Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed with MIL?

62 replies

Cutie18327 · 14/08/2021 19:10

Okay so long story cut short...

Myself and hubby are expecting our first child (I'm 39 weeks pregnant) and my MIL who currently lives abroad after her husband died stays with us whenever she comes to England (she has a house here but it's being rented so that she can live off of the income and not work, we also get a share of that rental because my husband is the one who manages it).

Now she arrived here two weeks ago and is staying until October, so until I've had the baby supposedly to help and to bond with her first grandchild. Since she has been here, she has not lifted a finger with the cooking at all. Unless something is actually put in front of her, she doesn't eat. So sometimes my husband will make her lunch, but a couple of times we have been out and she does not eat. Usually I make the dinner, but she does not help apart from a feeble 'Do you need anything' whilst she is sitting in the living room with her feet up. I feel like I can't just sort myself out food because it would be rude and sometimes I end up not able to eat because I feel awkward. She has done a bit of cleaning here and there but by large she hasn't really lifted a finger and I am worried about the extra burden on me when the baby comes. I don't want to have to be feeding and looking after a visitor!! The whole idea is that she is supposed to be here to help but I am getting more and more stressed.

I haven't mentioned my husbands contribution because he is very busy doing house DIY stuff and he does pull his weight...she also orders him around to make her tea (which he does) endlessly which also gets on my nerves.

AIBU? How do I navigate? I'm losing my patience and she still has another 2 months of being here...!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
QueenBee52 · 15/08/2021 16:15

[quote billy1966]@QueenBee52...exactly.

So she has been playing 90 expecting a pregnant woman to be house skivvy, but once spoken to is suddenly doing super cleaner on it?🙄

I wouldn't hold my breath OP, she sounds like a piece of work![/quote]

yip 😳

MrsHuntGeneNotJeremyObviously · 15/08/2021 16:09

To be fair, if the DH had spoken to the mil and she'd done nothing, people would be criticising her. She's shown willing. What you need to be aware of is flash in the pan changes. If this arrangement is going to work then it will need to be sustainable change that everyone is happy about.
The real test will be once the baby is born. Many new mothers feel more territorial about their homes and babies, once born, than they anticipated feeling beforehand. I often just wanted to retreat to my bedroom with my baby. I guess how this goes will hinge on whether your mil is sensitive and gives you and DH space to bond and just be or whether she will try to commandeer the baby. Even nice people with the best of intentions don't appreciate just how much they will love the new baby and this can be hard for mils because they have all this family love but they aren't the mum or the mum's mum! Which is why it's not great to be living together. I hope it works out for you all but remember it is okay to change your mind about this arrangement if it doesn't. You don't owe it to anyone to live like this if it stops work for you

billy1966 · 15/08/2021 13:35

@QueenBee52...exactly.

So she has been playing 90 expecting a pregnant woman to be house skivvy, but once spoken to is suddenly doing super cleaner on it?🙄

I wouldn't hold my breath OP, she sounds like a piece of work!

Holly60 · 15/08/2021 13:21

Also just to add no it’s not a great trait to not be able to say what you need and then quietly seethe at someone when they don’t read your mind. I think you’ve done the right thing speaking to DH but I also think it would be worth trying to work on being able to assertively ask for what you need :’morning MIL, I’d really like to get all the washing done this morning, do you think you’d be able to help me’ or ‘I’ve got a shopping list here, do you think you’d be able to go and do it for me’

QueenBee52 · 15/08/2021 13:06

@Cutie18327

As an amendment to the above post, my husband spoke with her early in the morning at the moment and I woke up to find that she has mopped, cleaned the kitchen and offered to hoover so fingers crossed we are heading in the right direction!

oh lord...

Im always wary of the extremes in behaviour ... 🤣

Holly60 · 15/08/2021 13:04

@Cutie18327

As an amendment to the above post, my husband spoke with her early in the morning at the moment and I woke up to find that she has mopped, cleaned the kitchen and offered to hoover so fingers crossed we are heading in the right direction!
Oh bless her, that’s brilliant. Maybe she didn’t know how happy you are to have her do these things.
Holly60 · 15/08/2021 13:02

She does sound hard work, however I’m a bit confused. With the dinner, are you not just making a bit extra of whatever you are having for her? So if you are doing spag Bol, making it for 3 rather than 2? Or it’s it’s jacket potatoes and cheese just putting an extra potato in the oven. Then it’s obviously up to her if she wants it. Or you could say, ‘I’m doing chilli con carne, would you like some?’.

With the not helping in other ways, I agree with other posters, just give her some jobs to do.

Also I would say to your DH to say something along the lines of ‘mum you aren’t a guest here, you are family, so please help yourself to cups of tea whenever you want’ if she asks for a cup of tea he says ‘ooh yeah that’s a good idea, do you want to stick the kettle on and get the cups out, I’ll just finish this job…’

Cutie18327 · 15/08/2021 12:35

As an amendment to the above post, my husband spoke with her early in the morning at the moment and I woke up to find that she has mopped, cleaned the kitchen and offered to hoover so fingers crossed we are heading in the right direction!

OP posts:
Cutie18327 · 15/08/2021 12:19

After having a very detailed and long conversation with my husband (he was very understanding and sympathetic, despite some comments he definitely does see the issues and is willing to try and resolve them first before escalating the situation), we have decided that he is going to talk with her without me around first of all as a buffer then we will have a conversation together. I have said in no uncertain terms, that kitchen duty will be completely his once the baby comes and I will start making lists of chores that need doing and putting it on the fridge for them to work through.

It just frustrates me that a houseguest wouldn't take the initiative themselves to get involved but I guess people are different. Plus my own mother is an absolute godsend and I will be welcoming her with open arms as often as she would like to come (she always comes armed with shopping to cook or pre cooked food) and will be asking her to involve MIL much more if possible.

Someone mentioned bonding activities between me and her and I do think that they help so I will definitely try that too.

OP posts:
Howshouldibehave · 15/08/2021 11:56

@GreenFingersWouldBeHandy

Actually asking someone else to do something I find rather uncomfortable hence why I am quietly seething as opposed to outright being straight with her. I know it's not a great trait of mine.

Sorry but this situation isn't going to resolve itself.

Either you need to say something or your DH does.

Or you'll just have to carry on seething, while sleep-deprived, with a newborn latched onto your boob, while this woman sits with her feet up watching TV and with you and DH at her back and call.

This!

Better to have an awkward conversation than put up with this for MONTHS!

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 15/08/2021 10:51

Actually asking someone else to do something I find rather uncomfortable hence why I am quietly seething as opposed to outright being straight with her. I know it's not a great trait of mine.

Sorry but this situation isn't going to resolve itself.

Either you need to say something or your DH does.

Or you'll just have to carry on seething, while sleep-deprived, with a newborn latched onto your boob, while this woman sits with her feet up watching TV and with you and DH at her back and call.

NapoleonOzmolysis · 15/08/2021 09:53

It would be cheaper to pay her to stay in an AirBnB than it would be to get divorced. Which is exactly what you will want to do when you realise having your MIL in the house post-birth and the pathetic way your DH has dealt with it has given you PND and ruined the first few months of your DC's life. The resentment will eat at you. When you can't wander round the house with antenatal insomnia, when you are aching all over from lack of sleep and birth injuries and you are having to make her dinner because otherwise you won't get to eat. When you are leaking at all ends and she's sitting on the sofa doing fuck all. All you will be thinking off is Go Away.

Kisskiss · 15/08/2021 09:42

Ahhh shes 52?!? Tell your husband to have a word with her! Make up the list of house tasks and leave it to him to split them with her

MrsHuntGeneNotJeremyObviously · 15/08/2021 09:22

Babies change things. Just because this was the arrangement, it doesn't mean you have to keep to it forever. You mil is still a young woman and should be running her own household, not living with you for months at a time. Being understanding of each others families is good but it doesn't extend to living with them frequently, for large chunks of time. Your husband shouldn't have asked this of you. Him being an only child doesn't mean he's responsible for his mum's life and happiness.
You know she can probably only retire because she's living off the money she makes renting out her house, whilst living with you. You are likely finding this arrangement. And if not, then she can afford to leave.
It's honestly not wrong to want your home to yourselves while raising your own family and being a young couple.
If you are genuinely happy with this arrangement, then you have to find your voice because resentment will only grow if you don't.
Personally I'd be telling both her and DH that this isn't making me happy anymore.

Feelingoktoday · 15/08/2021 09:04

52!!!!!!!!!!! She needs to go and live in her own property. Cheeky cow. So she has retired because she rents out her house so generates an income and then dosses at yours for free for undefined periods of time. She needs to go and rent somewhere else. It doesn’t work like that.

billy1966 · 15/08/2021 08:15

OP,

52?

I mean this very kindly, but you have been had and have been very dim to agree to her moving in for months.

She is a user.

This is going to get a lot lot worse.

She is going to ruin this time for you.

She is likely to stress you so much that you will get a bit of PND from it.

You need to stand up for yourself.

I'm 56 and have 4 children that I run around after so a 52 year old woman expecting to be waited on is utterly taking the piss.

You are being hugely used by this very selfish woman.

Wake up and deal with it by moving home to your mothers and telling your husband you will not be returning on till she is gone or suck it up and accept an utterly miserable time living with her whenever she wants for the next 40 years.

Flowers
Meraas · 15/08/2021 08:06

She needs to leave. Ignore the ‘don’t be mean’ comments.

Billandben444 · 15/08/2021 06:23

I'd stop making meals for her for a start - just make your own, then tell her to help herself if she's hungry.
Wow!
OP, it sounds as though you've all slipped into roles that don't make for harmonious house sharing. Your MIL has tentatively offered to help and it's been turned down so has become the pampered guest - what would the reaction have been on here if she'd arrived, all guns blazing, and reorganised your cutlery drawer and washed your smalls by hand? There is a middle ground and I'd have a sit down with just her (ask her to make you both a coffee as you want to talk about what will happen when baby comes) and then tell her that you'd like her help around the house now you're so big and what does she feel happy to take on? Tell her how you think the first couple of weeks will pan out and how lovely it would be if you knew she was on top of everything else to make life easier while you enjoy baby. Please don't be mean to her (can't believe some of the nasty comments on here) but decide beforehand what you want to get out of the chat and don't give up until you know she gets it. You can tell her son afterwards what's been agreed so that he supports you and there's no backsliding!

InpatientGardener · 15/08/2021 06:18

If she's come with the intention to help with the baby, I'd be worried that she'll be taking over baby duties whilst you do the housework and cooking, which is absolutely not what you want, it needs to be the reverse of that!

NumberTheory · 15/08/2021 05:21

I think pushing this off on to your DH is a poor approach. Generally I agree with each partner dealing with their own parents, but you are the one spending all the time with her, you are the one whose needs need accommodating. Having your DH mediate everything is impractical and liable to create misunderstanding and resentment.

You really need to learn to ask for what you need from her in a nice way. When she asks 'Do you need anything' tell her 'Yes, actually. It would be great if you could....'

Think about what you would like her to be doing once the baby arrives - say laundry is on the list, then next week, when it's time to do some, say to her 'MiL, why don't I show you how the washing machine works so you can help out once the baby arrives.'

Also, you might try and do some more social things with her - take her out for afternoon tea or just a coffee at a local Costa, maybe find a TV program you both like and watch together. She's going to be hanging out for months and you want to be comfortable when the baby's here. Good relationships with extended family don't just happen. Ideally there's a bit of chemistry, if not it's normally the older relative who leads the way, but if that isn't happening it's down to you.

Being shy makes it harder, but it doesn't let you off the hook, the chasm between you is going to be there until one of you finds a way to make a connection and you are the only one you can make do this. Besides, this will be good practice for being a mum - you need to be able to advocate for what your child needs and being too shy to do make connections will be a disadvantage. Practice really helps, honestly, it gets easier.

ShingleBeach · 15/08/2021 04:56

Where does your own Mum live?

How will she get chance to see your baby?

KhalliWhalli · 15/08/2021 01:19

I thought she was going to be about 80 years old! She’s younger than me! Your DH needs to give her jobs to do. Things like vacuuming and emptying the dishwasher. If she doesn’t eat, that’s her lookout. She’s not a child.

CraftyYankee · 15/08/2021 01:18

Hah, depression. Is your DH always blind to his mother's behavior?

You really need to have a talk with your DH and find your backbone or you will be at high risk of PND. This will not get better on its own.

Good luck getting dh onside, you're going to need it.

cadburyegg · 15/08/2021 01:13

Stop cooking and providing her with food. It’s not your job to ensure she eats. The cooking should be on the other 2 adults in the house now. You need to lay the law down now with your DH, because in a few days/weeks you will be at your most vulnerable. If she has depression then she is not the right person to be staying with you right now, that may sound harsh but I have depression myself and I wouldn’t dream of going to stay with someone who is just about to have a baby unless I knew I would be of use to them.

VladmirsPoutine · 15/08/2021 00:28

I know this will be of no help to you but as soon as the idea of her coming to stay for months to 'bond with the baby' or whatever was mooted 'd have put my foot firmly down. Absolutely NOT.

Anyway, get your husband to have a word. I do hope for all your sakes that when baby arrives she won't be criticising your parenting or how you do things and generally wading in to take baby off you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread