Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New school bag and lunchbox every September?

590 replies

AvocadoHo · 14/08/2021 18:06

Light hearted debate with OH.

Making a list of school uniform needed for daughter (8) going back to school.

He rolled his eyes snd asked "why does she need a new bag? What's wrong with the one she has?"

Nothing is wrong with it, it's just a bit grubby and battered. But when I was growing up we had a new bag and lunch box every year. He feels this is excessive.

Is it really that uncommon?

OP posts:
ineedaholidaynow · 17/08/2021 21:49

I don't think it is virtue signalling as such, it is meant to be showing how awful the attitude of some people are that their child couldn't possibly come to school without a new bag, but it is fine for children of poor families to do so.

EspressoDoubleShot · 17/08/2021 21:40

Yes @ineed and this was extended to Um.Why not donate the new items to the school, if there's nothing wrong with your kids bag/pencil case etc? I am asking is it a global give new items to poor pupils or only new items up to a certain value. So give a new pencil case or bag but don’t give a new coat or blazer?

EspressoDoubleShot · 17/08/2021 21:36

Right,there we are

So, You pay the occasional school meal, buy an occasional item for pupils. That’s very decent and may public sector workers do too.

It was suggested in thread that instead of buying new items,people should keep existing item and buy someone poor the new items with the equivalent sum of money. That’s A whole lot of virtue signalling

ineedaholidaynow · 17/08/2021 21:32

I thought some of these comments about buying something new for a disadvantaged pupil, were in response to other posters who are saying that their child could not possibly turn up to school on the first day of term in September without a new bag, but it is okay because they donate the old bag to charity (in other words, it is okay for a poor pupil to turn up with an old, used school bag but not their precious child)

FishfingerFlinger · 17/08/2021 21:31

Blimey this is an eye-opener.

Our lunch bag is going into 5th year of use this year having followed DS through nursery and beyond, and I bought a used school rucksack for £1 at the PTA sale which is now in its 3rd year of use with us, who knows how many in total? Bit scuffed but perfectly functional.

We could well afford new but really, what’s the point?

Whinge · 17/08/2021 21:25

@EspressoDoubleShot

Do you routinely forgo an item for yourself to buy new for someone else instead. Public sector health,SW and education buying or giving clients items when they’re skint,yes that goes on.regularly. I’m not asking you about the infrequent payment of a school meal or small item . I’m asking you do you regularly and routinely forgo buying yourself something say a new coat, but divert that sum of money to someone else? For example You do not upgrade your own tech as it still works but do you take the equivalent sum of money and spend it on someone else?

Most teachers,SW, HV,Doctors, OT, police have at some point bought or donated items for clients. That’s different from choosing to deny self a new item but buy the equivalent item for someone else because they don’t have it

Why does it need to be a regular occurence?

I don't regulary buy new coats or upgrade my technology, so no, I wouldn't donate the equivalent sum of money or buy those items for someone else. As I only replace them when mine are no longer usable.

The thread was initially asking about buying new lunch boxes and bags each September when there's nothing wrong with the old ones. I can suggest that it would be a nicer idea to donate the new bag or lunchbox if someone felt they had to buy new each September, without applying this to every area of my life.

EspressoDoubleShot · 17/08/2021 21:18

Do you routinely forgo an item for yourself to buy new for someone else instead.
Public sector health,SW and education buying or giving clients items when they’re skint,yes that goes on.regularly. I’m not asking you about the infrequent payment of a school meal or small item . I’m asking you do you regularly and routinely forgo buying yourself something say a new coat, but divert that sum of money to someone else? For example You do not upgrade your own tech as it still works but do you take the equivalent sum of money and spend it on someone else?

Most teachers,SW, HV,Doctors, OT, police have at some point bought or donated items for clients. That’s different from choosing to deny self a new item but buy the equivalent item for someone else because they don’t have it

Linguaphile · 17/08/2021 21:17

I wouldn’t think to replace a bag or lunchbox except if it was worn out or somehow unfit for purpose. Good ergonomic school bags don’t come cheap, and a decent quality bag should last longer than just one year.

Whinge · 17/08/2021 21:07

really….you make do and buy the “disadvantaged” new. Don’t believe you

If you don't believe me then I doubt there's anything I can say to change you mind. 🤷‍♀️

I work in a school, and like many school staff I have been known to buy new items for disadvantaged children. It shouldn't be a part of the job, but unfortunately it's not an uncommon occurrence.

EspressoDoubleShot · 17/08/2021 20:57

Those of you recommending redistribution of monies to the disadvantaged do you maintain that principle in your own life?

Invited to a wedding as a guest do you think, that money that I could have spent on outfit or accessories I’ll give to the disadvantaged. Or buy the outfit and give it to poor/less well off.

Surely it would be nicer to buy a new lunchbox for a disadvantaged child who may never have anything new, rather than giving them your child's seconds each year? really….you make do and buy the “disadvantaged” new. Don’t believe you

Um.Why not donate the new items to the school, if there's nothing wrong with your kids bag/pencil case etc? do you apply this logic to your own family..do you make do with existing item and buy new for someone else who is financially constrained? No phone or tech upgrades as existing item works, but donate new item to someone else?

ElephantOfRisk · 17/08/2021 18:46

That's always been an issue. Rich person might pay £100 for a pair of good quality leather shoes that can be maintained and give many years of wear. Someone else might be only able to afford a £15 pair of plastic shoes or cheap trainers and they are worn out or broken in months and need to save up again and they are usually not the type that can be re-heeled or waxed so can't just get a repair. £ for £, poorer person pays out much more in shoes for shit quality. Same applies to needing a money meter for fuel etc etc etc.

Pastrydame · 17/08/2021 16:19

Yes it is always easier to get better quality things when you have more money for the initial outlay, something which is not available to many people.

yikesanotherbooboo · 17/08/2021 11:49

Re earlier mention of Eastpak; DD is nearly 30 and persuaded me to Miyazaki her one in year 5 when they were all the rage. Her argument at the time was that it would last 25 years at which I massively rolled my eyes. It is still on the go for weekends away etc.and looks pretty good. She hasn't used it daily since school but it certainly owes us nothing at this point .

L1ttleSeahorse · 17/08/2021 08:41

I think it would be a good thing to break the cycle some have on here of "buying because its september" which is nonsensical when you think about it. It takes people choosing to stop to stop making it a "thing" in their family.

UserStillatLarge · 17/08/2021 08:34

there are some laugh out loud virtue signalling and conspicuous giving to the poor going on in this thread.

Yes I agree. I hope this thread has made some people re-consider why they buy new stuff every year (if they do). But trying to pass off buying new as a good thing because it means someone else can use the "too poor for my own child" item is pretty sad. Why not just say you buy new because you can and because you like to, although you do try to mitigate the environmental issue by passing the old item on to someone else.

careerchangeperhaps · 17/08/2021 08:28

DD had the same school bag from year 2 until the end of year 6 (a Kipling one). It's still in almost perfect condition. I've bought her a new bag for year 7 as the Kipling one is a bit babyish for secondary. (I'll sell the old one on eBay though as it will do someone else another few years easily).
The new bag is a good, solid bag (Dakine) in a plain design that I hope will last her at least until the end of year 11.

Neverrains · 17/08/2021 08:16

@EspressoDoubleShot

there are some laugh out loud virtue signalling and conspicuous giving to the poor going on in this thread., which I do not believe. So all this redistribute the money you could spend on new items and give the poor, are you actually doing this? The money you could spend on new coat and winter boots, do you actually think, I’ll make and do with my current items and give then monies you could have spent to the poor family at school? Do you regularly redivert your potential spends to the poor. Giving them the new items and you retain your current item?

Or are you making a virtue signalling point to bluster your way through an online spat…

Well… if something is in decent enough condition to give to charity, it’s in decent enough condition for me and my children to continue using. If it’s not in good enough condition for me and my kids, I will of course buy them new but I wouldn’t then give something old and unusable to ‘the poor’.
00100001 · 17/08/2021 08:14

@EspressoDoubleShot

there are some laugh out loud virtue signalling and conspicuous giving to the poor going on in this thread., which I do not believe. So all this redistribute the money you could spend on new items and give the poor, are you actually doing this? The money you could spend on new coat and winter boots, do you actually think, I’ll make and do with my current items and give then monies you could have spent to the poor family at school? Do you regularly redivert your potential spends to the poor. Giving them the new items and you retain your current item?

Or are you making a virtue signalling point to bluster your way through an online spat…

It's the faux "oh I give to the needy"l, aren't I wonderful' attitude that is wrong imo.

It's one thing if (say) the PPs kid had grown out of Barbie, and at the end of the year then wanted to donate her perfectly good bag, and get new one.
But it's another thing to just buy a new bag regardless of need. It feeds into consumerism and cult of the new.

And FWIW, yes i do buy new items, I get things like cots/baby clothes/bottles etc and give them to the Baby Bank.
Yes, I do give used items to charity shops etc, however, it's because the kiddo has grown out of it, not because I think we'll, he's worn that t-shirt 5 times, and it's now August, so I'll buy him new just because.

burritofan · 17/08/2021 08:08

Well, I don’t buy new shit all the time (perhaps DD is less ‘exuberant’ than some Hmm) and haemorrhage money to charity on a regular basis, so…

Not sure what your argument is, really, other than you’ve picked up the phrase ‘virtue signalling’ from some right-wing frothpit and you think it’s clever. Go on, call us ‘snowflakes’ next. Tell us we’re ‘triggered’.

EspressoDoubleShot · 17/08/2021 07:50

there are some laugh out loud virtue signalling and conspicuous giving to the poor going on in this thread., which I do not believe. So all this redistribute the money you could spend on new items and give the poor, are you actually doing this? The money you could spend on new coat and winter boots, do you actually think, I’ll make and do with my current items and give then monies you could have spent to the poor family at school?
Do you regularly redivert your potential spends to the poor. Giving them the new items and you retain your current item?

Or are you making a virtue signalling point to bluster your way through an online spat…

SE13Mummy · 17/08/2021 00:02

DC1 has just finished Y11 with the Eastpak backpack bought for the start of Y7. They walk to and from school each day and although the bag has been washed a few times and was repaired by Eastpak, it's still going strong and won't be replaced for the start of Y12. DC2 chose an Eastpak backpack when they started Y7 last year. The reason their primary bag wasn't used instead was because the secondary school specify that it must be a plain backpack so the previous one (used for 4+ years) wouldn't have been acceptable.

The Eastpak bags weren't cheap to begin with and I do realise that being in a position to buy a robust £50 backpack isn't something everyone can do. My DC know I'll always replace school items that have worn out or been outgrown but that's on a need basis, not because it's September.

ifindoubtdoit · 16/08/2021 23:24

I had a new one of each every year.
By the time I got to secondary school my bags never lasted a year with the weight of the books we had to carry!

LittleBearPad · 16/08/2021 23:18

‘Exuberant’ sounds like code from a school report…

Kanaloa · 16/08/2021 22:17

@EspressoDoubleShot

I will buy my kids new items for starting school,because the existing items are tatty, & knackered. On the basis of expected wear and tear they need replaced and I will replace them. The wear and tear arises from near daily use, being carried,dropped,piled and transported. For those who fear my children are too exuberant in behaviour and ungrateful for a supermarket lunch bag, fear not. Their exuberance and behaviour is entirely age appropriate and it’s what kids do. They run,jump,chase,pull at zips and hoik items on/off public transport and the said items deteriorate. Near daily use and the bags and water bottles go to summer club too. Then in August I replace the items. After 45 weeks use, yes I replace items with no compunction.
It might be normal/age appropriate to you but obviously judging by this thread it isn’t for lots.

Yes they open the zips and take the bag to school and back but I think by a certain age (6/7) a child can be taught to look after their belongings by treating them carefully, while still being ‘exuberant’ at playtime.

As I’ve already said, I’m not bothered if people just say ‘I want to buy new pretty stuff every year’ but why justify it by insisting every year the child’s things are trashed beyond any further use?

EspressoDoubleShot · 16/08/2021 21:31

I will buy my kids new items for starting school,because the existing items are tatty, & knackered. On the basis of expected wear and tear they need replaced and I will replace them. The wear and tear arises from near daily use, being carried,dropped,piled and transported. For those who fear my children are too exuberant in behaviour and ungrateful for a supermarket lunch bag, fear not. Their exuberance and behaviour is entirely age appropriate and it’s what kids do. They run,jump,chase,pull at zips and hoik items on/off public transport and the said items deteriorate. Near daily use and the bags and water bottles go to summer club too. Then in August I replace the items. After 45 weeks use, yes I replace items with no compunction.

Swipe left for the next trending thread