Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Treated like an alcoholic by midwife?

736 replies

MyMabel · 14/08/2021 17:45

Anyone else been in this situation?

Ok our telephone consultation appointment I was asked how much I drink prior to finding out I was pregnant - I said (honestly) I had about one or two gins every night, the occasion glass or two of wine instead. Couldn’t tell them in units as I have no idea.

I was never drunk, never drank until DP was home as we have a toddler DD so wanted to make sure if anything happened one of us can drive, plus I wouldn’t drink while solely responsible for her. - again, never drunk or even dizzy. Just a glass or two while watching telly before bed. I suppose with COVID and all I was just bored?

Anyway, was asked if I drank since finding out- said no, because I haven’t.

Come to my face to face appointment; Midwife explains that due to my alcohol intake before being pregnant I’ve been referred to speak to someone. I was in a bit of shock to ask questions and just said ok. But after I left I felt mortally embarrassed and now a bit worried they think I’ve got a drinking problem?!

Maybe I’m not BU in the sense that they could perhaps help someone who struggled with alcohol by doing this routinely.. but AIBU to think I really don’t need to speak to someone regarding what I drank in the evenings?

Did I really drink THAT much too much? I get it was too much and probably not healthy for my body.. but I don’t think it’s that bad?!

OP posts:
Belladonna12 · 16/08/2021 10:44

@pam290358

Yes, I wonder if men who drink couple of units over the recommended amount would get referred. It's an unbelievable waste of NHS resources

Didn’t take long for this to descend into a feminist argument did it ? If men had babies they’d be treated the same, and alcohol consumption is a normal part of the questioning at health reviews for both sexes. And it’s not a ‘couple of units over the recommended level’. If you’re drinking at home without using a measure, you can easily bump up the units. Two gin and tonics using a pub measure is 2 units of alcohol - taken every day this puts you at the maximum of 14 units for a woman. Home measures can easily double this without you realising it, so that two drinks becomes 4 units, which then puts you at twice the recommended level. And why is it an unbelievable waste of NHS resources. Surely identifying problem drinking at an early stage is worthwhile if it saves the massive expense to the NHS of dealing with the effects later on.

Has OP said that she never measures the gin? That seems to be the assumption of people based on their own inability to measure alcohol rather than anything OP has said. I don't drink gin but if I make it for someone else I would measure it. Why not? She also has not said that she drinks two drinks every night. She said she has drunk ONE or TWO. Believe it or not, that would mean some evenings she only has one. She may very well be drinking within recommended limits and if she is over then it may only be by one or two units a week and that was BEFORE she was pregnant. She is not drinking ANYTHING at the moment and won't be for nine months.

The referral seems to based on the belief that OP may be lying about how much she drinks when not pregnant when there is no evidence for that (why would someone who admits drinking alcohol be more likely to be lying someone who doesn't admit it) and a belief that she wouldn't have stopped when pregnant when there is no evidence that either. Furthermore OP's permission was not sought first and I think it's pretty well-established that IF someone has a problem with alcohol there is no point trying to force them to change . They have to want to change. All in all total waste of NHS resources.

pam290358 · 16/08/2021 10:44

I’m not ‘picking’ on anyone’s post, just trying to make a point. A lot of low level problems have surfaced during the pandemic because more people are drinking at home, and it’s so easy to miscalculate if the alcohol is unmeasured - I didn’t realise what I was doing until it was pointed out to me, and there will be lots of people in the same position. The male friend I mentioned was the same - he was a key worker during the pandemic and had added stress at work. He was drinking what he thought was a safe level at home -just one or two as a de-stressor at the end of the day. When he told his GP about his drinking habits during a health review, she referred him for a scan, which showed the start of fatty liver, and he was advised to cut back, which he did.

At the end of the day it’s a matter of informed choice. I had a wake up call which made me realise how easily it happens, and also how easily the habit is formed, and therein lies the danger. That’s all I’m saying - I think the medics are right to be all over this if they can prevent problems which will cost the NHS far more in treatment.

toooothacheee · 16/08/2021 10:41

I think the reaction will definitely feel over the top.

But someone else might have dependance issues that needs that level of support.

You clearly don't going off what you've said.

I would let them do their thing so they don't start claiming you are resisting support, clarify what your actual alcohol intake was, but make it clear that you don't need any further help from then on.

Supergirl1958 · 16/08/2021 10:31

[quote pam290358]@Supergirl1958 I think there have been a few posts on the thread, including my own which was backed up with medical facts, which kind of prove that one or two drinks certainly CAN be a problem if they are unmeasured at home and are being consumed every day. The problem is the cumulative effects, which are generally not noticeable until the alcohol consumption has damaged health. The cumulative effects also include the fact that alcohol is habit forming, so eventually over time, the one or two drinks a day that you look forward to, get more and more and end up being a need rather than a want. I think your own comment is a perfect example of everything wrong with the attitude in general in the UK - normalising problem drinking.

@Belladonna12. I don’t think the midwife was wrong to give a high score. She would have been able to work out the average units from what the OP told her, and would have factored in the fact that they were home measures, which are usually higher. She would also have been concerned that the drinking was every night - indicative of a habit which could possibly impact the pregnancy if the OP was unable to sustain abstinence.[/quote]
Pam, this is the second time you’ve picked on my post! I’m not talking about medical evidence, I’m talking about whether one or two drinks is a lot! It just isn’t in comparison to the quantities I’ve mentioned. If you can cut back (which the OP has, and has stopped) then it ISNT a problem! That’s my point. I haven’t said you are being judgemental either, your opinion comes from experience, but some people just are being extremely judgemental. We aren’t talking a bottle of vodka a night, we are talking a couple of drinks and the OP has even said it isn’t every night, but sometimes it can be. It isn’t a problem if you can recognise when you need to cut back, or indeed stop!

I think it’s fair to say we aren’t going to agree love, so let’s leave it there!

Belladonna12 · 16/08/2021 10:20

[quote pam290358]@Qwerty789. A male friends’ body was ‘policed’ in the same way because he reported drinking every day at a GP health check, so no I don’t think it’s unacceptable and yet another example of sweeping low level problem drinking under the carpet.[/quote]
I don't beleive for a minute that he got referred without his permission after reporting having one or two drinks each evening.

FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 16/08/2021 10:20

If men had babies they’d be treated the same

Lol good one

pam290358 · 16/08/2021 10:18

Yes, I wonder if men who drink couple of units over the recommended amount would get referred. It's an unbelievable waste of NHS resources

Didn’t take long for this to descend into a feminist argument did it ? If men had babies they’d be treated the same, and alcohol consumption is a normal part of the questioning at health reviews for both sexes. And it’s not a ‘couple of units over the recommended level’. If you’re drinking at home without using a measure, you can easily bump up the units. Two gin and tonics using a pub measure is 2 units of alcohol - taken every day this puts you at the maximum of 14 units for a woman. Home measures can easily double this without you realising it, so that two drinks becomes 4 units, which then puts you at twice the recommended level. And why is it an unbelievable waste of NHS resources. Surely identifying problem drinking at an early stage is worthwhile if it saves the massive expense to the NHS of dealing with the effects later on.

pam290358 · 16/08/2021 10:04

@Qwerty789. A male friends’ body was ‘policed’ in the same way because he reported drinking every day at a GP health check, so no I don’t think it’s unacceptable and yet another example of sweeping low level problem drinking under the carpet.

pam290358 · 16/08/2021 10:02

@Supergirl1958 I think there have been a few posts on the thread, including my own which was backed up with medical facts, which kind of prove that one or two drinks certainly CAN be a problem if they are unmeasured at home and are being consumed every day. The problem is the cumulative effects, which are generally not noticeable until the alcohol consumption has damaged health. The cumulative effects also include the fact that alcohol is habit forming, so eventually over time, the one or two drinks a day that you look forward to, get more and more and end up being a need rather than a want. I think your own comment is a perfect example of everything wrong with the attitude in general in the UK - normalising problem drinking.

@Belladonna12. I don’t think the midwife was wrong to give a high score. She would have been able to work out the average units from what the OP told her, and would have factored in the fact that they were home measures, which are usually higher. She would also have been concerned that the drinking was every night - indicative of a habit which could possibly impact the pregnancy if the OP was unable to sustain abstinence.

Belladonna12 · 16/08/2021 10:00

@Qwerty789

It is probably a situation where they need to refer anyone who is drinking above the recommended unit allowance

Well thats an epic waste of time and money as well as unacceptable policing of womens bodies.

Yes, I wonder if men who drink couple of units over the recommended amount would get referred. It's an unbelievable waste of NHS resources.
Qwerty789 · 16/08/2021 09:57

It is probably a situation where they need to refer anyone who is drinking above the recommended unit allowance

Well thats an epic waste of time and money as well as unacceptable policing of womens bodies.

Belladonna12 · 16/08/2021 09:57

The constant assertion that women can't measure their alcoholic drink and/or lie about it also ridiculous. And if they do lie why should it be the person that admits to having a drink. It may be the person who says that they don't drink at all that is lying.
And if people think women do lie/undestimate does it not occur to them that those who actually do suffer alcohol related disease probably lied about how much they drink as well? Mother of children with FAS may have drunk much more than they admitted to and yet people seem to take that as gospel. Very selective.

Belladonna12 · 16/08/2021 09:54

@Dnaltocs

What’s the problem. Is alcohol good for us? No. Then stop. Sounds to me many can’t stop. I read hear that “I’m not dependent. I just look forward to my alcohol” It’s doing you no good. Stop
You could say the same thing about chocolate or food high in saturated fat though. I bet most of the posters clutching their pearls about alcohol probably have more of that than they should for optimum health. There seems to be an inability to understand that some people enjoy a glass of an alcoholic drink in the same way as others enjoy chocolate. It doesn't mean that they are a raving alcoholic who can't stop when pregnant.
Belladonna12 · 16/08/2021 09:31

[quote Madwife123]@MyMabel

I’m a midwife. These questions have a scoring system based on how many units you drank. This determines how much of a risk it is of you restarting drinking in pregnancy. The midwife won’t have had any option but to refer you if you scored above the cut off, it’s not their decision.[/quote]
The midwife gave the score though without asking for more detail. She shouldn't have given a high score without checking how often OP drinks two rather than one glass and whether she measure the shot.

Dnaltocs · 16/08/2021 09:20

What’s the problem.

Is alcohol good for us? No.

Then stop.

Sounds to me many can’t stop.
I read hear that “I’m not dependent. I just look forward to my alcohol”
It’s doing you no good. Stop

Supergirl1958 · 16/08/2021 09:20

@Bertiebiscuit

Sorry but I think anyone drinking a substantial amount of alcohol every day has got a drinking problem - she was right to focus on this I'm afraid
This comment is everything that is wrong with the world (and yes I’m being dramatic!) one or two drinks is NOT a substantial amount. One or two Bottles per night certainly is substantial, but that’s not what this is!
TwinMama6 · 16/08/2021 09:12

@Blue4YOU

I wish the midwife and doctors had been so concerned about my first DD not moving in utero and subsequently dying.., oh but wait! I wasn’t drinking so nothing they could do. Op - don’t further engage if you want to stay sane
Flowers
SsVoix · 16/08/2021 08:57

Yeah, I mean I had an alcoholic mother and this was pretty much her level.
Dizzy, stumbling about, slurring words... Not how you define alcoholism.
Functioning alcoholics often never realise that they have a problem.
You are drinking a lot. I'm sorry but, if you can't identify the units, that's a lot. We have a drinking culture here and I'll probably be the rare exception who tells you the truth. I don't know anyone else who has had a referral for this. In a culture where you get a giggle of you say you think you shouldn't have got drunk last Saturday that's actually quite serious.
Try giving up when you aren't knocked up and see how it goes.

pam290358 · 16/08/2021 08:45

@PurpleVerbena. Your body may get used to it, but at that level, sooner or later the cumulative effects will inevitably cause health problems. I guess it’s down to knowing the facts and personal choice.

pam290358 · 16/08/2021 08:43

@SaltySheepdog. I agree with you, but I think the fact that OP was drinking at home is the problem - it’s harder to keep track of the actual units. After my diagnosis I went out and bought a pub measure to try to work out how I’d got myself into that position because I really didn’t think I was drinking that much - two drinks max per day. I was really shocked at the difference between the jigger measure equalling one unit of alcohol, and what I was estimating as a large gin. I was drinking between four and six units a day without realising it, and more than doubling the recommended level. I also agree with the poster up thread who said that alcohol dependency and problematic drinking tends to be normalised in this country - someone upthread mentioned that in European countries a glass of wine is drunk every day with a meal, but I don’t think that can be held up as a positive example without knowing the statistics on how alcohol affects health in those countries.

I think my main point is that it’s easier than you think to damage your health through alcohol, and this may be why some are at odds with what healthcare professionals consider excessive. They are more aware of the effects of alcohol on the body and the red flag signals. I know several people who don’t consider themselves to be excessive drinkers, who use the recommended levels as ‘targets’. Healthcare professionals will tell you that there is no ‘safe’ level of drinking, and that the recommended levels are just that, recommendations, beyond which it’s likely to cause damage. This is not just because of the effects of the alcohol itself, but the fact that it’s habit forming and long term regular drinking will add up to problems in later life.

PurpleVerbena · 16/08/2021 08:42

I think a lot of it is how you grew up. You are either a drinking or a non-drinking family. I come from a drinking family, and was first given watered down wine with dinner when I was about 10, a sherry on a Sunday at 12, and so on. It was quite normal to have a drink when you got come from work and then a couple of glasses of wine with dinner. Whether it's right or not, your body does get used to it.

SaltySheepdog · 16/08/2021 07:41

Your starting point needs to be working how much you actually drink. You can probably work it out quite easily and estimate the weekly units. This is something you will likely be asked again

BatshitCrazyWoman · 16/08/2021 07:32

@MouseholeCat

You absolutely don't need to take the referral, but I do think it's worth reflecting on the fact that your alcohol consumption met certain risk criteria.

That doesn't mean that you are an alcoholic by any means, but it can mean that you are more vulnerable to future alcohol health-related concerns or alcohol dependency.

I'm one of those maligned posters who thinks that alcohol dependency and problematic drinking is normalised in the UK, and I do think nightly (or close to nightly) drinking is not normal.

I agree.
pam290358 · 16/08/2021 06:52

if I thought for a moment that I needed rather than wanted a glass of wine, I'd be on it.

This is a good point. A poster up thread mentioned looking forward to a couple of glasses of wine at the end of the day, as I looked forward to my gin and tonic. If anyone suspects they are developing a problem, ask yourself if you are really just fancying a glass of something, or do you ‘need’ it as a comfort of some kind. Even if alcohol consumption is moderate, if you find that you can’t wait for that time to come around, it may be time to look at whether you’ve formed a habit which could store up future problems.

pam290358 · 16/08/2021 06:42

I don’t think there’s any question here that the OP has stopped drinking now she knows she’s pregnant, but the issue is that she told the midwife she drinks a couple of gin and tonics EVERY night. That’s a red flag as, despite what some are saying on here, it does suggest some level of dependence. It therefore speaks to whether she can sustain abstinence throughout the pregnancy and it will certainly warrant a referral under NHS scoring systems.

I think some posters are assuming you have to be falling down drunk every night to be at risk of alcohol related illness. You don’t - and if you drink at home, you are almost certainly drinking more because unless you invest in a jigger measure, your own drinks will be larger than a pub measure, and for every jigger it’s a unit of alcohol. After my bereavement it only took me six months of two of my own measures of gin and tonic most evenings to end up with fatty liver. If I had carried on, by now, a couple of years later, I’d probably be on the way to irreversible damage. Not suggesting that we don’t drink at all, just that it’s easy to exceed the recommended limits without realising it. And 14 units is not a ‘safe’ level. It’s also not a target.