Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed with MIL?

62 replies

Cutie18327 · 14/08/2021 19:10

Okay so long story cut short...

Myself and hubby are expecting our first child (I'm 39 weeks pregnant) and my MIL who currently lives abroad after her husband died stays with us whenever she comes to England (she has a house here but it's being rented so that she can live off of the income and not work, we also get a share of that rental because my husband is the one who manages it).

Now she arrived here two weeks ago and is staying until October, so until I've had the baby supposedly to help and to bond with her first grandchild. Since she has been here, she has not lifted a finger with the cooking at all. Unless something is actually put in front of her, she doesn't eat. So sometimes my husband will make her lunch, but a couple of times we have been out and she does not eat. Usually I make the dinner, but she does not help apart from a feeble 'Do you need anything' whilst she is sitting in the living room with her feet up. I feel like I can't just sort myself out food because it would be rude and sometimes I end up not able to eat because I feel awkward. She has done a bit of cleaning here and there but by large she hasn't really lifted a finger and I am worried about the extra burden on me when the baby comes. I don't want to have to be feeding and looking after a visitor!! The whole idea is that she is supposed to be here to help but I am getting more and more stressed.

I haven't mentioned my husbands contribution because he is very busy doing house DIY stuff and he does pull his weight...she also orders him around to make her tea (which he does) endlessly which also gets on my nerves.

AIBU? How do I navigate? I'm losing my patience and she still has another 2 months of being here...!

OP posts:
Cutie18327 · 15/08/2021 00:23

Thank you all for your responses. To address a few common questions!

  • She is 52, so is not old by any chance. She is fit and able bodied and is fully retired. My own mum is 56, less fit, and still manages to help considerably when she comes.
  • The agreement always was that she would stay with us when she came. My DH has no other siblings so it's all on his shoulders. We are accommodating to each others parents, I never imagined it would be quite this bad.
  • I am generally a very shy and quiet person. Actually asking someone else to do something I find rather uncomfortable hence why I am quietly seething as opposed to outright being straight with her. I know it's not a great trait of mine.

I think I will be having a word with DH about the division of work. He currently thinks she is suffering depression...I personally think she's using that as an excuse but he has more patience than me 😬

OP posts:
FortniteBoysMum · 14/08/2021 23:21

Tell her straight if she plans to eat she can cook. If she plans to stay she can help out. Set some house rules now and say once baby comes I cannot be running about after you and neither can dh. If you want to be here you pitch in. Do it sooner than later.

AutumnLeafDance · 14/08/2021 23:10

Give her a copy of 'The First Forty Days - The Essential Art of Nourishing a New Mother' to read. Tell her that you will be focused on recuperating and bonding with the baby post-birth, not feeding everyone else and running the household as per usual, and the best way she can support you is by preparing some of the nutritious recipes included.

Nsky · 14/08/2021 23:05

You should have had basic rules when she arrived, based on her ability, unless very frail it’s not ok.
I stay with family abroad, about 5 days, I always cook, pay for shopping and help out, it’s the right thing to do unless I’m really unwell

Howshouldibehave · 14/08/2021 22:59

Who suggested that she came?

What discussion was had at the time of this suggestion about what this visit would look like? Who was it benefiting?

August to October is a VERY long time to stay with someone.

ShingleBeach · 14/08/2021 22:54

I’d be putting her on the plane home and say she can come for no longer than 10 days no sooner than 2 weeks after the birth.

Has your DH got siblings or cousins or aunts and uncles she could stay with?

At the very least tell her that it will help if she takes over some significant jobs. Cooking 4 nights a week, for example.

Is your own Mum nearby? Or a sister? Honestly after the baby is born and your DH goes back to work I would go and stay with another family member for 5 days.

This will drive you beyond the edge of reason.

Howshouldibehave · 14/08/2021 22:50

My MIL has never stayed more than 3 nights-I can’t imagine anyone staying for that long.

She needs to leave-this is crazy! What does your husband think? She’s there to help but isn’t helping, then she can go!!

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 14/08/2021 22:45

You need to be very direct about it. Either you or DH.

Sit her down and say, "When baby comes, I will not be cooking for you. Not will DH. I would really appreciate if you could do A, B, and C everyday and support us as we get to grips with being parents for the first time.

If you cannot contribute to the general running of the house, it would be better if you could stay at a hotel. This would be shame but we cannot continue to keep running around you while looking after a newborn."

Or something along those lines depending on what sort of person you are. But you need to sort it NOW.

You don't need this stress at 39 weeks!

annacondom · 14/08/2021 22:41

This is not fair on you. Your baby does not need you to be stressed. If you can't get her out of your house, at least tell her what needs doing. As for offending her by getting yourself food, you are perfectly entitled to in your own home. It's her who is being rude, not you.

LouHotel · 14/08/2021 22:38

You seriously need to have a sit down with your husband, I don't think you both have fully comprehended the newborn stage and how much this set up has the potential to be a ticking time bomb that will have long term repercussions with your family and relationship.

Your 39 weeks pregnant and stressed imagine 1/2 weeks time when your sleep deprived, constipated standing in your bedroom naked using a hairdryer to dry your vagina cause you can't touch the stitches, having post delivery contractions (fucking astounding no one tells you about that) whilst still bleeding and thats without the day 3 baby blues.

This women unless you are extremely close to her will be seeing you at your most vulnerable....you are going to want to kill her if she asks you for a cup of tea.

I was going to post a fluffy congratulations posts and genuinely newborns are lovely and squidgy and it will be the most amazing feeling in the world holding your baby but that first 10 days is a reality check of your new normal coming at you like a freight train and its better to be prepared.

jellybe · 14/08/2021 22:29

You need to talk to your DH and have her staying somewhere else near by before the baby comes.

Why did you agree to this?
Next time she offers help ignore the feeble tone and say yes then give things to do. Or just tell her straight what you need from her.

Honestly this isn't going to do your relationship with DH or MIL any good if you don't set this straight now. Your resentment will build and then you will snap.

Hankunamatata · 14/08/2021 22:27

Ask her to do stuff. She's on a no win situation - she helps herself then she's too forward and interfering, then if she doesn't help then you feel put upon.

Have a chat with her and ask her to do stuff.

Shoxfordian · 14/08/2021 22:27

How have you agreed to her staying until October?!

Cherrysoup · 14/08/2021 22:26

Good Lord, send her some Airbnb adverts! Your dh needs to step up and tell her, big time. He should remind her she has come to ‘help’ but is actually creating more work, which is ridiculous given you’re about to pop.

Sceptre86 · 14/08/2021 22:22

Ypu haven't mentioned how old she is. If she was late 70s or in her 80s I would day yabu but it should be your oh cooking for her not you at 39 weeks pregnant. If she is in her 50s or60s and in good health then I would expect some help and ask for it. You need to be more direct and say I'd appreciate you taking over the cooking now as I'm struggling being on my feet too long. Ask if she can make some meals for the freezer. If she expects to be waited on then she will be of no use to you and your dh needs to tell her that so she can make other arrangements.

MsHedgehog · 14/08/2021 20:50

And you are definitely not being unreasonable. Your MIL is meant to be supporting you, not the other way round!

MsHedgehog · 14/08/2021 20:48

YABU for using “hubby”.

No, not really...I couldn’t resist! It’s one of those classic MN responses and thought I’d get in there first!

flameycakes · 14/08/2021 20:31

Stop pandering to her. Look after your own needs, she will soon get the message if you stop making her food etc. So what if it's rude, she doesn't seem to worry about how rude she is to you

Greenrubber · 14/08/2021 20:30

@GeorgiaGirl52
I'm a bit like your daughter lol
I feel other people just make more work for me! so that is why I also ask myself why do they think they are helping they know I always end up doing everything anyway!

Greenrubber · 14/08/2021 20:26

@Cutie18327

Just wanted to wish you all the best I know exactly how you feel
I have baby number 2 coming soon I've managed to talk MIL into waiting a week after the baby is here before she visits as I just want time to heal and not look after her also
I won't be allowed to go over so I'm hoping baby comes a little early Grin

Hiphopboppertybop99 · 14/08/2021 20:18

As PPs have said when she asks van she do anything, there is your chance " yes ease could you do X.. Thank you. I haven't been able to do Y... please could you? Thanks "
When baby is born just say to her "MIL, please feel free to make yourself breakfast/ lunch/ tea / coffee or whatever as I'll be feeding / looking after baby / napping when i can as my priority. If you need any help ask your son."
Hopefully she will take the home you won't be waiting on her hand and foot anymore. Good luck.

Gerwurtztraminer · 14/08/2021 20:18

Why can't you and DH be more assertive? Why do you care if it feels rude? Are there relationship issues making you reluctant to speak up?

What's holding you back other than misplaced politeness.

As for not eating - are you quite sure she'd let herself starve? Doubt it. She's either sneaking food and eating in her room, or just waiting knowing you'll crack.

Tell her now what you need and how it will change even more after baby arrives - no more expecting you to cook, she has to take turns with all household tasks and DH will not be tea making on demand as he'll be dancing attendance on you and baby. You have no idea how the birth and post natal period will go. It might be fine or you might have physical complications or other challenges. Tell her now she needs to step up and prepared for that, or go home early.

It's not rude to say this, she is rude to treat your house like a hotel.

Even if it feels rude, so what? You have every right to expect her to contribute. It's her grandchild on the way, she should want to help.

LadyTiredWinterBottom2 · 14/08/2021 20:13

Does she feel comfortable to make herself something to eat? Is she contributing to the food bill?

I would ask her what she wants when you go shopping if you are OK paying for it. Say you have noticed she doesn't always eat. If she calls when you are cooking tell her you could use some help chopping some veg.

Don't silently get annoyed, you are the only person suffering here.

MrsHuntGeneNotJeremyObviously · 14/08/2021 20:09

You are mad having her stay for this long. Either you or DH is going to have to have a word. Maybe she thinks you will be offended if she starts cleaning stuff and helping herself to food, so make it clear that you definitely won't be getting annoyed and would like her to make food for herself etc. Ask her to do things. If she's reluctant then it's time to tell your DH that this arrangement isn't working out for you anymore.
Or let your husband do it all - he might tell her himself to go home!

GeorgiaGirl52 · 14/08/2021 20:01

Maybe she is not sure what to do? My daughter has her "one right way" to do laundry and "one right way" to load dishwasher, etc. When I try to help she sighs, rolls her eyes, and refolds or reloads what I have just done.
Maybe give her specific suggestions -- "MIL, your special recipe Oyster Spaghetti is so good. Would you do it for dinner tonight? I have all the ingredients." Then walk out of the kitchen and leave her to it.