Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Told dd off, now feel crap about it (guilt) but I think I was right

34 replies

StrawberryJaM6 · 15/08/2021 12:58

Sorry, long winded title

I suffer from guilt if I tell my dc off due to my own abusive childhood but I know they need discipline so I do it when necessary.

Anyway, last week dd (13) had asked politely for a few things (haircut, manicure and some new bits for our holiday coming up)
I booked her hair appt
I did her nails for her
I got her clothes as swimwear (that SHE picked)

All was fine. Asked her today to please start packing so we are organised

I’ve been told she … hates her hair. She had removed the nail colour as didn’t like it anymore (took me ages 😡)
Doesn’t like her clothes wants different.

I’ve told she’s been rude and ungrateful that I won’t be taking anything back as she chose it. Today’s plans were lunch out but she was so rude and I just felt had a go at and unappreciated that I said sorry it’s lunch at home because I had no desire to go out after getting up to be spoken to like that.

Now apparently ive ruined the day. Which has made me feel guilty but why should I put up with being treated so rudely.

I’m planning to just go out alone at some point for a walk and I hope she realises how rude she was

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheYearOfSmallThings · 16/08/2021 15:47

Yes, either someone has spoilt her pleasure in her new clothes/hair/nails, or perhaps they just haven't been as transformative as she hoped. It is a difficult age and I wouldn't go back there for anything.

Having said that, she does not get to behave like an arsehole without consequences to herself. Nobody does, and you don't need to feel guilty about that.

I would talk to her about it if she's willing, though.

steppemum · 16/08/2021 15:39

@YouJustDoYou

I honestly don't understand excuses for poor manners and shitty behaviour. She's not an idiot just because she's 13. She is fully capable of understanding how She speaks to someone has repercussions ie- does she speak to her friends like shit? Her teacher? Her bf/he? Of course not. Because mum is fair game. I was a 13 year old. I respected my parents. I wasn't stupid, I just understood that you simply don't speak in certain ways or treat ANYONE in a bad way, parent or not. Stop giving excuses to teens.
well then you are amazing and I'm sure your mum was veyr proud of you.

Back in the real world, some teens find it harder than others to negotiate the landmine of friends and hormones.

I have 3, the older 2 were like you, and knew the boundariesa and could self impose them. But my youngest has found it really hard. She is 13, and we will get these uncontrolled massive outbursts of temper and rudeness.

At the time, the only thing that works is to let it go. Then later once the emotional outburst is over, we can talk about HOW she has spoken, and why it is not OK, and what she could have done instead to express how she is feeling.

It isn't always a choice, sometimes it is a overwhelming dump of emotion that they just don;t know what to do with. Often she is massively wound up about something completely different and it takes a while for the emotion to get allocated to the right thing. That may be an argument with a friend or worry about school, and it comes out as a rant at mum over dinner.

It is not about giving them excuses, or allowing bad behaviour, but it is about helping them to understand and negotiate their own emotional life

WhenZoomWasJustAnIceLolly · 15/08/2021 18:38

I think you were OTT tbh.

Teenage girls are insecure about their appearance and are full of hormones.
It was fine to say no, that she chose the clothes and you weren’t changing them (unless you were prepared to exchange them), but cancelling lunch out wasn’t necessary imo.

Perhaps you didn’t listen to how she felt? Have you never had a haircut you hated or changed your mind about an outfit you bought after trying it on at home? Perhaps her delivery of the message wasn’t ideal but she’s 13 and all that was needed really was to remind her to phrase it politely, sympathise and find a solution together.

YouJustDoYou · 15/08/2021 18:36

She's allowed to not like something, but she's not stupid, she should know by now it's rude to shit over something someone's gone to the effort of organising and paying for. I mean, ffs.

YouJustDoYou · 15/08/2021 18:34

I honestly don't understand excuses for poor manners and shitty behaviour. She's not an idiot just because she's 13. She is fully capable of understanding how She speaks to someone has repercussions ie- does she speak to her friends like shit? Her teacher? Her bf/he? Of course not. Because mum is fair game. I was a 13 year old. I respected my parents. I wasn't stupid, I just understood that you simply don't speak in certain ways or treat ANYONE in a bad way, parent or not. Stop giving excuses to teens.

TheSmallAssassin · 15/08/2021 18:28

Was she actually rude, or did she just say she didn't like her hair, the colour, the clothes? My daughter is always having crises of confidence and it can come out badly. I really wouldn't take it personally, her taking the nail polish off hasn't spoiled your pleasure doing it. Unless she has actually been nasty to you, I'd just let it be water off a ducks back. Being a teenaged girl is hard!

I think you are taking it hard because of your comparisons with your mum and how you wish that had been - that's not on your daughter!

A couple of books that might be helpful

The Book You Wish Your Parents Had Read: (And Your Children Will Be Glad That You Did) g.co/kgs/Za4znP

Get Out of My Life but First Could You Drive Me and Cheryl to the Mall? g.co/kgs/mAA4ii

Iggly · 15/08/2021 18:19

It’s difficult. I understand your reaction - I know the guilt having a shit childhood myself.

It’s worth reading the Philippa Perry book “the book you wish your parents had read”. It helps to process your reactions to your kids behaviour.

The fact is - she’s allowed to not like things, that’s her opinion. She just needs to be careful how she expresses that - and she’s learning but she’s only 13.

I’ve learnt with mine - we’ve learnt together - to be mindful of the other person when giving feedback but I try and be the grown up when they don’t like what I’ve done for them (DD will preface it with “I don’t want to be rude/please don’t be offended).

ohthatbloodycat · 15/08/2021 18:08

I think you're overreacting. Better that she confides in you about her feelings, than bottles it up because you'll take it so personally.

junebirthdaygirl · 15/08/2021 18:04

Just be ready for for some more mixed up thinking from your dd as the teen years go by. A lot of that is to do with their own insecurities and nothing to do with you as a mom. I found it helpful to chat to friends who had girls of the same age as seeing others were the same reminded me to let some stuff over my head. You are right not to put up with rudeness but things are changing and it may trigger stuff from your own teenage years. She won't always be grateful and changing her mind and being confused may be come the name of the game for a while.

LuaDipa · 15/08/2021 17:42

@MatildaTheCat

You were right to tell her off BUT at 13 she will be very hormonal, is probably doubting her choices, convinced everything looks awful on her and obviously it’s your fault because that’s how it goes at 13 Smile.

Have a chat with her and ask what it is she’s upset with and reassure her that she does look nice and the items do suit her.

It’s not a nice age for lots of young teens.

Agree with this. I took dd out and bought masses of new clothes for our recent holiday. We had a lovely day and she was really happy with everything she chose. We went away and she ended up wearing the same (old) 3/4 scruffy outfits on repeat. I was upset but realised quickly that it wasn’t about me, she was just feeling conscious of herself and her changing shape. It was such a shame as she looked so beautiful in her new things, but it wasn’t about me so I let it go and told her she looked lovely in the outfits she did wear.

I don’t think you were wrong to let her know that you were upset and hurt at the way she spoke to you, but I don’t think this has anything to do with gratitude and I think it would be helpful if you try and reframe the way you view this situation.

LitPearl · 15/08/2021 15:16

@NinjaBreadMan

My best is she was feeling good, snapped a picture and sent to her friends and someone, feeling jealous, has snapped back taking the piss.
oh bingo. Would put money on it.
LitPearl · 15/08/2021 15:15

Yes I bet it's insecurity about her appearance.

I'm similar to you, my mother was a very difficult tough woman and not sympathetic to me at all. If I ever cried she flew in to a rage, even if I was trying to hide it from her and /or if it was nothing to do with her.

My own daughter and I have a better relationship but i asked her if she'd ''allow'' me to choose and outfit for her because she always wears grey tracksuits. Initially she as gung ho with this plan. We ended up having a big fight because everything I tried to suggest to her was dismissed instantly and she was so rude to me, in the end she was crying saying she looked fat in everything. So that is the reason she tore my head off.

I agree that there is a limit to how much it's acceptable to DUMP on to your mother. I have accepted to much because my mother was so awful to me when I was upset. Precisely at the moment I needed support I got more abuse. So it is hard not to slip in to a pattern where your daughter is taking her issues out on you.

I recently banned my daughter from saying the word fat though, to me. I have just listened to her going on about being fat for at least a year now and she never does anything about it. She gets angry with me for what she thinks I'm thinking (ie, that she's fat) but really, it's what she's thinking.

QueenBee52 · 15/08/2021 15:10

@1forAll74

All this talk about a teenager being hormonal, is not an excuse for a teenager being ungrateful about the things that people have done for her,, she should be of the age,to have some proper manners by now.

exactly

1forAll74 · 15/08/2021 15:08

All this talk about a teenager being hormonal, is not an excuse for a teenager being ungrateful about the things that people have done for her,, she should be of the age,to have some proper manners by now.

NinjaBreadMan · 15/08/2021 14:56

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

GoWalkabout · 15/08/2021 14:55

She is a totally normal 13 yo, your parenting was fine to point out that she is being ungrateful. But avoid too much emotional weight - don't let her feel responsible for your upset feelings too much. And be pragmatic about the clothes, if she hates them return them but don't immediately provide money for more.

AliceW89 · 15/08/2021 14:53

Playing devils advocate here somewhat…but I’m struggling to see how confiding in you how she feels is rude? I’ve had haircuts and manicures where I’ve been disappointed with the results. I’ve bought clothes and then got them home and thought ‘what was I thinking?’ I agree her timing isn’t great and I’m aware we can’t tell how these things were said (and that is a big thing with 13 year old girls Grin) But fundamentally, expressing her opinions to you isn’t rude, even if you don’t like them or they upset you. It doesn’t sound like a personal attack on you and you need to be careful not to internalise it that way. Anyway I hope you can all enjoy your holiday.

QueenBee52 · 15/08/2021 14:50

@StrawberryJaM6

I’m going to talk to her in case someone has upset her 🙁

good idea 🌸

LagneyandCasey · 15/08/2021 14:49

I agree it's probably a remark from a 'friend' that has planted a seed of doubt in her mind about her appearance. 'My mum did my nails' may have been scoffed at - sad but true Sad

It's really difficult and upsetting but try not to take it too much to heart. Your experiences with your mum weren't good and you're trying your best with your dd as you didn't have that, which is great. Deep down she will appreciate it, and will remember those moments when she's older, but right now she's young and impressionable and finds it hard to realise she's hurting your feelings.

A big unMumsetty hug to you as I've been there with my dd's and know how crushing it is Flowers

AngelsWithSilverWings · 15/08/2021 14:46

My dd13 is just like this and it drives me mad. The number of times I've bought her clothes or paid for a haircut that she "loves loves loves" at the time and then a day later tells me that she hates it all.

It's almost always due to social media/a friend making a negative comment about it. I imagine due to jealousy or a general need to put her down.

UserStillatLarge · 15/08/2021 14:41

yes, she was rude by 13 year olds aren't mature communicators yet so perhaps try to understand what's at the bottom of this?

She can choose not to like her hair and nails even if it was what she wanted. She can change her mind about clothes she chose yesterday. Adults do these things too.

My teen DD is always having wobbles about her hair and clothes. I usually find telling her she looks great (if she does) or talking through what she's concerned about and if there are things she can change is more counter productive than just getting cross. Remember this is not an attack on you - she's venting at you because she can and because she thinks it's a safe space. By all means make it very clear that the way she is expressing her feelings is not appropriate, but try to understand her point of view as well?

SheWoreYellow · 15/08/2021 14:37

*is

SheWoreYellow · 15/08/2021 14:37

Yes deal with the rudeness.

But I’d there any point keeping the clothes if she doesn’t like them?

54321nought · 15/08/2021 14:35

Sounds like she is having a teenage tempertantrum, and taking it out on you.

She needs to know that is NOT ok, and you are upset, and her rudeness has consequences.

In short, she needs to grow up a bit, but she will, she's 13, and she clearly has a lovely mum!

StrawberryJaM6 · 15/08/2021 14:32

I’m going to talk to her in case someone has upset her 🙁

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread