Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Treated like an alcoholic by midwife?

736 replies

MyMabel · 14/08/2021 17:45

Anyone else been in this situation?

Ok our telephone consultation appointment I was asked how much I drink prior to finding out I was pregnant - I said (honestly) I had about one or two gins every night, the occasion glass or two of wine instead. Couldn’t tell them in units as I have no idea.

I was never drunk, never drank until DP was home as we have a toddler DD so wanted to make sure if anything happened one of us can drive, plus I wouldn’t drink while solely responsible for her. - again, never drunk or even dizzy. Just a glass or two while watching telly before bed. I suppose with COVID and all I was just bored?

Anyway, was asked if I drank since finding out- said no, because I haven’t.

Come to my face to face appointment; Midwife explains that due to my alcohol intake before being pregnant I’ve been referred to speak to someone. I was in a bit of shock to ask questions and just said ok. But after I left I felt mortally embarrassed and now a bit worried they think I’ve got a drinking problem?!

Maybe I’m not BU in the sense that they could perhaps help someone who struggled with alcohol by doing this routinely.. but AIBU to think I really don’t need to speak to someone regarding what I drank in the evenings?

Did I really drink THAT much too much? I get it was too much and probably not healthy for my body.. but I don’t think it’s that bad?!

OP posts:
pam290358 · 17/08/2021 18:58

@AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken. Don’t think it does any good at all in the long run. There are so many levels of ignorance surrounding alcohol use and abuse on this thread I don’t know where to start, and so many people who come across as angry and aggressive - it’s hard not to come to the conclusion that it’s because their own drinking habits are being called into question. The fact that a relatively small amount of alcohol consumed on a regular basis can form a habit and end up damaging your health seems to be a concept that some people either can’t or don’t want to accept. I find interesting that breast cancer hasn’t been mentioned. There is a proven link between even small amounts of alcohol and breast cancer - as little as 10 grams of alcohol is enough to raise estrogen levels and increase the risk, and yet the NHS is being castigated for being OTT and out to police womens’ bodies. Such hypocrisy.

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 17/08/2021 17:58

[quote pam290358]@Supergirl. I agree with you here, but I do think the discussion around alcoholism was warranted given that the OP said she felt as thought she was being treated as one - in fact she was not. She was being treated as someone who was engaging in alcohol abuse which may have formed a habit leading to alcohol dependence. I think this was the whole reason for the referral - not just the amount of alcohol, but the fact that it was on a regular basis. Addiction is defined as not having control over doing, taking or using something to the point where it could be harmful to you, but this is a grey area because even mild abuse of alcohol can be harmful without being an addiction.[/quote]
Absolutely.
If someone is using alcohol as a crutch, for example they need it after a tough day/ they need it to relax and they would struggle to find other ways to cope with those stresses, or they simply need the thought of a drink to at the end of the day to get them through, this is an indication that they have developed a dependency on it. This is not alcoholism in itself but it’s certainly on the same track.

I’m not sure what good shying away from this does.

toystoyseverywhere · 17/08/2021 15:54

They automatically have to refer someone who admits to drinking every day particularly as home measures are well known to be more than pub measures. Some people can be quite generous with the measures at times!

It's an automatic thing which the system will have picked up right away. Similar would have happened if it had been someone who smoked or someone who had smoked a lot and the midwife felt they might struggle with not smoking during pregnancy.

An awful lot of people tend to minimise how much they drink as well. I don't drink at all and I get numerous suspicious looks when I answer that question!

It will be box ticking and obviously it has to be done as she can't be seen to not be offering support in case you happen to go back to drinking every night at home once baby is here.

I do agree that a lot are thinking of their own drinking habits throughout this thread which is natural to do.

It's looking out for baby and mum as well but obviously more so for baby. They have to do it to protect themselves also.

pam290358 · 17/08/2021 15:27

@Supergirl. I agree with you here, but I do think the discussion around alcoholism was warranted given that the OP said she felt as thought she was being treated as one - in fact she was not. She was being treated as someone who was engaging in alcohol abuse which may have formed a habit leading to alcohol dependence. I think this was the whole reason for the referral - not just the amount of alcohol, but the fact that it was on a regular basis. Addiction is defined as not having control over doing, taking or using something to the point where it could be harmful to you, but this is a grey area because even mild abuse of alcohol can be harmful without being an addiction.

Supergirl1958 · 17/08/2021 14:02

@Beline4u

"An alcoholic is someone who has an addiction, addiction is not knowing when to stop!" You have!

You don't like to be challenged, you just want to be right. I'm being directive because I don't agree with your statement. You're very clear with what you say. The fact the MW has seen an unusual pattern means an intervention can happen! If it's not a problem fine but what if it is, now she can get the right support.

You’ve not even referenced it right! And now I understand your username!

I have identified alcoholism as an addiction...I have never once said that addicts know when to stop which is what you continually imply I do! I suggest you go back through my posts and read them correctly!

Be as directive as you like, again, if you go back through my posts I am quite willing to debate it, just because people have different opinions on the subject though does not mean one or the other is right...or wrong!

I don’t think the OP or any discussion around it has warranted a discussion on alcoholism...at all! I eat crisps whilst I watch tv...am I a crispoholic?? No, I am not!

I think it’s quite clear we aren’t going to agree Beline...so stop making one for me and let’s leave it the hey?

Beline4u · 17/08/2021 13:07

"An alcoholic is someone who has an addiction, addiction is not knowing when to stop!" You have!

You don't like to be challenged, you just want to be right. I'm being directive because I don't agree with your statement. You're very clear with what you say. The fact the MW has seen an unusual pattern means an intervention can happen! If it's not a problem fine but what if it is, now she can get the right support.

Noteshook · 17/08/2021 11:16

Cripes, a lot of drama on this thread. You just will have exceeded the arbitury threshold they have, but you can say no the referral without consequence- just say no and move on. Its a service they offer as some will benefit from it.

Personally I think drinking every day is excessive because it suggests the person takes some sort of comfort from it or has formed a habit; but that doesn't mean being an alcoholic or whatever. But you've stopped anyway so why does it matter.

pam290358 · 17/08/2021 11:12

@NotMyselfWithoutCoffee. I said in a post upthread that I was done with this discussion. Re-read some of the posts earlier this morning and came to the same conclusion as you. I decided to post again to try to clarify my experience because when I re-read the thread it’s clear that some people are hell bent on misreading or misinterpreting sound information and end up posting crap in reply. The tone of the whole thread is bad tempered and accusatory, when in fact it could have been a useful discussion about something that’s a growing problem in the UK, and in no small part due to the pandemic.

NotMyselfWithoutCoffee · 17/08/2021 11:01

@pam290358

You can't argue with ignorance.

Here's a gem from qwerty earlier.

"anyone who knows anything at all knows I am correct"

pam290358 · 17/08/2021 10:48

@Qwerty789 * Drinking does not affect breastfeeding unless you're drinking so much you'll drop the baby while doing it.
Midwife was wrong and so are you*

Breast milk is affected by alcohol. One study found that babies who had alcohol via breast milk slept for 25% less time than those who didn't. Alcohol also disrupts the hormone that controls the let-down of breast milk. Babies take around 20% less milk in the three to four hours after alcohol is consumed, and compensate by feeding more often. The levels transferred to breast milk from even moderate to low drinking may lead to drowsiness and deep sleep. Weakness and decreased linear growth in the infant are reported with higher levels of alcohol consumption while breast feeding.

pam290358 · 17/08/2021 10:32

@Supergirl1958. Sorry if I come across as having to be right - that’s not my intention, but from my point of view there are a lot of people on this thread who insist on either not reading my posts properly or misinterpreting what I’m saying. And I think I covered upthread, the fact that it’s not always alcohol that causes liver damage - LFT ‘s can differentiate. That’s not what we’re talking about here. The OP not only posed a question about drinking during pregnancy, but she also asked whether people thought she was drinking too much - she also clearly stated in the first post that she had one or two home measures EVERY night, and then corrected this down thread.

Alcohol consumption is always an emotive subject and I think it’s partly because when there’s a discussion like this, a lot of people recognise their own habits from the information that flows back and forth. And a lot are reluctant to admit it. I do think it’s understandable because people - myself included - enjoy a drink and don’t like to think that what they see as something pleasant to look forward to, as actively harming them. This is where I have the problem, and am possibly coming across as judgemental because having been through this myself and having had it explained to me in clear terms, I attempted to post factual information and got flamed for it. I’m not suggesting even for a moment that anyone who enjoys a couple of drinks at home is an alcoholic, by any stretch of the imagination.

What I am saying is that home measures are not reliable and it’s easy to end up drinking at a level which will start off liver damage, without even realising it. I did it myself - I only ever had a maximum of two drinks, and looking back, it probably wasn’t every night, but it WAS most nights. They were my own measures and I ended up with Steatosis after a relatively short space of time. My GP obviously recognised a pattern and her concern was enough to prompt her to refer me for a scan, which bore out her suspicions. She wasn’t just concerned about the levels of alcohol consumption, she was also concerned about the habit that was forming, and looking back I realise that if the problem hadn’t been recognised at that point, I probably would have carried on oblivious to the harm I was doing. Someone upthread highlighted the difference between looking forward to a treat, and that treat becoming a habit which becomes hard to break, and I think this is the key. There’s a difference between alcohol abuse and alcohol dependence. If you regularly drink even a little too much you are abusing alcohol, and forming a habit which could possibly then lead to alcohol dependence.

I attempted to educate myself after that because it scared me how easy it was to do damage without realising it. I know a bit more about how the liver and the digestive system works, and how alcohol affects blood pressure, and through that I now know how little it takes to put the liver in mild distress. Your metabolism, your weight, your diet, whether you’re male or female and whether or not you take drugs - particularly opiates - all affect how alcohol is metabolised. But however loud people shout and protest, it remains a fact that there is no safe level of alcohol intake and the recommendations are only based on minimising the damage caused by alcohol. It also remains a fact that one or two drinks a day can and does cause liver damage - reversible in the early stages, but that one or two drinks over a long period of time, has a cumulative effect. It’s also not a good idea to drink every day because it doesn’t allow your liver time to recover before you throw the next lot at it - and the mild distress becomes worse over time. People tend to forget that the liver is part of your digestion system, so it’s busy with other things too.

I’m also not saying that no-one should drink. I drink myself, but knowing what I know now, I’m much more careful. And in the end it’s down to personal choice, but to my mind, loading all the blame onto the NHS for being careful, using language like ‘policing of womens bodies’ and calling the approach a waste of money is at the very least unhelpful and attempts to detract from the issues that make people uncomfortable. I think the midwife, like all NHS professionals, has a responsibility for the well-being of her patient and she took appropriate action based on the information given by the OP - which, if you read the original post - WAS that she drank every day.

There are some really excellent posts on this thread, but to some I would say that just because you want something to be a certain way, doesn’t make it so, and you are posting incorrect and misleading information.

NotMyselfWithoutCoffee · 17/08/2021 10:26

@cleverpolly3

Yeah I mention this in my later comments.

It is negligible and also regarding the cosleeping thing.
I'm not an expert in how much alcohol is on breast milk, but i do remember the Dr being concerned when I mentioned drinking on my birthday lol!

Cleverpolly3 · 17/08/2021 10:20

Oh sorry see the sensible people beat me to it

Blossomtoes · 17/08/2021 10:20

@Paulinna

Drinking every night isn’t normal, sorry. Apart from anything else you’ll gain a ton of weight, if you haven’t already.
That was nasty - and uncalled for. Quite apart from being arrant nonsense. The calorie content of a gin or vodka and slimline tonic is negligible.
Cleverpolly3 · 17/08/2021 10:18

@NotMyselfWithoutCoffee

I don't think the midwife was wrong to refer. Bear in mind drinking affects breastfeeding and they may have concerns about drinking every night after the baby was born.
Actually you’d need to drink an amount sufficient to kill yourself before any detectable snd harmful amounts passed to the baby via breast milk

Google Dr Jack Warner abs there are links to scientific studies undertaken on this.
Alcohol is not absorbed into breast milk as it is the bloodstream

The dangers to your baby if you drank too much whilst happening to breastfeed are falling asleep while doing it, dropping them or suffocating them.

SmidgenofaPigeon · 17/08/2021 09:57

@Paulinna is there any need for that?! God, the nastiness on this thread. You have NO IDEA what the OP consumes as her calorie intake the rest of the time, nor is it any of your business. I’d have a wine over chocolate or cake any day.

Horrible, bitchy little comment.

Paulinna · 17/08/2021 09:43

Drinking every night isn’t normal, sorry. Apart from anything else you’ll gain a ton of weight, if you haven’t already.

jamdonut · 17/08/2021 09:38

Back in ‘92, ‘97, ‘00, I was actively encouraged by my midwife to drink a small Mackesons every evening to help with milk production! How times change….

NotMyselfWithoutCoffee · 17/08/2021 09:34

@qwerty789

Tut tut didn't you read my last post, think you may be a little confused yourself.

Bye bye dear.
Biscuit

Qwerty789 · 17/08/2021 09:32

I don't need to explain anything to you, anyone who knows anything at all knows I am correct.
You're confused, ill informed but loud. And I'm sure you do ignore anyone who can tell all that.

NotMyselfWithoutCoffee · 17/08/2021 09:31

@qwerty789

I see you avoided answering my last question and still haven't provided any weight to your arguments.

You insist on calling me wrong but have yet to provide a source or any genuine advice,
I trust the nhs guidance and trained professionals over some random.
Come back with some concrete scientific evidence on why I'm wrong dear, otherwise I'm just going to ignore you from now on. Smile

Qwerty789 · 17/08/2021 09:22

[quote NotMyselfWithoutCoffee]@qwerty789

Yes but it is often counted as sids as they can't always prove the cause of death, hence the advice to avoid alcohol while cosleeping.
Also when you drink you are less attuned to your babies movements and breathing.
Uhuh where did you get this knowledge from then, can you share the source?[/quote]
Wrong again. When will you give up?

NotMyselfWithoutCoffee · 17/08/2021 09:07

@smidgenofapigeon

I'm not saying that op is irresponsible, mainly that some people who have a genuine problem might see that it's ok to have one drink but then overdo it.

Also yes you can assume op knows all of that but the midwife doesn't, that's why they refer people to make sure they are are responsible and aware of safe limits with a baby.

NotMyselfWithoutCoffee · 17/08/2021 09:02

@qwerty789

Yes but it is often counted as sids as they can't always prove the cause of death, hence the advice to avoid alcohol while cosleeping.
Also when you drink you are less attuned to your babies movements and breathing.
Uhuh where did you get this knowledge from then, can you share the source?

SmidgenofaPigeon · 17/08/2021 09:01

@NotMyselfWithoutCoffee no one was talking about a piss up and breastfeeding, why do so many posters assume that one gin is a sure-fire way to being a character in a Hogarth illustration?!
presumably OP (having already had a child for a start) is well clued up and responsible with regards to safe sleeping.

Swipe left for the next trending thread