Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was my Sister Insensitive - AIBU?

57 replies

Googleboxfan · 15/08/2021 17:30

I'm having serious marriage and money problem worries. Don't know where I Will live if split is to happen and I am worried sick as I cant afford mortgage etc.
Yesterday I was having a bad day, feeling very panicky and tearful. I asked my sister to meet up with me for a walk.

Sister has been supporting me over the telephone and text for a few months.

I've been particularly stressed out with everything etc.

On our walk my sister had 'a go' at me for not asking how she is. How her house move is going and how my nephews GCSE's had gone and how her holiday went.
In all honesty I didn't even realise results day was Thursday.

I told her I've been extremely stressed out of late and can't seem to focus on things with the worry.

She just continued and said I should ask how she is and that it is bad I didn't even text her to ask. I told her she is being very selfish and insensitive considering the circumstances.

She also said there is nothing more she can advise me if I don't move out.

I was crying my eyes and I felt like I was close to the edge as can't cope no more with criticism. I eventually calmed myself down and we both apologised to each other.

AiBU towards my sister or was she being insensitive and selfish?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Lokdok · 16/08/2021 22:39

YABVU. I’m sorry you’re going through such a tough time though. Everyone has struggles though, and it’s just the right thing to do to ask how someone else is.

Boombadoom · 16/08/2021 22:30

@HunterHearstHelmsley I had pretty much the exact same thing with a friend recently. She told me I had no idea what she was going through… after hearing it for 18 months with nothing back for me in that entire period. I did cut her off and I feel incredibly free. It was so insensitive and hurtful and I couldn’t get past it.

ThePoint678 · 15/08/2021 20:40

After so long supporting you please don’t now suggest you meet and she can’t speak about her life. How rude.

I have lost a once great friend in similar circumstances. I spent years supporting her through her difficult break up then one day, years later, realised she had no clue what was going on in my life. I was basically her unpaid therapist. It was very sad. She also thought I was so unreasonable for not continuing to devote my life to her even though her problems had been resolved by then.

Time to wake up OP.

HunterHearstHelmsley · 15/08/2021 20:39

I have a friend like this. I've supported her with everything she needs for the best part of a year now. I had some bad news a few weeks back.. She phoned me on the day to moan about something and didn't even check in. It really hurt.

I've taken a step back now. It's not fair to put someone under that amount of pressure and never reciprocate.

If she called me insensitive then I'd probably cut her off.

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 15/08/2021 20:37

Yabu, just because you have problems doesn’t meant everyone else doesn’t or have life positives that you cannot even ask them how they are doing.

Relationships are only workable if it’s a two way friendship, not me, myself and I!

owlbethere · 15/08/2021 20:28

I can understand why you haven’t asked, when you’re wrapped up in your own worries it’s very easy to forget thst other people have concerns too and also need some support or interest shown in them.
I think some previous posters are a little harsh, if you don’t have kids in gcse year yourself why would you know when results day is? Particularly this year when it’s not at the usual time.
But I think your sister is right to remind you that she also needs your support sometimes.

queenMab99 · 15/08/2021 19:51

I think when you are in such a distressed state it is very hard to imagine that other people's lives are carrying on as normal, that people are going on holiday, or looking forward to a new house. It reminds me of that song, 'why does the sun go on shining, why does the sea rush to shore, don't they know it's the end of the world....................' I remember pegging out washing after a shocking bereavement, and thinking 'what am I doing! He is dead!'
I don't think your sister was being unreasonable, from her point of view, because if she has never been in your situation, she won't realise just how your mind has gone into a place where nothing except your immediate survicval matters, and protecting your children from knowing how dreadful you feel takes all your energy. You will get through it, don't panic, just keep going, write lists of things you need to deal with, and maybe get an appointment with your GP.

LadyCatStark · 15/08/2021 19:16

@Undisclosedlocation

So half an hour ago, you thought she was unreasonable And now you have been told by 100% of mumsnetters that yabu, you decide that in fact you have apologised to her several times and we’re definitely in the wrong?

Doesn’t really add up, does it?

Yes this! It’s really poor to not even ask about your nephews GCSE results. It’s been all over the news and surely, knowing that this was the year he’d taken them you’d take a teeny moment to find out when the results were out. You could even have asked your sister the last time you spoke to her if you’d have been interested. I bet this has been bubbling under the surface for her for a while and the GCSE results were the final straw.
SuperSketchy · 15/08/2021 18:32

You've done brilliantly to sort this out with her op. I also see your sister's point, but at the same time I can imagine how tough things are, going through a possible divorce and money worries. I get why you maybe became a little too absorbed in your own problems to ask her how she was. I think having a "no woes" policy outings would be good Flowers

Hekatestorch · 15/08/2021 18:31

Lots of people are calling you self-absorbed, but I think that it's far more complex than that. You're in a massively stressful period of your life and are very scared. Not knowing if you'll have a home or how you'll support yourself must be terrifying and all-consuming.

I disagree with this entirely. I fled my abusive marriage with 2 kids and slept on a frienda sofa with 2 kids. Got a house, then started getting letters through the post or things in joint names that I was half liable for. For 4 years I struggled through.

I still maintained 2 way relationships throughout this. I am not amazing or think I am perfect and sometimes I can imagine, it was sometimes a bit one sided. I still knew when my best friends dd had her first day of school and sent messages. Still asked her and supported her through her own stress.

Op sounds very down, but her sister is right. Everything has been about her to the exclusion of everything to do with her sister.

Googleboxfan · 15/08/2021 18:28

I told her I love her and we cuddled each other and kissed each others cheek. We do love each other and are very close

OP posts:
Soverymuchfruit · 15/08/2021 18:22

Sounds like you (both?) handled the conversation badly. When she started trekking you you'd forgotten to ask about her life, that was your cue to ask. Not defend yourself about why you hadn't. Of course it didn't help if she framed this as telling you off. But being defensive is seldom constructive.

Tell her you love her and then explicitly ask about this stuff.

Bluntness100 · 15/08/2021 18:01

@Googleboxfan

Yes. I definitely see that I am in the wrong and have apologised to my sister a few times now as I feel very guilty.
What since you started the thread 30 mins ago asking if sh was selfish and insensitive?
Clydesider · 15/08/2021 18:00

Lots of people are calling you self-absorbed, but I think that it's far more complex than that. You're in a massively stressful period of your life and are very scared. Not knowing if you'll have a home or how you'll support yourself must be terrifying and all-consuming.

Yes, it would have been polite to ask how your sister was, and I'm sure you'll do that in future, but I also think she was wrong to have a go at you. It seems cruel, to me, to heap more distress on someone who is stressed to hell already.

Bluntness100 · 15/08/2021 17:59

She should not have apologised, she’s nothing to apologise for.

The fact you started this thread is concerning. It’s like you feel her role is to support you and be there for you and that she, her family and her life is quite frankly irrelevant and not remotely important.. You didn’t even ask about yout own nephews results, or even how she was.

If this had been a sudden trauma over a week or so, it would be very different. But it seems this has been drama for months. So there’s no excuse.

Take her ar her word, if you refuse to leave then you need to stop with the drama and there is nothing more she can advise you on

Undisclosedlocation · 15/08/2021 17:58

So half an hour ago, you thought she was unreasonable
And now you have been told by 100% of mumsnetters that yabu, you decide that in fact you have apologised to her several times and we’re definitely in the wrong?

Doesn’t really add up, does it?

Googleboxfan · 15/08/2021 17:58

@mbosnz

Well, good on you for seeing that you have been in the wrong and apologising.

Breaking up, I imagine, is hellish, especially with money worries compounding it.

But moving house and supporting kids through these exams ain't a walk in the park either!

Maybe the two of you could do with agreeing to meet up to just enjoy each other's company, no talking about anyone's woes allowed?

That's a good idea. Will do this. Take our kids to the park and I won't moan about my problems
OP posts:
Lumpwoody · 15/08/2021 17:57

If you know you were in the wrong and have apologised, why did you start this thread asking if your sister was in the wrong?

mbosnz · 15/08/2021 17:56

Well, good on you for seeing that you have been in the wrong and apologising.

Breaking up, I imagine, is hellish, especially with money worries compounding it.

But moving house and supporting kids through these exams ain't a walk in the park either!

Maybe the two of you could do with agreeing to meet up to just enjoy each other's company, no talking about anyone's woes allowed?

fringeneedsatrim · 15/08/2021 17:56

You've apologised several times, so long as it was genuine and you've learnt from it, stop feeling guilty and move on. Good luck with all your stuff x

Starlightstarbright1 · 15/08/2021 17:55

Yabu..

You can have problems and take time for other peoples problems too.

It sounds like you have spent months talking, very little action and the world moves on.

Your basic question should be how are you ?

Hekatestorch · 15/08/2021 17:54

So you apologised, but still felt she was insensitive?

Sounds like you have got to a place where your problems are all consuming and yoh aren't thinking about other people. You seem to have forgotten they have lives too.

Googleboxfan · 15/08/2021 17:54

Yes. I definitely see that I am in the wrong and have apologised to my sister a few times now as I feel very guilty.

OP posts:
ohthatbloodycat · 15/08/2021 17:54

YABU.

LagunaBubbles · 15/08/2021 17:53

Sounds like she's a bit fed up and resentful you've made it all about you only.