Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

They shouldn't be sharing the name of the Plymouth shooter

67 replies

OverTheRubicon · 14/08/2021 21:41

In most terrorist incidents - and in shooting incidents in the US - the editorial policy has recently been to minimise press coverage of the aggressor, to allow for some background of why they did this and how they accessed weapons, but focus the attention on the grief and loss of the victims and not inspire further violence or adulation of killers.

Yet you can hardly move for coverage of the Plymouth shooter - he's the focus of most of the press and he's already being lauded on incel sites. He's the picture you see on every article, sometimes his mother, not other victims and grief stricken families even when they're names.

Aibu that we should be vastly downplaying him as the centre of this attention?

OP posts:
Bunnycat101 · 15/08/2021 06:58

And I would say you can look at societal factors - of course they contribute but if you take it to its full degree no-one has any self-determination.

On the mental health side, if it became apparent that he had a psychotic episode and though he was in a zombie film or something then at that point, I could accept diminished responsibility. It just sounds like he got angry and decided to shoot everyone he saw. That to me is a monster. He shot the dad from 15ft away and while he was dying he cradled his little girl to try and protect her. The bastard then came up to them and shot them at close range. For me that tells you all you need to know about his character mental health or not.

Spikeyball · 15/08/2021 06:56

Saying it was because he was evil or a monster won't stop this happening again. The only way to do that is look at what led up to it and what others could have done differently.

Fluffmonkey82 · 15/08/2021 02:56

@Bunnycat101

He was a monster. From the accounts I’ve read (and wished I hadn’t) the way he killed the little girl in cold blood makes him an absolute monster. I have relatives with severe mental health issues who have been sectioned frequently. They were very sick but would have never hurt a child. Yes let’s find out what contributed to this but I firmly believe he was evil - granted he may have been mentally ill as well but I wish the press would stop reporting on him and his vile face.
Yip totally agree. Anyone who can kill an innocent little girl is a monster in my book, no excuses.
FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 15/08/2021 02:19

@Badfootkk

I think it is important. He is not a monster.. His family tried to get him help. They were not heard. He was unwell ,unheard and cast aside. He was a person , that didn't ' fit in ' with an illness He did an awful awful action. I feel destroyed for those , but he was not well.
What a load of minimising nonsense.

He murdered a 3yo pushing a dolls pram in broad daylight then murdered her father. I wonder if their mother/wife sees him as a monster or a victim of society. The victim of society bollocks is exactly what incels use to justify violence

Clarissa111 · 15/08/2021 02:14

@Badfootkk

I think it is important. He is not a monster.. His family tried to get him help. They were not heard. He was unwell ,unheard and cast aside. He was a person , that didn't ' fit in ' with an illness He did an awful awful action. I feel destroyed for those , but he was not well.
Sorry but no. He was a vile man. Most mental health sufferers are only a danger to themselves. We cant keep making this excuse.
Henrytheehoover · 15/08/2021 00:52

He killed himself, the press don't need to worry about being sued for saying he killed these people.

For all the press likes to say it doesn't name perpetrators to honour the victims, you will probably find that they only avoid naming the perpetrators until they are convicted in a court of law, so they cannot be sued for stating they are guilty before they were convicted.

And yes, I am very cynical.

Snugglybuggly · 15/08/2021 00:47

@Badfootkk

I think it is important. He is not a monster.. His family tried to get him help. They were not heard. He was unwell ,unheard and cast aside. He was a person , that didn't ' fit in ' with an illness He did an awful awful action. I feel destroyed for those , but he was not well.
Sorry but he killed his own mother and a 3 year old amongst others I call that a monster
AllTheSingleLadiess · 15/08/2021 00:43

The terrorist had such a wide digital footprint that it was inevitable that his YouTube videos etc would become public.

We live in an era of conspiracy theories. Avoiding discussion of this monster will feed the conspiracy theorists. Is he being protected because he's been framed? Is he being protected because he's white? Etc

Of course you can be mentally ill and a monster. I'm not saying that he was a monster at birth but I feel for his family who tried to get help because I know it's an impossible task. Sad

LadyCatStark · 15/08/2021 00:27

He was a monster and I for one don’t want to see his disgusting face. Sky News was disgraceful to have shared some of the videos that he put on YouTube, that’s exactly what he would have wanted.

Throckmorton · 15/08/2021 00:14

It's possible to be mentally unwell and also be a total bastard. Saying mental illness caused this misses the fact that the vast majority of mentally ill people are not murdering bastards. This event was caused by the combination of mental illness PLUS him being a bastard. And I agree about his name and face. I don't think we should hide them, but they should not be the focus. The focus should be the innocent victims. In the same way that when some fucker annihilates his family, we should focus on the family not on the murderer.

AfternoonToffee · 15/08/2021 00:12

[quote BringBackThinEyebrows]@AfternoonToffee

reflect as to how society has caused / allowed / enabled this to happen

In what way is 'society' to blame? Of course I don't think he should have had access to a weapon, but I assumed you meant there are other solutions.[/quote]
Society as a whole, starting from the day children are born - better support, better access to services, offering children and families opportunities, not plunging families into an ever increasing spiral of debt, tackling crimes, gang culture. The list goes on.

This costs money though, and willingness to change and government policy that is committed to it. This will never happen though and instead nothing will happen, and Boris Johnson will continue to offer hypocritical platitudes.

AfternoonToffee · 15/08/2021 00:03

He was an incel and a terrorist. He hated women. We shouldn’t be suggesting otherwise or offering to bathe him in mermaid tears.

One can think you are absolutely correct on the first three things, but also think that he is not a monster.

It is a nature: nurture thing to me. Saying he is a monster (imo) is saying that this is just who he is and that nothing can be done (i.e born evil), rather than a multitude of internal and external factors got him to this point.

Not wanting to call him a monster, doesn't mean I want to bathe him in mermaid tears, but I can be sad, angry, frustrated that whatever has happened, or not, got him to the point that he did this. A point he should never have got to.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 14/08/2021 23:51

The internet being what it is, not giving his name could have resulted in incels mythologising him, probably saying he escaped and there was a cover up like sort of demented Scarlet Pimpernel.

And, naturally, the usual suspects were all over SM declaring that it had to be a Muslim, just as they always do before a photo and name are released to show it was a white English/American/whatever. Including a video showing a body which just so happened to have 'Tommy Robinson TV' tagged over the image on many shares. Another example of that is when the child was thrown off the 10th floor of the Tate Modern, SM was awash with them saying there wasn't a name or photo released because it was obviously somebody brown.

There has to be a balance between not giving a perpetrator notoriety or a starring role and making sure that there isn't an opportunity for inadequates and attention seekers to create a different version of events to suit their narratives.

BringBackThinEyebrows · 14/08/2021 23:50

@AfternoonToffee

reflect as to how society has caused / allowed / enabled this to happen

In what way is 'society' to blame? Of course I don't think he should have had access to a weapon, but I assumed you meant there are other solutions.

bellyy · 14/08/2021 23:44

We are in the UK.

Mummyoflittledragon · 14/08/2021 23:42

@Badfootkk

I think it is important. He is not a monster.. His family tried to get him help. They were not heard. He was unwell ,unheard and cast aside. He was a person , that didn't ' fit in ' with an illness He did an awful awful action. I feel destroyed for those , but he was not well.
He was an incel and a terrorist. He hated women. We shouldn’t be suggesting otherwise or offering to bathe him in mermaid tears.
Member869894 · 14/08/2021 23:41

Bride can you explain why you think hes a monster and find comments saying that mental illness cause his actions offensive ? I'm genuinely interested. Surely if he was mentally he wasnt responsible for his actions?

AfternoonToffee · 14/08/2021 23:31

Something (many?) has gone terribly wrong to get to this point, it is 'easier' though to just write these people off as bad, evil, monster then to actually reflect as to how society has caused / allowed / enabled this to happen and to take serious steps to try to prevent it. All costs time and money, and when you have services cut to the bone this is the outcome.

BringBackThinEyebrows · 14/08/2021 23:17

Charlie Brooker said similar in an old episode of Newswipe-

I think in this situation there was so much available for the media to use, recent YouTube videos plus loads of online comments, they probably couldn't resist.

toocold54 · 14/08/2021 23:13

He was from the area so as he was walking around people were already saying his name saying he had a gun. I think his name was out before the police even got there. He walked casually past a couple of people with the barrel pointing to the ground so they rang and said what they saw.
I went into his FB before the news said what actually happened and there were thousands of comments of people accusing him already.

I think because his name was so wide spread so quickly they had to release his name and then of course now the media is in a race to find out information about him before other media sources.

I also think there is an element of why it happened. So lots of people are doing their own research just to try and find a reason.

justasking111 · 14/08/2021 23:13

A very bright searchlight needs to be shone on the incel movement. My OH has no idea what they're about nor my sons.

MrsPsmalls · 14/08/2021 23:04

You sure you're a psychiatrist bride? I have certainly never heard any of my colleagues call a patient a monster.

OnceUponAMidnightBeery · 14/08/2021 23:01

@Perching

I know what you mean but otoh maybe this ‘movement’ needs a bot of sunlight to bleach it out? My husband wasn’t even aware of it and I consider him quite switched on. He was horrified when I told hom this evening about incels/reddit/red pill/blue pill and I only know about because of the feminist boards in mumsnet.
Likewise, DH had no idea this was even a thing, and was horrified when I tried to explain.

I only know the little I do about it because of MN. I should learn more. I’ve kept away because it makes me so angry, but you’re right, these despicable ideas need exposure.

RaininSummer · 14/08/2021 22:59

He is a monster. Mental health may play a part but as far as I know he had a job, went to the gym and was no more disenfranchised than any other young working class person. One of the biggest issues is why it was thought sensible to allow a person with anger issues, autism and online violent rants to have a gun.

Bunnycat101 · 14/08/2021 22:57

He was a monster. From the accounts I’ve read (and wished I hadn’t) the way he killed the little girl in cold blood makes him an absolute monster. I have relatives with severe mental health issues who have been sectioned frequently. They were very sick but would have never hurt a child. Yes let’s find out what contributed to this but I firmly believe he was evil - granted he may have been mentally ill as well but I wish the press would stop reporting on him and his vile face.