Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why doctor would be certify someone as unfit for any work with just a sprained ankle?

212 replies

Trevorsarse · 14/08/2021 19:42

Someone my dh works with has been off with a sprained ankle for three weeks. Happened on the last day of his holiday. He has just sent in his fit note (very late) and it says he is not fit for work. He does the same job as my dh, some work on their feet but everyone does plenty of desk work too. So, he could easily just do all the desk bits and other people do all the walking/standing bits. Apparently the boss would be happy to have him do shorter/less hours and take longer breaks too but the guy has said he's not capable as he needs to rest.
It's really effecting their work because there are other people off on holiday on their small team so its putting them under loads of pressure.
I'm just wondering why the doctor signed off as completely unable to work on the grounds of a sprained ankle because surely there is work that he can do? When I sprained mine (and it was bad as I ended up needing an operation on it) I just had 4 days off and then went back to work on my crutches with my colleagues helping me out fetching stuff etc. Never thought to get signed off for over 3 weeks! Am I the mug here?

OP posts:
ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 14/08/2021 20:59

I had keyhole day surgery and was in significant pain for 4 or 5 weeks. The hospital said l needed 6 weeks off work.

It’s still people rummaging around inside you and it’s still a GAConfused

IsItWorthTheHassle · 14/08/2021 20:56

[quote Trevorsarse]@stardrawers my husband is telling me this because it affects his work and he wanted to discuss it with someone. I'm posting on here cos I'm interested in what other people think about this situation. I was surprised at over three weeks off without any work at all. Not even from the sofa. Knowing this guy dh reckons he's probably milking it. It is a genuine sprain (pics of the bruise went on the WhatsApp when he did it) but he admits its not really as bad as he's making out to the boss.
Just seems like a hell of a lot of time to take off and the longer it goes on the more it affects the other workers. The pandemic has really hit their business and times are still tough. We have been worried that it would fold a few times. They don't really have enough staff but thats because the business can't afford them right now so everyone else there is pulling their weight to help. The boss owns the business and is putting in absolutely loads of extra hours himself to try and make it work.[/quote]
Three things that are coming to mind

  • has the boss proposed to be working from his sofa/do only the desk work. If he hasn’t, it’s hard to have a go at the coworker for not doing it.
  • there are other things going on that you don’t know about
  • he is a lazy a**e who doesn’t care either about his job or others

The problem is that you have no way to know if it’s the first, second or third….

VaccineSticker · 14/08/2021 20:54

Sprains can vary in intensity. My friend recently sprained her foot after a bad fall whilst runnin. She was advised to keep her foot raised for first ten days, then work from a seated position for the 4 weeks. She wore her boot for 6 weeks - ankle was still swollen at 11 weeks but by week 13 it started to look normal.
Sprains heal much slower than fractures.

Badabingbadabum · 14/08/2021 20:53

It might be something else which he doesn't want to discuss with anyone at work. The badly sprained ankle might be what he is telling colleagues.

LobotomisedIceSkatingFan · 14/08/2021 20:52

Meh. I can understand your (husband's) frustration, OP. People can advise you to keep your Mbeak out' 🙄 all they like, but I get it. I work with someone who had keyhole, day surgery. In and out in a few hours; nothing even found (it was essentially exploratory). That she got a doctor to sign her off for a fortnight was pretty odd; when she managed to get him to do another two weeks after that, my jaw pretty much hit the floor. I'd love to ask him how he arrived at that decision, honestly. She was covered, mostly, but sometimes she wasn't and it made our lives a great deal harder. She's also managed to self-isolate about half a dozen times, so at least she's managed to binge a nice lot of 'Pretty Little Liars' or whatever bilge she favours.

FatAnkles · 14/08/2021 20:51

I'm a veteran of sprained ankles. I also broke an ankle 6 weeks ago, and was restingit up for most of that time. Orthopaedic Reg says it's healing well and I'm now off crutches, but because of the way I fell foot went all the way forwards at some funky angles down some stairs the ligaments are buggered and I've been referred to physio. Altogether the ankle will take about a year to be as near normal as it was before. I'll be put on very light duties for some weeks yet. Ankles are very complicated. And yes, crutches are a total bitch (I have the shoulder injuries to prove it)

But besides all that, it's none of your business why your DHs colleague got a sick note from his GP. I myself told everyone I had a broken ankle at work on WhatsApp but then one of my colleagues had witnessed my fall, and a couple of others needed to organise my cover. I don't expect their spouses/partners to get so het up about it, to be frank.

madamim · 14/08/2021 20:49

You get different grades with sprained ankles, sometimes it can be worse than a break

StarDrawers · 14/08/2021 20:48

but he admits its not really as bad as he's making out to the boss. that could just be bravado. You have no idea. The GP does.

He might be on some lovely painkillers.

PostMenWithACat · 14/08/2021 20:46

I have had a third degree sprain. Strapped up, reviewed in A&E, given a stick, had one day off. Also had two dc to care for and get to school.

Broke 5th metatarsal. Had a day off and went back to work. Tool two paracetamol. Consultant at the fracture clinic started writing a sick note for 4 weeks. I had to say "excuse me, I've been back at work for a week". He said I couldn't drive. It was my left foot, automatic people carrier with tons of room in the footwear and I had already checked with DVLA and my insurers admit was fine.

Few years later badly wedged a vertebrae - GP wanted to sign me off for a month. I asked to go a week at a time. I was back at work after 9 days. Same GP refused to refer me to a neurologist unless the pain prevailed for more than 10 weeks. When In asked the waiting time I was told it was 10 weeks. When I said that meant I could be off work for more than 20 weeks and might not in future be able to pay tax and NI for the benefit of the NHS, she slammed the referral on the desk and told me it wasn't personal.

I think the NHS culture is so skive driven those doing the signing off look at the cop out culture rather than what is right or what individuals are capable of.

Thelnebriati · 14/08/2021 20:44

Using crutches is not the same as using a chair. Its actually worse if you only use them for a few weeks; its takes some time to get the hang of them. If you fall while using them, there's a good chance you'll break your wrist.

Trevorsarse · 14/08/2021 20:42

@stardrawers my husband is telling me this because it affects his work and he wanted to discuss it with someone. I'm posting on here cos I'm interested in what other people think about this situation. I was surprised at over three weeks off without any work at all. Not even from the sofa. Knowing this guy dh reckons he's probably milking it. It is a genuine sprain (pics of the bruise went on the WhatsApp when he did it) but he admits its not really as bad as he's making out to the boss.
Just seems like a hell of a lot of time to take off and the longer it goes on the more it affects the other workers. The pandemic has really hit their business and times are still tough. We have been worried that it would fold a few times. They don't really have enough staff but thats because the business can't afford them right now so everyone else there is pulling their weight to help. The boss owns the business and is putting in absolutely loads of extra hours himself to try and make it work.

OP posts:
KentuckyCriedFricken · 14/08/2021 20:41

Unless you are privy to the man’s full medical history you have no idea why he’s been signed off. He may have a muscle or joint disorder that means the sprain is more complex than usual. He may be on pain medication that affects some other condition that he has. Yes it’s a mess when it leaves a workplace short-handed but management should always take into consideration that someone could be off sick at any time when approving annual leave requests and factor that into the headcount. If the person had been in a hospital bed your husband’s work situation would be no different. Don’t blame the injured for poor resource planning by management.

It’s not the injured person’s problem that this leaves the workplace short of staff. Goodness, imagine if someone suggested that those on maternity leave should come back early and help out when short of staff, after all they could do the desk work. That’s what you have suggested for the injured man. If you’ve ever taken mat leave, did you feel guilty that it left the company short-handed? Or feel that you should go back immediately if you can sit at a desk?

SunbathingDragon · 14/08/2021 20:39

When I sprained mine (and it was bad as I ended up needing an operation on it)

It can be a relatively minor sprain that can need an operation and a bad sprain that doesn’t. Most people do more damage after the event that caused the sprain (or injury) in the first place by not recuperating and resting, or getting home from where they hurt themselves.

CovidCorvid · 14/08/2021 20:39

And when I had ankle surgery I had six weeks off work even though i now work from home as I had to have it elevated all the time.

CovidCorvid · 14/08/2021 20:36

Maybe if you’d rested more you wouldn’t have needed surgery?

Putting your leg up all day and reducing swelling can really help the outcome. How would he get to work? I went to work on crutches for a week once and it was a nightmare….I was useless on the crutches and what should have been a 8 min walk from the station took 30 mins and I was exhausted.

FangsForTheMemory · 14/08/2021 20:36

I had a colleague with a desk job who got signed off for six weeks with a broken arm. I always assumed it was actually stress or similar, but none of my business anyway.

SunbathingDragon · 14/08/2021 20:35

@Trevorsarse

I don't get that because your ankle is injured you can't do some desk-based work from home. Doing so would not be "presenteeism", it would be making a reasonably small effort to help your team out when you are totally able to.
Not if he isn’t able to focus due to painkillers or if he is constantly hobbling to the loo because the medication gives him diarrhoea or sickness. You don’t know. You believe without seeing him or his medical records that you are better qualified to judge his fitness than a doctor.

Sprains aren’t comparable. That’s assuming he even has one and isn’t signed off for something else. If the GP wanted an easy life and signed him off regardless, it would be unlikely to be for as long as three weeks. The GP genuinely believes he is not fit to work. That last sentence is all you need to focus on.

ConfusedParticle · 14/08/2021 20:32

are you IDS? Grin

ArchbishopOfBanterbury · 14/08/2021 20:30

The Dr knows the reason he can't do his desk job from home. You don't.

Not all sprained ankles are the same. Some require serious painkillers which mean even desk work is too much, and some require regular physio/excercises which can't be done while working.

Catchthepigeons · 14/08/2021 20:29

I did my ankle in about 10 years ago, I tried to walk after 3 days and it gave way again and bent at 90° under my weight. I couldn't walk for a month and had to basically lie down to elevate it and reduce the swelling. It was worse than a break as the ligaments are permanently damaged and even now I have a lump of scar tissue on the side of my foot.

He could easily be telling the truth.

StarDrawers · 14/08/2021 20:29

@Trevorsarse

I don't get that because your ankle is injured you can't do some desk-based work from home. Doing so would not be "presenteeism", it would be making a reasonably small effort to help your team out when you are totally able to.
Maybe the doctor has told him he has to sit with his ankle elevated. You have no idea and seem overinvested in your husband's colleagues' health.
Clocktopus · 14/08/2021 20:28

it would be making a reasonably small effort to help your team out when you are totally able to.

Potentially at the cost to your health. The thing about I juries is that you only get one opportunity to heal.

It is none if your business, OP. Beak out and keep your opinions to yourself. A doctor has decided he is not fit for work, there ends the discussion as car as anyone else is concerned.

Clocktopus · 14/08/2021 20:26

That too, @RJnomore1.

When I was off sick due to a complicated miscarriage I told work colleagues that I'd had a bad kidney infection.

Trevorsarse · 14/08/2021 20:26

I don't get that because your ankle is injured you can't do some desk-based work from home. Doing so would not be "presenteeism", it would be making a reasonably small effort to help your team out when you are totally able to.

OP posts:
RJnomore1 · 14/08/2021 20:21

Different viewpoint.

He’s telling people it’s an ankle, it may not be.