Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my dad could be more generous with his money

169 replies

Thewholeshackshimmy · 15/08/2021 09:37

Firstly, I love and care for my parents greatly.
I am 48, my dad 80 and mum 78. I have always been close to them and live just around the corner from them.
Although dad is in good health and still active my mum is not. She has a few health issues, the main one being that she suffers from Alzheimer’s. My dad has not coped very well with her diagnosis, he is angry with it and regularly picks her up on everything she forgets about and the things she does. He cooks for her but not much else, he seems to think if he keeps reminding her then she will do the thinks she is forgetting to do.
I check in on them almost every day. My dsis pops in twice a week and helps with cleaning (she runs her own cleaning company).
I organise everything else, all of my mums appointments, I arranged Attendance Allowance for her and I got dad a reduction in his council tax. I arranged for mum to go to a day centre once a week to give dad a break (I take her there and collect her), I organise and order mums meds (which are delivered once a month, I wash and blow dry her hair (sometimes my dsis does this too), I cut and paint her nails to make her feel better.
I don’t think she is showering as much as she should and dad doesn’t supervise her with this.
TBH as much as I adore my mum I don’t want to do any personal care, that just isn’t me I am not good with those sort of things. I feel guilty about this, I really do.
I will ask dad things like ‘is there any washing to be done?’ and I get a ‘How would I know??’ 🤷‍♀️ Yet I look in the dirty linen basket, which is always half full with his bloody clothes and I feel like saying ‘well you must have bloody put the stuff in there!’ So I do their washing too.
If I (or my sister) suggest that he needs to step up a little and do more around the house and for mum he gets all irritated and says he’s 80, he’s old, he shouldn’t have to do all these things!!
I have suggested a carer but they refuse and mum gets upset saying she is useless and wants to die and she doesn’t want a stranger in caring for her.
I don’t get any money for helping out and haven’t and would never ask. I haven’t ever asked my parents for any money and they have never given me any, even after my grandparents passed and they inherited money from them. I left home 23+ years ago.
Dad will give me £10 or £20 here and there as a thank you or offer me fuel, I ey occasionally if I use my car to drive mum somewhere.
I usually receive £30 for Christmas and for my birthday.
Now my my dilemma/AIBU.
When we were sorting out Power of Attorney and their wills I was quite taken aback at just how much money they have. I always knew they were not hard up as they inherited quite a bit from my grandparents will (mum’s parents) when they passed. They have a lot, enough to buy a 4 bed house and at least £10k each in their current accounts alone.
They spend little on themselves apart from food, bills etc.
Mum also has the extra £90 per wk Attendance Allowance which I got for her so they could buy things like ready meals to help dad or even pay for a carer a few times a week but it’s been sitting in her bank account accumulating since a year ago, untouched.
I have some on going health issues which are frankly ruining my life and making my day to day life quite hard and after endless NHS tests and visits to consultants and GPs etc I am getting nowhere fast and still suffering. I would love to see someone privately but just can not afford the fees. My dad is fully aware of my health issues but takes no interest and never offers any help, he just tells me that private consultants are just after my money and they can’t help me. I know Mum would have helped but as she has a five minute memory she would not remember anything I tell her.
I only work very part time, mainly because of my health issues and because I need to be about for my parents, dad facetimes me most mornings for something or other!
It does get me down that most of my friends parents are very generous with their money, even though most are no where near as financially comfortable as my parents. I know that if I had the money when I’m older I will definitely help my kids out, without a doubt.
So my AIBU is should my dad be a bit more generous with his money especially he knows I am struggling financially and health wise?
Obviously he is not going to be more generous with it but am I BU to think he should?

OP posts:
Thewholeshackshimmy · 15/08/2021 13:05

@BlueMongoose

To all those saying that savings are for care home fees, I'd like to point out that wise spending of savings and AA can prevent people going into care homes until much later in their illness, sometimes even at all. And can make the sufferer and those living with/caring for them a lot less stressful, and in the case of some matters like stairlifts etc, much safer too. Which is surely better all round?
This is what we are hoping for especially as my parents have so much money invested. We hope that we may be able to get carers in until it is absolutely essential mum goes into care. My neighbour had carers in every day for his wife who had dementia, she never went into a care home. However, he was much more into caring for his wife than my dad.
OP posts:
billy1966 · 15/08/2021 13:04

Your poor mother and poor you.

Your father sounds like a very mean, selfish man.

You are being used by him as a skivvy, taken away from your children.

An utterly thankless job.

You are a woman so he expects it done.

If he is capable of working in the garden and shed, he is well capable of laundry.

Stop doing it.
Stop being a skivvy.
Stop being used.

He has a huge amount of money and knowingly uses you as a skivvy despite your health issues that could be helped.

I certainly wouldn't be used like that.

Pull back and tell him you have health issues.

So common amoung some elderly to feel entitled to their daughter endless time while they refuse to pay for anything, despite being well able to.

Your poor mother.

Stop doing it.
Flowers

Thewholeshackshimmy · 15/08/2021 12:57

@Stressybetty

OP, my DM was diagnosed with Alzheimer's at 55, DF was same age. I had moved back into their home a year or so earlier with baby DD after splitting from exDH. DF was WFH own business. I was there 8 years in total and ended up working for him as his secretary, at his beck and call 24/7, gradually ending up doing all the housework, meals, shopping, ironing, caring for DM, washing her and trying to raise DD. DS and DB living their own lives miles away left me to it apart from the occasional visit. I was very isolated, had no friends in the area and if I had wanted to go out DF wouldn't have wanted anyone in the house to babysit. DF was in complete denial until DM had a mild stroke at home and SS got involved. After that we were offered help, carers and occasional daycare at a centre all of which he turned down as he felt we were coping and he didn't want strangers in the house. His life had hardly changed apart from a few small in-conveniences. DM was very aware what was happening to her and very angry at it for years. It wasn't until I started seeing exDH when he visited DD and decided to reconcile and move out that it spurred him into action. I moved back to exDH several hours away, he begged me not to go and leave him alone with her. After I left he went back to GP and asked for help, arranged occasional respite care, daycare a few days a week and started cleaning etc and coped very well until DM died 8 years later. The guilt then and now years later was incredible but I eventually had to leave for my own sanity and to have my own life. I was in my 20's and could see myself still there with no life for years to come.
Oh my gosh that must have been so very hard on you, how on earth did you cope at such a young age. The guilt is the biggest thing for me, it really is.
OP posts:
FreshFancyFrogglette · 15/08/2021 12:56

Up until about a year ago I probably would have said yabu, it's their money. But no, you are working part time to care for them, and taking a financial hit that way. Why the heck shouldn't they help you out if they can afford to??

Notaroadrunner · 15/08/2021 12:43

@TerribleZebra

OP I'm in a similar situation with a family member. All those people saying just tell them you've got someone to do their washing etc have obviously never experienced this situation. You cannot force adults to accept help. In my situation my relative is also well off but will not spend a penny on any form of help (garden, washing, cleaning, shopping). Her reasoning is that she will be well enough to do it herself again at some point. This has been going on for 2 years now. We cut down what we were doing for her to try and force the point that she wasn't coping. Her house is disgusting her clothes dirty and the garden like a jungle. I feel shit about all of this and still she won't accept any help. I also have POA but it's no good me paying for a cleaner if she sacks them (happened twice now) or refuses to let them in. My DH and I both work full time and we are at our wits end as to how this is going to play out. My guess is a fall followed by forced move to a home. None of this needs to be like this but unless a person will accept the situation they are in or the help they need there is nothing you can do.
I was in the situation but I didn't accept the fact my father just didn't want someone coming into the house. We organised carers, cleaner and meals on wheels whether he liked it or not - all had a key. As I said, he soon got used to it as he wasn't given much of a choice. It was either suck up the help or starve and live in squalor.
Namenic · 15/08/2021 12:43

Your dad is not being fair - and denying your mum the care she should be having by not paying. No one is saying that at 80, he should be doing it; but he should at least be using the attendance allowance for helping with care - at least personal care (where there currently is a bit of a gap - and likely to grow). He should also be reducing the load on you and your sister by paying for at least once weekly cleaning/laundry (either by your sister or someone else). This enables both of you to do other things with your mum - like take her out, chat to her; which will improve everyone’s quality of life.

Also have good boundaries for looking after your health too. If you need to spend more time working or saving up for a private appointment; then do so. Better than burning out early - which will make things a lot harder for you and everyone in the family.

PostMenWithACat · 15/08/2021 12:38

Having watched my mother do this to her detriment 20/25 years ago, I wouldn't.

You need to prioritise your job and I don't understand how you can undertake so much for your parents taking into account your health but your health prevents you from working more. If you and your dh need more money for things like private health then I think you need to work more to pay for it. This would break the control your father has over you and would force your parents to use the attendance allowance/their own money to purchase care to make their lives easier: personal care for your mother, cleaning/laundry, shopping, cooking. I wonder if your father would do more if the choice were do it or pay for it. I also wonder if he would expect sons to render the level of caring you provide - but that's a whole other thread.

What they should have done, and what we intend to do is to trade down to a small bungalow, give the money to our children and live off our pensions before we are 70. Either of our occupational pensions would go at least half way to care home fees and the balance could be paid upon the eventual sale of our final residence.

People just don't plan enough. However, having seen my grandmother progress through every stage of alzheimers I hope I shall be able to make a living will whilst I still have capacity and that dignitas will help me.

Georgyporky · 15/08/2021 12:32

If you have financial POA, surely you are entitled to take the Attendance Allowance from their bank account? Not a lot, but it would help you.

diddl · 15/08/2021 12:25

Your poor Mum-bullied & neglected by her husband.

FinallyHere · 15/08/2021 12:22

It suits your DF very much to brush off your objections and assume your DH is very wealthy. It gets him what he wants, excellent care with no bills.

I'm afraid that there comes a time in our lives when the parents / children relationship is reversed. Where your parents need the help. Older people are very often not very hood at accepting that they need help and prefer informal help from their children.

Working part time because they take up so much of your time is working for them but not for you. I'm afraid it's time to pull up your big girl pants and start to make changes. It's important for you to get your sister on board and to agree what you will offer to do from now on. Managing carers to visit them will still take up some of your time. It's only fair that they pay.

As for inheritance tax, between two, the allowance including passing on property to direct family, is just under £1Million. Are they likely to be over that threshold ?

https://www.gov.uk/inheritance-tax

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 15/08/2021 12:13

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Unsure33 · 15/08/2021 12:13

@Stompythedinosaur

Yes but some people are better at personal care than others . That’s just life . And some people literally may have other family commitments as well .

If people accept help and they have the money it could we’ll delay going into a home so it’s a win win .

Aprilx · 15/08/2021 12:13

I think it is more troubling that he won’t pay for proper care for your mother and to an extent himself, that should be a priority over your private health appointments.

I also think you do too much and maybe if you step back it will force his hand into getting in the proper care.

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 15/08/2021 12:12

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Unsure33 · 15/08/2021 12:11

@BlueMongoose

Yes we managed to get special beds ( OT ) helped with this and my mum gets 4 visits per day . Plus they said they will go to double handed visits if necessary to try and keep her at home .

We got special chairs and toilet aids as well .

Stompythedinosaur · 15/08/2021 12:09

I don't think your dparents have any obligation to support you when it sounds like they will need their money for care fees.

That said, if you want to be paid to provide care that isn't unreasonable either, but you need to talk about it.

No one loves doing personal care btw. People do it because they love the person who needs help and they don't want them to be uncomfortable.

Jaguar77 · 15/08/2021 12:09

Use your words ! They're not mind-readers are they? Tell them your situation and suggest a monetary amount if your father refuses then you'll know

Unsure33 · 15/08/2021 12:08

@Thewholeshackshimmy

My dad refused to move closer to us and now I wished I had just put my foot down .my mum would have had a better quality of life .

Now he has done it at least he knows if she falls there is someone on site or we are 10 mins away . Better than her lying on the floor for an hour as he would refuse to call anyone .

We are a lot tougher on him at the moment because mum always put him first in the marriage and now it’s her turn .

Camenbertsmuggler · 15/08/2021 12:08

This sounds very similar to my mums position apart from we lost my Nan 2 years ago. My mum claims carers allowance as she is my grandads primary carer

BlueMongoose · 15/08/2021 12:02

To all those saying that savings are for care home fees, I'd like to point out that wise spending of savings and AA can prevent people going into care homes until much later in their illness, sometimes even at all. And can make the sufferer and those living with/caring for them a lot less stressful, and in the case of some matters like stairlifts etc, much safer too.
Which is surely better all round?

Unsure33 · 15/08/2021 12:02

I totally sympathise with you . For years I have been coping with my parents affairs but as they have only some savings they have 4 care visits for my mum . I eventually persuaded them to move into an extra care flat closer to me and my sibling where it became obvious that they needed more help than the hours they were getting . In the end we came to an agreement that my sister would reduce her own work hours and she does the care and cleaning side and we pay her out of the attendance allowance ( she has gone self employed ) and I do all the other stuff medical / financial etc . I don’t get paid as I am in a better financial position . But it’s hard work . And tbh my dad is not grateful ( mum is )

I am not good at the care stuff ( and run my own business and don’t have much time ) and my sister is not so good at the financials

The way I look at it is they can afford to have cleaners and helpers but they won’t ( above carers for Mum). So they have to pay my sister .

If they don’t mum will end up in a care home earlier and we are doing everything to keep them together .

I am afraid if dad moans about things we just ignore him . We know we are doing our best and that’s all we can do .

Ariela · 15/08/2021 11:57

@Thewholeshackshimmy
You say your Dad misses the golf? Could your sister take him out to golf club and then while he is playing golf she goes back and does the cleaning?

As for the carer - I think you and sis need to be away same time on holiday and introduce carer then

BlueMongoose · 15/08/2021 11:56

You could, though it is drastic, decide with your sis that if your father refuses to help you and your sis persuade your mum to have a carer/cleaner/helper, you two will only do things for your mother. So you'll do her washing, not his, for example.
We started, as another poster suggested, by persuading my parents to have a cleaner. As lots of perfectly fit people have one, we were able to push the idea as one of convenience and time saving without harping on incapacity.
W.r.t. carers coming in, in the end, when we'd tried every other argument, we persuaded Dad to have a carer come into shower him (Mum wanted this too, but he didn't) by pointing out the plain fact that if Mum continued to do it, one day she'd slip and fall and hurt herself and then he'd have to go into care, as we lived too far away then to be able to plug the gap and all had jobs we couldn't leave. It wasn't a threat, it was simple fact, which had to be faced. We suggested he tried it just on a trial basis, which he did, and he is now fine with it.

Stressybetty · 15/08/2021 11:54

OP, my DM was diagnosed with Alzheimer's at 55, DF was same age. I had moved back into their home a year or so earlier with baby DD after splitting from exDH. DF was WFH own business. I was there 8 years in total and ended up working for him as his secretary, at his beck and call 24/7, gradually ending up doing all the housework, meals, shopping, ironing, caring for DM, washing her and trying to raise DD. DS and DB living their own lives miles away left me to it apart from the occasional visit. I was very isolated, had no friends in the area and if I had wanted to go out DF wouldn't have wanted anyone in the house to babysit. DF was in complete denial until DM had a mild stroke at home and SS got involved. After that we were offered help, carers and occasional daycare at a centre all of which he turned down as he felt we were coping and he didn't want strangers in the house. His life had hardly changed apart from a few small in-conveniences. DM was very aware what was happening to her and very angry at it for years. It wasn't until I started seeing exDH when he visited DD and decided to reconcile and move out that it spurred him into action. I moved back to exDH several hours away, he begged me not to go and leave him alone with her. After I left he went back to GP and asked for help, arranged occasional respite care, daycare a few days a week and started cleaning etc and coped very well until DM died 8 years later.
The guilt then and now years later was incredible but I eventually had to leave for my own sanity and to have my own life. I was in my 20's and could see myself still there with no life for years to come.

Medievalist · 15/08/2021 11:53

Op - I would just ask him for it outright in your shoes. Suggest treating it as a loan perhaps and stress that your continued health problem will limit your ability to provide help.

You lose nothing.

I do sympathise. As I said earlier, my dm counted every penny. Got me and dsis to contribute towards house repairs etc. Never ever offered us any financial help even when she knew we were struggling. She never revealed anything about her financial situation. When she died, in addition to owning her house, she had about £140k in the bank. But I just know she saw her savings as some sort of cushion/protection for future care needs. As it was, she spent 3 years in a care home and her pensions covered 75% of the fees.