Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Treated like an alcoholic by midwife?

736 replies

MyMabel · 14/08/2021 17:45

Anyone else been in this situation?

Ok our telephone consultation appointment I was asked how much I drink prior to finding out I was pregnant - I said (honestly) I had about one or two gins every night, the occasion glass or two of wine instead. Couldn’t tell them in units as I have no idea.

I was never drunk, never drank until DP was home as we have a toddler DD so wanted to make sure if anything happened one of us can drive, plus I wouldn’t drink while solely responsible for her. - again, never drunk or even dizzy. Just a glass or two while watching telly before bed. I suppose with COVID and all I was just bored?

Anyway, was asked if I drank since finding out- said no, because I haven’t.

Come to my face to face appointment; Midwife explains that due to my alcohol intake before being pregnant I’ve been referred to speak to someone. I was in a bit of shock to ask questions and just said ok. But after I left I felt mortally embarrassed and now a bit worried they think I’ve got a drinking problem?!

Maybe I’m not BU in the sense that they could perhaps help someone who struggled with alcohol by doing this routinely.. but AIBU to think I really don’t need to speak to someone regarding what I drank in the evenings?

Did I really drink THAT much too much? I get it was too much and probably not healthy for my body.. but I don’t think it’s that bad?!

OP posts:
Reallyreallyborednow · 18/08/2021 15:37

@Usernamerequired

I had a drugs, STD and Aids tests carried out at my first appointment in early 2000s. APPARENTLY it was routine but i was made to feel like a skank as i was young and we were not married

I had all these for both my pregnancies. I did question it out of interest and was told it is completely routine. I figured it was sensible.

I was in my 30’s and married.

peboh · 18/08/2021 15:27

I think yabu to assume that just because you aren't drinking to get drunk that couldn't mean you have an alcohol dependency problem. So many high functioning alcoholics don't binge drink, and aren't drunks. The midwife referred you as you told her you were drinking everyday (even if you said you aren't whilst pregnant- she has no way to know that you're telling the truth) she's just ensuring that you have the help if you need it. That's all. She's doing her job in protecting an unborn child.

Usernamerequired · 18/08/2021 15:20

@AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken thank you so much for your reply. Thats really good to know. Anyone i asked about the tests said they never had them, must not have been told about them. Thank you

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 18/08/2021 14:57

@Usernamerequired

I had a drugs, STD and Aids tests carried out at my first appointment in early 2000s. APPARENTLY it was routine but i was made to feel like a skank as i was young and we were not married.
They still test pregnant women for for HIV, syphilis and chlamydia and will also check for gonorrhoea if it is prevalent in your area.

Anything the midwife tests for or offers support for, is for the benefit of the mother and/ or the baby.

theycallmeuser · 18/08/2021 14:56

On MN you're an alcoholic if you have anything more than a thimble full of Sherry at Christmas.

🤣🤣🤣

Usernamerequired · 18/08/2021 14:28

I had a drugs, STD and Aids tests carried out at my first appointment in early 2000s. APPARENTLY it was routine but i was made to feel like a skank as i was young and we were not married.

Immaback · 18/08/2021 13:03

Sounds like just a bad covid habit to me. We were drinking Wine nearly every night last summer, it just kind of crept Up on us. Was only When I saw all the bottles pile up I was faced with the truth so decided to make some rules - just weekends.
Congrats on being pregnant by the way !

pam290358 · 18/08/2021 12:56

@Cleverpolly3. I did assume that level of vitriol was the reason she didn’t return, but she did actually ask whether others thought she had been drinking too much. But beyond confirming that if her drinks were unmeasured then yes, she may very well have been drinking more than she thought, I don’t think there was any need for some of the nastiness on this thread.

Cleverpolly3 · 18/08/2021 12:11

[quote pam290358]@Binnaggy. Very succinctly put. I think this is the crux of the matter really. When you know at heart that what you’re doing is not very good for you, but you’re still looking to make excuses to justify it, then it really is time to examine things a bit more closely and be honest with yourself. It’s perfectly simple. When taken in small amounts on a regular basis without a break, alcohol can do damage which is cumulative and silent until it gets to the point where it causes health problems. By then it’s much harder to deal with, and yet there have been posts absolutely castigating the NHS approach of early intervention to avoid future problems - the arguments have been picked to death !! We’ve moved away a little from the OP’s original point about the MW, but it’s still relevant as she asked whether others think that her intake was too much and there has been some very interesting and colourful discussion. I think this is one of the most bad tempered and vitriolic threads I’ve seen on MN for some time, and now I’m wondering how long it’ll be before the moderators regard it as time it was taken down.[/quote]
The thread took a turn when people decided to berate a woman who has stopped drinking as soon as she found out she was pregnant for not realising she in fact had a drink problem
The comments that centred around that should be removed

Do you not wonder why the poor woman never returned to her thread ?
Unless she’s self referred to AA and doing breathalyser tests round the clock many still wouldn’t be satisfied

SchrodingersImmigrant · 18/08/2021 11:57

At least it's not white bread

pam290358 · 18/08/2021 10:59

@Binnaggy. Very succinctly put. I think this is the crux of the matter really. When you know at heart that what you’re doing is not very good for you, but you’re still looking to make excuses to justify it, then it really is time to examine things a bit more closely and be honest with yourself. It’s perfectly simple. When taken in small amounts on a regular basis without a break, alcohol can do damage which is cumulative and silent until it gets to the point where it causes health problems. By then it’s much harder to deal with, and yet there have been posts absolutely castigating the NHS approach of early intervention to avoid future problems - the arguments have been picked to death !! We’ve moved away a little from the OP’s original point about the MW, but it’s still relevant as she asked whether others think that her intake was too much and there has been some very interesting and colourful discussion. I think this is one of the most bad tempered and vitriolic threads I’ve seen on MN for some time, and now I’m wondering how long it’ll be before the moderators regard it as time it was taken down.

Binnaggy · 18/08/2021 10:17

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

pam290358 · 18/08/2021 10:12

@Qwerty789. Would you like to back that up with sources ? I hardly drank before my husband died. My drinking increased to what my GP described as a low to moderate level, for just a few months. It did damage to my liver - thankfully reversible, but still damage. Again, not saying this would happen in all cases, because various factors are at play, but to describe the risks as ‘propaganda’ doesn’t make any sense. All of this stuff is easily googled. Do you think it’s all propaganda ? If so I think you’re deluding yourself. Or are you a troll ?

Qwerty789 · 18/08/2021 09:35

@Qwerty789. Wrong again. Even low amounts of alcohol have been proven to be harmful if drunk regularly and without a break

Nope. Not true. It's propaganda. That's not what the science shows.

pam290358 · 18/08/2021 08:49

@Qwerty789. Wrong again. Even low amounts of alcohol have been proven to be harmful if drunk regularly and without a break. And current medical evidence points to there being no ‘safe’ level of alcohol intake, which has been stated numerous times on this thread - the number of recommended units has steadily reduced over time in line with research.

I was simply stating that you can’t know what damage alcohol is doing simply by looking at someone, and that home measures are likely to be more generous than those in pubs unless you’re using a measure. There’s a perfect example of this upthread. A poster stated she had bought a measure and can now drink three 100ml glasses of wine instead of 2 pub glasses. Pubs use three sizes - 125ml, 175ml, and 250ml, so the maths is wrong - 300ml of 12% wine is 3.2 units and the average ABV for wine is anywhere between 11.5 and 13.5% and so can be slightly less or slightly more in units. If you’re drinking three glasses in one sitting and applying this as a general rule you can see how it would be very easy to exceed the recommendations even if you only drink 3-4 times a week.

I don’t know where you’re getting the statistics from for your posts, but they’re not consistent with anything I’ve found - and I’ve done a lot of research into this because what happened to me scared me, so I wanted to make sure it didn’t happen again.

Whether you like it or not, and whether you agree with it or not, the recommended units per week is 14. This doesn’t mean that you can safely drink this amount - it’s an indicator for keeping alcohol related damage to a minimum. These figures are not pulled out of the air, they’re based on scientific fact. Women absorb alcohol more easily than men because of their physiology and the onset of liver damage occurs more easily - and among other things it affects things like breast feeding and risk of various cancers. It’s not racist, it’s not sexist, it’s not ‘policing’ womens’ bodies, it’s biology. No one is saying that small amounts of alcohol will necessarily cause damage, and no one is saying don’t drink. It’s about balance and being mindful that the damage alcohol does is largely silent and takes time to get to a point where it causes symptoms - at which point it’s harder to deal with. So for that reason, rightly or wrongly, I’m in favour of the NHS approach because I now know from personal experience that prevention is better than cure, and for prevention you have to accept the facts and stay within the limits. That’s all. Personal choice.

user1470132907 · 18/08/2021 08:02

They’re probably assuming home measures are heftier than pub, and also that people declare fewer drinks than they actually drink, in which case you could be well over 14 units. Obviously you may make weak drinks and be telling the absolute truth, in which you’d be okay!

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 18/08/2021 07:19

@Qwerty789

The assertion that you know people who drink ‘low’ amounts which are not harmful, has no scientific basis

There is LOADS of scientific basis for very healthy drinkers. Tonnes of research on the meditteranean centenerians who drink red wine every single day.
Teetotallars are statistically far less healthy and live shorter lives than moderate drinkers, this is proven.

The Mediterranean way of drinking “healthily” is to drink wine or beer with a meal. It’s clearly stipulated that it is included as part of the meal so that your body absorbs it better. Mediterranean drinking doesn’t simply mean drinking small amounts every day and it’s definitely not about having a gin at the end of the day to relax.
Qwerty789 · 18/08/2021 01:14

The assertion that you know people who drink ‘low’ amounts which are not harmful, has no scientific basis

There is LOADS of scientific basis for very healthy drinkers. Tonnes of research on the meditteranean centenerians who drink red wine every single day.
Teetotallars are statistically far less healthy and live shorter lives than moderate drinkers, this is proven.

pam290358 · 17/08/2021 20:36

Like I said, not engaging any more. Everything I’ve said about the effects and risks of low level drinking was as a result of information given to me by health professionals and from my own experience - the rest is easily verified by googling. Pick it to bits all you want - just because you don’t like it doesn’t make it any less true. Done now.

Belladonna12 · 17/08/2021 20:24

I don’t think anyone has actually said that daily drinking of small amounts in itself means you’re dependant on alcohol.

A few people on this thread and certainly on other threads have said that those who drink daily are dependent on alcohol.

What IS being said is that even small amounts of alcohol can damage your liver if drunk on a regular basis, and that regular drinking of small amounts can be habit forming and can lead to problems later on.

No, there is no strong evidence that small amounts of alcohol will damage the liver if drunk on regular basis. It is very hard to know how much alcohol people with liver damage have had as they are llikely to underreport and some people will be much more susceptible to damage than others.

The assertion that you know people who drink ‘low’ amounts which are not harmful, has no scientific basis

As I was talking about my parents who are in their 80s I am pretty sure that one small alcoholic drink each day has not been harmful to them and I doubt they are an exception.

Much of the discussion has been around the fact that home measures are frequently larger than pub measures, which means that it’s not just a small amount - it can actually take you over the recommended level without you even realising it.

You may have poured yourself large drinks but and not realised what you were doing but why do you keep on insisting that everyone else does the same thing. I am quite capable of measuring liquids and do so if making a drink for someone and I'm sure other people do the same thing.

The NHS has been criticised for treating the OP as an alcoholic. That’s not what was happening - the OP admitted to a level of drinking that was technically abuse, which could possibly form a habit which could possibly then lead to dependence. And this is the point.

OP didn't admit to drinking an amount that was technically abuse. She said that she had one or two drinks gins each evening and the midwife made the assumption that it was always two and always large as you have done.

We’re not talking about alcoholics - we’re talking about people who are possibly not aware that they are drinking at an unsafe level, and who may actually want to do something about it before the problem gets out of control. How is that a waste of NHS resources when to allow such problems to progress unchecked will cost the NHS vastly more ?

How is it a good use of NHS resources to make a referral for someone so that it can be pointed out that they may be drinking more the the recommended units? Firstly the midwife hasn't actually ascertained that OP is drinking too much (see above) and secondly if it was just to make the point, the midwife could have done it herself. Refering someone without their permission is not a good way to change peoples drinking habits.

pam290358 · 17/08/2021 19:54

Sorry, just seen your post about breast cancer. I haven’t been insisting that others underestimate the amount of alcohol deliberately - my point is that it’s easy to misjudge, I wasn’t accusing anyone of lying. As for your point about the amount of alcohol relevant to increased risk of breast cancer - I have an interest in the studies because my mum has had it twice and none of the studies I’ve seen on the link between the disease and alcohol consumption have relied solely on anecdotal evidence from women. The data from various sources are pooled and the conclusions are reached scientifically. I’m definitely done with this thread now - continually repeating myself because people either can’t be arsed or don’t have the mental capacity to read the posts properly and then post crap in response.

pam290358 · 17/08/2021 19:40

@Belladonna12. I don’t think anyone has actually said that daily drinking of small amounts in itself means you’re dependant on alcohol. What IS being said is that even small amounts of alcohol can damage your liver if drunk on a regular basis, and that regular drinking of small amounts can be habit forming and can lead to problems later on. Why do you find that weird ? The assertion that you know people who drink ‘low’ amounts which are not harmful, has no scientific basis - everyone is different, no amount of alcohol is ‘safe’ and you can’t tell how much damage the consumption is doing to someone without testing because the damage can build up over time without symptoms - some people, are not aware of the damage until it shows up during testing for other things. Much of the discussion has been around the fact that home measures are frequently larger than pub measures, which means that it’s not just a small amount - it can actually take you over the recommended level without you even realising it. The NHS has been criticised for treating the OP as an alcoholic. That’s not what was happening - the OP admitted to a level of drinking that was technically abuse, which could possibly form a habit which could possibly then lead to dependence. And this is the point. One poster put forward the argument that it was a waste of NHS resources because an alcoholic couldn’t be helped unless they wanted to be. We’re not talking about alcoholics - we’re talking about people who are possibly not aware that they are drinking at an unsafe level, and who may actually want to do something about it before the problem gets out of control. How is that a waste of NHS resources when to allow such problems to progress unchecked will cost the NHS vastly more ?

Hesma · 17/08/2021 19:34

You don’t have to be pissed to be alcohol dependent… sounds to me like you have an issue if you drink every day like that

Belladonna12 · 17/08/2021 19:16

[quote pam290358]@AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken. Don’t think it does any good at all in the long run. There are so many levels of ignorance surrounding alcohol use and abuse on this thread I don’t know where to start, and so many people who come across as angry and aggressive - it’s hard not to come to the conclusion that it’s because their own drinking habits are being called into question. The fact that a relatively small amount of alcohol consumed on a regular basis can form a habit and end up damaging your health seems to be a concept that some people either can’t or don’t want to accept. I find interesting that breast cancer hasn’t been mentioned. There is a proven link between even small amounts of alcohol and breast cancer - as little as 10 grams of alcohol is enough to raise estrogen levels and increase the risk, and yet the NHS is being castigated for being OTT and out to police womens’ bodies. Such hypocrisy.[/quote]
So you think that there is proof that only 10g increases the risk of cancer? Love the fact that you assume women in the studies of breast cancer are totally honest/accurate about their alcohol intake when you have been insisting others underestimate it.

Belladonna12 · 17/08/2021 19:03

I find it weird that people assume that daily drinking even small amounts means someone is dependent on alcohol . It's not necessarily any different from having a bar of chocolate and automatically referring someone just because the alcohol is drunk each day regardless of whether the weekly amount is relatively low is a waste of NHS resources. I don't drink that much myself but my parents would always have one drink when they got home from work everyday and still have a drink each evening. They are certainly not dependent (have no problem stopping if on a diet) but even if they were I don't see that it matters given the overall amount they drink is low and not harmful to them. They are both in their 80s now and in good health for their age.

Swipe left for the next trending thread