Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New school bag and lunchbox every September?

590 replies

AvocadoHo · 14/08/2021 18:06

Light hearted debate with OH.

Making a list of school uniform needed for daughter (8) going back to school.

He rolled his eyes snd asked "why does she need a new bag? What's wrong with the one she has?"

Nothing is wrong with it, it's just a bit grubby and battered. But when I was growing up we had a new bag and lunch box every year. He feels this is excessive.

Is it really that uncommon?

OP posts:
SuperSketchy · 15/08/2021 10:55

Thinking about it, I think we did get a new bag most years as kids. My dcs have ugly, overpriced logo bags, because the school insists on them. They don't get new ones unless they are absolutely dead. There's no joy in buying those things anyway, so even if I was someone who didn't give a single shit about the planet, (which I'm not), I wouldn't want to buy one every year.

ChevreChase · 15/08/2021 10:51

I think DS has gone through four lunch bags in the seven years of infant and junior school, and two school bags. The school bag he has had for the last four years is retiring now, and he'll get a new one for senior. It wouldn't have occurred to me to replace them. In primary, they don't get much use, so I don't see how they wear out - it's not as if the children are constantly getting things in and out, as they do in senior. It just hangs on a peg all day.

CecilyP · 15/08/2021 10:50

Could not send a teenager to school with something that was more appropriate for a reception child

I know some things are made to last but it is unlikely that a themed item would last a whole 7 years. It is still OK to replace worn out things. There’s is a difference between one year and 7 years!

00100001 · 15/08/2021 10:40

@BarbaraofSeville

Just because something is cheap doesn’t mean we should have to accept that it’s thrown away after little use

I know. I have a standard metal water bottle that wasn't expensive and has to be 20 years old that I take out with me most days including on hiking trips. Those things are indestructable. It does have a small dent in it because I dropped it on a rock the first time out Hmm but that doesn't stop it from functioning as a water bottle or make it needing to be replaced.

I can't see ever needing to replace it. Sometimes the seal gets a bit manky and if a soak in milton doesn't work, I might replace that, but otherwise, it will be with me until the day I die.

I can see that a teen won't want to be carrying a unicorn rucksack, so replacing things for fashion might be occasionally justified, but it's also worth remembering that if you normally replace things annually, and you change this to every five years, you have reduced your usage by 80%, which is hugely significant and easy to do for things that they don't grow out of and shouldn't be damaging or wearing out.

Even every 2 years would make a difference!

I could only justify a bag for nursery through reception infants. A new bag at juniors (maybe). Maybe a new bag at year 7 and then year 10 through to sixth form. So maybe 4 bags for reception through sixth form?

TheSkatesOfCoachBombay · 15/08/2021 10:38

DS gets a new lunchbag because after a year of use even though I Dettol it every day it becomes discoloured and stained on the inside. And it gets scuffed up as it's slung about 🙄

But bag...he's had the same small rucksack since he was 3 he's 7 now. It was £15 in M&S dark navy with muted coloured dinosaurs on it. It's surviving really well! I'm impressed. And as DS is still in love with dinosaurs he likes it.

Once it rips or breaks I'll replace but for now, it's absolutely fine. So I see no need.

But then again at 31 I still have dresses and clothes in my wardrobe that I've had since my late teens! They still fit are in good order and are timeless in their fit and colours. So I don't replace them. I've had my trusty rucksack handbag for 6 years.

I'm a lone parent, I am not a high earner though I do work full time. We have about £1800 a month to live off so the less I have to buy and replace I do!

00100001 · 15/08/2021 10:37

@lazylump72

I think a bit about my replacing and I do accept the critisism its fine but its the trends. We change trends for ourselves so why not with the kids? Princess and unicorns will look dated.I am mainly talking about primary school years here where the things tend to be so cheap to replace. You can get so much cheaply at supermarkets etc.Like a new water bottle at Sainsburys was only 12.00 so I dont mind changing whenever really, had I been spending 40 or 50 on a bag etc I would think again maybe,
But just because it's "cheap" doesn't mean it should be replaced just because it's September...
BarbaraofSeville · 15/08/2021 10:24

Just because something is cheap doesn’t mean we should have to accept that it’s thrown away after little use

I know. I have a standard metal water bottle that wasn't expensive and has to be 20 years old that I take out with me most days including on hiking trips. Those things are indestructable. It does have a small dent in it because I dropped it on a rock the first time out Hmm but that doesn't stop it from functioning as a water bottle or make it needing to be replaced.

I can't see ever needing to replace it. Sometimes the seal gets a bit manky and if a soak in milton doesn't work, I might replace that, but otherwise, it will be with me until the day I die.

I can see that a teen won't want to be carrying a unicorn rucksack, so replacing things for fashion might be occasionally justified, but it's also worth remembering that if you normally replace things annually, and you change this to every five years, you have reduced your usage by 80%, which is hugely significant and easy to do for things that they don't grow out of and shouldn't be damaging or wearing out.

qualitygirl · 15/08/2021 10:17

@lazylump72 then they key is to not buy ones that are dated!

This is the one I bought my DS last year! He will use it again this year, he hasn't even thought of asking for a new one because it's not an option. He isn't aware it could be an option. It is in perfect condition and it's not themed! I'm expecting him to use it for a another few years too to be honest!

New school bag and lunchbox every September?
Sirzy · 15/08/2021 10:16

Lazylump you completely unintentionally sum up the issues with the throw away society we have.

I don’t replace my own clothes regularly. I wear things for as long as they last or fit I’m not a follower of fashion because I know what I like and I wear it. Certainly don’t buy new every season because “trends” say we should.

Just because something is cheap doesn’t mean we should have to accept that it’s thrown away after little use. For items such as bags and coats which you expect a lot of wear from it’s easy to avoid things like unicorns which may very quickly become an unliked item.

Reflections2021 · 15/08/2021 10:16

Could not send a teenager to school with something that was more appropriate for a reception child Smile

Reflections2021 · 15/08/2021 10:15

Unless no longer age appropriate, in which case would send to charity shop and replace.

Reflections2021 · 15/08/2021 10:14

Replace when needed.

lazylump72 · 15/08/2021 10:13

I think a bit about my replacing and I do accept the critisism its fine but its the trends. We change trends for ourselves so why not with the kids? Princess and unicorns will look dated.I am mainly talking about primary school years here where the things tend to be so cheap to replace. You can get so much cheaply at supermarkets etc.Like a new water bottle at Sainsburys was only 12.00 so I dont mind changing whenever really, had I been spending 40 or 50 on a bag etc I would think again maybe,

Crossstitchismyhobby · 15/08/2021 10:08

I knew someone who bought new bags and lunch boxes every term
It was to ‘prove’ to nobody but herself that they could afford to-from what I can gather,they had a cupboard full of almost new bags and boxes
I didn’t unless they needed something replacing-3 out of 6 lunchboxes lasted the whole of primary

Kanaloa · 15/08/2021 10:07

@CatsArePeople

I was responding more to the idea that some people say they ‘need’ a new bag and pencil case every year as they will be broken/ripped and have holes in. For me I wouldn’t be happy with that, I don’t really see how a pencil case is getting such hard use that it’s ripped and broken by the end of the school year. However I am pretty strict about caring for belongings so maybe it isn’t as much of an issue to others.

Terhou · 15/08/2021 10:04

I wouldn't dream of replacing school bags and lunch boxes while they're still perfectly usable.

Antsinyourpanta · 15/08/2021 10:01

My parents couldnt afford to buy new every year, I remember everyone got a new geometry kit every year - it was a real moment of excitement when I realised you could buy the individual items if you had broken your protractor or lost something from it!Blush

AllTheSingleLadiess · 15/08/2021 09:59

I replace when broken but with teens they aren't advertising a brand like Disney Princess which they might fall out of love with quickly. Bags last minimum 2-3 years here.

Sirzy · 15/08/2021 09:59

@lazylump72

Guilty! New everything here every September and obviously top ups and changes if things look a bit shabby at the end of terms. I like my dd 9 to look well turned out.She doesnt come home that way at the end of the day but she looks immaculate first thing!! Things are so cheap now a days it doesnt cost much to replace anything thats worn. I wash and press all her used stuff and send it to the uniform swap shop.
Ds always looks smart when leaving the house. That doesn’t involve buying things just because of the date though!
Spondooliesforholibobs · 15/08/2021 09:59

Also never crossed my mind to get new ones at the start of each year.

pollylocketpickedapocket · 15/08/2021 09:55

@therarebear

Children are all being taught at school about how they can take steps to reduce pollution and environmental damage. Being the parent who insists on brand new items each school year (if existing bag/lunchbox are still in fine condition) and contributing the 'old' items to landfill is setting an awful example. How can you not see that?
My kids school sends balloons off for various occasions. I doubt they’re spinning hard lines about the environment.
00100001 · 15/08/2021 09:55

@lazylump72

Guilty! New everything here every September and obviously top ups and changes if things look a bit shabby at the end of terms. I like my dd 9 to look well turned out.She doesnt come home that way at the end of the day but she looks immaculate first thing!! Things are so cheap now a days it doesnt cost much to replace anything thats worn. I wash and press all her used stuff and send it to the uniform swap shop.
My DS was well turned out thanks. His bag lasted him 7 years. New doesn't mean better than others...
lazylump72 · 15/08/2021 09:54

Guilty! New everything here every September and obviously top ups and changes if things look a bit shabby at the end of terms. I like my dd 9 to look well turned out.She doesnt come home that way at the end of the day but she looks immaculate first thing!! Things are so cheap now a days it doesnt cost much to replace anything thats worn. I wash and press all her used stuff and send it to the uniform swap shop.

Starlightstarbright1 · 15/08/2021 09:52

I bought my son new ruc sack this week. He had his last 2 years. I plan for this one to go through year 11.

CornishTiger · 15/08/2021 09:52

And if you want to make them last then do make sure the bags are emptied of stuff especially food regularly and stuck through a wash every now and again.

Swipe left for the next trending thread