Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this may be a good idea? Childbirth related

57 replies

Justanideamaybe · 16/08/2021 23:57

Not a health care professional.
I am a mother who’s had a very near miss with a poorly managed birth , very close thing. My sister has had to deliver in a very dangerous way , my friend has serious injuries from a huge , poorly positioned baby. I’m just thinking , shouldn’t it be procedure to do an ultrasound on arrival at hospital in labour? Would it not be wise to have a quick look at where baby is, the position, the size , the blood flow through the cord? Give the mother a choice? My son was almost born bollocks first , huge, cord around his neck , he would almost certainly have suffered some oxygen deprivation and I some serious damage to get him out quickly. Luckily we were saved by a consultant who responded to the red button and c-sectioned him out within 8 minutes. It was a busy and chaotic night in that hospital and the dr that answered the red button complained that the ultrasound machine was ‘ the wrong type, a gynae machine, set to the wrong settings or something … but within 20 seconds she saw that my son was breech, strangled and fat… no way he was being dragged out by forceps. The right call was made and we all made it . If they’d done that scan on arrival at hospital, he’d never had been in danger in the first place. I’d have been wheeled up to wait for the inevitable section. Some babies are in the wrong position , tangled in cords , too fat and all kinds of problems that can make birth so risky. Why don’t they do a quick scan in labour? Just before birth? It could save so many horrible labours or poorly or dead babies . Why doesn’t it happen?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TonkaTrucker · 18/08/2021 09:35

Medical intervention doesn't always equal 'harm'
Just saying something 'increases chance of intervention' doesn't mean that's intrinsically harmful

Ihaveoflate · 18/08/2021 09:17

A scan before labour would have saved me a very traumatic birth and ongoing complications (prolapses).

My baby was back-to-back but this was not identified before I was induced and forceps were used in the delivery room. The maximum pulls were performed with some force before I was taken to surgery and opened up further. By that time the baby had been dragged half way down the birth canal so it was too late for an EMCS and the consultant had to use Kielland rotational forceps to deliver her.

The result of this was permanent facial scarring and lip palsy to my baby and posterior prolapse for me. It's taken me a very long time and a lot of hard work to be able to walk any sort of distance without discomfort.

I am so very grateful that my baby survived and things could have been so, so much worse. But that is such a low bar as an expectation of birth in a Western country. It all makes me so cross.

Jent13c · 18/08/2021 08:57

I've had one NHS birth and one private birth abroad with scans every week and CTGs from 36 weeks. 2nd baby was born with the cord wrapped around him 8 times...so much so that the experienced obgyn asked the nurse to take a picture of him just out. My routine CTGs were always just not quite right and so I had them every day from 36 weeks along with 3x weekly scans. My obgyn suspected that the cord was wrapped so she sent me for a more detailed us at the main hospital and the doctor there told me that they could not confirm it by us and we would just take it day by day. He is here safely and has no deficits but I had a very difficult birth. No intervention happened apart from a sweep.

I was the most anxious I have ever been while getting all those scans and I did have a fleeting moment where I thought..if this was the NHS I wouldn't even have known and although the outcome was good it would have saved me all that anxiety. I guess I say that as someone who had a good outcome though, perhaps I would feel entirely different if that wasn't the case.

Completely agree with you about women should have the choice. There are a lot of mums who have had great experiences from minimal intervention, midwife supported births and im glad we live in a country where that can happen in a safe environment with quick access to a higher level of care if required. Unlike the experience in US where some mums are choosing to go for freebirths so they can avoid the more medical model of perinatal care which is something that worries me a lot. I just worry if we move towards a more medical based birth (routine scans throughout 3rd trimester/ctgs/scans in labour) some women may feel they have to choose more intervention out of fear when really its not always required in every situation. It would be so interesting to see more evidence on it but in my limited experience (sample size 2 births Grin) more scans and routine tracing and dr led care wasn't a better experience of birth for me.

BeansMeansBeans · 18/08/2021 08:00

How would we make this into a Mumsnet campaign?

Brown76 · 18/08/2021 07:56

I agree, and also the thing about staying at home until you’re late in labour and then setting off for hospital. I think that’s a bit mad. It was the scariest part of my labour as I had to walk out in the street while having contractions every 2-3 minutes and nearly delivered in the car park. There should be a early labour area where you can go when you’re 40 weeks plus and having contractions. Post natal care should also be home visits daily for 10 days, I’m sure many cases of tongue tie, PND and post birth complications would be picked up earlier. My mid wife told me that the total post natal care budget is about £200 for both mother and baby for all the post natal checks.

welshladywhois40 · 18/08/2021 07:22

Agree. I was induced in jan at a UK hospital and was scanned first to check babies position before they started. Not sure if this is standard

VioletSand · 18/08/2021 02:08

And yes, yes, yes to the private scan before due date. I don't mean to scare you - she will probably be fine - but to reduce the risks, it's a total no-brainer so if you can possibly afford it then do it. Wishing you all the best for the new baby in your family! Thanks

VioletSand · 18/08/2021 02:06

Also post-natal care is even worse so get her home asap. After sections I walked out both times after about 18 hours. It was soooo painful getting to the car but the best option by far.

VioletSand · 18/08/2021 02:04

@Speakuptomakeyourselfheard

Reading all this has absolutely terrified me, as my granddaughter is due to have her first baby soon. I was under the impression that giving birth with the NHS had improved since I had my own child under terrible circumstances, 40 odd years ago, but this year, I have heard so many horror stories, and all topped off by the death of a young friend during childbirth earlier this year. Are things really this bad for so many young mums these days? Should I recommend that my granddaughter has a private scan just before her due date? Is there any advice I can pass on to her to try and keep her and her baby safe?
Yes, to be honest, it is horrendous. Does she have a strong birth partner with her who will advocate for her? So if she asks for painkillers/ an epidural/ C-section they will make sire the medical staff will listen to her and respect her right to choose this? That will make it far less risky, because a large proportion of these tragedies happen because medical staff do not listen to the mother.
Speakuptomakeyourselfheard · 17/08/2021 22:00

Reading all this has absolutely terrified me, as my granddaughter is due to have her first baby soon. I was under the impression that giving birth with the NHS had improved since I had my own child under terrible circumstances, 40 odd years ago, but this year, I have heard so many horror stories, and all topped off by the death of a young friend during childbirth earlier this year. Are things really this bad for so many young mums these days? Should I recommend that my granddaughter has a private scan just before her due date? Is there any advice I can pass on to her to try and keep her and her baby safe?

Fernando072020 · 17/08/2021 21:42

rate*

Fernando072020 · 17/08/2021 21:41

@teezletangler

It's a routine part of care in the rest of Europe and the absence of it in the UK has been frequently highlighted by European experts as one of the leading causes of porer obstetric outcomes in the UK.

Really? I'd like to see the source for this. I work as a midwife in Canada (granted not Europe but another western country) and it certainly isn't a part of routine labour care here. We occasionally do scans in labour to assess position. I have never heard of this being routine in the US either.

I'm from the UK but live in Europe. I can only speak of my personal situation and those of my friends here who have given birth here but you have check-ups every 4 weeks, 2 if you're high risk. Three ultrasounds are covered by your health insurance, the rest of the time it's ctg check, and a checkup for mum. You have the option to pay out of pocket for three more scans, it was only 60 euros so we went for it (peace of mind after a MMC). So I was scanned nearly every appt. I had high blood pressure and I was scanned every time I went to the hospital for checks in the last 6-8 weeks. I was induced early due to high blood pressure in the end. Before they induced me, again I was scanned to check baby was in the right position and size/weight estimates were looking good. Previously, I had been told that if I were to reach my due date, there would have been check-ups every 3 days at the hospital until labour started, including scans.

The stillbirth late is one of the lowest in this country and I'm guessing the pre-natal care is the reason why

VioletSunlight · 17/08/2021 21:39

@teezletangler

It's a routine part of care in the rest of Europe and the absence of it in the UK has been frequently highlighted by European experts as one of the leading causes of porer obstetric outcomes in the UK.

Really? I'd like to see the source for this. I work as a midwife in Canada (granted not Europe but another western country) and it certainly isn't a part of routine labour care here. We occasionally do scans in labour to assess position. I have never heard of this being routine in the US either.

Do you think other countries are investing in scans in late pregnancy/ labour just for fun, with no evidence that it improves outcomes? Doesn't seem very likely. I have family living in 9 other countries and all were shocked by how few scans the NHS provides, and especially zero routine scans after 20 weeks!

If you look at international stats it's pretty clear that NHS maternity care is not designed to optimise medical outcomes, it's designed to be as cheap as possible.

Recessed · 17/08/2021 21:27

I always wondered this too. I'm in Ireland and it's the same here. It could have most likely prevented the trauma that was DD1's birth. Maternity care is abysmal here too unfortunately. Far too many horror stories.

GoWalkabout · 17/08/2021 21:21

Could this be a Mumsnet campaign? My friend lost her baby boy because he was an undiagnosed breech and the cord got wrapped around him when she delivered.

CustardGoodJamGoodMeatGood · 17/08/2021 21:07

I had a scan during labour, they couldn't feel DD's head and thought her bum was her head and she was breech. A scan showed her head was actually so far down, they just weren't able to feel it. I agree that it should be routine

couchparsnip · 17/08/2021 21:03

This would have saved me hours of unproductive labour. Baby was too big and not coming out that way. It took 27 hours of labour to find that out though.

Fernando072020 · 17/08/2021 20:57

Yanbu
I live in a European country. And it's standard practice here to have a scan when you're in hospital.
I went up with high blood pressure and before inducing me, they scanned me to make sure baby was in the right place, weighed enough and looked fine. It was all very calm and reassuring

endofthelinefinally · 17/08/2021 20:53

@OatyLatte

My mum was a midwife (long time ago) and I'm sure she said something about how they used to do an ultrasound scan later in pregnancy back in the day, for this exact reason. She was baffled by how poorly managed my care was when DC didn't engage at all and there was risk of cord prolapse etc.

I absolutely agree they should do this though, it would potentially save a lot of trauma.

I agree with your mum. She is probably my generation.
OatyLatte · 17/08/2021 08:50

My mum was a midwife (long time ago) and I'm sure she said something about how they used to do an ultrasound scan later in pregnancy back in the day, for this exact reason. She was baffled by how poorly managed my care was when DC didn't engage at all and there was risk of cord prolapse etc.

I absolutely agree they should do this though, it would potentially save a lot of trauma.

Lagomtransplant · 17/08/2021 08:40

@Dddccc

Maybe the funding could come from all the savings that would be achieved through preventing a good slice of bad outcomes for both mothers and babies. Last time I checked, an ultrasound machine was way cheaper than lifelong compensation for a child severely disabled by birth injuries and there was far less time involved in doing a couple of extra scans every day than repairing a 4th grade tear in a single woman, especially if you consider her subsequent quality of life.

OwlinaTree · 17/08/2021 08:29

mostlylurking I think that's the issue with cords, lots of babies are tangled or have them around the neck during the birth but they are fine.

As Birththoughts said, it would need proper assessing, as it could increase the number of babies born by section unnecessarily, or women feeling pressured to have sections I suppose. I had 2 planned sections post loss and they both went really well, but there is a risk. I would argue a planned sections is much less risky than an emergency one though.

However, a routine scan would be useful for identifying babies who have not turned head down, and to look at the condition of the placenta and cord. I had extra scans of the cord and blood flow from placenta during my next pregnancies, so it is possible to do these things.

Lemonsandlemonade · 17/08/2021 04:39

I agree re scan I was lucky my baby was transverse. On my 40 weeks examination the midwife thought maybe baby was in wrong position and sent me to the general hospital for a quick scan on labour ward.

One of the doctors scanned me and quickly showed he was transverse.

Two days later I had c section.

Mostlylurkingiam · 17/08/2021 04:34

A scan won't tell you all the things you want to know - estimating size by scan at term is really inaccurate. Cords are the way they are so they can be squeezed in labour, a lot of babies have them around neck/body and are fine, there are better ways to check if they are an issue - that is why baby's heart rate is checked often. Often people will use portable scans to check if baby head down if there is any doubt, but this can also be felt on palpation or vaginal exam and then just confirmed on scan.
I'm not saying births couldn't be better managed in a lot of cases but routine scans are probably not the way to do it - they give only a snapshot not an overall picture.

Nat6999 · 17/08/2021 04:26

The biggest problem is there aren't many private hospitals to give birth in, except London, otherwise it is take what you are given & if you don't like it tough luck. Maternity care in this country is at best average & in the main poor. This isn't knocking the NHS, just the government's who refuse to fund it properly.

Swipe left for the next trending thread