Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say yes, I am a part of this village?

279 replies

draghimtothemits · 15/08/2021 07:33

I recently joined the local village FB group having recently moved here.

I asked a question about what local hospital people generally used since it isn't clear which one is the local one.

A few responses there, then a woman asked 'where are you then dear'. I explained I was in one of the new build houses at the back.

The responses are out there! 6 different people falling over themselves to say I'm NOT a part of the village.

One comment said 'that's not x village, that's the outskirts'

I said my address is this very village. He replied 'no, that simply isn't possible' Confused

Another response said 'you're not one of us! You should be banned'. Granted, that comment for a few laughing face reactions, but not a soul has come on to say that yes, I am a part of the village.

AIBU to think I am a part of the village?!

OP posts:
GintyMcGinty · 15/08/2021 10:05

Unfortunately you get morons like this everyone.

Our new build estate took about 15 years to be regarded as part of the town and even now there are still eejit comments on the comments section of the local newspaper about incomers.

However this sort of behaviour has only ever been online in my experience. Most people would never be so rude if they were face to face with you. They need the protection of their keyboards.

C8H10N4O2 · 15/08/2021 10:04

[East European] It doesn't have to be a negative observation (although it probably is in this context), if you saw a group of American college students or Scandinavians wouldn't you know straight away by looking at them what part of the world they come from?

No its racism. In rural Brexit Britain East European is wholly negative as a descriptor in that context.

Re organised lobbying against individual planning applications:

Planning applications have been posted in my local grourp many times, a planning application is a public document for the very purpose of people to comment on it. Facebook is a good way to let people know about local developments but it's still the local councillors who decide. A valid objection is a valid objection however it comes about

Again, not what the poster was describing. You can't whine about lack of opportunities and housing for young people and FB approved locals whilst pulling the full NIMBY routine at every development proposal. Lobby for extensions of services as part of larger applications, use them to increase the case around transport but communities that shut out new joiners die over time.

OP: Don't waste your time on FB groups full of bottom feeders who can't look up from dog poo and casual racism.

In Beds you might find a relevant regional parents group for your son's condition which would be more helpful and less stuck up their own arses.

Disneycharacter · 15/08/2021 10:03

@MoreRainThanAnyYet

Make a few comments about dog poo. They’ll soon take you to their hearts.
Haha! Every other post is bout dog poo and litter.
Babymamamama · 15/08/2021 10:03

Next time you need local info OP just use Google. These people sound awful. Leave them to it.

TheWeeDonkeyFella · 15/08/2021 10:01

@Penistoe @dryasaboner

Scarecrow competition? Kurtan is that you?

Mind your own business Len. And change your trousers

Grin Grin Grin

Dragon50 · 15/08/2021 10:01

Ah yes, never the locals.

Apparently during lockdown, the residents of Bishops Stortford realised that the Facebook rants about non-local airport users parking badly in residential areas was actually…

Local(ish) residents!

Disneycharacter · 15/08/2021 09:58

My local fb village group are always taking the piss out of the people on the new development. Never said yet they are not part of the village but it's clear they are resented for living in houses a developer bought which used to be a village walking area. Ignore the eejits

wonderstuff123 · 15/08/2021 09:57

Ugh, one of the very reasons I'd never live in a village. What a load of shite

Changechangychange · 15/08/2021 09:57

DM has lived in her house for 35 years, and is still “an incomer” because it’s an (old) new build. People who moved in five years ago but into an older house (still 1960s!) are apparently fine 🤷‍♀️

People in villages can be weird, especially about planning issues.

C8H10N4O2 · 15/08/2021 09:56

@MrsSkylerWhite

Hot Fuzz 😱
Yes - brilliant documentary!
MrsSkylerWhite · 15/08/2021 09:55

Hot Fuzz 😱

Camphillgirl · 15/08/2021 09:54

@BrilloPaddy

We've got an official FB page where people write crap about how wonderful the village shop is (run by the village idiot and his simpering idiot wife); the WI meetings and the Parish council. It's vomit inducing.

Then someone started a "Spotted X" page and it's great. Rants about hooligan teenagers on bikes (there are about 3), dog shit, cat shit, and noise at 7pm. It gets some really funny comments on most of the time, and the ubiquitous "which takeaway delivers out here" to which the answer is always "none, it's the backarse of nowhere".

Start an unofficial one and have some fun with it Grin

Our official FB is always populated by the same few who rant about about fireworks, dognapping, visitors (never locals) littering or not clearing up after dogs, Eastern European men in white vans chalking on pavements, cars parked outside their houses on public street, what time does post office open, is there a food bank locally, (virtue signalling) why is PTA, Scouts, church, local Council etc run by “newcomers “ when born and bred people know better how to do stuff. Colonel blimps resurrecting planning permissions given several years ago and suggesting protest groups. People demanding local privately owned properties should be turned into free car parks, restaurants, supermarkets, etc. without reference to the owners. Demanding M&S or Waitrose move into empty properties.
Howshouldibehave · 15/08/2021 09:54

@AwFeebs

Ah the joys of village FB groups. Grin

I find dog poo, fireworks and traffic complaints are the hot topics.

And parking!
callmeadoctor · 15/08/2021 09:54

I think that you are making it far too big a deal. Its just Facebook, I can pretty much guarantee that you had people also on your post being nice to you too. It does seem to come across that you don't really want to be there OP, you won't go to local playground, you aren't using the school or the GP (obviously for your good reasons). The Scarecrow competitions are just a bit of fun and won't your child enjoy seeing your scarecrow in the garden? Knowing its his (or his mums work). If you haven't got time to do it, how about asking some friends over with ideas?. Honestly a mophead would do with a mask, It doesn't have to be amazing.........................

Livelovebehappy · 15/08/2021 09:53

Jeez......do people actually behave like this? Does it matter whether you live in the village or are 6 foot outside the boundary as to whether you can join in with questions about services and the communities within your area? I’m so glad I don’t live amongst people that are so far up their arses. All the crap in the world at the moment and people really froth at the mouth about someone who doesn’t technically live within the boundaries of ‘their’ village?

SmashingBlouson · 15/08/2021 09:52

Perhaps the OP should just regard the new estate as their 'village' and treat it accordingly. Form a new community there without all the BS of normal village life! If it goes well, nobody will give a hoot what the 'villagers' think.

Dragon50 · 15/08/2021 09:50

@draghimtothemits my comment wasn’t a criticism of you AT ALL, they are being awful to you and you have every right to use local services from shops to GPS.

If they have an issue with local services they need to take that up with whoever they voted in.

You didn’t set planning or resources, and you asking re local hospital details should have ended with the information given.

I see how my sloppily message read and Flowers for the shoddy treatment.

TwoMountains · 15/08/2021 09:49

We moved into a village (although not a new build estate! Wink )

We’ve found that most people are absolutely fine and normal, happy to be nice to new people, but a minority of people can be really, really weird about who - or where - counts as being a proper part of the village.

There was one post on the village FB page recently where some poor woman was being flamed for daring to say that she was proud of coming from the village.
Her crime was to have confessed that her parents hadn’t moved into the village until she was a week old. 65 years ago!
Certain people were incensed that she’d claimed to be a proper villager when she had lived somewhere else first (for a week at most!!). The whole thing was totally bizarre Confused

kumquat365 · 15/08/2021 09:48

@draghimtothemits

The thing is this, the land was part of the village before the houses were put there so it isn't a new bit of area being added on

What makes me laugh is there are a few big country houses just on the actual outskirts, mentioned this and someone replied straight away?! To say yes they are part of the village! But the address doesn't even have the village name in it at all and a different post code?

Where you live now used to be fields. The people on the edge of the village used to have nice views and now they have a view of houses. They bought their house and loved it because of the view. They're mourning their loss. They've had months, possibly years, of noise and building work and mess and disruption and cement mixers going past their front door when it used to be lovely and quiet. And their homes have lost value — because a house with a garden backing onto fields is so much nicer than a house that's overlooked by another property. You may well feel the same way they do in 20 years time when the next estate is built at the end of your garden.
Gyoza · 15/08/2021 09:47

Sounds like my parents village, anyone who has moved there in the last 30 (maybe even 50) years is considered ‘new’ and met with suspicion. Don’t pander to them with litter picks of what they consider to be the village. Keep your own estate nice and build a lovely community there. They will soon start to include you when they realise that without new builds on the periphery of their village, there won’t be any young people at the schools or keeping local shops open as families are priced out of their exclusive central village district.

Bortles · 15/08/2021 09:43

We're surrounded by lovely country houses just like the one we live in. The difference is - we rent. The locals can't STAND it! Our neighbours, otherwise quite faux nice take every opportunity to shoehorn it in with new people to the village. 'Oh, Guy is having a party. He's having his garden redone. Of course Bortles RENTS so you wouldn't do that would you Bortles?'
Villages are weird. It's not even young people who might have the excuse of being immature. It's people in their 50s and 60s many of whom are relentless social-climbing snobs.

Marmitemarinaded · 15/08/2021 09:42

And “fitting in”…. Why should you have to “fit I “ to be welcomed by a community.

That’s what made the community where I lived In London so brilliant

There was no “fitting in”. You were accepted for who you were

Marmitemarinaded · 15/08/2021 09:41

[quote Rubyupbeat]@Marmitemarinaded its not brown nosing, its fitting in.[/quote]
But why would she went to fit in with such an obnoxious and unwelcoming community?!

TheRabbitStoleMyHat · 15/08/2021 09:40

I live in a town and our fb page is quite entertaining. ‘Anyone know why a helicopter just flew past’ and ‘Is this cat lost?’ With picture of cat in someone’s garden, feature regularly. Because all cats are lost.

Rubyupbeat · 15/08/2021 09:39

@Marmitemarinaded its not brown nosing, its fitting in.

Swipe left for the next trending thread