Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Autistic brother makes it impossible for me

363 replies

IAmHereButNotHere · 16/08/2021 12:58

As title says really.

He’s in a routine and will not break his routine, ever. So he lives with my mum, visits my dad Tuesdays, Thursday and Saturday.

He cannot cope with me being there too, I get in the way, not deliberately but I just talk when he wants quiet so we can’t be there at the same time. And he cannot cope at all with my 7 year old, who I’m a single parent to – just her being there upsets him. He says he likes her but can’t cope with being around her.

He can’t cope if mum goes out outside of his routine, so if she goes out at 10am instead of noon he can’t cope so I can’t go on daytrips with my mum as she also has to be back at a certain time. If she;s not there when he gets back from dads, he gets upset. If she’s there when she’s not supposed to it upsets her.

Mum got a new car the other day and he couldn’t cope with that either, keeps saying it’s not mums car.

I try to understand but it affects my life too. I can’t see my parents when I want to, I can’t ask them to care for my DD unexpectedly, I can’t just pop in when I’m walking passed, my mum can’t just get my DD from school or holiday club as a one off, everything to do with my parents and brother has to be organised down to a tee – my brother cannot cope with my DD being even in his house touching anything so any childcare is at my house and I can’t be a minute late because it upsets my brother.

Because of covid I haven’t seen my dad for over a year. Brother used to only go twice a week but he’s increased it to 3 times. I get weekends off but my dad has a hobby on Sundays with some friends of his who still work so I can’t see him then, I also get Tuesday off but can’t go then due to my brother. If I suggest he doesn’t go one week so I can I get told by my brother that upsetting his routine will upset his rhythm and he may never be the same again, my parents suggest it and get told that they need to consider him over me because of his autism – I sort of agree with that tbh he lives with my mum so should come before me and his AN mean he needs my dad more than me.

I am just moaning here. My whole life revolves around my brother. I love him but I am sick of having to consider him when I want to see either of my parents. I can’t go on holiday with either parent as it upsets my brother so much.

I am lucky I have supportive friends and good childcare options nearby, but I am mourning the relationship I thought I’d have with my parents. My DD barely recognises them.

I know I am VUR and prepared to be told so. Sorry for the rant and sorry if any of my wording is wrong or offensive, I don't mean to be.

OP posts:
intothewoodss · 17/08/2021 12:01

I will have my son with me for as long as he wants to be. We will show him options at various stages in his life, and encourage him to be as independent as possible, but DH and I fully envision an annexe of some sort for him on our property where he can (hopefully) live semi independently.

I don't give a shiny shit what anyone here has to say about that. He can have as much of me as he wants before I die. My mum died at 56 and I am well aware I could too, or even earlier. Of course we will provision for him in our wills, of course we will access as much social care support as possible, we would never expect his sibling to take over from us. But if he wants to be with us, he absolutely can.

TheNestedIf · 17/08/2021 11:54

that’s fine (so long as you are not pretending you will). I don’t see any guilt tripping. Families don’t all work in the same way. Some are more a support net and some more of a spring board (and some something to run hard away from). The assumption that ALL autistics who can’t live independently are best living in supported living or institutions, is AS offensive as the idea all should live in the parental home. It’s like saying all children would be happier at boarding school or all babies should be in nursery..

Accepted. I don't feel guilty. So, what does my brother do when my mother dies?

5zeds · 17/08/2021 11:46

I’m sorry @RedToothBrush I don’t understand your post. It sounds like you are saying no family should be allowed to live in an “extended family”??? Why? It’s not a criticism of how your family works or how you think it might work with similar members, any more than choosing to be a SAHM means you think everyone should be.

RedToothBrush · 17/08/2021 11:37

[quote 5zeds]**@TheNestedIf* I'm not taking my brother on, for his own sake as much as mine, and nor should the OP. Fuck that, and fuck the implicit guilt tripping of siblings like us.* that’s fine (so long as you are not pretending you will). I don’t see any guilt tripping. Families don’t all work in the same way. Some are more a support net and some more of a spring board (and some something to run hard away from). The assumption that ALL autistics who can’t live independently are best living in supported living or institutions, is AS offensive as the idea all should live in the parental home. It’s like saying all children would be happier at boarding school or all babies should be in nursery.[/quote]
Babies grow up and become independent.

Autistic adults and their parents carers have the opposite problem with aging.

Keep ignoring the crisis this creates by using the offense card if you want.

Still doesn't stop people getting old and dying. And social services having to come in and deal with the fall out. And probably not in a nice way if the autistic person is distressed and threatening staff. Not forgetting they don't have the comfort and advocacy of their parent there to help them through that situation if it had been confronted earlier.

Reality doesn't feel offense.

MichelleScarn · 17/08/2021 11:33

@5zeds

"My mum is also terrified of her going into supported living so I have promised to take care of her". Why is your mum terrified of this? Your sister will learn independence skills there and she will be happier than at home.. Perhaps the mother has seen what supported living looks like and doesn’t think she’ll be happier than at home or develop. Your mum is too old to be dealing with the severity of these issues and really not fair to ask you to take over. many seventy year old women are the backbone of their families supporting the lives of relatives and friends. Your sister is an adult now and needs these independence skills and her own life really. She wont be locked away and you'll be able to have days where you can all go out to lunch etc. She'll feel like a proper wee woman and will love it. She may “need” all sorts of skills she can’t have it won’t make the slightest difference. I meet large numbers of disabled adult out and about with their carer and I can assure you that many of them aren’t happy or well supported. There are good set ups but they tend to be those that support people to stay more involved with family than the occasional lunch out Shock. Many people don’t respond well to the life you seem to think suits all the disabled ones. Read some boarding school survivors threads and imagine if it was forever, with less funding, and less emotional resilience.

OP what can you do to help your brother, and what can you do to help your parents? You seem to see yourself as the victim in this scenario, I honestly think your mother has shouldered so much for you to be relatively free of it all.

OP what can you do to help your brother, and what can you do to help your parents? You seem to see yourself as the victim in this scenario, I honestly think your mother has shouldered so much for you to be relatively free of it all.

Op (and those in similar situations) if you do take anything from this thread, please do NOT let any of it be the horrific guilt tripping in this post!

5zeds · 17/08/2021 11:22

@TheNestedIf I'm not taking my brother on, for his own sake as much as mine, and nor should the OP. Fuck that, and fuck the implicit guilt tripping of siblings like us. that’s fine (so long as you are not pretending you will). I don’t see any guilt tripping. Families don’t all work in the same way. Some are more a support net and some more of a spring board (and some something to run hard away from). The assumption that ALL autistics who can’t live independently are best living in supported living or institutions, is AS offensive as the idea all should live in the parental home. It’s like saying all children would be happier at boarding school or all babies should be in nursery.

TheNestedIf · 17/08/2021 10:58
RedToothBrush · 17/08/2021 10:41

OP what can you do to help your brother, and what can you do to help your parents? You seem to see yourself as the victim in this scenario, I honestly think your mother has shouldered so much for you to be relatively free of it all.

Why is this the responsibility of the OP?

Its ok to say "no" without a massive guilt trip.

If you have no relationship with your other children because of the demands of one, even if they have learning disabilities the situation is out of control and the parents are not handling it well. Thus needs to be recognised as problematic and deeply unhealthy for all parties.

This concept of enforced guilt isn't ok. Its coercive and manipulative.

Its one thing for someone autistic who doesn't understand to be difficult. Its another for some third party on the internet to be spouting off about what a sibling / parent should or shouldn't be doing because the autistic person is more important. Its not true. Carers and relatives need and have the right to their own good mental health. Its hard enough dealing with the situation they have without some balloon coming in and adding their pennies worth of guilt making.

The fact the mother hasn't said no, and just has taken it all on above and beyond the level she should because of the abusive behaviour she endures if she doesn't, isn't something that should be shared and not tackled.

The whole point is that a lack of management and teaching coping strategies / having aquedate support when its clearly desparately needed.

The whole guilt thing lets social services off the hook. Indeed social services seem to actively encourage it.

All this does is set up an autistic person to an exceptionally traumatic scenario when the parents die. We never hear about this. For obvious reasons. Thats never in the best interests of the person concerned.

If supported living isnt good in quality then it should be improved. Hiding the problem away unseen in people's homes doesn't help that and there isn't any real oversight into these domestic situations and whether they are healthy for all those concerned.

We have a number of posters here explicitly detailing domestic abuse as part of the dynamic it creates. This is being dismissed and minimised as 'just something you have to suck up' as a carer.

This is not ok.

Don't be part of the problem by trying to shove it back into the closet as a problem that must be dealt with by family members only even if its harmful. The accusations of disablism of this thread are utter appalling because all it does it remove public awareness and reduce support for better services and support for families who clearly need it desperately.

Unless you have the conversation that autistic people need to be actively guided and supported through change even if they don't like it and find it distressing and this is a normal thing that has to be dealt with sensitively as part of their care, then they will always be set up to eventually have a situation of massive change, no preparation and no real support to get through it which will be even more traumatic and possibly will leave them vulnerable to various harms they wouldn't otherwise had.

Honestly the denail of reality that parents don't live forever and will reach a point where they are no longer able to care adequately is actually a scandal. It should be viewed as such.

The mantra that autistic people dont understand just doesn't cut it because they don't live in isolation or a magic immortality bubble.

Sockwomble · 17/08/2021 10:07

And I have a severely disabled teenager so I know the feelings associated with thinking about that move.

Sockwomble · 17/08/2021 10:06

"Perhaps the mother has seen what supported living looks like and doesn’t think she’ll be happier than at home or develop."

But the mother won't live forever and even if the move isn't happening yet then plans need to made and the necessary coping skills beginning to be put in place.

Didiplanthis · 17/08/2021 09:44

I gave 2 ND Dc and one NT. One if my ND boys would absolutely control the entire family unit at all times given the chance. I know he is not being naughty or selfish - it makes him feel safe but I cannot let him think it is possible or acceptable as it makes life intolerable for his siblings. But I can see how your parents have got to this point as the daily grind of fighting against him in this is utterly exhausting. I would suggest that you with plenty of preparation and warning change his day and when he kicks off you keep reiterating he coped with changing his days when HE wanted to. Yes it is going to be hard but he is behaving badly as well as struggling with his autism.

welcome2021 · 17/08/2021 09:43

@Rainbow1378 I'm sorry your family are in this situation. I was told from a young child that my parents had me so I could look after my brother one day. My mum is a very, very nice person, very placid and loving and when dad died early she and my brother were left together in the family house. At the time I suggested that it would be a good idea for him to move to independent living. Because of the work I did at the time I knew of several really brilliant schemes that I thought would help him blossom (he was early thirties then). Mum wouldn't have it. She has always had an aversion to him having any contact with other learning disabled people.

As the years and decades have gone on I've repeatedly asked about what would happen when she dies. Her plan was that he will continue living in the house with 'a nice lady' moving in to look after him. She's always told other people that I will look after him, although I have told her directly and repeatedly that I won't be doing that. It's only recently that I've understood that I've been manipulated by guilt for all these years into colluding with the situation. Neither of them are happy. Neither has had a good life living under my brother's rules. Mum very nearly died ten years ago as she was ill, needed an urgent operation and was too frightened to upset my brother to call an ambulance. Had it not been for a neighbour popping in and insisting whilst my brother screamed and shouted she wouldn't be here now.

Things changed this year when a new social worker became involved and my mother's dementia became worse. It's clear mum won't live much longer, and if she does she probably won't know who my brother is, so plans are finally being made for him to move to independent living - and he seems to like the idea.

My advise is to say no and mean it. I worked part time for 30 years, never having a career because I was supporting my mum. My brother living at home was not the best thing for him or her.

TheNestedIf · 17/08/2021 09:33

"My mum is also terrified of her going into supported living so I have promised to take care of her". Why is your mum terrified of this? Your sister will learn independence skills there and she will be happier than at home.. Perhaps the mother has seen what supported living looks like and doesn’t think she’ll be happier than at home or develop.

So what happens when the mother dies?

Your mum is too old to be dealing with the severity of these issues and really not fair to ask you to take over. many seventy year old women are the backbone of their families supporting the lives of relatives and friends.

So what happens when the mother dies?

Your sister is an adult now and needs these independence skills and her own life really. She wont be locked away and you'll be able to have days where you can all go out to lunch etc. She'll feel like a proper wee woman and will love it. She may “need” all sorts of skills she can’t have it won’t make the slightest difference. I meet large numbers of disabled adult out and about with their carer and I can assure you that many of them aren’t happy or well supported. There are good set ups but they tend to be those that support people to stay more involved with family than the occasional lunch out shock. Many people don’t respond well to the life you seem to think suits all the disabled ones. Read some boarding school survivors threads and imagine if it was forever, with less funding, and less emotional resilience.

So what happens when the mother dies?

OP what can you do to help your brother, and what can you do to help your parents? You seem to see yourself as the victim in this scenario, I honestly think your mother has shouldered so much for you to be relatively free of it all.

I'm not taking my brother on, for his own sake as much as mine, and nor should the OP. Fuck that, and fuck the implicit guilt tripping of siblings like us.

MrsSkylerWhite · 17/08/2021 09:27

Of course you’re not BU. Sadly, neurotypical siblings often have to take a backseat. Tough as an adult, even more difficult as a child.

itsgettingwierd · 17/08/2021 09:24

@Bogeyes

He can't change his routine but he increased his visits to your dad?
It's a misunderstood myth about the 'not being able to change routine' for people with autism.

The routine they require is to help them manage the executive function deficits quite often and help control the anxiety that can manafiest alongside autism.

The anxiety is often from not being able to read people. So if you do the same thing the same time each day you are likely to come across the same people, you learn about them and create a routine about how you communicate with them etc.

So with him changing his routine - it's because it's possible. He's decided that he wants to do 3 visits and so he's in control. Those 3 visits could easily have been different days with some support to understand that his routine also needs to take into account the needs of others. It's the understanding of others thoughts feelings and emotions that's generally another area that's struggled with.

You often find that some autistic people cannot tolerate noise - unless they're making it!

You have 2 viewpoints on this. Should those around them keep quiet? No - because they have a right to a life. Should the autistic person avoid places they cannot deal with - well yes on the whole.

But the better solution is somewhere in the middle. Give them a chance to experience somewhere they find difficult if that's what they want and make the environment accessible for them initially. Then build up.

The o,portent thing is not to enforce a situation that's difficult. So with my ds he will join in family meals but if he needs to leave when eaten we leave. If he needs to get up and go outside for some space then he goes - and the important bit is he goes without others judgement or making comments.

I hate crowds etc (now! - loved nightclubs etc as a teen!). So I don't go to them. I don't go and expect others to give me space because playing human pinball machine causes me stress!

5zeds · 17/08/2021 09:19

"My mum is also terrified of her going into supported living so I have promised to take care of her". Why is your mum terrified of this? Your sister will learn independence skills there and she will be happier than at home.. Perhaps the mother has seen what supported living looks like and doesn’t think she’ll be happier than at home or develop.
Your mum is too old to be dealing with the severity of these issues and really not fair to ask you to take over. many seventy year old women are the backbone of their families supporting the lives of relatives and friends.
Your sister is an adult now and needs these independence skills and her own life really. She wont be locked away and you'll be able to have days where you can all go out to lunch etc. She'll feel like a proper wee woman and will love it. She may “need” all sorts of skills she can’t have it won’t make the slightest difference. I meet large numbers of disabled adult out and about with their carer and I can assure you that many of them aren’t happy or well supported. There are good set ups but they tend to be those that support people to stay more involved with family than the occasional lunch out Shock. Many people don’t respond well to the life you seem to think suits all the disabled ones. Read some boarding school survivors threads and imagine if it was forever, with less funding, and less emotional resilience.

OP what can you do to help your brother, and what can you do to help your parents? You seem to see yourself as the victim in this scenario, I honestly think your mother has shouldered so much for you to be relatively free of it all.

itsgettingwierd · 17/08/2021 09:15

@AngeloMysterioso

I now have an autistic child myself so I now understand where my mum has been coming from all these years, because I have to put his needs first, even above his twin's and even if it makes life harder for everyone else.

Speaking as the NT child (although not a twin) in this scenario, I’m sorry but this is a disastrous approach to take. By always putting your other child second, all you are doing is setting them up for their own issues in adulthood and a shit relationship with you. I now as an adult am absolutely shit at communicating my problems to others, I bury things until they reach unsustainable levels because all my life it was made very clear to me that my wants, my needs and my problems were always going to be overridden by those of my sibling and I was simply less important, so there was no point talking about what I was going through or asking for help. This has had very serious consequences for me in a number of different ways.

This message is very important to all parents - regardless of SN etc.

My sister was always domineering and I was passive.

I'm the same re not being able to communicate my feelings because I was programmed to be second (well third actually because I also had an even younger sibling)

Everyone deserves attention, love and care.

We are fighting for equality but it cannot be at the detriment to others. True equality is equality for all.

TheNestedIf · 17/08/2021 09:11

I'm In a similar position to you @Rainbow1378, except for the fact my brother is mostly quiet and passive unless something frightens him, and that I don't participate in his care.

My parents keep putting off looking into supported living because "he doesn't want to leave home", but they're in their late 70's and this just cannot go on indefinitely. I don't think it's entirely guilt. I suspect it's also control, because I think my mother is also on the spectrum.

I can't and won't look after my brother. I am too far away for it to work practically, and actually I don't want to. It would be terrible for any relationship we had. This conversation has been had many times. It used to begin with my mother recounting my brother's latest difficulties, and I would follow it up with asking what they planned to do about his living arrangements. Sadly, I have had to go NC in the hope that it hammers home the fact it's not fair to just die on my brother and leave him dealing with bereavement and a massive change in circumstances at the same time. Also that it's not fair to assume I can deal with that as an emergency from a distance.

I second that you shouldn't agree to look after your sister. It's not your job and you may not even be the best option for her.

As for the OP, I agree that the brother can change when it suits him, as can mine, so he has to get gradually used to the idea that he has to change when things are non-negotiable for other people. His needs might usually come first, but they cannot also come second, third and last for the family to function.

DottyHarmer · 17/08/2021 08:58

I think it's very important for people to openly discuss this, and share information. Posters roaring about disablism and no doubt reporting the thread are not just unkind, but potentially thwarting someone getting help, especially for aged parents.

I was a sibling who was always second. Dsis wasn't diagnosed, but lived a life on the edge of violent rage and terrible jealousies over.... anything. In order to preserve a semblance of peace, dsis had to be deferred to in all things. I agree with a poster upthread, I was taught to be a people pleaser to the extreme. Always put yourself last. Never eat what you want to eat, always let everyone go first, never win a game, never be proud of yourself, always put yourself down...

Rainbow1378 · 17/08/2021 08:51

@Gab2

I haven't no, will have a look at it though. I have contacted numerous psychiatrists in the past, none of them have been able to help because my sister refuses to communicate with them.

Rainbow1378 · 17/08/2021 08:48

@welcome2021

@RedHelenB

Sorry wasn't sure how to reply by tagging . Responses below

Rainbow1378 · 17/08/2021 08:40

[quote RedHelenB]@Rainbow1378 don't promise to look after your sister yourself.[/quote]
I wish it was that simple, I just don't know how to start that conversation and I don't want to disappoint or worry my mum. She's been through a lot and has a lot of health issues.

Rainbow1378 · 17/08/2021 08:38

[quote welcome2021]@Rainbow1378 totally feel for you and your situation. My mum was 90 and showing signs of dementia before anyone would even start talking about future planning for my brother. There are brilliant places out there and help for our disabled siblings, but it needs our parents to get behind the idea. Even now, in her nineties my brother's welfare is the one thought in my mum's mind.[/quote]
I read your posts and I couldn't believe some of the stuff you wrote was so similar, in this situation I literally feel as though I'm totally alone. Although I am so sorry to hear your mum is having a difficult time too.
It's always on my mind, it makes me feel so low to think about God forbid if anything was to happen, I don't want to be in the same situation and be put through what my mum has been but i don't know how to not be, and I have 2 LOs as well. I just don't know how I would even start that conversation with my mum and I don't know why supported living has always been her fear.
She gets absolutely no respite, my sister rules her day from the moment she wakes up- she has to follow her orders and do the routine (even my mums routine of when she can make coffee or have a shower) if she doesn't follow it she can get screamed at for hours, I know my mum is doing it wrong, but I can't explain how difficult it is for her not to do it.
It's also a nightmare to get her to wash, she just refuses to wash and my mum can't get her to, so every Saturday I go there and wash her because she seems to listen to me with the washing.
She also doesn't accept my mum to own anything by herself, for example if my mum has something, it needs to be recognised in my sisters eyes as belonging to both of them not just my mum.
My mum is also not allowed to sit anywhere on her own, my sister tells her where to sit and has to sit with her.
Thank you for replying to me and reaching out, it's a comfort knowing I'm not completely alone.
Has your mum spoken to you about what would happen if God forbid anything happened? Does she expect you to care for him?

intothewoodss · 17/08/2021 08:21

@GreatAuntEmily

I did some voluntary work in the past and the parents of some disabled children, especially the mother, seem to feel a sort of guilt. This seems to increase their determination to do everything to make their child's life easier - even if it seems to disadvantage the child.
Big old sweeping judgement you've made there.
RedHelenB · 17/08/2021 08:15

@Rainbow1378 don't promise to look after your sister yourself.

Swipe left for the next trending thread