Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why doctor would be certify someone as unfit for any work with just a sprained ankle?

212 replies

Trevorsarse · 14/08/2021 19:42

Someone my dh works with has been off with a sprained ankle for three weeks. Happened on the last day of his holiday. He has just sent in his fit note (very late) and it says he is not fit for work. He does the same job as my dh, some work on their feet but everyone does plenty of desk work too. So, he could easily just do all the desk bits and other people do all the walking/standing bits. Apparently the boss would be happy to have him do shorter/less hours and take longer breaks too but the guy has said he's not capable as he needs to rest.
It's really effecting their work because there are other people off on holiday on their small team so its putting them under loads of pressure.
I'm just wondering why the doctor signed off as completely unable to work on the grounds of a sprained ankle because surely there is work that he can do? When I sprained mine (and it was bad as I ended up needing an operation on it) I just had 4 days off and then went back to work on my crutches with my colleagues helping me out fetching stuff etc. Never thought to get signed off for over 3 weeks! Am I the mug here?

OP posts:
melj1213 · 14/08/2021 23:35

YABU - the last time I "sprained" my ankle I actually chipped one of the ankle bones but did more damage to the ligaments and muscles than the bone itself so it was treated as a bad sprain, bandaged up but not casted so I was given a walking boot and crutches

I was told by the doctors that for the first 14 days I was to keep it elevated and do no weight bearing on my foot at all. After that I was told to use the crutches for at least the next 6 weeks, increasing the weight bearing time incrementally.

I work in a supermarket, I was off for 4 weeks because I was not allowed to weight bear for 2 weeks and then it took another 2 weeks before the boredom of house arrest kicked in to make me want to go back to work for me to build up enough energy to be able to manage to do anything other than sitting on the sofa - including mastering my crutches and not getting exhausted from the 2 minute (which became closer to 5 minutes with crutches) walk to the bus stop to just get to work.

Mantlemoose · 14/08/2021 23:35

Some GP's will put something on a line which is true but actually not the full reason they're off work.

Itwontstopraining · 14/08/2021 23:26

OP when you're told to 'keep your leg elevated' it means 'keep your ankle higher than your heart'
Popping your foot on a stool doesn't cut it. I'm sorry you didn't understand your doctor's instructions last time you had them, but your ignorance doesn't qualify you to judge your husband's employee.

WhatAShilohPitt · 14/08/2021 23:21

Oops posted too soon. But he should surely be able to do some desk work at home.

WhatAShilohPitt · 14/08/2021 23:21

You are spot on with your comment about people asking why you care when they are the ones looking and replying on a forum!

It’s hard to say without knowing the private details of the note. My sprain meant I couldn’t walk properly or drive for months. Sometimes the advice is to properly rest it. You can’t do that if you have to commute.

ChequerBoard · 14/08/2021 23:17

Tell you what OP, why don't you send your email address to all the local GPs and the orthopaedics team at your nearest hospital and tell them to be sure to consult you whenever anyone sprains their ankle as clearly, having sprained your own ankle once, you are the expert?

DeflatedGinDrinker · 14/08/2021 23:16

3 weeks for a sprain?! My child had 3 weeks off after 6 hour emergency open surgery. That sounds ridiculous for a sprain.

Imnothereforthedrama · 14/08/2021 23:15

@Trevorsarse

Like I have said, the company is under pressure and has been since the pandemic, they were shut down and lost a huge amount if money. It ws not mis-management and compared to many in the industry, they've bounced back really well so i'd say it was actually pretty well managed but has really suffered due to pandemic/brexit etc. The guy who runs it seems pretty decent and and looks after his employees well.

I love people saying I should mind my own business and why am I interested in my Dh's work situation when they are the ones spending their saturday evenings posting to someone they don't know, about someone else they don't know, working at a company they don't know! At least I have some (negligible) real life investment.
We all are interested in talking/thinking/posting about these sorts of things that is why we are on an internet forum which is basically all the same gossipy shit. In the same way I am enjoying judging this guy, you are enjoying judging me for judging him.

I do sometimes feel sorry for some that post on Aibu but not you op . You asked opinion and funny enough said yabu but instead you’d rather bitch about those doing the same as you posting on mumsnet the irony op.
grapewine · 14/08/2021 23:09

When I did my leg I managed to keep it elevated very well while at my desk, just popped a stool and a cushion under it. I am sure going back to work fast didn’t cause me any probs.

He's not you, and you're not his doctor. The fact that you keep at this - why?

Clydesider · 14/08/2021 23:06

You're a judgmental, busybody type, aren't you.

You don't have a clue how this person is affected, either by the injury or the medication he is likely to be taking. Doctors don't sign people off work without good reason. I think its time you started minding your own business.

rubbletrouble · 14/08/2021 22:56

@Trevorsarse

He gets picked up by team mate for work as he only lives round the corner so he doesn’t drive himself. When I did my leg I managed to keep it elevated very well while at my desk, just popped a stool and a cushion under it. I am sure going back to work fast didn’t cause me any probs. Dr had said at first a&e assessment that op was fairly definite and in fact at later appointments they were surprised i’d not had more trouble with it considering the damage.
You are aware every situation is different so to keep referring back to your experience does not make it any more unreasonable for this guy to be signed off.
stevalnamechanger · 14/08/2021 22:55

@IsItWorthTheHassle

I agree with pp.

The GP thought it was a good enough reason for him to be off work. You have no idea of what other stuff is happening or not and the reasons the GP decided he was unfit.

I don’t think any of us, including you or your DH can make a judgement on that. Just trust the GP.

This!
rubbletrouble · 14/08/2021 22:54

The guy has been signed off as that is what is required to safely get him back to work. End of.

Now the nice boss has the timeframes to work with (and not try and get sick guy to work from home) he can arrange for temp staff to come in and take the pressure off the staff for the few weeks ??

Trevorsarse · 14/08/2021 22:52

He gets picked up by team mate for work as he only lives round the corner so he doesn’t drive himself.
When I did my leg I managed to keep it elevated very well while at my desk, just popped a stool and a cushion under it. I am sure going back to work fast didn’t cause me any probs. Dr had said at first a&e assessment that op was fairly definite and in fact at later appointments they were surprised i’d not had more trouble with it considering the damage.

OP posts:
a8mint · 14/08/2021 22:39

1 How does he get to work?
2 Maybe he needs to keep it elevated?

Feelingmardy · 14/08/2021 22:39

Not all sprains are the same. Some are much more severe and sometimes you need to keep your leg up and are taking pain meds that make it impossible to properly think

MintMatchmaker · 14/08/2021 22:32

How do you know the man doesn't have something else other than a sprained ankle. If he knows that he works in a gossipy workplace then he may choose not to share the entire story.

A medical professional has signed him off work, that should be accepted. It is not up to those less qualified and without full knowledge of the situation to decide that the doctor is wrong.

XenoBitch · 14/08/2021 22:25

Your DH is BVU to even be discussing it with you, and YABU for wondering about it. This chap's doctor signed him off. End of discussion.

Gonewiththegin · 14/08/2021 22:23

Quite frankly it is none of your business and your opinion on the situation is irrelevant.

grapewine · 14/08/2021 22:17

Sit down, this is none of your business. And perhaps suggest your husband has empathy rather than suspicion.

Exactly this. I'd hate to have a colleague like him.

IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves · 14/08/2021 22:17

You don't need to understand it.
His GP has assessed him as needing time off. End of story.
The fact that some others would crawl over broken glass then up and over a mountain of salt to get to their job is neither here nor there.

DailyMaui · 14/08/2021 22:09

I broke my wrist REALLY badly. I was signed off work for 5 weeks. The pain was excruciating.

Work colleagues were also like you and a bit Hmm

When I returned after 5 weeks the fuckers had cleared my desk.

i have never forgotten nor forgiven.

Sit down, this is none of your business. And perhaps suggest your husband has empathy rather than suspicion.

Alcemeg · 14/08/2021 22:07

In the same way I am enjoying judging this guy, you are enjoying judging me for judging him.

Probably the deepest thing I've read on MN, nice one OP 😀

Alcemeg · 14/08/2021 22:04

I know it sounds like a brilliant skyve, but I was once signed off work for 2 weeks with a sprained wrist. I couldn't believe my luck! I queried it with the specialist (surely I could at least answer the phone?), but they insisted I mustn't even attempt it. Apparently absolute rest was required or I ran the risk of more long-term damage.

Probably the happiest memory of my entire working life!

I suppose the thing is that in a work situation you can't just guarantee you'll just sit there not moving.

LumpyandBumps · 14/08/2021 22:01

I don’t know why but this post took me back many years to when I worked for what was then called the DHSS.
A clearly frustrated GP, having been asked for many ‘ sick notes’ by a long term customer, for a variety of minor ailments, recorded his diagnosis as ‘pendulum plumbocity’ 😊