Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To make visitors wear masks when holding our newborn

162 replies

pearlsandpetals · 15/08/2021 13:18

Hi everyone! I'm currently pregnant and due later this year.. I've started thinking about what measures to put into place to keep our baby safe, particularly if covid cases are high at the time and also because it will be the middle of winter and cold/flu season. I'm thinking that anyone who wishes to hold our newborn baby should have to wear a mask and sanitise hands first. My partner disagrees with the mask wearing and thinks that it's not fair to ask family to wear them, as they will want nice photos with the baby. I also think want there should be a limit on the number of visitors until our baby is at least a couple of months old. I want just close family members and people who have been played a part during the pregnancy to visit. Are these things unreasonable? I don't want to be made to feel like it is OTT but I just want to do everything I can to make sure our baby is safe and healthy whilst her immune system is so fragile.

OP posts:
LagunaBubbles · 16/08/2021 08:00

Apart from hand washing very OTT. Do you have problems with anxiety in general?

Aggy35 · 16/08/2021 07:58

I am not surprised at the comments as so many people have underestimated covid and/or disregarded rules.We were given 2 m distance to follow for all of us and yet golding the baby whilst breathing on it etc should be fine? I'm sorry nice pics comes last.If the baby catches covid he /she could be in serious trouble.I am not originally from UK and where I come from it is actually a custom only for the close family to visit new born for the first month exactly because they are so vulnerable and shouldn't be passed from hand to hands.

Arcminute · 16/08/2021 07:52

I had a baby last year. We didn’t really have any visitors because restrictions were much higher than they are now. But for those few who we did see I did not make them wear masks. We perceived the risks to us as a family and to the baby to be very different.

At the time, the risks were considered to be higher from us to other people because we had been in contact with HCPs and in medical settings and were far more likely to have picked it up there ourselves.

ttcsucks · 16/08/2021 07:51

For a start OP, masks provide limited protection and really only in crowded places. If someone is visiting in your living room say there for an hour and has Covid, the mask isn't going to do a lot.

As you asked for opinions I think you sound massively OTT and I'd do a massive eye roll if you were one of my friends or family members.

You probably ought to be more concerned ought to be more concerned about older family members getting Covid than your new born, they are the people at risk here.

Your fear is illogical and not based on any facts.

If anything perhaps ask them to get tested, I think that's more reasonable than asking for masks.

Ticksallboxes · 16/08/2021 07:47

You are absolutely not being unreasonable.

I've been very relaxed throughout the pandemic but I would definitely limit visitors in the way you've suggested - I did in a normal year as I was exhausted.

I would also totally understand being asked to wash my hands and wear a mask to hold your baby. You can get some lovely photos a few months later.

Anything else just isn't worth the risk.

User5827372728 · 16/08/2021 07:37

I think MN gives unvaccinated pregnant women a hard time during this. I can understand why many women are unsure of the vaccine as it’s something that hasn’t been given to pregnant women before.

Especially black women, who already may have a lack of trust in medical staff and the Government.

supersonicginandtonic · 16/08/2021 07:02

Ridiculous, absolutely ridiculous! Covid is hardly a high risk to a newborn. Get the vaccination and Pass on the antibodies. The biggest risk to your baby at present is YOU catching covid and YOU being hospitalised due to a bad case, because YOU are unvaccinated. The baby is then at very high risk if being born prematurely.
I had my baby at the beginning of April and we were still being advised not to be vaccinated. A fellow expectant mum got covid abd was in ICU very poorly. She nearly lost her baby. She is now campaigning for mums to do their research and get vaccinated.
You need to let your baby build an immune system. Masks isn't the way to do that. There so many young babies, hospitalised at Present due to respiratory illnesses. This is being outdown to lockdowns abd people's immune systems being affected.
Also your pictures, your memories will look ridiculous

Ginfilledcats · 16/08/2021 06:39

Family wore masks the first time they met my baby but it was last year in the height of covid when it was illegal for my own mother to visit me after a traumatic birth. However by the second visit the masks went. But I will say family were very good about washing their hands and using anti bac and always wore clean clothes when they came. Over the passing weeks our nervousness relaxed.

Staryflight445 · 16/08/2021 06:36

Without me having to ask I mean, I definitely would send a message when baby is here reiterating what would make you comfortable during visits to keep everyone safe, in particular your baby who is trying to get used to the surroundings outside of the womb and isn’t strong enough for many infections.

Staryflight445 · 16/08/2021 06:35

You’re not being unreasonable at all, anyone with any respect for you would walk in and wash their hands regardless of covid.
My mil always did this when she came to visit our babies when they were ‘fresh’.

BritWifeInUSA · 16/08/2021 04:37

Another one who thinks an anti bacterial hand sanitizer will protect against a virus?

Hand sanitizing is not a bad idea at any time. Especially if people are coming into the house after being on public transport or at work. But YABVU if you think it will stop COVID.

ElleGee1 · 16/08/2021 04:14

Also people who are saying risk to babies is low. If that was the case fine. Bit extreme here but yeah that’s fine, just let the parents catch it then. Just because people are vaccinated doesent mean you won’t be ill with it and then having to look after a new born

ElleGee1 · 16/08/2021 04:05

Your baby, you choose. Will the people who are telling you this is ridiculous be dealing with a baby with covid should the worse happen ? No. Do what you feel comfortable with. I’m 8weeks post partum, had visitors right away, all had been vaccinated and they didn’t wear masks but I did ask them all to wash hands. No problems and no one raised an eyebrow. Tbf 3 years ago when I had my first people washed their hands without being asked.
I’m still waiting on my 2nd dose. I have a friend who is a non believer, won’t have vaccine and is out every night (lol not jealous at all 🤣). That made me feel a bit uncomfortable but I’m seeing her soon as baby will be a little older.
Just because restrictions have now changed doesent mean the risk is gone. My baby had a cough and cold like symptoms in first few days, I asked midwife if risk to babies was low, she said no one really knows. Be aware of isolating yourself , if people are well let them help you, my mum works in Gp practice and would do a lateral flow before coming to see baby, never asked her to but helped ease any worry about her being in an environment where she might catch covid.

octoberfarm · 16/08/2021 04:01

Surprised by some of the responses here. I don't think you're being OTT about hand washing or mask wearing at all. Huge congrats on your upcoming arrival, OP Smile

ImAddictedToMyPhone · 16/08/2021 03:27

Sorry to be brutal but you obviously wasn't that concerned about covid before you started trying for a baby. 🙄

MissTrip82 · 16/08/2021 02:47

I’d be more worried about RSV. We’ve had a terrible run of it as covid restrictions eased.

People should certainly wash their hands before cuddling the baby. I wouldn’t worry as much about masks but it’s your choice.

Saoirse82 · 16/08/2021 02:36

@Ilovechinese you're misinformed, babies are higher risk than older children as their immune systems aren't fully developed. And even older children aren't without risk. Yes, overall they are still fairly low risk but why would you want to take any risks if they can be avoided?
And if OP isn't vaccinated how will she pass on antibodies through breast milk to a newborn? It takes months to build up full immunity through being double vaccinated and by then the baby will no longer be new born Confused
And playing a part in someone's pregnancy may be accompanying them to scans or midwife appointments, helping decorate the nursery etc not just touching her bump 🙄

Ilovechinese · 16/08/2021 02:24

😂😂 sorry but I think its stupid! Babies and children aren't at risk from covid and like someone else mentioned imagine the photos and your baby looking at them when they are older seeing everyone in masks. Like something out of a horror movie! Agree with someone else that breastfeeding is the best way to pass natural antibodies and strengthen your babies immune system. I definitely wouldn't be taking the vaccines whilst pregnant as no one can no what the long term effects will be on the baby. Also how can people play a part in your pregnancy? Do you mean like just sharing your excitement and touching the bump? Not sure what else they could do to play a part lol

Saoirse82 · 15/08/2021 22:50

YANBU. Friend and her newborn were close contacts with covid case when baby was 9 days old and it was a very upsetting time for her as at the same there was a 3 week old baby from our area in ICU with covid.
I'm due in November and although I won't be asking people to wear masks I am only allowing people who are double vaccinated to visit. I couldn't really give a shit what other people think about this, it's not open for debate. This doesn't include family children though as they can't be vaccinated. Its about reducing the risk, we can't eliminate it. That's why my friends who aren't vaccinated aren't getting over the door if cases are high as they are covid deniers and I don't think I'd 100% trust them to say if they'd started having symptoms since they don't believe it's real!
I wouldn't worry what other people think, i don't care if people think I'm being overly precious as it'll make me feel less anxious and that can only be a good thing. I'm double vaccinated so hope the baby will have some anti bodies but i got my first dose before getting pregnant and 2nd at 16 weeks so I'm not 100% sure and it's probably something I need to research a bit more.

LionGiraffe · 15/08/2021 22:29

It’s your baby, so your rules, so you’re not being unreasonable. However, I wouldn’t personally do what you’re proposing and if someone told me I’d have to mask up and sanitise I’d probably just politely decline to hold the baby.

We had a baby during the lockdown and I was very strict about grandparents only seeing her within the rules, outdoors only when permitted etc. It’s my biggest regret - I should’ve just broken the rules and let them see their grandchild.

Yaty · 15/08/2021 22:19

I think there are some harsh responses here. I had a baby last summer just after 1st lockdown. I was anxious as well to start and just had grandparents and siblings visiting. They all washed their hands and wore masks when holding the baby and no one cared or at least no one said they did. Didn't have any other visitors for a while but this was still when people weren't really seeing each other in houses anyway. I can see why you are anxious, we've been in a pandemic ffs, some of these responses are really dismissive of that. I would say though you might change your mind once the baby is here. After the first few weeks I did relax and wasn't bothered about masks etc. As others have said best thing for your baby is for you to be vaccinated before birth so baby has some antibodies.

BunnytheFriendlyDragon · 15/08/2021 22:12

Saying that some of my relatives have come in masks but then it annoys me when the mask is over their mouth and not their nose. It's more annoying than if they didn't bother!

BunnytheFriendlyDragon · 15/08/2021 22:12

Tbh I don't think it's OTT to want people to wear masks and wash hands but unfortunately the majority will not think of this / offer to do so and I honestly found it difficult to raise especially with DH family. My family were more inclined to come in a mask.

I have been nervous about people holding him though so I haven't automatically just let people do so.

If you want to ask them to wear masks etc then do it OP and good on you for being up front.

Boopeedoop · 15/08/2021 22:10

Also to add, I work on an ambulance Last night I took dealt with a 4 week old covid positive baby. His great grandmother died of covid as I was tending to him.

Covid is still here and it's not a joke.

Boopeedoop · 15/08/2021 22:08

My niece has a new baby and I wear a mask and do an lft before I see baby.

Wash hands and antibac before touching her too.

I love that baby too much to risk her life.