Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the person inviting you out for a meal to celebrate friend/family special bday, should pay for the meal?

165 replies

TableFlowerss · 16/08/2021 20:43

Birthday meal organised by partner of birthday person. A big birthday. Asked to go for meal to celebrate, 7 people all together.

Looking at about £30/35 per head for starter, main, desert.

Should the ‘host’ offer to pay for everyone’s meal?

OP posts:
LimeRedBanana · 17/08/2021 20:27

After that it’s an open bar.

Pay bar, I’m guessing. Grin

No surprises no-one turned up!

catconvention · 17/08/2021 20:27

Sorry, not open bar - I meant a normal bar - ie a pub where you get your own. This was his 40th in Reading.

catconvention · 17/08/2021 20:23

This reminds me of a man who invited a load of people to his 40th in Reading. Nobody lived remotely near Reading. Most were in London or further afield. Most were also at the stage of young kids / babies - so attending would mean a babysitter; on top of the cost of a hotel, travel and a gift.

The couple magnanimously invited everyone to be there for 8pm in time for their FREE glass of white wine. Woohoo! Yes, we’ll all be rushing to Reading for a free glass of Chardonnay. After that it’s an open bar. But never mind that.

The couple were mystified and quite put out that NOT ONE PERSON was available on that date.

LimeRedBanana · 17/08/2021 20:20

Who’s saying that?

Some people will pay for everyone, if, for example, it’s a special/big birthday. That’s OK.

Other times, everyone will pay for themselves.

Insisting on doing something that wasn’t the host’s intention, is rude.

AveryGoodlay · 17/08/2021 20:16

You're quite right. Us poor or average people shouldn't be able to celebrate. It could ruin the atmosphere for your rich lot if the riff raffs allowed out!

LimeRedBanana · 17/08/2021 20:15

@Mumontour85

Is this your first time as a guest at this kind of thing?! Not only would I expect to pay for my own meal, I would expect, nay - INSIST - that the cost of the bday person to be split between the guests too.
The OP is the host. That’s why she’s asking.

Besides, you’d be monumentally rude to do that, if the host’s intention was to pay.

Which is why many would simply slip away torwards the end of the meal and pay the bill unseen.

3scape · 17/08/2021 20:11

If you invite you pay.

tortoiselover100 · 17/08/2021 20:08

No, don't be ridiculous, the inviter shouldn't pay!

LadyMacbethWasMisunderstood · 17/08/2021 19:58

In my extended family we have had lots of meals out for birthdays. The organiser (child or spouse of the birthday celebrant) always pays. We aren’t rich.

catconvention · 17/08/2021 19:55

Of course if tog invite people out to dinner at a venue / time of YOUR choice to celebrate YOUR occasion, you pay. Confused Is this even a question?

If you invited them to your house for dinner, would you expect them to bring the food? No you would not.

Just imagine - “Hello all you lucky best friends. I’m turning 40 next month. As such , you are invited to MY favourite restaurant at this time. Who knows what it will cost you, on top of travel, a gift and a babysitter. Never mind though, I know you’re all delighted to be there because I’m so wonderful. Thanks!”

Hesma · 17/08/2021 19:38

For my 40th I went out for a meal with friends and they paid for their meals but I got wine for the tables. I was on maternity leave at the time so couldn’t afford to pay for all. If it’s an issue for you then just don’t go 🤷‍♀️

Vates · 17/08/2021 19:04

Absolutely not, lol. YABU.

MauveMagnolia · 17/08/2021 19:03

Depends on your social circle, here if you invite then you pay

DoubleTweenQueen · 17/08/2021 18:49

If I was organising/coordinating a group meal out then a venue would be mutually agreed & each person would be paying - likely all pay for birthday person.

If I was organising a special meal out, at a restaurant of my choice as a really special occasion, I would invite key guests and expect to cover the bill.

Skybluepinkgiraffe · 17/08/2021 18:43

When we were broke young parents, if my parents invited us out they would pay.
We tend to do similar if we arrange a family get together now.
But otherwise, no, if I'm invited to a friend's birthday dinner I expect to split the bill, and chip in to pay the birthday persons share.

Blossomtoes · 17/08/2021 18:40

@Mumontour85

Is this your first time as a guest at this kind of thing?! Not only would I expect to pay for my own meal, I would expect, nay - INSIST - that the cost of the bday person to be split between the guests too.
Why? If the host intended to pay, that would be incredibly rude.
Mumontour85 · 17/08/2021 18:15

Is this your first time as a guest at this kind of thing?!
Not only would I expect to pay for my own meal, I would expect, nay - INSIST - that the cost of the bday person to be split between the guests too.

abstractprojection · 17/08/2021 17:41

I would never expect to not to pay and would chip in for the birthday persons meal too

I do often pay for small group meals if I’m inviting older family or family friends who I know have low incomes

coodawoodashooda · 17/08/2021 17:38

[quote AngryWhompingWillow]@TableFlowerss

I have done this before. Never again. Several times it was a celebration for me, (or DH,) and we offered to pay, (there were 8 other people.) The last time AND the 2 times before, the other people went batshit; ordering the most expensive meals, and starters and desserts etc.

The last time (for 10 people, me and DH and the other 8,) it cost us £325.00. Mine and DH's was only £33 between us. So the other 8 cost nearly £300 between them - so roughly £37-40 each. It wasn't anywhere fancy either, just a Novellos/Nandos type joint ...

The first time it was a bit pricey, but manageable, then the second time (a year later,) it was more, and we were a bit Hmm But the third (and last) time, which was 9 months after the second time, was the killer - a £325 bill. Shock

So we said we'd never do it again. These people never ever EVER order as much when they're paying for their own, and when I went out with the same 8 people and we all paid for our own, (a year ago,) it came to £190 for all 10 people!

Funny how people go crazy and order loads of (expensive) stuff when they're not paying. Hmm But are MUCH more careful and frugal when they're paying for themselves.

It's like our kids, when they wanted stuff as children/teens, they always wanted the most expensive stuff, and chucked all sorts of name-brand stuff in the trolley, and circled all the most expensive stuff in the Argos catalogue when they were choosing Christmas presents. Now they're grown, and having to pay for it all themselves, they buy all budget stuff, and/or buy stuff in sales. Hmm[/quote]
If someone does this to me i just cant be their friend anymore. It is so disrespectful.

AngryWhompingWillow · 17/08/2021 17:01

@TableFlowerss

I have done this before. Never again. Several times it was a celebration for me, (or DH,) and we offered to pay, (there were 8 other people.) The last time AND the 2 times before, the other people went batshit; ordering the most expensive meals, and starters and desserts etc.

The last time (for 10 people, me and DH and the other 8,) it cost us £325.00. Mine and DH's was only £33 between us. So the other 8 cost nearly £300 between them - so roughly £37-40 each. It wasn't anywhere fancy either, just a Novellos/Nandos type joint ...

The first time it was a bit pricey, but manageable, then the second time (a year later,) it was more, and we were a bit Hmm But the third (and last) time, which was 9 months after the second time, was the killer - a £325 bill. Shock

So we said we'd never do it again. These people never ever EVER order as much when they're paying for their own, and when I went out with the same 8 people and we all paid for our own, (a year ago,) it came to £190 for all 10 people!

Funny how people go crazy and order loads of (expensive) stuff when they're not paying. Hmm But are MUCH more careful and frugal when they're paying for themselves.

It's like our kids, when they wanted stuff as children/teens, they always wanted the most expensive stuff, and chucked all sorts of name-brand stuff in the trolley, and circled all the most expensive stuff in the Argos catalogue when they were choosing Christmas presents. Now they're grown, and having to pay for it all themselves, they buy all budget stuff, and/or buy stuff in sales. Hmm

Balonzette · 17/08/2021 11:30

In some cultures the host would pay, but in my experience this is very much not the done thing in British culture, especially among the younger generations. I've been to many, many celebration events and never has the host paid, no has it crossed my mind that they should.

Killahangilion · 17/08/2021 11:17

Make sure you word the invitation correctly and say something like, ‘there’s plenty of choice to suit every budget’ and include a copy of the menu.

Maybe offer to put a couple of bottles on the table or ‘your first drink is on me to toast the birthday boy’ and then it’s clear that after that, they pay for themselves.

thebeatingofthedrums · 17/08/2021 09:31

@transformandriseup

I assumed the OP meant a causal birthday meal rather than a formal party with invitations. That I would expect the host to be paying for but would always budget to pay just in case.
Oh, yes, formal invitations (WhatsApp does not have the same effect!) are another sign that the event is being hosted (so the host pays) as opposed to a meal you are attending (where you pay).
KeyWorker · 17/08/2021 07:49

If it was an invitation to a function room type set up with a buffet I’d only expect to pay for my drinks. If it was a case of booking a table at a restaurant or pub and everyone was ordering of the main menu then I’d expect to pay for myself.

Confusedandshaken · 16/08/2021 23:24

I would always pick up the bill if I'd organised a special meal out and invited everyone. Same as if I'd invited people over for dinner I would pay for the food I'd cooked and not give people a bill.

If a third party had arranged it, eg someone organised for a group of us to surprise a friend or relative in a local restaurant, I would expect all of us to chip in for our own meal and for the meal of the guest of honour.