Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed DH did a big shop & made this meal?

414 replies

lechatnoir · 14/08/2021 19:55

I've been at an event all day with one of my dc and asked DH to get a few bits from the shops. I asked him just get the basics to tide us over until the food order comes on Monday evening plus gave him the ingredients needed for a specific pasta salad dish my friend asked me to make for her bbq tomorrow.

So first AIBU: to be annoyed he did a massive shop - cupboards & fridge are full so I'm going to have to cancel the order I spent a good hour doing last night and then faff around working out whether we've actually got any meals for the week in the £180 shop he did Angry

And 2nd AIBU: to be really pissed off he's made some other completely random pasta salad dish. It does sounds lovely BUT it is neither what was requested by me/the host and won't be touched by the kids which was the whole point of mine! I can't work out if he was doing it to save me a job (in which case I look like a bitch) or to show-off his cooking he is a keen amateur chef convinced he'll win master chef one day Hmm

DH is always saying he feels he can't say or do anything without me criticising so I really really don't want to moan but FFS how hard is it to just get what I asked!

So AIBU and a negative, moaning old nag who needs to let it go or AINBU and he's a knob who ignores instructions & requests,, goes off piste then gets cross when criticised.

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 15/08/2021 13:31

Your own domestic arrangements (or mine) have nothing to do with it

You asked me for my alternate. I told you. Get it?

SemiFeralDalek · 15/08/2021 13:30

Yanbu and I'd be miffed too. I get it.

But I've had major conversations with my dh about him not listening to me, doing something "nice" (going off piste, creating problems and extra work which is then my responsibility to fix) and being pissed off that I'm not then eternally grateful to him.

PlumpCushion · 15/08/2021 13:26

OP I get it. I hate it when my DH does an off piste food shop because we end up with more beige processed food with no meal planning - and I’m still ‘expected’ to cook. He’s also far less likely to look at what we actually have in already and often forgets that I’ve recently done a big shop!
The mental effort of the food shopping had already been done. It’s disrespectful of him to have undermined those efforts. Her DH should’ve communicated with her before doing a big shop. It’s all very well being spontaneous and ‘uncontrolling’ about meal planning but in a busy stressful working week then the mental effort of deciding what to cook when I’m already dog tired can push me over the edge in terms of stress levels. I’m not saying that’s necessarily the case for the Op but the time for the DH to have his input and take control the week’s shopping should be before the op went to all the effort of planning things.

Shakespeare79 · 15/08/2021 13:23

@Blossomtoes
Your response to me is totally irrelevant! I don’t care how your marriage works, or what you think you’ve deduced about mine.

A PP suggested that OP should basically do it all herself if her DP’s way wasn’t good enough. I commented to the effect that this is indeed what strategically incompetent men want. You then chimed in to suggest that refusal to accept half-arsed domestic efforts was ‘playing into their hands’ (presumably because the poor put-upon man will then feel justified in not pulling his weight). I objected because I think strategic incompetence should be dealt with not tolerated.

Get it?

Your own domestic arrangements (or mine) have nothing to do with it.

Blossomtoes · 15/08/2021 13:09

[quote Shakespeare79]@Blossomtoes
Well could you explain the alternative then, if I’ve got it so wrong? If it’s ‘playing into their hands’ to reject half-arsed domestic efforts because it leads men to strop off and refuse to do anything, how do women achieve a situation whereby the man learns to pull his weight properly??

Or was your ‘playing into their hands’ comment in fact just complete goady bollocks? Hmm[/quote]
No, it wasn’t “goady bollocks”. If you’re as delightful in your marriage as you are here, your bloke’s life must be a bloody nightmare.

The alternative is that we both accept we have different approaches and standards for some things. He doesn’t make a bed, he makes a dogs’ breakfast so I do it. I can’t cook to save my life so he does it. If I asked him to make the bed I know in advance it won’t be to my standards so I wouldn’t complain. Equally if I cooked, he wouldn’t expect cordon bleu. It’s called playing to your strengths and team work, it’s been very successful for over 20 years.

Mynameisthecatwhogotthecream · 15/08/2021 13:07

Also if you can afford it don't cancel tomorrow's order but get him to go through it with you so that between you can now cross off anything you don't need as he's already bought it

Mynameisthecatwhogotthecream · 15/08/2021 13:04

I can see where your annoyance has come from, I wouldn't criticise him but ask him to help go through the meal plan for the next week and help plan new meals with what he's bought, don't do it all yourself, make him help as he's done the shopping

Shakespeare79 · 15/08/2021 13:00

@Blossomtoes
Well could you explain the alternative then, if I’ve got it so wrong? If it’s ‘playing into their hands’ to reject half-arsed domestic efforts because it leads men to strop off and refuse to do anything, how do women achieve a situation whereby the man learns to pull his weight properly??

Or was your ‘playing into their hands’ comment in fact just complete goady bollocks? Hmm

vampirethriller · 15/08/2021 13:00

Yanbu.

yomellamoHelly · 15/08/2021 12:59

Change the date on your slot to the following week. At least then you haven't wasted your time planning and choosing. And dh takes responsibility for meals / feeding everyone from the shop he did for this week.

Blossomtoes · 15/08/2021 12:56

[quote Shakespeare79]@Blossomtoes
What? Are you serious? It’s ‘playing into their hands’ to insist things aren’t fucked up repeatedly? So what’s the alternative. Actually, I know what your alternative is: do the bulk of all the proper work and then simper praise if the man actually does any job at all, even if it ultimately causes more work. Great! Grin[/quote]
You clearly know fuck all about me if that’s what you think.

Shakespeare79 · 15/08/2021 12:50

@Blossomtoes
What? Are you serious? It’s ‘playing into their hands’ to insist things aren’t fucked up repeatedly? So what’s the alternative. Actually, I know what your alternative is: do the bulk of all the proper work and then simper praise if the man actually does any job at all, even if it ultimately causes more work. Great! Grin

Blossomtoes · 15/08/2021 12:44

Well, that’s what many men want, isn’t it

Then why play into their hands?

MoiraNotRuby · 15/08/2021 12:42

@Ohsugarhoneyicetea

I would be extremely annoyed that my whole weeks meal planning had been chucked out the window by someone who just fancied a big foody spend up on the spur of the moment. I have neither the time or money to deal with that crap. I would be making it very clear that whoever bought all this food was responsible for all making all the meals that week. The person responsible for cooking the food, buys it, simple. I'm not running ready steady cook in my kitchen every night.

Again with the pasta dish, catering for others especially kids, can be complicated, allergies, intolerances, dislikes. Tricky to put together a menu for a group. Deviating from what was agreed with the host is unfair on the host, who no doubt is juggling lots already & doesn't need this crap.

The sex of who did what is completely irrelevant. It's just applying some basic common sense & courtesy to other people as well as some self control. He needs to be solely responsible for his actions here.

I agree with this. Feeding a family on a continuous basis is hard work. This DH sounds like a Disney Kitchen Dad. I can't stand 'glory cooks' parachuting in, messing up the system and declaring how amazing they are. Regardless of budget, food waste, getting five a day into kids, etc.
drpet49 · 15/08/2021 12:35

Your husband is not a dog. Assume it's his money too. Flipping heck the level of disrespect is awful. Sorry OP you sound awful to live with.

^I agree

Postdatedpandemic · 15/08/2021 12:32

OP could still make the kiddies pasta salad. Then there would be an adult pasta salad and a kids one. At no time has she said that he did not supply her with the necessary ingredients.

We have no idea if OP slaves over a computer for a good hour shopping and planning all on her own. Does the shop and plan with DH near by so he has some input or they do the shop, plan and cook almost 50/50. We have been told all three.

Would love to hear the other side of this.

Nc123 · 15/08/2021 12:24

Honestly the comments on here.

You don’t know why the host’s child needed pasta salad made a specific way. They could have a medical problem, or be going through a two-week fussy stage. That’s not the point. The point is that OP agreed to make the pasta salad according to what the host needed, and now can’t because someone else ignored what was needed to do what they thought would be nice. If OP’s sister or MIL had done the same thing instead of her husband, I guarantee the “be grateful” comments would be a lot thinner on the ground.

Shakespeare79 · 15/08/2021 12:15

@snowspider

I am shocked at the number of people who run their home lives like employment with plans that can't be deviated from and micromanaging by issuing instructions that specify exactly how you contribute to the home. Instructing your partner to buy and make an exact recipe salad for someone else's bbq because their children are extremely fussy is mad.

On the grateful not grateful front, whenever we eat in our house a few mouthfuls in to the meal someone who didn't cook (and even if they did make a contribution like peeling potatoes) pipes up with "Thank you for cooking'. And is usually followed with , yes it's delicious or I think I should have tried to get the pastry a bit crisper. Or this chicken is nice, is it the one from that new butcher. etc etc It's just nice.

The op seems to be in a situation where the pleasure has been sucked out of something which is a large part of life and much better if both partners find a way to enjoy it.

Some of us have very busy lives. Lists are made. Plans are compiled. Everyone needs to pull in the same direction. It’s just life.
C8H10N4O2 · 15/08/2021 12:12

Here's a partner who decided to do a bigger shop than asked, and make a pasta salad slightly different to the specification, and gets a kicking for not doing as he's told

If you read the OPs first post it was completely different and won't be eaten by the kids. So a waste of time, money and quite unnecessary.

He's not a pet. It's his food budget and weekly meal plan too. For this week only, he fancied going off piste. So bloody what

OP was quite clear that they agreed the plan together - if he wanted to go off piste why not raise it then?

Or are we saying men should take responsibility for aspects of the mental load but only if they comply with our specific instructions or risk being slated for doing it wrong

No. If you have agreed to do something stand by that agreement, especially when its something for a third party. He is wrong, why on earth should the OP be grateful for it?

Ohsugarhoneyicetea · 15/08/2021 12:12

I would be extremely annoyed that my whole weeks meal planning had been chucked out the window by someone who just fancied a big foody spend up on the spur of the moment. I have neither the time or money to deal with that crap. I would be making it very clear that whoever bought all this food was responsible for all making all the meals that week. The person responsible for cooking the food, buys it, simple. I'm not running ready steady cook in my kitchen every night.

Again with the pasta dish, catering for others especially kids, can be complicated, allergies, intolerances, dislikes. Tricky to put together a menu for a group. Deviating from what was agreed with the host is unfair on the host, who no doubt is juggling lots already & doesn't need this crap.

The sex of who did what is completely irrelevant. It's just applying some basic common sense & courtesy to other people as well as some self control. He needs to be solely responsible for his actions here.

Whatwouldscullydo · 15/08/2021 12:06

Is it? To me, it's equivalent to this: A asks B what B's child would like for Christmas. B gives a few specific suggestions. A gives child something else because that's what A fancied buying. Present is never played with

Exactly. Why ask what to bring if you have no intention of bringing It. Say at the bloody time or don't offer. Now with the host basing what they are making on the stuff they've been told will be being brought, now isn't perhaps as catered fir as hoped.

Maybe someone else is bringing something similar ajd they wanted a meat free/ dairy free/ non spicy version which now doesn't exist

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 15/08/2021 12:02

Instructing your partner to buy and make an exact recipe salad for someone else's bbq because their children are extremely fussy is mad.

Is it? To me, it's equivalent to this: A asks B what B's child would like for Christmas. B gives a few specific suggestions. A gives child something else because that's what A fancied buying. Present is never played with.

BarbaraofSeville · 15/08/2021 11:55

But he was doing a job that had already been done. They'd put together an internet order that's arriving on Monday and they just needed a few bits to bridge the gap.

snowspider · 15/08/2021 11:54

I am shocked at the number of people who run their home lives like employment with plans that can't be deviated from and micromanaging by issuing instructions that specify exactly how you contribute to the home. Instructing your partner to buy and make an exact recipe salad for someone else's bbq because their children are extremely fussy is mad.

On the grateful not grateful front, whenever we eat in our house a few mouthfuls in to the meal someone who didn't cook (and even if they did make a contribution like peeling potatoes) pipes up with "Thank you for cooking'. And is usually followed with , yes it's delicious or I think I should have tried to get the pastry a bit crisper. Or this chicken is nice, is it the one from that new butcher. etc etc It's just nice.

The op seems to be in a situation where the pleasure has been sucked out of something which is a large part of life and much better if both partners find a way to enjoy it.

fourminutestosavetheworld · 15/08/2021 11:53

We're always hearing about how women shoulder their family's mental load.

Here's a partner who decided to do a bigger shop than asked, and make a pasta salad slightly different to the specification, and gets a kicking for not doing as he's told.

He's not a pet. It's his food budget and weekly meal plan too. For this week only, he fancied going off piste. So bloody what.

Or are we saying men should take responsibility for aspects of the mental load but only if they comply with our specific instructions or risk being slated for doing it wrong.