Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Council tax exemption for a student who earns very well

64 replies

tiredofwork · 15/08/2021 15:58

Just for traffic / out of interest, following an offline discussion with someone.

Do you think someone who is a full-time student but also brings in a very good wage (say, £50K-£60K, a mature student still working in their previous profession) should be entitled to claim student exemption from the council tax (around £2K, they are a homeowner)?

YABU - no, this is a measure designed for young people with pocket money wages and rented shared households, this student is an atypical case and should not exploit this opportunity.

YANBU - they are legally entitled to it due to being a student, and there's nothing morally wrong with it.

OP posts:
tiredofwork · 15/08/2021 18:00

@beigebrownblue

Also, which part of a part-time Masters in any subject (whilst doing a job at the same time) can possibly be described as 'laid back'?

It's hard work. Have you ever tried to do it?

Well, I don't really want to say what the subject is, but something like philosophy. Technically yes, 21+ hours but practically can be condensed into a couple of hours / week.
OP posts:
bruffin · 15/08/2021 18:00

@tiredofwork
I know, but she doesnt want to ask . She is moving out when her lease finishes and getting a smaller place with an earner.
She knew she would have to pay CT but not that much. Its a large 5 bed house so a high band.

burnoutbabe · 15/08/2021 18:00

I have claimed for the last 2 years. So we get 25% discount as I am disregarded and partner gets single person rates.

I am doing a second degree "for fun" and probably a masters too. I also worked one day a week getting 1/5 of my old "head accountant" salary.
It's hardly a scam. It's the sane as Rich older people getting winter fuel allowance. I also claim student discounts when offered and travel discounts. It's not really any sort of moral decision.

I also paid for the degree in full.

beigebrownblue · 15/08/2021 17:56

Also, which part of a part-time Masters in any subject (whilst doing a job at the same time) can possibly be described as 'laid back'?

It's hard work. Have you ever tried to do it?

AdventuresDownRabbitholes · 15/08/2021 17:54

Is it really any different to relatively wealthy pensioners / people working past pensionable age claiming
Free TV licences (until recently)
Free prescriptions
Attendance Allowance
Bus passes

Or indeed anyone who doesn't strictly need something claiming it, even though they're entitled?

tiredofwork · 15/08/2021 17:53

@TractorAndHeadphones

Also to add - the number of people who are 'full time' students but still working must be very very small - you need at least 21 hours of coursework a week to be considered full time. I didn't even think it was possible. If this is real then kudos to them and you sound a bit jealous...
No, not jealous at all. I am the student in this scenario, to be fully transparent.
OP posts:
beigebrownblue · 15/08/2021 17:53

@Mummyoflittledragon

As this is a hobby degree, I 100% think the person should be paying full council tax.
OP thinks it is a 'hobby' degree, but we have no idea what they are studying and other people may have other opinions. Studying has been known to help stave off dementia and so for the over fifties (as i am) in my book that is a good enough reason for studying anything at all.
tiredofwork · 15/08/2021 17:52

@ErrolTheDragon

I'm just surprised they've got time for extra admin if they're doing a full time job and a full time degree (i can't see the point paying for and doing one which isn't pretty much as much work as a full time job).
It is not a full time job, and the degree is a masters so quite laid back.
OP posts:
ErrolTheDragon · 15/08/2021 17:50

I'm just surprised they've got time for extra admin if they're doing a full time job and a full time degree (i can't see the point paying for and doing one which isn't pretty much as much work as a full time job).

tiredofwork · 15/08/2021 17:47

@Skiptheheartsandflowers

Do you pay over and above what you're required to in tax, OP?

I'm far more concerned about companies who make massive profits exploiting loopholes in order to avoid paying tax, than I am about one individual who will be in this position for 3 years maximum.

I agree re the large scale tax optimisation schemes, but in this case it is more about the morality of personal decision making. And I agree that closing this loophole (i.e. making the benefit income-based) probably would cost more money than keeping it open. My question was more about whether you think it is right or wrong as personal decision making (as you have to apply for it explicitly, it is not automatic).
OP posts:
Suzi888 · 15/08/2021 17:45

In the grand scheme of thingsConfusedthey are entitled to it and it disadvantages no one.

tiredofwork · 15/08/2021 17:43

@bruffin

My dd has just graduated but staying on in the same house that is otherwise all students and has to pay 2000 in council tax by herself earning 25k and that is with the 25% discount
This is bizarre... I think she has (at least a moral) case to share the load a bit more equally between the tenants. That's more than one month of her salary gone on the council tax only!
OP posts:
drpet49 · 15/08/2021 17:41

No they shouldn’t be entitled to free council tax

TractorAndHeadphones · 15/08/2021 17:40

Also to add - the number of people who are 'full time' students but still working must be very very small - you need at least 21 hours of coursework a week to be considered full time.
I didn't even think it was possible.
If this is real then kudos to them and you sound a bit jealous...

Reallyreallyborednow · 15/08/2021 17:35

My dd has just graduated but staying on in the same house that is otherwise all students and has to pay 2000 in council tax by herself earning 25k and that is with the 25% discount

When I was a student I took in my jobless brother. It took him a year to find a job- he did a couple of unpaid internships etc.

In some wierd loophole this meant I was liable for the full 75% of council tax. Even though my brother was unemployed, and had we not been related we would have had a complete exemption- because we were related I was expected to support him during his unemployment, which meant i was liable for the council tax!

TractorAndHeadphones · 15/08/2021 17:30

Degrees are expensive and cost a lot of time and money so no, I don't begrudge anyone studying taking advantage of anything the government offers.
If it's a 'hobby' degree it's likely to be even more expensive (at least £7000 a year) so they're still putting in several thousand of their own money.

girlmom21 · 15/08/2021 17:13

Thanks for clarifying @bruffin - I was just being nosey really Smile

memberofthewedding · 15/08/2021 17:06

I claimed CT exemption right upto the time I finished my Ph.d. I was also working at the uni as a tutor. However I believe in claiming all the concessions you legally can.

Stealbee · 15/08/2021 17:04

I don't imagine many people would be enough of a martyr to pay council tax when they don't have to, why would you?

ErrolTheDragon · 15/08/2021 17:01

If she's no longer a student and is living with other adults is she actually entitled to the 25% off?
Is that because she's the only non-student so the others don't class as 'adults'?
If there's only one person in a house paying council tax they get a reduction whether there's others who don't have to pay or not, I assume. That seems entirely correct.

pinkyredrose · 15/08/2021 17:01

They should abide by the law

They are!

TheUndoingProject · 15/08/2021 17:01

I think expecting people to volunteer to pay more tax is a very high moral standard. They’re entitled to the exemption and changing that would cost more to administer than would be clawed back.

bruffin · 15/08/2021 16:59

@girlmom21
From the council website
If there is only one person who is not in full time education in the house they are liable for council tax but will get a 25% reduction on their bill.

LadyCatStark · 15/08/2021 16:58

They’ll be paying a shit load of tax and national insurance while some people get everything handed to them on a plate so why shouldn’t they claim what they’re entitled to??

newnortherner111 · 15/08/2021 16:57

They should abide by the law, and if this loophole exists, perhaps get your MP to campaign for a change.

Swipe left for the next trending thread