Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My 10 year old just told me he is gay

138 replies

Didifuckitup · 14/08/2021 22:00

Did I fuck it up. I don’t know if I responded wrong.
This has come from nowhere. He hasn’t hit puberty yet. He’s so young. He’s had the usual little girlfriends at school and crushes on girls.
And like a bolt out of the blue told me today , mum I don’t know how to tell you this. I’m gay.

It came out of nowhere at all . He’s the most boy ish boy and totally unexpected.

Can you really know if you are gay as young as ten? He has had sex Ed type stuff lately at school and he said he “knows all about gay/bi and alllll the genders now.. “
I don’t know if those lessons have made him feel like he needs to “tick a box” or “fit” or if he’s just sure he’s gay.

I basically said, “ oh that’s fine, no biggie. It makes no difference to me and dad if you are gay or straight as long as you are confident and happy. You will hit puberty soon and hormones will be raging, and you will fancy all kinds of people. You may fancy girls down the line, or boys, or both. And don’t be confused by that if you do. It’s all normal . You are only ten and that’s really young , please don’t feel like you have to pick a sexuality at your age, these things will all figure themselves out in time”

And then I thought shit was that the wrong thing to say. I don’t know. He suffers with anxiety and a few other health issues and I don’t want to mess this up but maybe I already did. Can you know you are gay so young? Can these school chats confuse kids these days? Should I say anything else ?

Hope I haven’t confused him more

OP posts:
irresistibleoverwhelm · 18/08/2021 00:16

@SarahAndQuack

I don’t think it’s automatically reproducing homophobic tropes to say that sexual orientation can change over time.

No, but I don't think anyone has said it was.

What is homophobic is to say someone might 'choose' to be gay because it's 'fashionable'. Or that they might 'change their mind'.

The reason the phrase 'it's a phase' is so persistently associated with homophobia is because there's a very well-known theory that homosexuality is an immature form of sexuality, which most people experience as a 'phase' in early youth, but which some fail to progress beyond.

The reason that 'changing your mind' carries homophobic implications is that it presumes that sexuality is a conscious choice: you can choose to be gay, and you can choose to be straight. This is the rhetoric that gay conversion advocates adopt, when they insist people can 'change their minds'.

It is possible to acknowledge the complexity of sexuality without reinforcing homophobic tropes.

Which well known theory are you thinking of? (Aside from general folk belief). I’m a cultural historian who works on the history of sexuality and there isn’t really any systematic theory of this, even in psychoanalysis which is actually very complex in terms of framing multiple theories of sexual orientation.

The contemporary orthodoxy of you can’t choose your sexuality isn’t intrinsically homophobic. If you thought that most people are essentially bisexual, or somewhere in the middle of a spectrum of sexual orientation, but that the social conditioning of patriarchy leads most people - especially women - to adopt heterosexuality as a compelled choice rather than an innate orientation, you might well believe that we could make different choices about our sexual orientation. As a woman who has been variously either lesbian or bisexual for long periods of my life, I also object to either the idea that I’m either “really” a lesbian who can’t escape the “comphet” (in the Tumblr terminology); or that I’m a deluded person who was “always” really bisexual.

The dogma in current LGBT+ circles is automatically and unthinkingly against whatever they perceive as “political lesbianism”. However, the history of the way we think about sexual orientation is complex and always political. Especially in Europe, where there has always been much more interest in universalist forms of gay activism and theory. In the US, the narrative of “orientation is inborn and any attempt to suggest otherwise is conversion therapy” has historically been much more successful because of the rights endowed under the constitution to “inalienable” qualities of the person. Any rights-based discourse in the US tends to adopt this stance because it is politically much more successful there (and the US discourse currently dominates here).

However, there are also long histories of alternative, non-identity-based models of sexuality and sexual orientation that also exist alongside that, which are obscured by the current obsession with identity, and which are in some respects more open and progressive. (They are not, either, allied with “conversion therapy”.) They are, however, out of fashion because they suggest that a lot of how we experience sexuality - as well as gender - is socially constructed and/or even coerced, in the case of heteronormativity. (And homophobes - as well as the patriarchy - actually find this a lot more threatening than the idea that sexual orientation is inbuilt and can’t be changed. Probably just one of the reasons why desire or drive or spectrum-based models of sexuality have been suppressed in recent years. The other being that if women did think they could choose to be lesbian or bisexual, with today’s reproductive technology they might just decide to…and patriarchy cannot have that! Wink)

Italiangreyhound · 18/08/2021 00:15

OP I think you did great. Well done.

SarahAndQuack · 17/08/2021 23:36

I don’t think it’s automatically reproducing homophobic tropes to say that sexual orientation can change over time.

No, but I don't think anyone has said it was.

What is homophobic is to say someone might 'choose' to be gay because it's 'fashionable'. Or that they might 'change their mind'.

The reason the phrase 'it's a phase' is so persistently associated with homophobia is because there's a very well-known theory that homosexuality is an immature form of sexuality, which most people experience as a 'phase' in early youth, but which some fail to progress beyond.

The reason that 'changing your mind' carries homophobic implications is that it presumes that sexuality is a conscious choice: you can choose to be gay, and you can choose to be straight. This is the rhetoric that gay conversion advocates adopt, when they insist people can 'change their minds'.

It is possible to acknowledge the complexity of sexuality without reinforcing homophobic tropes.

irresistibleoverwhelm · 17/08/2021 23:03

I don’t think it’s automatically reproducing homophobic tropes to say that sexual orientation can change over time. The political narrative at the current time is that sexual orientation is fixed from birth; but that hasn’t always been the case, historically; and it certainly isn’t how everyone experiences their sexuality. Some people experience their sexual orientation as fixed, and some experience it as more fluid or changeable (this is true for me and lots of others I know).

I think it’s perfectly fine to say that he might change his mind or might not and that either is okay. And whereas sometimes the “it’s a phase” thing might be a “homophobic trope”, it doesn’t mean that what the OP has said makes her homophobic. Sexual orientation can go through “phases”; and not to acknowledge that is itself rigid and excluding (if I were a teenager I would say it was “biphobic”; but instead I just note that there are plenty of seeming “straight” people whose sexuality is not actually that straight either, and who might feel freer to identify as less straight if we had a more flexible understanding of sexual orientation, particularly bisexuality).

Didifuckitup · 17/08/2021 22:29

@SarahAndQuack

Seriously piss off. You are picking at everything and taking it All the wrong way. Very irritating

I think you're showing your true colours here.

I have responded several times on this thread, taking a lot of time and care to consider your feelings and to acknowledge that you did a lot of things right for your DS, but also explaining why homophobia is so damaging. I did that because, like others on this thread, I really do know what it feels like, first hand, to have a parent say 'oh, I think I did really well didn't I?' when actually, what they said played right into homophobic tropes.

You've responded by getting angry, as if what's wrong is that not enough people told you how wonderful you were.

Look at the thread. If ego-massage is what you want, it's there in spades. You can listen to all those people telling you you are wonderful.

So why don't you?

Is it because, deep down, you know I have a point? I think so.

😂 that is all.
OP posts:
SarahAndQuack · 17/08/2021 22:23

Seriously piss off. You are picking at everything and taking it All the wrong way. Very irritating

I think you're showing your true colours here.

I have responded several times on this thread, taking a lot of time and care to consider your feelings and to acknowledge that you did a lot of things right for your DS, but also explaining why homophobia is so damaging. I did that because, like others on this thread, I really do know what it feels like, first hand, to have a parent say 'oh, I think I did really well didn't I?' when actually, what they said played right into homophobic tropes.

You've responded by getting angry, as if what's wrong is that not enough people told you how wonderful you were.

Look at the thread. If ego-massage is what you want, it's there in spades. You can listen to all those people telling you you are wonderful.

So why don't you?

Is it because, deep down, you know I have a point? I think so.

Didifuckitup · 17/08/2021 22:15

@Aprilx

I am surprised posters are saying it was a text book response. I think it sounded really dismissive and also like you are more or less telling him he will grow out of it. I think if he brings it up again, some acceptance of what he is saying might be appropriate. I definitely knew that I liked boys when I was ten years old.
I didn’t tell him that. I told Him not to be s confused if his feelings change back and forth between boys and girls as that’s normal? He may end up preferring girls boys or both and I wanted him to know that’s fine if things change when he hits puberty
OP posts:
Aprilx · 17/08/2021 22:12

I am surprised posters are saying it was a text book response. I think it sounded really dismissive and also like you are more or less telling him he will grow out of it. I think if he brings it up again, some acceptance of what he is saying might be appropriate. I definitely knew that I liked boys when I was ten years old.

Stormyequine · 17/08/2021 22:02

Your response was fine, and the important thing is your DS now knows he has his parents support. I think it would be worth finding out exactly what he has been taught in school though. I thought parents were generally made aware of sex education when it is being taught in primary school in case DC come home with any questions.

BigGooseyLucy · 17/08/2021 21:57

Please ignore any of the negatives comments that have been said and the nitpicking comments!

There is nothing wrong with what you said to your child or what you typed and even if there was something wrong with what you said and typed, you were saying it from a loving place and meant well! Your child will know this!

Don't stress about it, I think you did awesome and if your child brings the topic up again atleast you won't be caught off guard.

Didifuckitup · 17/08/2021 21:50

@SarahAndQuack

I expect so.

Or maybe the men who beat them up were given the message, when they were little boys, that there's no need to 'let it out' to anyone.

Seriously piss off. You are picking at everything and taking it All the wrong way. Very irritating
OP posts:
Didifuckitup · 17/08/2021 21:48

[quote SarahAndQuack]'Just a crush or whatever'.

Yes, he should definitely hide it from you if it's 'just a crush or whatever'. Hmm

There are also people wondering why two men in their 30s 'felt the need' to 'let out' their feelings. Some of those people did this: www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2021/aug/17/men-injured-in-homophobic-attack-in-birminghams-gay-village[/quote]
People on here are so good at twisting your words.
That’s not what I meant.
Jog on.

OP posts:
Ancientcistern · 17/08/2021 13:38

@FortunesFave

SarahAndQuack

How dare you call me homophobic!? You don't even know me. What I said is perfectly valid...and when DD came out we accepted it. However now that she's straight again, it's natural to assume she said she was gay in order to be fashionable.

She's not the only one either...MN is full of similar stories...kids coming out, going in, chopping and changing.

It's fashion without a doubt. And it DOES invalidate the kids who are actually gay!

If she thought she was straight then discovered she was gay would you think she was pretending to be straight to be fashionable?

I doubt anyone would pretend to be gay. Homophobia still exists, as you prove.

Blessex · 17/08/2021 12:56

You did great!

anonforamo · 17/08/2021 12:55

Regarding your question, I have many LGBTQ family, friends and students, as well as a teen I raised who is currently in a same sex relationship though doesn't identify as gay and is working out feelings which I always give reminders that there's time and no rush.I don't think it so much as 'a need to let it out' as the fact it's part of their identity.

I think at 10 he may be frightened it wasn't okay with you and so maybe he needed that reassurance. He also may needed that good messaging that whatever he is feeling is normal.

There are some wonderful support groups for parents. I found them very helpful.

anonforamo · 17/08/2021 12:52

You did so well @Didifuckitup and all you said is true. Sexuality is far more fluid than people realize.

I think you should be so pleased he confided in you and that you gave a message of acceptance. I'd let him know he can talk to you about his thoughts/feelings/questions, or you can also find someone else he can talk to if he'd like.

Well done!

Darthwader · 17/08/2021 12:23

Diamond pony - In the first series he is attractive. I saw it recently.

diamondpony80 · 17/08/2021 12:03

I had a highly inappropriate crush on Captain Kirk from Star Trek at about 8 or 9 so I definitely knew I was straight. Inappropriate because William Shatner is about 50 years older than me. In my defence it was re runs of the original series & I had zero clue about sex or anything like that. I knew I was attracted to him in a “girl boy” way though. I recently watched a few episodes of Star Trek and wondered what I was thinking!

Helendee · 17/08/2021 11:13

The more I’ve thought about it the more being ‘Pansexual’ makes more sense to me… being attracted to a person regardless of their biology.
Aren’t we all like this to a certain extent? We admire and feel strong attractions to some people and sexual attraction towards others.

Lucillegoldenring · 17/08/2021 11:08

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

SarahAndQuack · 17/08/2021 10:58

I expect so.

Or maybe the men who beat them up were given the message, when they were little boys, that there's no need to 'let it out' to anyone.

Eggfriedpower · 17/08/2021 10:49

Maybe those men were just trying to be fashionable...

SarahAndQuack · 17/08/2021 10:24

'Just a crush or whatever'.

Yes, he should definitely hide it from you if it's 'just a crush or whatever'. Hmm

There are also people wondering why two men in their 30s 'felt the need' to 'let out' their feelings. Some of those people did this: www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2021/aug/17/men-injured-in-homophobic-attack-in-birminghams-gay-village

VanillaAndOrange · 17/08/2021 10:02

Can you really know if you are gay as young as ten?

I'm not gay, but I think I realised I was straight (although I wouldn't have described it as that then) when I was 8 or 9.

I really like your response.

Didifuckitup · 17/08/2021 01:39

@chalamet

It’s impossible to know if he is gay or if he will change his mind once, or multiple times in his life. All are ok! I think you handled it fine!
Thank you. I just wonder why he felt the need to let it out if it’s just due to a crush or whatever.
OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread