Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to break the best mate code ?

118 replies

Butterfingers1977 · 17/08/2021 01:32

I really need some opinions as have had to keep this secret in RL and o think I need perspective -;will try to be brief !
Had a on/off casual relationship from when I was 18 to 26 and we had an unplanned ,but much loved son who is now 18. No hard feelings , good friendship to base smooth co- parenting on , all good. I had a horrid marriage of 13 years in between that I have been out of for over a year. DH dad been very supportive , friendship resumed how it had been and he is a complete rock and someone I consider 100% trustworthy and am very happy and lucky to have in my life.
He has a best friend that he has had for about five years or so , previously I had only briefly met him once. When they were both on a drunken night out. Few months ago , DH 's dad ( I don't really see him as an ex partner tbh) I must have come up in conversation , and he gave his best mate my number and said why don't you take her out ? So he messaged me a few times , we agreed to go out in a date.
Ds dad was not happy when o mentioned it in conversation and was very much that no he would not like that it made him uncomfortable and it was breaking the mates ' code. So i duly cancelled the date , but as I thought about it I felt a bit resentful as I really got on well with this bloke and I thought it might be fun. We sort of tried to stop texting but unsuccessfully. Fast forward four months and we have been chatting and really really want to go out properly and see whee it goes but we both feel more than a bit conficted as DSdad has expressly said it would not be a good idea.
So I suppose my AIBU is , AIBU to still go out with this man even though it feels like we have to do it in secret ? We are both single , consenting adults. Or would it be too much of a risk for an old friendship to take ?

OP posts:
NewlyGranny · 17/08/2021 08:38

And OP? I wouldn't ask the opinion of someone who drank 11 pints on what colour teatowels to buy, not even when they were stone cold sober.

Butterfingers1977 · 17/08/2021 08:38

Thank you newlygranny x what a great answer thank you x to be clear I have no romantic feelings toward DSdad at all - I love him and value his friendship in my life but irrespective of how he feels or doesn't I do not intend at any point to start up a relationship with him . O instinctively agree with your logic and that is why initially I agreed to stop ( conditioned to do as told ) but then grew a bit resentful .

OP posts:
Butterfingers1977 · 17/08/2021 08:34

See this is what I mean - 2rebecca you are right , and dsdad s opinion matters to me , he finds my terrible(lighthearted ) dating stories entertaining. But I suspect this is too close to home for him for the potential future issues . And overthethamesfromyou is also right - it would change dynamics whether I want it to or not ... And rightly or wrongly , that needs to be considered.

OP posts:
NewlyGranny · 17/08/2021 08:34

YABU to think there is a "code" in this situation. Does your ex believe he's scent-marked you for life or what?!

Unless he can tell you some valid, substantiated reason why you should not date this man - he's a registered sex-offender, paedophile, loan-shark - you should go ahead as openly as you would with any other intriguing man you met who asked you out.

And if this man is any of the things listed above, why is your ex friendly with him?

If he wants to be in a fully committed, permanent relationship with you (not just co-parenting) he could ask you how you felt about that, and accept your answer. If he doesn't, he has nothing to say about who you date or form a relationship with. Single mothers don't have to stay celibate for life, and your "child" is an adult now anyway!

There is no reason for you to hesitate on your ex's behalf; there is no mates' code except in the weird minds of controlling men; there is no reason for secrecy; your ex has no right to interrogate you about any relationship you may form.

overthethamesfromyou · 17/08/2021 08:29

It will completely change the dynamic between you and DS's dad and also between him and his best mate. Someone will lose out in this triangle, if not all of you, so I would leave well alone.

2Rebecca · 17/08/2021 08:22

I find it odd that you seem so dependent on your ex's opinion. Is your close friendship with him and your desire for his approval stopping you moving on? Also so what if your relationship with this bloke doesn't work out. Your relationship with your ex didn't work out and you survived. He sounds quite controlling "take her out" " stop taking her out".
Your son is 18 so won't your ex occupy a smaller place in your life now, especially if you want another relationship. The best mate thing is for the blokes to sort out

Butterfingers1977 · 17/08/2021 08:10

Tillytopper - I swing between this and what Dottydoodah says. I am swingwing wildly front one end to the other and getting no closer to a decision Hmm

OP posts:
Butterfingers1977 · 17/08/2021 08:09

Good points - all of them . I am , of course , free to do what I want, I know that. Part of my marriage legacy is a terribly bad indecisivness , which can be infuriating for those around me. I know in my heart DSdad must have said it for a reason and that is what matters - Eddielzzard that is exactly what needs to happen I think

Desmondo2021- I am hoping that it is as simple as that it just makes him a bit ick and wary if it goes wrong it will make him uncomfortable in the future . I am going to talk to him today I think to stop all this overthinking !

OP posts:
TillyTopper · 17/08/2021 08:06

Personally I wouldn't date him. It probably won't work out (on odds), it seems just some fun for you. You risk losing the good parenting relationship with DS's Dad which would cause far more hassle and the guy is probably not worth it.

Desmondo2021 · 17/08/2021 07:57

Just do what you want to do and what feels right to you? Why on earth would you be considering, as a single woman, dating someone and keeping it a secret because your best friend may not like it. You're massively over thinking it.

You painted friend up to be this excellent reliable character so now's his chance to be that reasonable, supportive person else he isn't really quite how you described!

Eddielzzard · 17/08/2021 07:53

Well a frank and open conversation needs to be had with DS's dad. It's not good enough to give out your number and then have a fit when his friend calls you. He's got to explain a bit better than 'mate's code'.

dottydodah · 17/08/2021 07:53

Well no one can stop you meeting this chap can they? Its not 1900 and Dad isnt happy! Maybe your ex thinks hes a bit of a player ,or is it worse that he has a bad attitude towards women? Either way just go out and see how you get on surely .

robotcollision · 17/08/2021 07:48

I'm confused. You are a single adult, so you can go out with whoever you want. But in your position I might dig a bit deeper and find out what your DS's dad means by his friend's attitude to women.

Butterfingers1977 · 17/08/2021 07:48

I know x me neither . But I am getting very close to giving up on it- it would be disappointing in the short term but I think for the best as it's just not worth the risk Confused

OP posts:
MoiraRose4 · 17/08/2021 07:44

I don’t understand why he gave your number to his friend and suggested he take you out, and then is kicking off about you going out. Makes no sense at all.

Butterfingers1977 · 17/08/2021 07:37

Aaagh am completely torn more now with these extra thoughts I didn't have ! That is why I came on here as I can't really talk to anyone in RL but now I feel very jittery about it all xx thank you for giving me more perspectives / outcomes to think about everyone xxFlowers

OP posts:
Butterfingers1977 · 17/08/2021 07:27

07:04ThinWomansBrain and 06Diverseopinions its a good point - at this stage I can't think of anything That sticks out from memory - he is know as a sort of cheeky charming Chappie but no history of abything bad - but blokes talk different ly when they are with their mates so who knows ?

OP posts:
Butterfingers1977 · 17/08/2021 07:25

He said he was drunk and can't be held accountable for what he did after 11 pints xHmm

OP posts:
Butterfingers1977 · 17/08/2021 07:22

07:14Beefcurtains79 that is also a very good point and spot on accurate. He was there offering support not judgement when I decided to leave - and that is part of the reason his friendship is more important than anything and I don't want him to feel deceived.

OP posts:
YesIReallyDoLikeRootBeer · 17/08/2021 07:21

This makes no sense. Did you ask him WHY he gave your number to his friend so he could ask you out? He gives him the number then gets upset when you guys do what he suggested? Why?

stayathomer · 17/08/2021 07:19

Thank you that's a very valid point of view. Xx

Best of luck with it all opBrewCakeFlowers

Beefcurtains79 · 17/08/2021 07:14

If he had to stand by and watch his son being brought up in a house with you in an abusive relationship, maybe he just really wants you to be careful this time?

ThinWomansBrain · 17/08/2021 07:07

can you do that police "right to ask" thing on new partner to find out if he has been abusive or controlling in the past?

Diverseopinions · 17/08/2021 07:06

You only know DS mate from chatting and joking around. I think you're putting confidence in him being a good person and good for you.

There could well be a reason for your son's dad warning you off. I would have thought friend's name would have come up in conversation between you and dad's dad - over the years - so cast your mind back to what he has said about him in the past. Try to build up a picture of him beyond the banter. Is he a Jack the lad? Does he have his own complex on/off relationships?

Now that your son is an adult, he will be likely to be forming firmer opinions himself; to be more likely to relate to the world of his dad; the adult interactions and goings on in your small town. What he thinks, and whether he takes your dad's view, might also become an issue - making things a bit messy.
If this guy is a womaniser, your friend might be looking out for you. Taking somebody out for a drink and a laugh, if you were feeling down at the time, is different to encouraging them to form a relationship. The friend might have someone else he is interested in, and 'friend code' in terms of loyalty, means ds dad feels he can't come out and say this.

I can imagine ds dad could envisage a time when he and your son, are in the pub, and his friend comes over, and recently , his friend has been involved with you, messed you about, even two-timed you, and it all will be awkward.

Best to heed the warning and avoid and avoid this man. Doing things in secret won't be thought well of - particularly not by your son.

ThinWomansBrain · 17/08/2021 07:04

he knows how the guy feels about women
You need to understand more about that - if your ex is aware the guy has been abusive towards partners in the past - you need to know, and probably avoid. If it's the way guy speaks about women when they're out drinking, or a particular relationship that didn't work out in the past - helpful to know and for you to make your own decisions.
If ex is such a good friend, he should discuss his concerns with you more openly, not just expect you to end (or keep secret) new relationships just because he says so.