Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Autistic brother makes it impossible for me

363 replies

IAmHereButNotHere · 16/08/2021 12:58

As title says really.

He’s in a routine and will not break his routine, ever. So he lives with my mum, visits my dad Tuesdays, Thursday and Saturday.

He cannot cope with me being there too, I get in the way, not deliberately but I just talk when he wants quiet so we can’t be there at the same time. And he cannot cope at all with my 7 year old, who I’m a single parent to – just her being there upsets him. He says he likes her but can’t cope with being around her.

He can’t cope if mum goes out outside of his routine, so if she goes out at 10am instead of noon he can’t cope so I can’t go on daytrips with my mum as she also has to be back at a certain time. If she;s not there when he gets back from dads, he gets upset. If she’s there when she’s not supposed to it upsets her.

Mum got a new car the other day and he couldn’t cope with that either, keeps saying it’s not mums car.

I try to understand but it affects my life too. I can’t see my parents when I want to, I can’t ask them to care for my DD unexpectedly, I can’t just pop in when I’m walking passed, my mum can’t just get my DD from school or holiday club as a one off, everything to do with my parents and brother has to be organised down to a tee – my brother cannot cope with my DD being even in his house touching anything so any childcare is at my house and I can’t be a minute late because it upsets my brother.

Because of covid I haven’t seen my dad for over a year. Brother used to only go twice a week but he’s increased it to 3 times. I get weekends off but my dad has a hobby on Sundays with some friends of his who still work so I can’t see him then, I also get Tuesday off but can’t go then due to my brother. If I suggest he doesn’t go one week so I can I get told by my brother that upsetting his routine will upset his rhythm and he may never be the same again, my parents suggest it and get told that they need to consider him over me because of his autism – I sort of agree with that tbh he lives with my mum so should come before me and his AN mean he needs my dad more than me.

I am just moaning here. My whole life revolves around my brother. I love him but I am sick of having to consider him when I want to see either of my parents. I can’t go on holiday with either parent as it upsets my brother so much.

I am lucky I have supportive friends and good childcare options nearby, but I am mourning the relationship I thought I’d have with my parents. My DD barely recognises them.

I know I am VUR and prepared to be told so. Sorry for the rant and sorry if any of my wording is wrong or offensive, I don't mean to be.

OP posts:
welcome2021 · 16/08/2021 17:59

@SionnachRua this was a lesson I only learnt in the last year or so. I've spent 30 years having it drummed into me that I was expected to take over as mother of my brother when my mum dies. No matter how much I explained that I have my own life and family it was ignored and I was told I'd be expected to look after him when she dies.

OP. The issue here is with your parents.

SionnachRua · 16/08/2021 17:52

I don't mind helping a bit, but i might have my own young children or even grandchildren and I absolutely want to be a part of my DDs life as well, I'm happy to do bits of shopping and I will help him get set up, and I'm always at the end of the phone for him, but I don't want to do what my mum does now.

Which is totally fair! You're not the parent, and this was one of the hardest things for me to 'unlearn' in therapy - being expected to step into a parenting role and take on things that weren't mine to deal with. It might just be something to tease out with your mum in future.

IAmHereButNotHere · 16/08/2021 17:49

@SionnachRua

He can't cope with her in the house at all, if she touches something or even speaks even if he's in his room he literally melts down. I'm not going to force my DD on him as he clearly can't cope but I do need to do something.

For me, this is the area to be dealing with asap as this must be horrendous for your dd to deal with, not to mention what it could be teaching her about family relationships. I know I internalized all kinds of shit from dealing with my psycho of a sibling (not that I'm calling yours or others that btw, that's just my experience) and I wouldn't let him anywhere near my kids now. I don't want that trauma for them.

I think my mum in particular thinks it'll all be alright without really thinking of the future. Her own parents are still alive and in their 90s so I think she thinks she'll still be around but I can't imagine my grandparents coping with a man in his 50s in the same way my mum does now. That's not to say I don't sympathise, it must be so hard, and in a way I'm an outsider as I no longer live with either of my parents.

With my mum, there was always an expectation that I'd 'step up' and get involved when she died. Therapy helped me make clear that there's not a hope in hell I'll do anything of the sort, which caused her a lot of distress. I wonder if your mum may be feeling that you'll step in and help him manage when she's gone? You might be happy to, I don't know...but I know for mine, thinking that helped her keep her head buried in the sand as to how bad everything was.

I don't mind helping a bit, but i might have my own young children or even grandchildren and I absolutely want to be a part of my DDs life as well, I'm happy to do bits of shopping and I will help him get set up, and I'm always at the end of the phone for him, but I don't want to do what my mum does now.
OP posts:
SionnachRua · 16/08/2021 17:46

He can't cope with her in the house at all, if she touches something or even speaks even if he's in his room he literally melts down. I'm not going to force my DD on him as he clearly can't cope but I do need to do something.

For me, this is the area to be dealing with asap as this must be horrendous for your dd to deal with, not to mention what it could be teaching her about family relationships. I know I internalized all kinds of shit from dealing with my psycho of a sibling (not that I'm calling yours or others that btw, that's just my experience) and I wouldn't let him anywhere near my kids now. I don't want that trauma for them.

I think my mum in particular thinks it'll all be alright without really thinking of the future. Her own parents are still alive and in their 90s so I think she thinks she'll still be around but I can't imagine my grandparents coping with a man in his 50s in the same way my mum does now. That's not to say I don't sympathise, it must be so hard, and in a way I'm an outsider as I no longer live with either of my parents.

With my mum, there was always an expectation that I'd 'step up' and get involved when she died. Therapy helped me make clear that there's not a hope in hell I'll do anything of the sort, which caused her a lot of distress. I wonder if your mum may be feeling that you'll step in and help him manage when she's gone? You might be happy to, I don't know...but I know for mine, thinking that helped her keep her head buried in the sand as to how bad everything was.

intothewoodss · 16/08/2021 17:45

@IAmHereButNotHere

I absolutely do not begrudge my dad his hobby, he's worked hard all his life and it's 1 day out of 7, he should see friends and enjoy something other than his DC and DGC. It's not golf as suggested here but another similar hobby that requires commitment, he could in theory drop down to once a month or once a fortnight but why should he?

My DDs after school activity is a hobby and I make sure she goes unless ill, to me it's the same thing, it's something away from "life" to kick back relax and have something else to enjoy.

I think approaching him in the spirit of giving your mum a break would be a good tactic here. You can definitely make things a bit easier, if you all commit to putting the ground work in, and having the patience to take it slow.
IAmHereButNotHere · 16/08/2021 17:43

I absolutely do not begrudge my dad his hobby, he's worked hard all his life and it's 1 day out of 7, he should see friends and enjoy something other than his DC and DGC. It's not golf as suggested here but another similar hobby that requires commitment, he could in theory drop down to once a month or once a fortnight but why should he?

My DDs after school activity is a hobby and I make sure she goes unless ill, to me it's the same thing, it's something away from "life" to kick back relax and have something else to enjoy.

OP posts:
Gwenhwyfar · 16/08/2021 17:40

@Eggfriedpower

I wonder if people talking about people with physical disabilities in this way would be allowed? Calling a relative fucking annoying because they can't walk?
But this isn't about what the disabled relative can't do, it's about what he prevents the OP from doing ie seeing her parents when she wants to and her daughter having a relationship with her grandparents.
Boredmotherofone · 16/08/2021 17:39

@welcome2021 You need to get your Mum out of there 😳 Adult social services, police, women's aid - whatever it takes. This is serious

FatCatThinCat · 16/08/2021 17:38

@Boredmotherofone

My child has mild autism (although you're apparently not supposed to call it that anymore.... Though she's very, very different to those with severe autism like your Dbro) and it's really difficult to know where to draw the line and say "Look you're being a bit silly now" especially as there are some deluded people out there who believe that a person having autism means they can get whatever they want, whenever they want it, always get their own way etc - coz Autism. Well, call me mean but I wholeheartedly disagree! I'll preface this by saying that whilst it may not sound like it, I am extremely lenient with my DD and have moulded my entire life around her and making her happy & comfortable - as I should, as her (only) parent! However some of her demands are entirely unrealistic and often simply impossible to achieve! I have to say no multiple times per day, like any other parent and whilst I'm sympathetic as to why she wants something a certain way and always try to find a workable solution, I HAVE to tell her to find a way to deal some things sometimes.

Do you parents never try to explain to him that these demands are simply not workable sometimes? If yes, how does he react?

I agree. I'm autistic myself and have 2 autistic children, one now an adult. You have to find a balance doing what you can to support and make their lives easier and not allowing their autism to control everyone's lives. We have to find ways to cope with life and that won't happen if we never have to step outside of our comfort zones.
IAmHereButNotHere · 16/08/2021 17:36

@kidsatuniemptynester

Your brother can manage change; he changed from 2 days to 3 days at your Father's house. I know it is easy for me to say, but there is more than one person in the family, and your brother needs to learn that he cannot, always, have everything exactly as he wants it. Tip toeing around him, pandering to what he thinks he needs has made life very difficult, and will make the necessary changes to his future life even more difficult. There will come a time, in 20 or so years, when your parents will not be able to cope with him, so you all need to start, as a family, to ease the parental burden and at the same time, allow you and your DD to have a bit of time with your parents too. If he can;t bear to have your DD in the house, tell him to go to his room. Being autistic does not give him carte blanche for full on selfish and entitled behaviour, he is part of family.
He can't cope with her in the house at all, if she touches something or even speaks even if he's in his room he literally melts down. I'm not going to force my DD on him as he clearly can't cope but I do need to do something.

Thank you everyone else for the suggestions, you're right that he can cope with change with enough warning, he decided himself and told everyone during lockdown 3 he was going from 2 days to 3 with dad, so I might suggest doing the same in reverse to him.

I think my mum in particular thinks it'll all be alright without really thinking of the future. Her own parents are still alive and in their 90s so I think she thinks she'll still be around but I can't imagine my grandparents coping with a man in his 50s in the same way my mum does now. That's not to say I don't sympathise, it must be so hard, and in a way I'm an outsider as I no longer live with either of my parents.

I think I will approach my dad first, if I can calve out time with him things may feel easier and I can tackle the other issues with my mum. I think it is going to have to be a slow change.

OP posts:
itsgettingwierd · 16/08/2021 17:34

Thing people are missing is that he can change his routine.

When he decided he wanted to go to dads 3 times instead of 2 he changed everyone's routine including his quite happily.

So he can develop new routines. What he needs to work on is understanding it cannot be at the detriment to what everyone else needs or wants.

Gwenhwyfar · 16/08/2021 17:33

@Butchyrestingface

I get weekends off but my dad has a hobby on Sundays with some friends of his who still work so I can’t see him then

Can't your father occasionally prioritise his own daughter over his golfing buddies?

Do you know any golfers? (if it is indeed golf) And everyone should be entitled to some time for doing their hobby and seeing friends too.
Diverseopinions · 16/08/2021 17:30

I think promoting independent living is going to come when families join together to have strength in numbers. Taking part in National Autistic Society campaigns is the answer.

I feel that it seems like more emphasis was placed on promoting independent living a decade ago. I suspect that funding cuts have meant that the emphasis has come off this aspiration, as far as various authorities are concerned. This is wrong.

intothewoodss · 16/08/2021 17:29

You've got this so wrong.

Try imagining it this way... the wheelchair user DOESN'T KNOW that using the wheelchair will help them. They can't see how it would help them because they have been managing fine without it. They are terrified of using the wheelchair. Every time the wheelchair is mentioned or brought out they become so stressed and upset that they have physical reactions to it.

Or maybe just don't even try to analogise and make up bullshit comparisons between one type of disability and another.

intothewoodss · 16/08/2021 17:24

Don't get me started on the wheelchair analogy I've just read. It shows that the world has a very very long way to come with understanding autism, which just depresses me immensely.

Eggfriedpower · 16/08/2021 17:22

@Triffid1

I don't think the wheelchair analogy works as a standalone. A sibling in a wheelchair who requires care is not the same as this situation. A more accurate example would be a sibling who requires a wheelchair to move around but refuses to use one, insisting on staying in bed, with parents bringing chamber pots, doing all cleaning, cooking and personal care.

A sibling in a wheelchair who needs normal accommodations - eg in living arrangements, in planning activities, in support re work, in transport is very different to a sibling who needs a wheelchair but refuses to learn how to use one.

OP's brother clearly has a significant disability, but nothing I've ever read or seen regarding autism suggests that the person can only function if every single one of their needs is met 100% to their preferred level. In fact, I have always understood that conditions such as autism, and the support provided for autistic children, is about helping them to function as much as possible within the framework of the world they're in. DD has two autistic children in her class and she does come home talking about how one or the other had a meltdown because of x or y, but I know a key part of the work the school and their parents are doing is helping them to manage that.

Well if your daughter knows two autistic people, you must be an expert.

If he can't cope, I don't see how that's the same as refusing to use a wheelchair.

welcome2021 · 16/08/2021 17:21

I think the best thing parents can do for their disabled children is to investigate and promote independent living. My mother putting her head firmly in the sand and giving into my brother's every demand has done nobody any favours in this family. My brother has had an isolated and miserable life where his only daily activity has been controlling my mother and the house. My sister moved away and never visits because my brother doesn't like his routine disturbed. I've spent 30 years worrying about the situation, keeping my children safe from him and being sad and annoyed at the same time.

intothewoodss · 16/08/2021 17:20

@SionnachRua

I'm not denying it's the truth. I'm saying that living with that truth is painful.

I completely get that but I think if the thread topic is distressing you, it's on you to exit the thread (this is meant in the kindest way possible). Of course it's horrible to think about what could lie ahead but it seems like it's an area OP's family haven't explored yet. And for those of us with autistic siblings - seems like there's a lot of us here - it's something that doesn't get spoken about much and it's an important topic.

Nice.
SionnachRua · 16/08/2021 17:16

I'm not denying it's the truth. I'm saying that living with that truth is painful.

I completely get that but I think if the thread topic is distressing you, it's on you to exit the thread (this is meant in the kindest way possible). Of course it's horrible to think about what could lie ahead but it seems like it's an area OP's family haven't explored yet. And for those of us with autistic siblings - seems like there's a lot of us here - it's something that doesn't get spoken about much and it's an important topic.

Kanaloa · 16/08/2021 17:16

[quote Cuddlyrottweiler]@Kanaloa that's awesome ways of helping him prepare for things, I do those things myself and it really does make so much difference. Studying menus of restaurants and maps of shopping centres and things beforehand also really helps me, just ideas :)[/quote]
Thank you! They are not all my ideas but also his classroom helper who has been like a fountain of knowledge.

Love the idea of checking menus beforehand, right now we make sandwiches to take because he rejects most things, but possibly if he could see everything on offer and decide before then he would try them. He actually does like trying things, but we always say he’s like a new fish, you need to let the bag sit in the water for a bit!

intothewoodss · 16/08/2021 17:13

@SionnachRua

As the parent of an autistic child it's really quite upsetting to repeatedly read how I am 'going to die decades' before my child. Of course I know this but do I really need to read it over and over? Come on guys, have a little consideration.

But it's the truth of it though, isn't it? It's an unpleasant one but it's something that the family need to be thinking about (and sooner rather than later because you never know what's coming around the corner). People would be doing OP a disservice to not mention it.

I'm not denying it's the truth. I'm saying that living with that truth is painful.
SionnachRua · 16/08/2021 17:12

As the parent of an autistic child it's really quite upsetting to repeatedly read how I am 'going to die decades' before my child. Of course I know this but do I really need to read it over and over? Come on guys, have a little consideration.

But it's the truth of it though, isn't it? It's an unpleasant one but it's something that the family need to be thinking about (and sooner rather than later because you never know what's coming around the corner). People would be doing OP a disservice to not mention it.

Triffid1 · 16/08/2021 17:11

I don't think the wheelchair analogy works as a standalone. A sibling in a wheelchair who requires care is not the same as this situation. A more accurate example would be a sibling who requires a wheelchair to move around but refuses to use one, insisting on staying in bed, with parents bringing chamber pots, doing all cleaning, cooking and personal care.

A sibling in a wheelchair who needs normal accommodations - eg in living arrangements, in planning activities, in support re work, in transport is very different to a sibling who needs a wheelchair but refuses to learn how to use one.

OP's brother clearly has a significant disability, but nothing I've ever read or seen regarding autism suggests that the person can only function if every single one of their needs is met 100% to their preferred level. In fact, I have always understood that conditions such as autism, and the support provided for autistic children, is about helping them to function as much as possible within the framework of the world they're in. DD has two autistic children in her class and she does come home talking about how one or the other had a meltdown because of x or y, but I know a key part of the work the school and their parents are doing is helping them to manage that.

intothewoodss · 16/08/2021 17:10

[quote Cuddlyrottweiler]@Kanaloa that's awesome ways of helping him prepare for things, I do those things myself and it really does make so much difference. Studying menus of restaurants and maps of shopping centres and things beforehand also really helps me, just ideas :)[/quote]
Putting the work in really does real the benefits.

Seriously79 · 16/08/2021 17:09

It's easy for me to say this, as I'm not in this situation, but I feel that you need to do some research into Autism.

It isn't that your brother is 'trying to be awkward' maybe you should get in touch with The National Autistic Society, they are fantastic and I'm sure could offer some advise.

Swipe left for the next trending thread