Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I can still be Godmother unofficially

35 replies

54321nought · 15/08/2021 21:11

Well, friend J asked me and friend L to be Godmother to her daughter S, and I was delighted.

However, that was precovid, and the Christening has been delayed, and in the mean time Js sister now lives back in the UK, and wants to be Godmother herself.

The vicar is saying only 2 Godmothers.

I don't think I need to be one of the people who stand up in Church during the service to make promise formally.

I am intending to offer to stand down, and make a more private promise, just between me and God and J and S

I think that will still make me a Godmother, and avoid a family rift.

Has anyone else ever done anything privately to take on a Godparent role, rather than make the official promise publicly in church?

Any ideas how to make it nice, but not a big deal?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MauveMavis · 18/08/2021 21:27

I don't think standing up in church influences your role in a child's life. It is your actions that do that.

I'm a "not a godparent" to one child (I'm not religious)and have a similar role in the life of other children who also have official godparents. In several cases they see more of me and do more with me than with the official people.

It is unbelievably gratifying to discover in their teenage years that I did something right as even though they now have much more choice over how they spend their time a day out with "auntie" mavis is still something worth doing.

MsSquiz · 18/08/2021 21:23

It is traditional to have 2 godmothers, 1 godfather for a girl and vice versa for a boy, but there is no limit.

It is more usual these days to have 2 couples as godparents.

Godparents also have no legal standing so, other than "guidance on the eyes of the church" they're kind of irrelevant. You can be there for the child throughout their life, however you wish, godparent or not.

I do find it odd that you have "stood down" but will still be in "all photos" like a godparent and carrying the child up to the font.
It's not actually up to the vicar to limit godparents!

To think I can still be Godmother unofficially
CabbagesGreen · 18/08/2021 21:17

@54321nought

well, the Vicar didn't want more than 3, so this is what's happening. The sister is officially taking my place, but I am still going to consider myself Godmother, and I will be the person carrying S up to be Christened, so I will be in the thick of it, in all the photos.

J is very relieved I have offered to give my place to her sister

So we are all set for a nice day on Sunday

Ah that's a lovely way around it and you can still take him to church and talk to him about God.
godmum56 · 18/08/2021 21:14

@54321nought

well, the Vicar didn't want more than 3, so this is what's happening. The sister is officially taking my place, but I am still going to consider myself Godmother, and I will be the person carrying S up to be Christened, so I will be in the thick of it, in all the photos.

J is very relieved I have offered to give my place to her sister

So we are all set for a nice day on Sunday

that's lovely :) but what a mean miserable vicar
LittleGwyneth · 18/08/2021 19:07

Thats bonkers given that it's traditional to have three - two of the same sex as the child and one of the opposite.

54321nought · 18/08/2021 18:53

well, the Vicar didn't want more than 3, so this is what's happening. The sister is officially taking my place, but I am still going to consider myself Godmother, and I will be the person carrying S up to be Christened, so I will be in the thick of it, in all the photos.

J is very relieved I have offered to give my place to her sister

So we are all set for a nice day on Sunday

OP posts:
BumbleMug · 16/08/2021 11:49

@54321nought

no one has suggested to me that I step down, it just seems like a peaceful solution , and I feel that having agreed to be Godmother, I already have taken on that commitment , all be it privately rather than publicly.

I am not going to raise the topic with L. That seems like it would be pressurising her to consider standing down.

I will either offer to stand down myself, and take up the role unofficially, or try and persuade the vicar to change his mind!

There is also a Godfather, the vicar has said that the limit is 3, 2 of one sex and 1 of the other.

Is this not standard?

No not standard. DD has 4 - 2 of each.
lanthanum · 16/08/2021 11:36

It's "at least 3", assuming Church of England. The vicar might want to read www.churchofengland.org/life-events/christenings/christening-faqs#na

You can't be an official godparent if not present at the service to make the promises, but all that means is that your name is not on the official record of the christening. There's nothing to stop you doing everything else a godparent might (and of course you can make the same promises as in the service - they just won't be witessed by that congregation).

Tuliptulip · 16/08/2021 10:12

My DC all have five godparents - it is completely fine. As a PP said all the Cambridge children have five or more.

1stWorldProblems · 16/08/2021 10:05

Both our children have 4 (2 men & 2 women) and neither CofE vicar had a problem with it. (DD1 originally asked GDF turned out not to be christened so we were worried that he wouldn't be allowed but our vicar said that he was just glad to see children being christened & godparents being happy to take the role so he was allowed to be one. DD2 got 4 because otherwise it wouldn't be fair.

Personally I don't understand asking siblings to be godparents as they already have a relationship to the child. I value my godparents & my children's because they provide a close friendship with friends of the parents that you wouldn't otherwise necessarily have. Historically they'd have lived a slight distance from your family, in case most of your close family /village got wiped out by a plague.

borntobequiet · 16/08/2021 10:00

My two brothers are godfathers to my two children. My younger brother is godfather to my older child and my older brother to my younger. In fact now the children are older, due to circumstance they are each closer to the other’s godfather than to their own. What matters is that there are adults other than birth parents to help young people grow up in a loving, friendly and supportive way, whether the relationship is formally recognised or not.

Babdoc · 16/08/2021 09:51

It’s much easier in the C of S. The entire congregation stands and vows to support the child in its development of faith.
Having specific people to stand beside the parents as they make their own vows to raise the child in a Christian household is pretty much optional, and they play no active part in the ceremony.

newnortherner111 · 16/08/2021 09:50

I hope regardless you can attend the baptism. My godmother (and until his death my godfather) is still a part of my life and I am in my fifties, and I hope you are able to be a part of your friend's life for as long if not longer.

notanothertakeaway · 16/08/2021 09:46

I think you sound lovely and thoughtful

AIBU would be a dull place if everyone was like you. Don't you know you're supposed to stamp your feet and make a fuss, to keep us all entertained?

Applesandpears23 · 16/08/2021 09:45

I had three god parents as a child and 2 of them were my aunt and uncle. I always felt short changed compared to my siblings who each had 3 non family god parents. I think it lovely that you will do this unofficially if you can’t officially.

orangejumpsuit · 16/08/2021 09:43

Maybe your friend has changed her mind about wanting you to be godmother, and now wants her sister instead ( could be family pressure or something, who knows).
With that in mind I wouldn't push it or press it, and certainly do not contact the vicar!
Just graciously step back

godmum56 · 16/08/2021 09:41

@54321nought

no one has suggested to me that I step down, it just seems like a peaceful solution , and I feel that having agreed to be Godmother, I already have taken on that commitment , all be it privately rather than publicly.

I am not going to raise the topic with L. That seems like it would be pressurising her to consider standing down.

I will either offer to stand down myself, and take up the role unofficially, or try and persuade the vicar to change his mind!

There is also a Godfather, the vicar has said that the limit is 3, 2 of one sex and 1 of the other.

Is this not standard?

no it absolutely is not...if its ok for the Queen and all that www.townandcountrymag.com/society/tradition/a22064625/queen-elizabeth-godchildren/

This won't be applicable to your case but I inherited my godchild. My late husband was the godfather and we are very close to the family but not related. When DH died, godchild was already adult but DH had kept up the GP/GC relationship so I inherited them.

MatildaTheCat · 16/08/2021 09:34

Don’t the royals have multiple god parents? Might be worth mentioning since the Queen is head of Cof E!

You sound lovely and if it isn’t possible for you to have the official title I’m sure your friend will bite your hand off at your generous offer.

Habber · 16/08/2021 09:32

My Dsis didn’t ask me to be Godmother I was internally sad about it but I know I am Aunty. I wouldn’t have said anything to my sister though and let her pick who she wanted

54321nought · 16/08/2021 09:29

no one has suggested to me that I step down, it just seems like a peaceful solution , and I feel that having agreed to be Godmother, I already have taken on that commitment , all be it privately rather than publicly.

I am not going to raise the topic with L. That seems like it would be pressurising her to consider standing down.

I will either offer to stand down myself, and take up the role unofficially, or try and persuade the vicar to change his mind!

There is also a Godfather, the vicar has said that the limit is 3, 2 of one sex and 1 of the other.

Is this not standard?

OP posts:
StarDrawers · 16/08/2021 09:26

@MindyStClaire

I think you sound lovely. I would just say to your friend "I can step down if you would like, I won't be in the slightest bit offended, and of course it won't make any difference to how I treat X, I'll always be there for her".
This sounds perfect. And you can still buy her a nice bible on the day.
MindyStClaire · 16/08/2021 09:22

I think you sound lovely. I would just say to your friend "I can step down if you would like, I won't be in the slightest bit offended, and of course it won't make any difference to how I treat X, I'll always be there for her".

Hardploc · 16/08/2021 09:21

There’s no limit so I’m not sure why the priest is insisting on 2

Sssloou · 16/08/2021 09:16

What about friend “L” ?

Why have you decided it’s you who has to step back?

Why is J worrying / anxious about her sister your concern? Has J been bothering you about it and hinting you step down?

honeylulu · 16/08/2021 09:10

It won't be official but godparent has no legal status outside the church anyway. I can't see any reason why you can't be an "unofficial godparent". My daughter's godmother is also unofficial godmother to another little girl (no baptism as parents were not believers) as well as two others "officially" and she takes her role just as seriously as her official godchildren.

I've also known some parents have a secular naming ceremony if they didn't want a religious one and those have "sponsors" rather than godparents but essentially it's a similar role: that you are expected to remain in the child's life and support them morally/spiritually, in a way that is meaningful to that individual.

My sister's godmother was a bit rubbish and sister sort of adopted my godmother (much better at the role) and we used to refer to her as a "fairy godmother"!

Vicar is a meanie to stick to the traditional 2 godmothers. The C of E allow an unlimited number!

Swipe left for the next trending thread