Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Regret having children?

371 replies

PumpkinKlNG · 15/08/2021 19:15

Is it ever ok to admit you regret having children? (Not to them of course) people say you never regret having a child but aibu to think that isn’t true?

OP posts:
Darbysmama · 04/09/2021 03:13

First of all, I’m not a parent. Just a fur baby mama. (Go ahead, ask why I’m here… I just like chatting with people, even if their lifestyles differ from mine.)

Second of all, my sister has four kids. She had them all two years apart. So, um, needless to say— very chaotic! They all have behavioral issues and learning struggles. I pride myself on being a good auntie. Meanwhile, my husband and I have none. It allows us some luxuries. Disposable income, more freedom (walk around the house naked, sleep in until noon, swear up a storm if we feel like it, skip dinner if we want, etc.), lots of travel, more ability to focus on his career/my businesses, being able to go out on a date night whenever we want. My sister has confessed to me in moments of weakness that she wishes she hadn’t had so many kids or maybe even had kids at all. I think that’s normal. I’m sure you get frustrated. Wish for a little more freedom. When you have kids, they come first. And I’m sure it can get tiring feeling like second fiddle in your own life, right? I think that’s only natural. I don’t know why we lambast parents for being honest about it. All that does is make people feel guilty and more isolated and like they have to hold that feeling in.

Touching on OP’s remark about the parents not saying it to the child, my mother has actually told me she wishes she hadn’t had kids and that my husband and I are smart for not having done so. That seems harsh, but I understood where she was coming from. She had my sister in high school and me five years later. My sister’s dad bolted, my dad was barely present, and my stepdad was an abusive alcoholic. Plus she has severe bipolar disorder. She’s also generally skeptical of the sort of world kids are being born into. So I know she loves us, but there’s also regret there too.

No matter what in life, when you pick a path that means you’re not going down a different path. There’s always going to be some regret or what if. Sometimes when my friends are chatting about their kids first day of school I feel some regret too. That’s totally normal and doesn’t mean I’m not happy, just like parents sometimes regretting doesn’t mean they don’t love their kids. We’re all just human.

Susannahmoody · 04/09/2021 03:07

I think people are honest about how hard it is... But it falls on deaf ears when you don't have kids.

Having kids is very tough and not for everyone. I was one of those on the fence people but can honestly say I love it. Babies are very hard though... We could have used more support.

I agree with a pp that said, time, money, a good network and NT/easy kids make all the difference.

AnnieSnap · 04/09/2021 02:47

@DozingDoughnut

Be interested to know how many parents of adult children feel regret. Or whether it’s those in the thick of parenting small kids
Mine range from 44 to 39 and I regret having them. I really enjoyed being a mother when they were little (even though I didn’t really want to have kids - my husband persuaded me). I found parenting stroppy adolescents hard though and two out of three have grown into self-entitled adults who have no interest in their parents lives unless they want something.
AnnieSnap · 04/09/2021 02:37

@SecretSpAD

Many years ago when I first started working as a GP I had a patient come in for a consultation because she hated being a parent, felt nothing for her children and was depressed at the thought of that just being her life forever more. She made an appt with me because people kept telling her she had PND and she'd feel better when they were older. But she didn't. She felt worse and more trapped each year. When she rang to make the appt she specifically asked for a GP who didn't have children because she was fed up with being told that it would get better etc. Or not believe her when she said she didn't love or even like her children, just resented them for ruining her life.

I arranged for counselling for her and the last I heard she had walked away from her husband and children and moved to another part of the country. I often wonder how she is and whether she found the peace she was looking for.

That’s so sad. I hope she found happiness. No doubt many have condemned her.
Meatshake · 02/09/2021 18:22

I don't regret it for a minute. I had the best day today with my 5 year old, we went shopping, had coffee/milkshake, and she is just the coolest little person. Our personalities vibe hard though. My 3 year old as well is the funniest little guy... I don't know, watching them learn and try and succeed at stuff just gives meaning to my life, but then I'm not one to have ever previously found fulfilment with career or possessions.

My friend has a kid a similar sort of age and although it's never been said I can see that my friend struggles to bond with the kid- they have really polar opposite personalities- child is the kind of personality that grows on you a bit- clever but also very active, impulsive, opinionated, and spirited (yup), and my friend is bit of a perfectionist and holds themselves to a high standard- the personality v misbehaving child is a bad mix, and you can see how the child both simultaneously leans towards the other parent/excludes my friend AND misbehaves in order to get attention from my friend. I sense a brewing teenage shitstorm with that one.

The younger child is an easier, more genial personality and people just like her immediately. you can see how my friend just finds that relationship so much easier because it's what she expected a child to be like.

IceLace100 · 02/09/2021 18:06

@HateJudgmentalPeople

I could never say in real life what I’ve said here, people flame you for it and my ex friends man said I was selfish for not wanting another kid when the actual reason for his statement is that my friend and her partner had a kid same age as mine, and she had health issues and they had sex for 10 years without contraception and she didn’t fall pregnant and so they thought she couldn’t have any more, until one day she fell pregnant and they are 100% against abortion so had their second kid but were mighty pissed off about it and I think they just wanted me in the same boat as them, more than one kid I didn’t want, they do say misery loves company. Their eldest is 18.5 now and the other is 7 and they thought all that child rearing stuff was over!
That poor poor 7 year old.

It would be hard for the parents attitude not to show.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 02/09/2021 12:49

Dozingdoughnut

So true. 6 months in if you'd asked me at 4am I probably would have happily swapped DD for a badly trained dog!

For most people the picture is very different a few years in when you are getting more sleep etc.

Plumtree391 · 02/09/2021 12:48

I expect it is when they are in the thick of it or have other difficulties.

DozingDoughnut · 02/09/2021 12:34

Be interested to know how many parents of adult children feel regret. Or whether it’s those in the thick of parenting small kids

MorriseysGladioli · 02/09/2021 12:17

I think that kind of thing is trumpeted like some sort of badge of honour.
Taking 4 hours to get a toddler to sleep, arranging play dates, worrying about the contents of a toddler's lunch box.
It's the same as "ooh, it's wine o'clock".

ttcwithpcos1 · 02/09/2021 12:13

agree with those who experienced the opposite. right from pregnancy people started with the birth horror stories, then it was sleep deprivation horror stories, i was gleefully told "you won't ever have time to do youor makeup/blow dry your hair again", etc. every day some influencer is showing off a selfie of stretch marks or talking about how tough it is. if one of them shows a picture looking alright they're slammed for not showing 'the reality.' and this is coming from someone whose babies were colicky and didn't sleep over an hour at a time til 6 months so not blessed with an easy time.

HateJudgmentalPeople · 02/09/2021 12:12

I could never say in real life what I’ve said here, people flame you for it and my ex friends man said I was selfish for not wanting another kid when the actual reason for his statement is that my friend and her partner had a kid same age as mine, and she had health issues and they had sex for 10 years without contraception and she didn’t fall pregnant and so they thought she couldn’t have any more, until one day she fell pregnant and they are 100% against abortion so had their second kid but were mighty pissed off about it and I think they just wanted me in the same boat as them, more than one kid I didn’t want, they do say misery loves company. Their eldest is 18.5 now and the other is 7 and they thought all that child rearing stuff was over!

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 02/09/2021 12:01

The only thing that puzzles me is people saying that parents lie to them about the reality of having kids?I heard ONLY how exhausting, relentless, physically painful and arduous, thankless and mundane having a baby would be. And I told my friends the same!

This. My reality was nowhere near as bad as the utter shit show I was warned to expect!

dayslikethese1 · 02/09/2021 11:31

I agree six people talk about how terrible parenting is constantly so I don't understand the posts saying its idealised and no-one tells you about the bad stuff. If MN is anything to go by, regret is common; I've seen loads of these threads over the yrs.

sixthtimelucky · 02/09/2021 11:11

People have been very honest on this thread and that's a big and welcome change, I've been on MN for 15 years and responses used to be very different. It must be a huge relief to be able to say this in a safe space and not get annihilated for being honest.

The only thing that puzzles me is people saying that parents lie to them about the reality of having kids?

I heard ONLY how exhausting, relentless, physically painful and arduous, thankless and mundane having a baby would be. And I told my friends the same! Countered with 'but you love them more than you can ever imagine loving another human' (my experience I realise now, not everyone's).

I wonder if people only hear and see what they want to and disregard the negatives. And if anyone is going by bloody insta posts esp by celebs or influencers, then for the love of God you've only got yourselves to blame!

Holskey · 02/09/2021 10:43

[quote ttcissoboring]**@ClareBlue* @Holskey* - many parents do though - modern day parenting has become much more helicopter then it used to.

Nowadays children occupying themselves is considered child abuse, at least by many posters on MN. It's crazy.

One lady on a thread the other day was judging parents for checking their phones in a coffee shop when out with DC and not showing them attention?

It's like nowadays your whole life has to disappear and therefore that makes you a great parent (or at least stops judgement from others and parents seem particularly sensitive to judgement these days).

[/quote]
Ah okay, I see what you're saying. Yes, there's a lot of pressure. Your earlier post seemed to imply you can avoid running around after your children and that they can fit in with your life. That's not possible much of the time, mostly due to children's needs and for the sake of their well-being. The judging makes life more difficult, but parenting is at times relentless anyway. Just making sure a toddler doesn't kill themselves is extremely tiring!

Firingpingpongs · 02/09/2021 09:36

In order to empathise with someone's experience you must be willing to believe them as they see it and not how you imagine their experience to be. For the latter just completely invalidates them.

I regret having children for many reasons. The physical and mental toll on my body for starters. I love my children, they are great and at the time I did want them but more so I wanted that acceptance that I was doing the right thing by conforming to societal expectations of married, 2.2 kids etc.

I tell my kids all the time how much I love them and I think I do a better job of parenting them than my own mother did on me BUT I also tell them not to bend to what is perceived to be the norm if it doesn't feel right for them. I have told them that having kids is hard, to my daughter I've explained all the potentials of what can go wrong. I don't give a flying fuck if I'm judged on that but I hate this pretence that everything is fucking rainbows and unicorns just so that we're all in the same boat to justify someone else's life choices.

They can make their own mind up if they want children but they will know both sides of the story and their decision will be a well informed one, not a fucking fairy story.

VladmirsPoutine · 02/09/2021 09:26

I commend every woman living with the regret - getting by day by day trying to hold/keep it together to give their dc some semblance of a happy childhood.

VanGoSunflowers · 02/09/2021 08:11

And by the way Isthisit many don’t regret their actual children. They regret having to be a parent.
I said upthread that I love my DS but I do not love being a mum.

ttcissoboring · 02/09/2021 08:11

@ClareBlue @Holskey - many parents do though - modern day parenting has become much more helicopter then it used to.

Nowadays children occupying themselves is considered child abuse, at least by many posters on MN. It's crazy.

One lady on a thread the other day was judging parents for checking their phones in a coffee shop when out with DC and not showing them attention?

It's like nowadays your whole life has to disappear and therefore that makes you a great parent (or at least stops judgement from others and parents seem particularly sensitive to judgement these days).

VanGoSunflowers · 02/09/2021 08:06

@Isthisit22

This thread is so sad. People are wasting their lives regretting something they can't change.

Can't imagine regretting my children. They bring me so much love everyday. Watching them find happiness in the smallest things makes me appreciate life. They are so innocent, curious and joyful. I must be lucky. Yes they can be annoying and I do worry for them (and didn't sleep for years) but I cannot relate at all to the idea of regretting them. Very sad.

Trust me, your post does not help women who feel this way. In fact, you’re likely to make others feel quite inadequate. Not everyone is in the same circumstance as you. Not everyone feels the same as you. Is that so hard to understand??
ClareBlue · 01/09/2021 23:36

[quote Holskey]@ttcissoboring
Parents put too much pressure on themselves to put their child's life before theirs and not have a life. Run around after DC with DC ruling everything. Back in the old days DC had to fit into parents life not the other way around

Do you have children? This doesn't sound like something someone with children would say (unless it was someone who had children so long ago they'd forgotten what it was like!)[/quote]
Agree, there are plenty of things parents say but not really this, in these terms anyway.

ClareBlue · 01/09/2021 23:31

@HateJudgmentalPeople

I also never suffered with anxiety until I became a mother, there are too many things to worry about when your a mum and I think I would be in a mental hospital if I had any more, I hate that my daughter is 19 and can go out when she likes, come in when she likes, it’s so worrying and I do tend to think the worst, I need to stop watching true crime things as I get things in my head that may happen to my girl, it’s awful.
Yes, we definitely have irrational fears for our children. Mine are all adults but I felt stressed when one adult daughter was late communicating last week on an arranged time. It's weird because all rational thinking would say I was being unreasonable, but as a parent you genuinely can not stop. And then we have to think what we did to our parents...
Plumtree391 · 01/09/2021 23:16

I 'get' that, Vulva. I'm eternally glad there was no Mumsnet (maybe no internet), when I had mine back in 1979. I had none of the struggles that so many seem to face on here and we got on fine, just muddling through.

VulvaTeeth · 01/09/2021 22:50

Agree but I also think people (parents) need to be tougher standing up to judgements and parenting the way they want to rather than how society/other people expect them to.

Agreed. It's all very well complaining about societal pressure but plenty of people manage to ignore the mummy blogs and the #makingmemories and just get on with it. It's natural to wonder occasionally if you're doing right by your children but good God the endless hand wringing on here about food hobbies and parenting styles. People seem to imagine that the world's looking over their shoulder ready to tell them that Junior shouldn't be eating anything that isn't a hundred percent organic... But, for the most part, no one else gives a crap.