Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DP should get a new place with me

86 replies

littlepieces · 15/08/2021 12:45

DP owns a flat with his brother (25) who he lived with for a couple of years until the brother lost his at the start of the pandemic. Unable to pay the mortgage, the brother went to live at home with their parents in the suburbs, and I moved in with DP, paying for the brother's share of the mortgage.

18 months later, the brother finally has a (remote) job and wants to move back in asap because he's bored at home and Tinder isn't as good there... Their family's expectation is that I'll simply move out, back into a houseshare, and the brother moves back in and continues to live with DP...

DP wants to leave and rent somewhere with me. However, in December they're expecting a huge service charge bill for essential works on the building, circa £40,000 that they don't really have. There could be more costs too. He says he doesn't want to be paying more to rent somewhere when he has this bill to pay. (For us to rent somewhere similar would be more than double the current cost of mortgage and bills).

Aibu to be pretty gutted I have to move back into a random flatshare?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
littlepieces · 30/08/2021 21:52

Actually that's an interesting point, aside from the issue. It hasn't really felt like a progression of the relationship which I think it should. Living together has just been a means to an end.

OP posts:
WTF475878237NC · 16/08/2021 19:31

I have to agree it's been a mutually convenient arrangement, not a progression of the relationship.

Paq · 16/08/2021 17:50

Well @Suprima if he's really a selfish, exploitative git who domestically enslaved OP (and I think you're speculating there) she's better off without him. Which still leaves her back in a house share Grin

Lockheart · 16/08/2021 17:41

[quote Suprima]@Paq

Yes, he’s definitely not her dad Confused

Because no decent father would use her to keep a mortgage paid, then tell her to make other arrangements. No actual partner or friend would do that, unless they were a complete user. It’s a very big step in a relationship and covid gave him the opportunity for them to play house due to convenience and solving an equal problem (he needs the mortgage paid, she’s paying rent anyway, what’s the big deal?)
…but now the pandemic is over, it’s clear this was basically a mutual business agreement, not ‘moving in together’.

This is the problem here. OP has been very convenient to pay him and his brother’s mortgage, and wild speculation- but I’d still bet money- has probably been doing more domestic drudge around the house. But now he doesn’t want to live with her…because of a cladding bill…?

There are very clear workarounds so they could live together. Subletting his place for one, squeezing in for the short term. He is not suggesting these, which clouds how committed he is to their relationship. A conversation needs to be had between them to make sure they are on the same page.[/quote]
Equally, you could say OP has "used" him by benefitting from very cheap rent, as she has said herself.

No-one has exploited anyone here. Both parties have benefitted from the arrangement.

Suprima · 16/08/2021 17:38

@Paq

Yes, he’s definitely not her dad Confused

Because no decent father would use her to keep a mortgage paid, then tell her to make other arrangements. No actual partner or friend would do that, unless they were a complete user. It’s a very big step in a relationship and covid gave him the opportunity for them to play house due to convenience and solving an equal problem (he needs the mortgage paid, she’s paying rent anyway, what’s the big deal?)
…but now the pandemic is over, it’s clear this was basically a mutual business agreement, not ‘moving in together’.

This is the problem here. OP has been very convenient to pay him and his brother’s mortgage, and wild speculation- but I’d still bet money- has probably been doing more domestic drudge around the house. But now he doesn’t want to live with her…because of a cladding bill…?

There are very clear workarounds so they could live together. Subletting his place for one, squeezing in for the short term. He is not suggesting these, which clouds how committed he is to their relationship. A conversation needs to be had between them to make sure they are on the same page.

AlmostSummer21 · 16/08/2021 11:58

I think you need to be SURE that DP WANTS to live with you. His honesty in that is very important.

I get it's a small 2 bdrm (I've rented in London, very familiar with the shoeboxes!) but IF DP genuinely wants to live with you, there are several options that people have already laid out.

Where you all work depends on what you do. But it would seem to me that it's in ALL your best interests to make it work. You carry on paying what you've been paying (as it seems you thought it was reasonable & less than a room share - but check out the 'going rate' for roomshares in poky boxes)

The brother keep splitting the mortgage & bills as they were pre you - if they're both still happy with that and they save your rent towards the cladding costs.

Accommodating one more person WFH isn't actually that difficult if you think outside the box.

You benefit living with DP & cheaper rent than a house share

DP benefits living with you & money towards the cladding

DB benefits not living with parents & money towards cladding costs.

ALL you have to do is be flexible around working space & general living space

It's worth it to ALL of you?!

Cladding bloody well should be paid for by the developers/insurers/govt for approving the cladding...any/all if the above, but not the owners who bought in good faith.

I presume the brothers are signed up to all groups fighting this??

Paq · 16/08/2021 11:55

@Lockheart

ultimately he would happily see you go into a house share with randoms than continue playing house with you.

House shares with "randoms" are a very normal type of accommodation, he's not chucking her out destitute onto the streets.

Agree. He's her boyfriend, not her dad. She's a working adult. She's had many months living at a cheaper rate because her boyfriend's brother lost his job - luckily the living situation benefited both of them - but now circumstances have changed and she has to adapt. Boyfriend can't just click his fingers and absolve himself of the financial and other responsibilities of his flat.

House shares aren't everyone's first choice but they're fine and maybe this will encourage OP to save for her own place.

Suprima · 16/08/2021 11:53

@Lockheart

ultimately he would happily see you go into a house share with randoms than continue playing house with you.

House shares with "randoms" are a very normal type of accommodation, he's not chucking her out destitute onto the streets.

I know…..I’ve lived in many Grin

But however a nice flat share it is with ‘professionals’ and house plants and a friendly cat- he still would rather she lived there, rather than with him.

Lockheart · 16/08/2021 11:30

ultimately he would happily see you go into a house share with randoms than continue playing house with you.

House shares with "randoms" are a very normal type of accommodation, he's not chucking her out destitute onto the streets.

TeeBee · 16/08/2021 11:26

Are they able to sublet though if cladding is the issue? Is it considered unsafe?

Suprima · 16/08/2021 10:49

He could always sublet his room and you get a place together?

Ask why he is not suggesting this.

If he really doesn’t want to rent, there are options for co-working spaces.

Again, he is not suggesting this.

It comes down to ‘if he wanted to, he would’, and he doesn’t want to.

Suprima · 16/08/2021 10:47

Your boyfriend doesn’t want to live with you. You have conveniently paid the mortgage but now the brother is coming back, he doesn’t want this partnership with you.

Dress it up pragmatically however you want ‘finances’ ‘big bill’ ‘not enough space’ - but ultimately he would happily see you go into a house share with randoms than continue playing house with you.

MargosKaftan · 16/08/2021 10:30

It comes down to what your dp wants.

If he wants to live with you, can live with you in the current flat as DB moving back in, can't live elsewhere with DB having a tenant because no friends and DB can't afford alone,then the obvious solution is to rent it out as a BTL, use the rent money to cover the mortgage and give them both a bit extra money, so you can rent your own place and DB can rent. He can go in a flat share with strangers, it happens all the time.

But this will make DPs life a bit harder. The main question is - would living with you make up for that? Or as a PP said, is he hoping you will rent elsewhere by yourself, he will spend most of his time there, but you pay 100% of rent /bills because you live alone and he lives in the flat? Do not fall for that.

Jerseygirl12 · 16/08/2021 10:09

Could you stay living there and rent a work space?

littlepieces · 16/08/2021 09:40

And they plan on selling the flat as soon as it can be sold and paying the 40/50k bill with whatever money they get back from equity/the deposit. Which will probably be most of it 😬

OP posts:
littlepieces · 16/08/2021 09:33

A lot of people have correctly guessed the flat is embroiled in the cladding issues. This means the flat can't be sold until it's all been resolved (both DP and DB would be shot of the bloody flat in a heartbeat if they could be!) so that's kind of an extra layer of difficulty here. It's going to take 1-2 years to fix so if I move out we'll be living apart for probably 2 years.

As for the pokey 2nd bedroom, it was fine for DP's brother pre pandemic. But with 3 of us there working all day, most days, not feasible. There's no room for a desk in either bedroom and the living area barely accommodates 2 people working.

OP posts:
BoomChicka · 16/08/2021 07:55

This is a tricky one, the cladding/repairs needed will presumably mean they can't sell for a decent amount, plus apartments are less favourable than before covid or that would be the obvious answer. If you really can't all fit in the flat in the short to medium term then you or you and dp will have to move. How will they find the 40k for repairs??

Lockheart · 16/08/2021 07:52

Lots of people live in house shares (me included) because they can't afford their own place. It's not ideal and frankly I think it's fucking criminal that rents and house prices are so high that even those with reasonably well-paid professional careers are forced to share but it's hardly the worst thing in the world.

Standrewsschool · 16/08/2021 07:52

18 months is quite a long time for dp to live with you, then decide not to, although I can see dp is stuck in the middle between family and yourself.

If dp and brother move back in together, how long does he envisage this set up to last? Is it temporary with plans to live with you in the future, or permanent?

They ‘re not related to the Mitchell’s are they, where family come first!

Bluntness100 · 16/08/2021 07:46

I can see why you’re upset, but it’s his brothers flat so he’s entitled to live there and your partner is correct, it’s best for him to live there and not pay more rent when he’s got a big bill to pay.

I get why you’re upset though, if you can only afford a house share.

MargosKaftan · 16/08/2021 07:43

If the mortgage is low compared to the rent of a similar property and there's a £40k bill looming, and bil can't afford it alone, but has family who's prepared to let him stay...

If dp wants to live with you, then dp and bil rent out the flat- see if they can remortgage to a btl mortgage to cover the renovation work. Bil rents somewhere he can afford alone and you and dp rent somewhere together, or all 3 of you rent together a property that's big enough for you all?

But if dp now expects you to leave and just go back to being a visitor, then its a sign he would not have asked you to move in previously, you were just a tenant that had the side benefit of sex.

Not sure its worth trying to save that relationship.

Standrewsschool · 16/08/2021 07:21

If brother moves into flat, can he take a lodger which would cover Dp’s part of the mortgage.

You and dp rent a place. Then dp wouldn’t have two lots of rents/mortgages.

Another option would be to sell the flat, and everyone start again afresh.

It seems a but mean to expect you to move out when you’ve been living together.

If dp wants to live with his brother, what does that say about your relationship?

SaltySheepdog · 16/08/2021 07:09

The alternative is that you all live there together and you rent an additional space which everyone can work in on rotation.

Lockheart · 16/08/2021 07:07

If DP and his brother own the flat, I don't think you have any expectation that you could stay and effectively displace his brother.

It sounds like it's been very convenient for you (cheaper "rent") and them (no missed mortgage payments) over lockdown, so I don't think it's a case of anyone exploiting anyone else.

It's a shame and I'd be annoyed too, but in this case I'd just move back out for now.

SaltySheepdog · 16/08/2021 07:07

Move into shared accommodation for a while and leave the brothers to live in their mortgaged house. This 40k payment will come and go, then once things are calmer reassess the situation.