Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My 10 year old just told me he is gay

138 replies

Didifuckitup · 14/08/2021 22:00

Did I fuck it up. I don’t know if I responded wrong.
This has come from nowhere. He hasn’t hit puberty yet. He’s so young. He’s had the usual little girlfriends at school and crushes on girls.
And like a bolt out of the blue told me today , mum I don’t know how to tell you this. I’m gay.

It came out of nowhere at all . He’s the most boy ish boy and totally unexpected.

Can you really know if you are gay as young as ten? He has had sex Ed type stuff lately at school and he said he “knows all about gay/bi and alllll the genders now.. “
I don’t know if those lessons have made him feel like he needs to “tick a box” or “fit” or if he’s just sure he’s gay.

I basically said, “ oh that’s fine, no biggie. It makes no difference to me and dad if you are gay or straight as long as you are confident and happy. You will hit puberty soon and hormones will be raging, and you will fancy all kinds of people. You may fancy girls down the line, or boys, or both. And don’t be confused by that if you do. It’s all normal . You are only ten and that’s really young , please don’t feel like you have to pick a sexuality at your age, these things will all figure themselves out in time”

And then I thought shit was that the wrong thing to say. I don’t know. He suffers with anxiety and a few other health issues and I don’t want to mess this up but maybe I already did. Can you know you are gay so young? Can these school chats confuse kids these days? Should I say anything else ?

Hope I haven’t confused him more

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Ancientcistern · 23/08/2021 13:26

I don't see anyone saying that it should be celebrated, just that it shouldn't br dismissed.

54321nought · 23/08/2021 12:39

[quote Ancientcistern]@54321nought

What's your point?[/quote]
My point is not to "box them in" by celebrating being gay to such an extent that they are not comfortable about telling people later that they are straight.

I have known "gay" teens tie themselves in all sorts of knots about "coming out" as straight when they are older, to the extent that some have left the area they have grown up in, and cut all ties with old friends!

Accept, don't insult anyone by saying their sexuality isn't "real" or just a phase, but just that being gay now might last a life time, or might not, and either is ok

Ancientcistern · 23/08/2021 12:35

@54321nought

What's your point?

TheCuttySharp · 23/08/2021 11:34

I say I'm bisexual but my DH is the only man I've ever been attracted to Confused Every single other crush and relationship in my life has been with women. Weird really

TheCuttySharp · 23/08/2021 11:33

I knew at 10 that I was attracted to girls. It must have been earlier actually as I had a crush on an older girl who was in year 6.

I knew that lots of girls in my class were giggling about boys and I didn't share the interest but felt the same about a few girls.

I also knew this wasn't 'normal' (in my young 1990s head) and didn't say anything.

I think if I grew up now and saw the positive movements around being gay and knew it was OK (it was never discussed in my childhood) then I might have 'came out' at a young age too?

I mean what is coming out? It's just stating your attraction, which many 10 year old do with the same sex. When a 10 year old girl fancies Harry styles it's cute. So if she fancies a female equivalent is it that big of a deal?

I'm actually bisexual, but from very young to 15 I thought I was a lesbian.

54321nought · 23/08/2021 11:26

@YouJustDoYou

My little sister knew when she was 10.
Real does not mean permanent

You can really be gay when young, and then heterosexual when you are older- this is a common experience

It is not helpful to anyone to pretend this doesn't happen

Some people who are gay when they are young are still gay when they are older

Some people who are gay when they are young are straight when they are older

Sometimes the other way around too

Ancientcistern · 23/08/2021 10:35

@stoconsole

www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-birmingham-58297761

Yeah being gay is so fashionable. I wonder if teenagers are pretending to be gay in predominately Muslim areas.

That's shocking, I hope they go to jail for a very long time.
stoconsole · 23/08/2021 10:14

www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-birmingham-58297761

Yeah being gay is so fashionable. I wonder if teenagers are pretending to be gay in predominately Muslim areas.

lazylinguist · 18/08/2021 15:05

I didn’t tell him that. I told
Him not to be s confused if his feelings change back and forth between boys and girls as that’s normal? He may end up preferring girls boys or both and I wanted him to know that’s fine if things change when he hits puberty

I don't think it's a bad response, and I may well have said much the same in that situation. But I have to say, these kinds of thread do often show up the fact that parents often seem to give the ''It's fine, we love you whatever your sexuality turns out to be" response (airily and casually implying that it's likely to change), when they wouldn't even think of responding that way if their son showed an interest in girls.

SarahAndQuack · 18/08/2021 14:31

@Italiangreyhound

But the op did not say what you are implying!
The OP isn't the person who first used the word 'fashionable,' no. That's why my post refers to what 'people' (plural) on the thread are saying.
YouJustDoYou · 18/08/2021 11:50

My little sister knew when she was 10.

Hadtocomment · 18/08/2021 11:12

I haven't read this entire thread but a large chunk of it. Whilst I think you said all the right things in one way I think you come across as highly anxious in your posts here and also looking to explain it away and anxiously checking if people do know at that age as though you would very much prefer him not to be. Presumably you haven't worried about the influence of his having little gfs etc in a childish way as a lot of adults will talk in that sort of way and think nothing of this. The chat or encouragement of that is surely as influencing but you don't seem to have noticed that. It also strikes me that you launched into a big speech rather than chat with him and just listen. Maybe he wanted to talk to you rather than have you talk to him? At least showing him he can talk to you seems to be key. I realise my reply sounds bit critical which I don't mean. I am just surprised that everyone is going that's a great reply without maybe thinking about how we communicate more with how we say things. And kids really pick up on stuff. You say he shut you down when you tried to suggest he wasn't gay. For example. To me I get the impression you are anxious and not completely relaxed about it. I think the not wanting your child to suffer or be teased argument may be powerful to you but it's also not a brilliant way to think and often the excuse brought out when parents push their kids in a particular direction. Not saying you are doing that you are obviously a caring parent. I think rather than launching into talking to him again I'd maybe take a bit of time to think about whether you do mind even if you're coming up with justifications of why or whether you do have assumptions and maybe tackle them a bit for yourself first so he doesn't pick up on them.

Italiangreyhound · 18/08/2021 09:51

But the op did not say what you are implying!

SarahAndQuack · 18/08/2021 09:39

@irresistibleoverwhelm - why on earth do you think 'affirming' someone's expression of their sexuality has to do with adult sexual desire? That is a very peculiar way to interpret what I said.

And yes, I know there are plural ideas about sexuality in the past. That's not up for debate. The point is that you said there was no coherent theory of homosexuality as immature, and that is not true. It is pretty well known, as I have pointed out, and it's the idea of homosexuality as an immature phase of sexual development that has done damage in recent years/decades (not the idea of Greek love, or whatever else you might want to discuss).

There's nothing wrong with simply saying to a child 'yes, ok' without adding all the stuff about 'ooh I bet this is just a fashion and it's all new'. That is the damaging bit. You can see it in multiple posts - people are claiming it's recent and new to think you're gay at a young age. It patently isn't.

Tal45 · 18/08/2021 09:38

TBH I don't think there is a perfect answer especially when you're put on the spot like that. As long as he knows you love and support him it'll all be fine, I think as parents we can really over think these things!

I told my mum I was a lesbian at 10 and she told me I wasn't and that I didn't even know what it meant. I told her I did and stormed off. I've been married to a man for 20 years, bicurious certainly but not a lesbian once puberty kicked in.

Ancientcistern · 18/08/2021 09:09

@TrifleCat

I think some of you may not be aware but currently in UK teen/youth culture it is very fashionable to be gay/bi/pan etc , and it’s important to acknowledge a child’s feelings whilst also not encouraging this ridiculous trend to label oneself.

And I think it’s poor form for a poster to assume that every child who says they are gay at age 10 definitely must be because they “knew from a young age”. Everyone is different.

FFS not this again. There's another thread here where a posters son came out to his friends and received homophobic comments.
borntobequiet · 18/08/2021 09:07

Good response. I’m sure some people realise they’re same-sex attracted quite young. I was a secondary teacher for many years and realised that in every new Y7 year group there were one or two boys who were obviously gay - there was a reasonably accurately identifying set of behaviours that identified them. Lucking it was a supportive school community and many happily came out as they got older. This was 1990s onwards.

Italiangreyhound · 18/08/2021 09:00

Brilliant post irresistibleoverwhelm.

TrifleCat my child told me their friendship group at about 14 contained, one asexual, one gay person, one trans person, one bisexual and one straight person. It's possible in the long run that will all be true. But do those 14 or 15 year old girls really know at that age. I think there are trends at work.

TrifleCat · 18/08/2021 08:10

I think some of you may not be aware but currently in UK teen/youth culture it is very fashionable to be gay/bi/pan etc , and it’s important to acknowledge a child’s feelings whilst also not encouraging this ridiculous trend to label oneself.

And I think it’s poor form for a poster to assume that every child who says they are gay at age 10 definitely must be because they “knew from a young age”. Everyone is different.

YouHaveNotFuckedUp · 18/08/2021 07:56

Hi OP

Just adding to the responses saying you have done great and eye rolling at the nitpicking.

It was obvious what you were talking about when describing a boyish boy. (Speaking as a reasonably boyish gay man!)

I don’t think saying that all things are possible dismisses this as just a phase and will send him back into the closet to endure some torturous teenage years. The overall message is one of love and support and anything is ok. This is what he will have heard and remember. The fact he told you this so early means he knew this anyway.

Smile
LakieLady · 18/08/2021 07:55

Your answer was great, OP.

I think people can know their orientation pretty young. One friend says they knew they were gay by the time they were 7, and that they'd always felt "different" from their same sex friends in some way. Another didn't realise until they were in their 30s.

Backtomyoldname · 18/08/2021 07:28

I think that your response was fine. A kind, supportive and loving answer.

Sadly too many parents build up the barriers when their children come out. All of my 3, now adult, children are out. They can all tell terrible stories of friends’ parents who have, and still are, behaving appalingly.

As for the age. My children came out at 15-16. Like many post gcse and when starting 6th form college.

They say they knew in late junior school but kept it to themselves/didn’t quite understand.

irresistibleoverwhelm · 18/08/2021 02:53

I don’t think that what the OP said is anything like what you’re suggesting. I do think it sound like you are reading what she says through the filter of your own experience: I don’t get any sense that she hasn’t “affirmed” her child (which is an odd word to use, anyway: a ten year old doesn’t require his sexuality to be “affirmed”, as it isn’t an adult sexual identity anyway! Child sexuality is in the process of development at 10: even if he knows he is gay, he doesn’t have an adult sense of what that means at all as yet. If a child announces they’re straight - my 8 y o DD has in effect announced that to me - I don’t “affirm” that as her identity either! (I might personally be secretly disappointed she might not be a lesbian, but what I actually said to her was a version of what the OP said to her son — “that’s lovely dear, but when you grow up you can like men or women or both or change your mind later and that’s okay too.”

Should I have “affirmed” her sexual identity instead? (I thought I liked boys at 8: turns out I didn’t.) It sounds very much like double standards if you think different messages should go to a kid who announces they’re gay at 10 versus straight?

Myself, I would have wanted my parents to say what the OP said and not make any big deal out of it. I really didn’t get the sense from anything the OP said that her intention was to say “it’s a phase, don’t mention it again later.”

Early modern to modern ideas about same sex desire don’t at all treat homosexuality as necessarily immature; they don’t of course for a start have a conceptual model of sexuality that approaches our modern idea of it anyway. (As a historian, you know that constructions of sexuality were entirely different in earlier periods: some things only look homophobic if you read them back through a contemporary lens of identity).

Instead of reading these examples as constructing homosexuality as immature, don’t they look more like constructions in which people found opportunities for articulating the existence of same-sex desire within existing cultural narratives of religious and social norms, ie. you can normalise your same sex desire by reference to a Greek model in the early modern court or mid-nineteenth-century university; you can make it possible to visit your lover in her father’s house if it’s constructed as a “romantic friendship” of schoolmates before she ends up being married off; etc etc. And girls did meet each other at school: they were largely chaperoned as teenagers, and girls and boys lived in different social worlds, so same sex relationships when they did happen likely did begin young - and social norms and financial necessity made it likely they would have to take up heterosexual lives later (especially women). But there are also plenty of other historical examples of thinking about same-sex desire that don’t construct it as immature either.

SarahAndQuack · 18/08/2021 02:04

@irresistibleoverwhelm, to take your points in order:

Try Freud, Adler, Rado (with homosexuality as an injury to the child); try early modern English ideas of same-sex desire as a step on the way to maturity or (in the case of women) a greensickness that is a pathological condition. Look at more recent ideas of women's 'passionate friendships' that needed to mature into marriage. Look at conversion therapies in the US and the UK. You are right: I should have been clearer that there's not one unified theory of treating homosexuality as immature; there are many theories.

(Shit, sorry, should I pretend I'm not a cultural historian? I'm not really. I'm just employed in a university history department these days.)

I agree the rhetoric of choice might well change (I'm not wedded to it myself). But we are talking about a ten year old child. There is no reason not to affirm that child. It's perfectly possible to affirm a child's statement without feeling the need to give them a university-level lecture on sexuality. Just let them be!

It would be fine to say that sexuality is changeable, if we said it to everyone. But we don't. So every child who plucks up the courage to say they might be gay, risks hearing that they're not really gay. They're mistaken. Things might change. It's probably a phase. Meanwhile - don't mention it again!

A child who tells their parent they really like a child of the opposite sex? Why that's normal. Nothing to do with sexuality! Perfectly ok. Why would you comment on it, let them grow and develop without censure. It's sweet, enjoy it!

Those are two very different responses and we do need to think about the damage that's done.

irresistibleoverwhelm · 18/08/2021 00:18

Sorry - my phone cut out a bit of text there randomly! Second para should start:

“The contemporary orthodoxy of you can’t choose your sexuality is just that, an orthodoxy: to say otherwise isn’t intrinsically homophobic.”