Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New school bag and lunchbox every September?

590 replies

AvocadoHo · 14/08/2021 18:06

Light hearted debate with OH.

Making a list of school uniform needed for daughter (8) going back to school.

He rolled his eyes snd asked "why does she need a new bag? What's wrong with the one she has?"

Nothing is wrong with it, it's just a bit grubby and battered. But when I was growing up we had a new bag and lunch box every year. He feels this is excessive.

Is it really that uncommon?

OP posts:
KazenoTaninoNaushika · 16/08/2021 20:46

So for me, this isn't about deciding whether or not to bother making an effort for the environment but to decide where you are going to make that effort.

So it turns out that, for my youngest, a new bag and (in his case) a new coat for the start of his first proper school term in P1 was really important. I only found that out today (we're in Scotland, so term starts today). When I suggested that he could just wear the mac he'd worn to nursery as recently as last week, he bawled his eyes out. "That can't possibly happen, mum." (Apparently.) "Because that was a "nursery" mac and now I'm a schoolboy." Okaaaaay.

So it seems to me that rite-of-passage shit, like new bags and lunchboxes, may be really psychologically important to (some) kids......makes sense I guess, as kids live in an environment where their sense of self-worth is coloured by whether authority figures think they have been "good enough", so even wanting a different bag for your new teacher between P1 and P2 seems like maybe them wanting a "fresh start"?? And I make a zillion mistakes in my life every day, and feel constantly guilty, so I'm all about understanding the concept of "A Fresh Start" ;-)

So in that case, because the threat to our planet is terrifying and real, I'm going to cut back on some item of clothing that I may have otherwise got for myself (because it's fashionable, or because I think I need a new pair of trainers, or even because it really does have holes in it and need to be replaced) so that he can have this rite-of-passage thing that obviously means so much to him. And then next time, when he asks me for a piece of plastic tat in the toyshop, which he doesn't need, but actually I do really need a new pair of trainers cos the oldies have holes in, I'll refuse his request, and "save" the environmental waste there, whilst adding it to my moral account :-)

melj1213 · 16/08/2021 20:38

I went to a Kindergarten to Sixth Form private school and the school bag was part of the uniform. Nobody was ever bothered about new bags every school year as you couldn't tell the difference between new bags and old ones.

In Primary you had a book bag with the school logo and a plain black drawstring bag for PE kit. The book bags usually lasted your entire primary years. The PE bags generally needed replacing every couple of years (as they would get worn out from kids dragging them along the floor) but they only cost about £5 and most people just replaced them as they wore out. Some kids got new ones every year but not many.

When I started in Kindergarten, secondary students had to use a briefcase but by the time I got to Yr7 they had allowed students to carry backpacks - a lot of students cycled or had long walks to school so briefcases weren't practical - but it had to be the school issued ones which came in two styles - one smaller one and one larger one. PE bags were the same - it had to be a plain black holdall or one with the school logo.

Everyone got a backpack in Yr 7 and pretty much everyone kept the same bag till Yr 11. The only time people tended to get new bags is if their bag was worn out or got damaged which rarely happened unless kids were seriously rough as they were a good quality and heavy duty design.

Instead of getting new bags evey year, kids would buy new keyrings and accessories to hang off the bag zippers to identify their bag (since they were all identical) which was still wasteful but replacing a plastic toy with a fluffy pompom is a lot less wasteful than replacing a whole bag.

DingoDollar · 16/08/2021 20:37

Ours (smiggle bought last summer) look barely used.

There was a whole term when they weren't used.

Luckily my DC don't have any notion of needing new for the new school year.

Primary school though so just hang on pegs all day anyway.

Secondary I'll probably be more inclined to get them new.

wedwewerpink · 16/08/2021 20:18

@Fudgein I don't get it!!??...if an item is in good condition then please enlighten me? Why is it good enough to be donated but not good enough to use for longer? How sad!

kowari · 16/08/2021 20:05

Um. Why not donate the new items to the school, if there's nothing wrong with your kids bag/pencil case etc?
Yes, I'm sure disadvantaged children would love something new too, particularly if it is as you say and the majority are getting new each year. That would put a lot of pressure on struggling parents and make their children feel left out. If you enjoy back to school shopping and can afford it you could shop to donate instead, maybe replace your child's bag less often and donate a new bag in the years in between.

00100001 · 16/08/2021 19:44

@Fudgein

I buy new every year, as does everyone I know. However I do always give any items still in good condition to the school & they distribute them to families who need them. I do the same with uniform & mostly it's all in good condition as my DD seems to grow at lightening speed. Although I generally only buy 2 new school outfits as, like previous posters mentioned, I will be buying more at christmas time when my DD will no doubt have grown again.
Um. Why not donate the new items to the school, if there's nothing wrong with your kids bag/pencil case etc?
AccidentallyOnPurpose · 16/08/2021 19:43

Can't we just spoil them" is the attitude causing massive issues with overconsumption, waste and using up resources. Yes its OK to spoil kids from time to time, but I would wager its not from time to time is it?

Not to mention that if it's tradition and regular and expected, it's not even spoiling them anymore . It's something that just happens.

Whinge · 16/08/2021 19:39

So it’s ok for your children’s classmates to have your castoffs? But heaven forbid your own children use the same bag two years running.

I'm glad i'm not the only one who thinks it's a crap attitude. Surely it would be nicer to buy a new lunchbox for a disadvantaged child who may never have anything new, rather than giving them your child's seconds each year?

bedtimestories · 16/08/2021 19:24

I teach my kids about being wasteful, they don't ask for new lunch boxes and bags every year. They've had the same bag and lunch bag since September 19 when they needed replacing

LittleBearPad · 16/08/2021 18:58

@Fudgein

I buy new every year, as does everyone I know. However I do always give any items still in good condition to the school & they distribute them to families who need them. I do the same with uniform & mostly it's all in good condition as my DD seems to grow at lightening speed. Although I generally only buy 2 new school outfits as, like previous posters mentioned, I will be buying more at christmas time when my DD will no doubt have grown again.
So kind Lady Bountiful!

So it’s ok for your children’s classmates to have your castoffs? But heaven forbid your own children use the same bag two years running.

Mummyratbag · 16/08/2021 17:56

But @burritofan think how "smart" they will look with their shiny unicorn pencil cases as they write about their weekends spent bailing out the downstairs of their homes...perhaps they can fill the old school bags with sand to act as barricade.

burritofan · 16/08/2021 17:46

A few people have said this, or something similar. But why can't you just institute a new "going back to school" tradition, that doesn't involve buying unnecessary items? Going for a milkshake after school shoes/uniform shopping, for example?
Back-to-school wildfire watching, or back-to-school wading through flash floods. 🥰

Kanaloa · 16/08/2021 17:40

@ineedaholidaynow

DS's school are asking him to bring in a laptop in the new term. Following on from parents buying everything new in September, do I need to buy a new laptop every September, to go with his new bag and pencil case?
And a new laptop case. You don’t want him to be the scruffy kid with last year’s Apple Mac.
ineedaholidaynow · 16/08/2021 17:39

DS's school are asking him to bring in a laptop in the new term. Following on from parents buying everything new in September, do I need to buy a new laptop every September, to go with his new bag and pencil case?

HungryHippo11 · 16/08/2021 15:27

@lazylump72

I see a lot of different attitudes on here and I may be rightly so regarded as selfish and frivolous but what about the kids?Cannot we just spoil them?Why can;t they have what they want?Who says you have a bag you must respect that bag or die trying?You must value said bag or you are a horrible child...its bull. Kids change their minds, they like and want new things all the time I see no problem with this if parents can afford to do so.
"Can't we just spoil them" is the attitude causing massive issues with overconsumption, waste and using up resources. Yes its OK to spoil kids from time to time, but I would wager its not from time to time is it? Its a new backpack one week, new trainers another week, toys, magazines, more clothes they don't need etc etc. Multiplied by 66 million people...
Terhou · 16/08/2021 15:15

@waterlego

Well, I must say I’ve been convinced. ‘It’s nice’ and ‘I loved school shopping’ seem like excellent reasons to buy unnecessary stuff and contribute to landfill.
Grin Grin
00100001 · 16/08/2021 14:18

@PrincessNutella

awww, come on, I'd always get them a new one at the beginning of the school year, I loved school shopping!
But why would you get a new one just because it's September?

It's consumerism! The shops obviously want you to spend spend spend... But that doesn't make it the right thing to do.

I have never encouraged my kid to want new things for the sake of wanting new things. Yes, it's nice to get a new bag, or whatever. But the new bag is because the old one is falling apart, not because of a need to feed a desire to get new things.

waterlego · 16/08/2021 13:41

Well, I must say I’ve been convinced. ‘It’s nice’ and ‘I loved school shopping’ seem like excellent reasons to buy unnecessary stuff and contribute to landfill.

Neverrains · 16/08/2021 13:04

@PrincessNutella

awww, come on, I'd always get them a new one at the beginning of the school year, I loved school shopping!
What do you do with the old ones?
Neverrains · 16/08/2021 13:03

One of them has had the same bag since reception?!

They might not have had one in reception if they had school dinners?

PrincessNutella · 16/08/2021 12:54

awww, come on, I'd always get them a new one at the beginning of the school year, I loved school shopping!

BluebellCockleshell123 · 16/08/2021 12:48

2 of them have had the same bags since they started school.

DC1 (yr 12) has had 3 bags (2 broken zips)
DC2 (yr 9) has had only 1 bag
DC1 (yr 6) has had only 1 bag

Fudgein · 16/08/2021 12:47

I buy new every year, as does everyone I know. However I do always give any items still in good condition to the school & they distribute them to families who need them. I do the same with uniform & mostly it's all in good condition as my DD seems to grow at lightening speed. Although I generally only buy 2 new school outfits as, like previous posters mentioned, I will be buying more at christmas time when my DD will no doubt have grown again.

Yourstupidityexhaustsme · 16/08/2021 12:35

@BluebellCockleshell123

I have 3 DCs who have a combined total of 25 school years.

Just worked out that they have had a total of 5 school bags between them!!! Imagine the waste if I had bought one every year.

To be fair, I do buy really good ones at £50 a pop so they should last.

One of them has had the same bag since reception?!
Yourstupidityexhaustsme · 16/08/2021 12:35

@DariaMorgendorffer

I agree with you on this.

It’s all relative. Some posters vehemently condemning people buying a new school bag may eat meat every night and go on two plane holidays a year. I’d say a new bag for someone with a low carbon lifestyle is a very low level problem vs a new bag for a high carbon lifestyle. It’s all about little steps, not the total eradication of planetary impact.

At the end of the day, we could all still be using our school book bags and 70% of carbon emissions are coming from the big companies.

Swipe left for the next trending thread