Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New school bag and lunchbox every September?

590 replies

AvocadoHo · 14/08/2021 18:06

Light hearted debate with OH.

Making a list of school uniform needed for daughter (8) going back to school.

He rolled his eyes snd asked "why does she need a new bag? What's wrong with the one she has?"

Nothing is wrong with it, it's just a bit grubby and battered. But when I was growing up we had a new bag and lunch box every year. He feels this is excessive.

Is it really that uncommon?

OP posts:
qualitygirl · 14/08/2021 21:00

I think a lot of you saying that your dc found it important/really enjoyed it etc etc are totally not getting it! They felt that way because YOU Instilled that in them. As we say here in Ireland "they didn't lick that off the ground" Hmm

DiscoDown21 · 14/08/2021 20:58

This I wasn’t uncommon even when I was a kid. I remember going stationary shopping in the 1990s getting my new stationary/pencil case for the year. Was only cheap stuff but I loved it.

Even in the 80s we always got a new lunchbox and flask even tho we were pretty skint. Our bags came from the market. My grandma made our PE bags with embroidered initials. No school branded book bags then.

Lots of things aren’t great for the environment are they. Cars/transport, air travel, fast fashion, meat eating, fossil fuels, having families.

Neverrains · 14/08/2021 20:56

Mine are primary and haven’t ever asked for new bags or lunch boxes. They chose ones they like a couple of years ago and still like them.

ButtonMoonLoon · 14/08/2021 20:56

My daughter always has new ones every school year- we generally get them from Tk Maxx, aldi or Smiggle sale.
The old ones get washed and then donated to a local charity who distributes things to children in foster care to avoid their belongings going into plastic bags.

Audreyhelp · 14/08/2021 20:53

The shops are filled with bags stationary and lunchboxes. So I think lots of people buy new .

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 14/08/2021 20:52

Mine are young adults now (19 and 21) and I do remember how important it was for them to have a new bookbag and lunchbox when they started a new term in Primary/Junior School.

By Secondary , DS was happy to drag his rucksack about until it split open.

In that short space of time how much has changed

grapewine · 14/08/2021 20:44

@burritofan

Monday: IPCC issues code red for humanity and the climate emergency. Tue-Fri: heatwaves, floods, disasters. Saturday: lol, lighthearted debate but should we buy a reusable item annually because sentiment?

I’d say “burn the world” but we already are. (Sorrynotsorry not feeling very lighthearted tbqh)

On point!
pollylocketpickedapocket · 14/08/2021 20:44

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Killahangilion · 14/08/2021 20:43

@RJnomore1

Ok I’m bored I’ll rise to the whinging. I’m guessing you’re bored too.

Which kid wants the same one? None I’ve ever met...

I’m presuming you live with one pair of trousers, one bra, one handbag, one plate, one mug per person as you don’t see the point in having more than one of anything.

Anyway you’re deliberately missing my point which is that this entire thread is a pile on for people to go on about how worthy they are, and how much better than those profligate two bag owners they are. It happens, asi pointed out, repeatedly and on many topics and has no relationship to real life for most people.

Although I do love the homeopathic chicken threads.

Nope. I don’t know any kids at DS’s primary school that are interested in what school supplies they use. I’m sure there must be some that want new bags and pencil cases every year, but I can’t think of a single boy amongst DS’s pals who would give a toss about stuff like that.

They’re either interested in their sport or tech.

SciFiScream · 14/08/2021 20:41

[quote MorganHunt]@DariaMorgendorffer:

I don't agree. I would never put the environment above making my child happy. I never fly anywhere, I don't own a car, I don't eat meat and my carbon footprint is probably minus. All I do is buy a new schoolbag and a new pencilcase for my happy child each year. If that messes up the planet we live on, I don't care.[/quote]
There is absolutely no way your carbon footprint is minus.

You have a child for starters.
You eat food
You drink water (cleaning water is one of the most energy inefficient things we do)
You are accessing the internet somehow to post your message
You must use electricity

You wear clothes
etc, etc, etc

KingdomScrolls · 14/08/2021 20:41

Some of this is about money and actually lack thereof, oh just buy a kanken it'll last ten years, a lot of people can't afford the initial outlay and whilst it may cost more over a decade to buy a new under £10 minions/Spider-Man/Fortnite bag each year, the child feels they've been treated and the parent hasn't had £75 to spend on a backpack. We are fortunate and can buy more expensive brands and will do if the quality is good and keep using them, the school by my office has over 60% eligible for free school meals and they will all have new bags/lunchboxes in September

MrsMiddleMother · 14/08/2021 20:38

No not anymore. We started to buy new as thought that was the 'done' thing but after the 3rd year when we bad 3 fairly decent backpacks hanging up realised how ridiculous it was to buy new each year.

Montsti · 14/08/2021 20:37

I can’t remember what I had but I have bought pretty expensive bags for my children with the view that they will last at least 5 years…
My son has had his bag for 4 years and counting. Am hoping it last another year and a half and he can get a new one for high school! His friends seem to get new bags all the time…

Lovemusic33 · 14/08/2021 20:36

I think I have the only children that don’t ask for new school stuff, I ask them if there’s anything they need for September and they say “no, I will use what I already have” 😬, dd1 hates me buying her things she doesn’t need, she understands it’s wasteful.

BarbaraofSeville · 14/08/2021 20:30

[quote MorganHunt]@DariaMorgendorffer:

I don't agree. I would never put the environment above making my child happy. I never fly anywhere, I don't own a car, I don't eat meat and my carbon footprint is probably minus. All I do is buy a new schoolbag and a new pencilcase for my happy child each year. If that messes up the planet we live on, I don't care.[/quote]
Of course your carbon footprint isn't minus. You've produced at least one child, the most environmentally damaging thing you can do. Flying to New York and back every month is less environmentally damaging, which I found surprising but this thread about so many people buying so much unnecessary crap for their DC explains it.

burritofan · 14/08/2021 20:30

I would never put the environment above making my child happy.
But our children’s happiness is contingent on the environment. The climate emergency means millions of displaced people, wars, famines, droughts, poor air quality, food and water shortages, infertile soil, increase in violent crime, decrease in cognitive function, increasing costs of everything – from your child’s new pencil case to the roof over their head to the non-existent food they can’t put on the table because it’s all burned or flooded or unable to grow. All of which will affect your kid even if the UK escapes the worst of the direct effects. And all of which has already begun; it’s not the future, it’s here. We’re living in it.

Honestly it’s not about worthiness – I used to work in the bloody fashion industry, I’ve done as many climate crimes as anybody, I’m still unpicking my own practices – it’s about realising we’ve left it far too bloody late and we need to radically rethink our way of living and consuming. We have all fundamentally misunderstood reduce, reuse, recycle and think that so long as we recycle the cardboard sleeve our new junk came in, we’re OK. We’re not.

So what if you all have happy memories of new stationery every September? So do I. I’d like my daughter to have happy memories of “the Gulf Stream not stopping” and “might be able to have a child of her own without worrying about the ocean rising” and “everything not being dead”. It’s a bloody pencil case/lunch box/bag; ideally you can give them a happy childhood without it and if you can’t, why on earth not?

(And fuck the “haha it’s the MN chicken” crowd, too, while I’m here.)

cookofcastamar · 14/08/2021 20:28

My 6 year old is going to his third year in school mad still has the same school bag. It cost me almost €50 in 2019 so no changing it if it isn't broken 😂
My 8 year olds school bag is on its second year. He was the finicky child that wanted fortnite bag and it didn't last so. Bought a good non toy one last year and it is still in good condition just need to be washed.

Quornflakegirl · 14/08/2021 20:28

If you get decent quality bags and lunch bags they’ll last. I got my girls Cath Kidston backpacks and Paperchase lunch bags in Reception and they’ll be using them again going into year 4 this September. I wash the lunch bag on a quick cold wash every Friday and they look perfectly clean. No way would I buy new if they are perfectly useable. They did cost me £90 new for all 4 so it was money well spent.

pollylocketpickedapocket · 14/08/2021 20:27

@user1471539385

DD is at a ‘big name’ private school (ie one that people have heard of nationally) and had the same school bag and overcoat for years 7-9. She has just had a new bag, because the other one was thinning and she didn’t want to risk everything dropping out of it, but will continue in the coat. Her classmates are the same. There’s nothing cool about not caring about the planet, and today’s kids know better than to replace things ‘just because’.
I can see this probably being a class thing too. My nana was dirt poor growing up and scrimped and scraped to make sure her children had the very best she could provide. That is ingrained in my family, no matter what your children are fed, clean and impeccably turned out.
haaaahoooo · 14/08/2021 20:25

Agree with everyone saying how wasteful it is. DS isn't getting a new bag even though he's starting secondary in September - he got a generic sports brand rucksack in Year 5 which has hardly been used (they weren't allowed bags in school during Covid), so it's still in perfectly good nick and perfectly appropriate for secondary. I did actually ask him if he wanted a new bag for secondary and his response was a pretty baffled 'no, what's wrong with this one?'. I'm not claiming he's some model non-consumerist angel child (he's pretty keen on getting a PS5, I can tell you), but I do think that the supposedly universal desire among kids to have new stuff all the time is at least partly modelled by parents.

L1ttleSeahorse · 14/08/2021 20:25

Really bad modelling. I am amazed people are blindly going along with this!

SageRosemary · 14/08/2021 20:25

Oh, this is so, so wasteful - and think of the effect on climate change.

DD1 is on her second school bag, first one was used for 8 years at school, now used for dance class etc as it is too small for school, second bag is bigger and has been in continuous use for 5 years.

DD2 is on her second bag, it is in continuous use for 10 years. Her first bag was a gift, a nice novelty bag that lasted for 1 whole year.

I can recommend Jansport and Sporthouse bags. Long lasting and get used in the holidays as carry-on for air travel, day trips, sleepovers etc. They survive being machine washed.

I would recommend a bag in a deeper or patterned colourway, avoiding novelty characters that your child will grow out of.

Save the characters for lunchbags that will need replacing more often.

My DC go to a state school where most of the students will be from families with a middle/high earning background. I would say most students would have the same bag for several years. And, the uniforms will be mended where possible. We are all saving with aspirations for our DC to go to 3rd level education, if that's what they want.

qualitygirl · 14/08/2021 20:25

@RJnomore1

Which kid wants the same one? None I’ve ever met...

When my dd picked out her school bag it was explained to her that she would be having it for as long as it lasts. I spent €50 on it and it's now entering its 4th year of use. Of course she had made noises of wanting a new one. BUT that's when I cease the opportunity to explain the difference between a NEED and a WANT. It's a great life lesson to learn. She gets it now...last week we were in town and she saw a nice pair of earrings. She said "they are lovely, but that's half my money and I want them but I don't need them. I have 5 pairs already". That's a success in my eyes! Smile

justustwoandmoo · 14/08/2021 20:24

I always buy a new school bag in September along with new stationary etc. Always been a thing for my daughter and she loves that shopping trip!

I had the same growing up x

babybelling · 14/08/2021 20:21

Excessive and wasteful. And not teaching good habits to the kids.

Swipe left for the next trending thread