Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Autistic brother makes it impossible for me

363 replies

IAmHereButNotHere · 16/08/2021 12:58

As title says really.

He’s in a routine and will not break his routine, ever. So he lives with my mum, visits my dad Tuesdays, Thursday and Saturday.

He cannot cope with me being there too, I get in the way, not deliberately but I just talk when he wants quiet so we can’t be there at the same time. And he cannot cope at all with my 7 year old, who I’m a single parent to – just her being there upsets him. He says he likes her but can’t cope with being around her.

He can’t cope if mum goes out outside of his routine, so if she goes out at 10am instead of noon he can’t cope so I can’t go on daytrips with my mum as she also has to be back at a certain time. If she;s not there when he gets back from dads, he gets upset. If she’s there when she’s not supposed to it upsets her.

Mum got a new car the other day and he couldn’t cope with that either, keeps saying it’s not mums car.

I try to understand but it affects my life too. I can’t see my parents when I want to, I can’t ask them to care for my DD unexpectedly, I can’t just pop in when I’m walking passed, my mum can’t just get my DD from school or holiday club as a one off, everything to do with my parents and brother has to be organised down to a tee – my brother cannot cope with my DD being even in his house touching anything so any childcare is at my house and I can’t be a minute late because it upsets my brother.

Because of covid I haven’t seen my dad for over a year. Brother used to only go twice a week but he’s increased it to 3 times. I get weekends off but my dad has a hobby on Sundays with some friends of his who still work so I can’t see him then, I also get Tuesday off but can’t go then due to my brother. If I suggest he doesn’t go one week so I can I get told by my brother that upsetting his routine will upset his rhythm and he may never be the same again, my parents suggest it and get told that they need to consider him over me because of his autism – I sort of agree with that tbh he lives with my mum so should come before me and his AN mean he needs my dad more than me.

I am just moaning here. My whole life revolves around my brother. I love him but I am sick of having to consider him when I want to see either of my parents. I can’t go on holiday with either parent as it upsets my brother so much.

I am lucky I have supportive friends and good childcare options nearby, but I am mourning the relationship I thought I’d have with my parents. My DD barely recognises them.

I know I am VUR and prepared to be told so. Sorry for the rant and sorry if any of my wording is wrong or offensive, I don't mean to be.

OP posts:
Kanaloa · 16/08/2021 22:34

Autism isn’t a choice but it doesn’t entitle you to control other people’s lives and behave badly towards them. Of course someone with autism might need extra support to understand why people are behaving in a certain way/to cope with changes in their life, but that should never allow them to dictate others’ lives in this way.

Gab2 · 16/08/2021 22:27

@Eggfriedpower

I wonder if people talking about people with physical disabilities in this way would be allowed? Calling a relative fucking annoying because they can't walk?
I agree, some of the comments here are horrible and ignorant. Most people here seem to think that autism is an act or a choice ffs.
SpaceOp · 16/08/2021 22:12

Agree with everything @itsgettingwierd has been saying. This idea that because someone is disabled means that everyone else must suffer, particularly when it's clear that the person in this case can when necessary, make at least some changes, is astounding. Her parents are carers whose lives are completely controlled by someone else with zero respite. OP's brother appears unwilling to even try any shifts in behaviour. I am not unsympathetic to how difficult things are for him or that some things may well be impossible forever, but that doesn't mean no efforts should be made for relief for the rest of the family.

GreatAuntEmily · 16/08/2021 21:48

Haven't read the full thread.

I was wondering if there was any chance of DB staying over at his DF's - that way Mum gets a break and you get a chance to spend a day with her. It could be proposed as being an arrangement to benefit DB in the case of Mum being ill, needing to go into hospital or similar.

Does he have interests or hobbies?

5zeds · 16/08/2021 20:40

The father who won’t give you time on a Sunday is blameless while the mother caring daily with her adult disabled son is framed as unfair and the disabled man is expected to just miraculously get over his difficulties.Hmm

FrenchBoule · 16/08/2021 20:37

@Sowingbees I think you misunderstood me.

The thread I mentioned was in Chat a few years ago so it disappeared.

I was not surprised that people with disabled siblings had resentment towards their parents when they always came second and the were expected at some point in life take over caring duties.

This is what OP’s parents are doing to her by placating her brother all the time.

What is going to happen,how the brother is going to manage if mum has a GP appointment before 12pm or the other medical treatment out of the time she’s “allowed” to go out?
OP’s parents opt for an easy life placating the brother and further pushing OP’s away.

What I was trying to say was that the change is unavoidable and should be introduced gradually.

Every person with autism is different but I’m not sure if OP’s brother demands are caused by his condition or not?

He managed the change when it suited him to further detriment to OP.

I had to implement changes for my ASD son. He doesn’t like them sometimes,he’s upset and very vocal about it (he’s 7 and non verbal but with some understanding).

I had to do it for the sake of my other son who can’t live his life up to his brother whims and demands.

It sucks. Constant juggling and reasoning.

Don’t tell me to fuck off.

Life is hard already.
I do whatever I can to give my kids possible best childhood.Both of them because I can’t sacrifice one for the sake of another.

I’m trying to be fair.

Butchyrestingface · 16/08/2021 20:12

Do you know any golfers? (if it is indeed golf)

Yes.

And everyone should be entitled to some time for doing their hobby and seeing friends too.

Which is why I said occasionally. Not suggesting he forfeits his hobby entirely but that occasionally he could prioritise the child he hasn’t seen for a year.

Mayhemmumma · 16/08/2021 20:02

You're not unreasonable but it is no doubt painful for your parents too.

Talk to your mum and dad about how you and your daughter feel and see if there are gentle ways in which you can stretch them time you spend together.

Sowingbees · 16/08/2021 19:59

@FrenchBoule

A while ago there was a thread on MN about people who have disabled siblings. The amount of resentment and sometimes bitterness towards the parents was shocking.

Some things in life make sense after several years.

I have 2 kids,younger with ASD and the older one is NT.
Emotional and physical needs of one child don’t trump another’s

OP, your parents are very unfair to you. They have 2 children,not just 1.
If your brother managed to change from 2 to 3 days I’d say he manages change when it suits him effectively elbowing you out of your family of origin.

Speak to your parents- either they will manage to carve out some time for you and manage your brother’s unreasonable and manipulative demands or just back off completely as you’re literally left out with no other options to see your parents.

Honestly fuck off. It's not shocking that a child who doesn't have any of their needs met because of their sibling harbours some bitterness. No matter what happens in their life , no matter what support is required they are always second.

Just read the rest of your post. Your latter doesn't fit with the first paragraph, so it's not at you, just the parents who expect the sibling to cope

DaisyDreaming · 16/08/2021 19:41

@Diverseopinions I know our local social services 15 years ago would grant whatever disabled people wanted (obviously within reason). It was amazing and disabled people were given the help they needed not just for basic needs but things that enhanced their quality of life and that most people take for granted. They are now in so much debt people are lucky to get even their most basic needs met :(

DaisyDreaming · 16/08/2021 19:37

SS probably arent helping as they don’t have to. Sometimes your parents have to threaten to stop caring to get any kind of help. It will be hard and stressful for you all but might work in the long run. Fact is social services could fund for him to live elsewhere with support but they are over stretched so if your parents don’t say they can’t carry on then they won’t do anything. It might be worth it, I don’t mean to sound flippant as it will be so hard but it needs to be done at some point or else it will just continue until your parents are frail. It’s hard for carers to say ‘I’m not doing this’ but it’s the only way to get help

80Dodgeballs · 16/08/2021 19:36

Also, look into PDA to see if it rings any bells.

5zeds · 16/08/2021 19:28

It’s pretty shit for you, your parents and your brother. Lots of people wish their lives were different. Your parents could behave differently as could your brother as could you.

Madwife123 · 16/08/2021 19:27

I’m sorry you’re having to deal with this.

My teenage son is severely autistic and I see the huge impact it has on his siblings. I worry about him as an adult.

I adore my son but I can’t pretend he hasn’t made life harder and less enjoyable for his siblings and it’s very unfair sadly.

PermanentTemporary · 16/08/2021 19:22

I wonder if you have ever had that conversation with your parents 'how do you see things working out for [brother] when you're not here any more?'

IAmHereButNotHere · 16/08/2021 19:15

@CoffeeWithCheese

And I also tell my NT other child that it is perfectly OK to feel frustrated, pissed off, wound up, annoyed and everything else toward her sibling at times - and that it does not make her a "bad" person - it makes her human and even the most saintly of siblings annoy the living daylights out of you at times (look at Perfect Peter in Horrid Henry). It's how you manage those emotions that counts - not trying to pretend they're not there.
Thank you so much for the understanding, thats absolutely how I feel. I feel an awful person for feeling frustrated that I don't have the relationship I wanted with my parents and annoyed that because of the autism my brother is this way.

Generally he's a lovely person, just not very flexible which of course isn't his fault.

Thank you also @CoffeeWithCheese I like suggestion of a timetable that'd work. I think I'm going to aim to see my mum on the night my DD is with her dad which is one weekend a fortnight. I am not going to thrust my DD on my Brother as it wouldn't be fair to either of them.

OP posts:
CoffeeWithCheese · 16/08/2021 18:52

And I also tell my NT other child that it is perfectly OK to feel frustrated, pissed off, wound up, annoyed and everything else toward her sibling at times - and that it does not make her a "bad" person - it makes her human and even the most saintly of siblings annoy the living daylights out of you at times (look at Perfect Peter in Horrid Henry). It's how you manage those emotions that counts - not trying to pretend they're not there.

HeyDemonsItsYaGirl · 16/08/2021 18:52

I just think that is someone called someone else fucking annoying because they were blind or deaf or in a wheelchair it would not be as acceptable

I can't use stairs or walk for more than a minute before needing to sit down. It's fucking annoying for my friends who have to suffer the same restrictions when we're together. It's fucking annoying for me as well. This is okay and not disablist.

CoffeeWithCheese · 16/08/2021 18:51

I'm waiting for an autism assessment, one of my children is waiting on the final stage of an ASD assessment and I've done a lot of work with people at various points on the ASD spectrum over the years.

Would he respond to (gradually) being introduced to the idea of "planning" out his week and feeling that HE controls it (within the limits of what you're trying to achieve)... so give him a plan for the week and so many "cards" or pictures or whatever for days he can see dad, days he can choose to do things with mum - so he starts to feel that he can sit and plan that out... then you could phase in what YOU want to be doing each week so if he wants to see dad on a Thursday - your picture is there already so he knows it'll be dad+you, or he'll have to pick another day to do it. Kind of coming at it from quite a PDA management via choices of options you want to achieve anyway but letting him feel like he's got control over it manner. Might also mean he's got a tool later on for slotting things like appointments in and whatever else as time goes on. If he has something visual that HE feels he's had ownership in creating it might help to both increase his understanding of life (some of the challenging behaviour may well be him hanging a sketchy understanding of some concepts onto a routine so he can get through things), drop his anxiety down a bit and give him something to hook his days onto.

AuntMasha · 16/08/2021 18:42

@welcome2021

If there had been forums like this when I was in my twenties I would have been able to see the wood for the trees a bit sooner. As it was I was conditioned from a young child into believing that my brother was the only person who mattered in my family and keeping him from kicking off was the most important thing for us all. Can I state again, this is not the fault of my brother.
Yes, the same happened to me. My father was also adhd. I grew up not knowing about boundaries and had a devastating mental breakdown when I reached adulthood and have been on meds all my life. My sister also suffered and has anxiety and panic attacks.

My brother died because he abused alcohol and it killed him in mid life.

Despite everything I loved him dearly and miss him every day. But I won’t pretend my childhood wasn’t marred or that I didn’t live in fear sometimes.

Good luck OP 💐

80Dodgeballs · 16/08/2021 18:30

I haven't read all of the thread.

I have two children who are autistic. My 11 year old's opinion is to remember that it's not your brother enforcing all of these rules, it's the autism and the related anxiety. Although we appreciate it is exceptionally difficult for you.

I also believe that I'm on the spectrum. I echo what another poster said that my 20's were tricky. I took longer to grow up and I needed my parents support.

I also get the self harm and the worry that goes with that if things don't go their way. That awful feeling in your stomach when you know things are going pear shaped/meltdown/starving themselves.

Regarding your daughter, I've been told that you g children can be tricky for autistic people because they can be unpredictable. They might suddenly jump up and start spinning around and give the autistic person sensory overload. So, it's not likely to be your daughter, just that she might behave like most kids that age and be unpredictable which is scary to some autistic people.

Could you parents make small changes. Mum is coming home today at 12.01 not 12.00. While you're waiting for Mum, you can watch TV, play with a sensory aid, speak to Mum on the phone. Do this every day for a few weeks to a month and then make it until 12.02 etc

I think that you will need to start introducing the idea of carers now for when your parents need more help. So the carer comes while Mum's there for a few weeks. Then mum's out in the garden for a few minutes while the carer is still in the house. This could take many months but until your brother can have someone else with him while Mum is off doing something.

Of my two children, I think that one is going to need possible assisted living. Both will definitely take longer to grow up but one I think will take much longer. They are almost a teen but they are not safe to be out alone. They still need help with dressing, washing, bedtime etc. My other child needs some help but not as bad as the other child. But they have no concept that they're incapable of looking after themselves. Your situation has given me a heads up that I need to slowly let someone else help me to help my child cope without me one day.

Also, apply for disability benefits to be able to pay for that carer.

You have my sympathy. It must be so hard on you. People don't always realise that caring for disabled people impacts the whole family.

RedToothBrush · 16/08/2021 18:22

@intothewoodss

You've got this so wrong.

Try imagining it this way... the wheelchair user DOESN'T KNOW that using the wheelchair will help them. They can't see how it would help them because they have been managing fine without it. They are terrified of using the wheelchair. Every time the wheelchair is mentioned or brought out they become so stressed and upset that they have physical reactions to it.

Or maybe just don't even try to analogise and make up bullshit comparisons between one type of disability and another.

Except this non wheelchair user can do change on within his own terms.

Change is possible if managed.

Its not that change is impossible. Just difficult.

The lack of acknowledging this and looking to adjust on this basis for the long term for his own interests is outright cruel because he will hit a point where change just happens on a large scale which he cannot be in control of and isn't managed because he is so dependent on his parents maintaining his routine.

A long term planning strategy for those with both physical and mental disabilities is essential. Its not about analogies which are bad. Its saying if you are dependent on others for care, it doesn't matter what your disability is, you are going to have to deal with change because carers aren't immortal.

It may upset the autistic brother to discover this, and he may struggle to deal with it but its not a choice he has nor is it something anyone who has 'been educated' (a phrase which is used in an abusive manner too much) can prevent.

It happens. Prepare for it to minimise the distress that it will inevitably cause. Even if this is difficult.

It sounds very much like the parents in this case arent really fully coping, and yet their health needs (both mental and physical) are somehow irrelevant and the only one who counts is the autistic brother.

No this absolutely isn't right and shouldn't be framed as such. It should never be framed as 'impossible to change' for this reason. It should always be framed as 'needing managed to support to change to enable long term care plans which are suitable for all parties'.

welcome2021 · 16/08/2021 18:22

If there had been forums like this when I was in my twenties I would have been able to see the wood for the trees a bit sooner. As it was I was conditioned from a young child into believing that my brother was the only person who mattered in my family and keeping him from kicking off was the most important thing for us all. Can I state again, this is not the fault of my brother.

SionnachRua · 16/08/2021 18:08

[quote welcome2021]@SionnachRua this was a lesson I only learnt in the last year or so. I've spent 30 years having it drummed into me that I was expected to take over as mother of my brother when my mum dies. No matter how much I explained that I have my own life and family it was ignored and I was told I'd be expected to look after him when she dies.

OP. The issue here is with your parents.[/quote]
Flowers Yup, right there with you. I do understand that the sibling taking over would be the easy fallback for some parents but it's so wrong to raise a child as an unwilling keeper of another. Even now my dad will hopefully talk about "oh when you and your brother patch things up"...never, ever. Unless perhaps personality transplants are invented.

Unfortunately OP, I've also learned that you can't make your parents see or do anything. All you can do is say your piece and then protect yourself and your family as best you can.

itsgettingwierd · 16/08/2021 18:01

The biggest issue for carers is that they're not recognised as victims of abuse or recognised a humans with human needs.

If a husband demanded a wife only went out 10-3, verbally abused them when they went early or returned late, used physical violence towards them because they were angry etc it would be so,enticed violence.

When a carer suffers the same treatment - it's because they are a carer.

This attitude has to stop. Carers get less than £2 an hour based on the 35 hours care minimum they must receive.

The state need to provide better care facilities for those with disabilities when they reach adulthood. For everyone's sake.