I suspect because you DP is obviously a keeper

Some days Grin

Butterfingers1977 · 17/08/2021 06:49

40Hekatestorch thank you . Yes I am an adult making decisions you are absolutely right . The dynamic between your best friend and you is very interesting to me and I am glad it all worked out; I suspect because you DP is obviously a keeper ! I dont think this guy is , but he has potential , and I have been on my own for a while now and feel ready to try .but you are right , I have to make that decision knowing that there will likely be consequences.
Billandben444 that is completely it in a nutshell. 100% . Maybe the reasons are immaterial really - I value my friendship above everything else and I don't want to sneak around - I already feel guilty enough Confused

OP posts:
Butterfingers1977 · 17/08/2021 06:42

06:37Whinginadeville- you say that , but I'm my small town there really aren't Grin and I really like this bloke. But you are right , it may be more hassle / disruptive as you say. 06:36UnsuitableHat yes that was my thinking either that , or just go out with him and test the water to see if it's worth all this - I sense it is really good , but who knowsm wish I had a Crystal ball !

OP posts:
Billandben444 · 17/08/2021 06:40

If DS's dad feels strongly that you shouldn't date this bloke (the reasons are immaterial) then you'd need to weigh up whether it's worth losing his respect and friendship over what could be a fling. He's made it quite clear where he stands on this and you have a choice to make but I wouldn't lie about it as you will get found out.

Hekatestorch · 17/08/2021 06:40

It sounds like ds dad, doesn't thi k this would be a great relationship though.

I am in the fence. Because he handed your number over, but I assume he has thought about it later or his friend has made some sort of comment that's made ds dad think twice.

But also, if a friend I had known for years, loved and trusted said this person wasn't great in relationships I would listen. But also if I had such a trusted a friend, I wouldn't do anything to make them uncomfortable.

You are a grown adult and definitely make this decision for yourself. Just make it really thinking about it, the possible fallout from it.

You tall as though you aren't making a choice to text this man not 'We sort of tried to stop texting but unsuccessfully.'

As above you are an adult. You can make these decisions for yourself, including, wether you text him or not. Just be aware it could cause some issues wether it turns our to be a great relationship or not.

I can see both sides. My dp is my best friends brother. She was the first person I spoke to. I can genuinely, say I would have walked away if she wasn't happy. Me and her are close and been there for eachother through devastating events, the best events. If me and dp broke up, she would cut him off before she cut me off.

Butterfingers1977 · 17/08/2021 06:40

Good point thumb witches - I could perhaps see if I can find anything out . I am leaning towards honesty being the best policy though - I think DSdad is not being clear why - perhaps he gave him my number then regretted it ? Perhaps he doesn't want to be disloyal to his friend and is already feeling the conflict of loyalties which would make good sense.
Cabbagesgreen - yes this mysterious 'mate' code . Friend is worried about it and it is making him feel guilty too - another discussion needs to be had and maybe as the big chicken I am , it should come from the friend . Lots to think about !

OP posts:
Whinginadeville · 17/08/2021 06:37

I wouldn't. There's plenty of men out there why risk a great relationship with your sons dad

UnsuitableHat · 17/08/2021 06:36

If you like this guy and he wants to give it a go with you, I’d say go for it. DS dad may just have to get his head round it a bit.

Butterfingers1977 · 17/08/2021 06:35

ThumbWitchesAbroad thank you that's a great balanced reply . Thank youx
Just as an aside ;
(You were in a "casual" relationship with the father of your child? YABU for even saying that. Couldn't be bothered to read past that.)
No idea why that offends you so much !i live in a small town ,where everyone knows everyone , and it was the 90s Grin we just got caught out . It actually in the end was a really good coparenting arrangement because there was no bitter recriminations or divorce to negotiate
parenting through . Much easier and more of a team effort than so far has been with. STBEXH . DS knows we do and have always got on so accepts this as completely normal for him .

OP posts:
CabbagesGreen · 17/08/2021 06:32

Any mate code is for the mate to worry about

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 17/08/2021 06:29

Oops, took me so long to type that, I crossposted with you.

If your DS's dad knows that his mate is a philandering bastard who just uses women, then why the fuck would he give him your phone number in the first place? If he wanted to protect you from him, he should never have done that. But it is possible that he did it in a moment without thinking, and on reflection, realised that this bloke could end up hurting you.

Are there any 3rd friends you could ask about potential bloke? See if he really is a not-ideal partner?

Butterfingers1977 · 17/08/2021 06:28

I understand what is being said - generally the feeling is IANBU but I should attempt to perhaps tell him and not keep it a secret - that is the bit i am struggling with as I am not naturally a deceptive person . I don't want to disrupt their good friendship - bymaking him feel like be the third wheel , or disrupt our friendship because he means a lot to me too. But I do feel he is a little bit judgy , and I have spent a long time being married to a controlling man so I am rather resistant to feeling I am being told what to do. So I am kicking back a bit. The friend is not an abusive arsehole for sure , but maybe I should open the discussion with DSdad again .... Thank you everyone - fantastic advice and thoughts thank you Flowers

OP posts:
ThumbWitchesAbroad · 17/08/2021 06:26

It's not on you, really, is it.

The "mate's code" is between DS's dad and his mate.

If I'm understanding correctly (yes, your use of "DH's dad" did muddy the waters) then DS's dad gave his mate your number and told him to take you out, so why the fuck is he giving you grief about it now? Has he had second thoughts?

I think you really need to have an open and frank conversation with your DS's dad, find out what his objection is and why his feelings have changed now - and let him know that you and the friend would really like to go out. I don't think you should do it in secret at all - I think that's more likely to stir up trouble.
The bloke here should also have a chat with DS's dad for the same reason.

I hope he can be brought to see reason - it's unreasonable of him to keep you from what could be a potentially great relationship for no good reason other than "mate's code".

Butterfingers1977 · 17/08/2021 06:21

Morning all - apologies for the lack of clarity - but thank you so so much for your thoughts. Yes it was a typo - DS dad is the one who gave my number to his best mate .I have a great friendship with him - we did when we were younger , and we have parented a child and we are still good. I don't think he carries a candle for me after all these years , perhaps vague hopes of sex who knows . We are older now , and I love and value him beause he is the father of my son and a fantastic one at that but I do not look at him romantically at all . ( Life would be very straightforward if that was the case !) . I tried to talk to him as to why I could not go out with his friend originally and he said that he knows how the guy feels about women ...whatever that means. I did say that I appreciate that perhaps he didn't think it was a good idea bearing in mind the marriage I have left , but I an a grown woman and would like to judge for myself .
To the people who say that there are plenty of fish in the sea - yes there are of course but this guy really really makes me laugh and there is real chemistry which can be quite rare in my limited experience. Of course he may be saying all the right things etc but I am going in completely eyes wide open , and prepared to risk that .

OP posts:
MyOtherProfile · 17/08/2021 06:11

Sounds like your friend is scared of losing you. Worth checking out it's not because he knows bad stuff about his mate though. Except it would be weird if be did and still gave him your number.